What Is A State? Essay

2298 words - 9 pages

Max Weber, a forefather of modern science, created the modern definition of a state. Weber believed that a state was a, “community that claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory.” The state creates a legitimate means for the use of force, or the right to use violence within the state or to another state. Very simply put it is the domination of men over men by legitimate means. From this concept, Weber determined politics to be the striving to share power or influence the distribution of power with a state or among groups within a state. This is a good point especially when one considers how a political official has a great deal of influence on how power is distributed throughout a government. In order for those in a position of power, such as political officials, there must be a just cause by which the dominated submit themselves to authority (Weber 1958).
Weber explains that there are three different types of legitimized authority. The first authority that Weber describes is the authority is rooted in the ancient ritual and tradition to conform to the principle authority of forefathers (Weber 1958). This is exemplified in the form of patriarchy and an inherited authority. England is an exceptional example of this because while many European nations had monarchy authority in their history, England still recognizes the royal bloodline and has a monarchy. While the position of the monarchy within the government has changed from commander and chief to the chief of state, England holds onto this authority by which they legitimize their state. The second form of authority, Weber refers to as “gift of grace”. The concept of this authority is that the legitimacy comes from a certainty in a revelation, an act of heroism, or other charismatic individual leadership attributes (Weber 1958). A mythological example of this authority would be the story of Sir Arthur pulling Excalibur from the stone and by this revelation he was crowned King Arthur. Some might argue that while U.S President Barrack Obama’s authority is legitimized because he was elected into office, it is his charisma and ability to make the American people believe he can changes things is why people submit to authority. Weber explains that is it because the people of the state believe in their leader that they follow him. The final authority Weber discusses is legitimacy through legality or by created rules. U.S. President Obama while to some may be considered a leader by the “gift of grace” by U.S. political standards he is a legitimized leader because he was chosen through a specific process outlined by specific rules for leadership selection, or in other word election candidacy. In this model, leaders gain authority within the state by being a servant of the state and by imposing domination in the best interest of the state. Weber chooses to focus on the “gift of grace” legitimized leadership and how it ties into having a political vocation...

Find Another Essay On What is a State?

Happyness is a state of mind.

697 words - 3 pages Untitled Happiness is a state of mind There are many people in this world who says just because of him/her I am not happy, but is it true? Happiness is just a state of mind, and It only depends on your mind, many people `you are the ruler of your mind'. If you want to be happy you will be happy, if you have a bad experience at you office or workplace by which you are upset you keep on thinking the incident that has taken place

The Relationship Between State and Religion in Turkey: Is Turkey a Secular State?

1722 words - 7 pages The Relationship Between State and Religion in Turkey: Is Turkey a Secular State? Casper Gelderblom s1393162Introduction to Area Studies, Section A Instructor: E. Erol March 27, 2014Word count: 1490Two and a half years ago, Turkish prime-minister Erdogan visited Tunisia, the country where the so-called Arab Spring began. During his visit, Erdogan delivered a speech in which he made the case for "the Turkish model" to be accepted by the revolting

The Relationship Between State and Religion in Turkey: Is Turkey a Secular State?

1722 words - 7 pages The Relationship Between State and Religion in Turkey: Is Turkey a Secular State? Casper Gelderblom s1393162Introduction to Area Studies, Section A Instructor: E. Erol March 27, 2014Word count: 1490Two and a half years ago, Turkish prime-minister Erdogan visited Tunisia, the country where the so-called Arab Spring began. During his visit, Erdogan delivered a speech in which he made the case for "the Turkish model" to be accepted by the revolting

The Debate over Palestine: Is it a State?

1019 words - 4 pages edge of the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River) and it divided the area into two parts; a state for the Jewish and one for the Arab people, Palestine. While Israel was given statehood, Palestine was not. Since 1947, one of the most controversial issues in the Middle East, and of course the world, is the question of a Palestinian state. Because of what seems a simple question, there have been regional wars among Israel, Egypt, Jordan, Syria

Is the European Union more than a regional state-system?

1928 words - 8 pages that stress the supranational character and the autonomous power institutions have in the European Union and the ones who claim that it is only a regional state-system where national governments play the decisive role. The former is commonly referred to as the federalist school of thought while the latter go by the name of the intergovernmentalists. These main camps have throughout the years developed various subdivisions with slightly different

To Become Educated is a State of Mind

1702 words - 7 pages become educated to me is not something one can instantly become in a place of formal educating, such as schools, colleges, and universities. To call yourself educated you must first obtain a proper state of mind; a thirst of knowledge is truly required to become educated. I know not of what is to become of me, but I shall continue to keep this moving in the direction of this mindset. The only other question is: “Will the rest of our growing society

What is the impact of globalization on the sovereignty and autonomy of the nation-state?

1527 words - 6 pages Globalization is a relatively new concept. As little as ten years ago, the term was hardly used. Today globalization is being discussed everywhere; by businessmen, politicians, economists, academics, right through to the average person on the street. It affects all aspects of our modern lives, from what we eat, to what we watch on telly, to the type and amount of crime we experience and to how much money we have in the bank. In this essay I

What are the key features and limitations of a liberal democratic state?

1620 words - 6 pages Parliament and other assemblies. In the modern pluralistic democratic state, power typically is exercised in groups or institutions in a complex system of interactions that involves compromises and bargaining in the decision process, hence Parliament. Democracy tends to be equated with a good system of government and 'remains the best defence against arbitrary government and tyranny'.However, is this system of government and control truly beneficial to

The American history of slavery has been conveniently shrouded by a comfortable state of "national amnesia". By what means and how far successful is Morrison in addressing this issue in Beloved.

641 words - 3 pages Toni Morrison contends that American history of slavery has been conveniently shrouded by a comfortable state of "national amnesia" However, this has brought about destructive effects which are highlighted through the symbolism and character developments. By not "passing the story on", there is no healing process and the community is missing out vital gaps which are required for lessons to be learnt and an identity to be built.Toni Morrison uses

What would Aristotle have thought about a state lottery? This essay uses Aristotle's views on justice to evaluate the morality of a state lottery.

688 words - 3 pages One aspect of justice, which Aristotle elaborated on, was that which was concerned with a fair distribution and proportionate equality. These aspects are directly related to the debate about whether a state lottery would be unjust toward those citizens of the state who are the least able to afford it. For the sake of argument we will assume that a lottery is a disproportionate tax on the poor, who are more inclined to play hoping of financial

What is the relationship between the state, the economy and power? Discuss with reference to liberal and realist accounts

3159 words - 13 pages act aggressively because otherwise they face risking economic penalties imposed by other members of the international community. Economic success of individual states now rests on the success of the global economy.Liberals strongly believe that in order for economies to strive, the embodiment of the free market is a prerequisite, i.e. minimal state interference. However this requires a nation-state to have a democracy where the state is

Similar Essays

What Is The State Of Your Household?

1003 words - 4 pages /shepherding houses are places where we can be refreshed. While all Christians are called to pray, share the gospel, teach and care for one another, it is most likely that one of these aspects is most prominent in your house. At this point, a good question to ponder may be, “what are the special and unique characteristics of your household that God has given you to bless another”? While we may all camp under one of the four figurative banners

Is France A Socialist State? Essay

956 words - 4 pages to get them back on their feet to be a contributing factor to society. One of the main beliefs of Socialism is to put people before a profit. In a European context, there are a few countries that are socialist. These would include: Denmark, Portugal, Finland and the Netherlands. Possibly the two biggest things to be considered a socialist state is that the government has a steady hand in the job sector and that the state is secular. France fills

The State Of Nature Is A State Of War

1484 words - 6 pages of War. The third assumption is that man has the logic required to plan for the future. Through man’s futuristic thought comes the ability to anticipate the actions of other men, which create fear since man can never know what might happen if he does not pre-emptively strike first. Thus for Hobbes we are stuck in a State of War because man is equal in strength and mind, man’s principle desires and man’s ability to plan. In order to avoid this

Success Is A Subjective State Of Mind

1194 words - 5 pages something that is successful.” Unfortunately even within this definition, there are concepts that are hard to explain and explore. “Correct” is a term that is subjective and hardly ever is there one correct way of doing anything. How can one succeed at anything without there being an absolute way of determining success? I believe that success is a subjective term and society develops there own individual basis of determining what it means. It is a