This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Is A Transparent Epistemic Rule? How Does It Relate To Privileged Access?

1032 words - 5 pages

Privileged access and epistemic transparency are very interesting ideas. They deal with the idea of individual truths. These truths focus mainly on things that can be true to you, but false to others and can encompass things that may momentarily appear true, yet are generally false. The question philosophers have focused on is as follows: How can something as solid as a “truth” vary from person to person, and mind to mind? The general idea behind this topic is, as discussed in class, that some mental states belong to an individual because only that individual can access them. One can hypothesize others mental states based on how they act, however one can not really know the true state of mind.
According to Descartes we have direct access to our experiences, thoughts and emotional states. This results in a transparent mind. Transparency is the idea that if you believe something, then it is true. For Descartes, this was a no brainer, a completely obvious point. It seems logical that one’s own mental states are transparent to one because they are conscious of them. This follows his Cogito argument, where one can be certain of their existence because they are thinking. We can have knowledge of our self existence only as far as being a thinking thing, carrying out mental acts such as judging, wondering and being afraid. To Descartes, the transparency of mental events, such as the Cogito argument, form the basic principles upon which all human knowledge can be based, and go hand in hand as fundamental ideas.
While Descartes believes this to be incredibly fundamental to human knowledge, there have been several critiques of this over the years. One example that goes against mental transparency is Freud’s idea of the unconscious mind. The unconscious does not include what is in the conscious, but rather looks at what is repressed from a knowing conscious. Things repressed can include unacceptable ideas, wishes or desires, traumatic memories as well as painful emotions. He argues that unconscious thoughts are not directly accessible to ordinary introspection, but can only be tapped into with special methods and techniques that the ordinary conscious mind cannot reach without direction. These unconscious thoughts can be viewed as cryptic with special meanings that the conscious mind cannot easily decode. This makes Descartes claims a bit sticky. Because Freud argues that we have biologically based instincts that are part of the human mind, like urges, as well as uncontrolled repression, which are these things found in the unconscious, it causes individuals to not be consistently aware of their mental state. His argument therefore displaces Descartes claim of transparency of mental states.
Transparent epistemic rules allow us to figure out what is true from the evidence available to us. They are rules that rely on an individuals privileged access, or ability to have a good understanding of himself or herself. They access an individuals mental state...

Find Another Essay On What is a transparent epistemic rule? How does it relate to privileged access?

Content theory of motivation- why is it a content theory? What are the features and how does it apply to the workplace?

664 words - 3 pages needs are. Maslow (1954) outlined what is perhaps the most influential of the content theories. According to A. H. Maslow, human needs become reasonably well satisfied, a person places more emphasis on the secondary needs. He suggested there is a hierarchy of needs up which people progress. Maslow separated the five needs into higher and lower orders. Physiological and safety needs were described as lower-order needs. The two orders were

How does the constitution relate to education - grand canyon university - A lesson plan for middle school

270 words - 2 pages it and then send it to the president. The president would veto the bill. The class would have to discuss why they feel the bill was vetoed and what needs to be done to get it passed. Examples from the constitution would need to be stated to explain what changes need to be made and why and why the bills might have been vetoed. The second learning activity can be a mock trial regarding a controversial issue in the news today. I would type out the

Identity Fraud. What is it? How does it impact over 33 Million Victims since 1990? How does a person protect themselves from it?

2584 words - 10 pages What is Identity Fraud?In the year 2002 alone there has been a total of 161,819 reported cases of Identity Theft according to the Federal Trade Commission. According to Consumer Reports, "Identity theft [is] the fraudulent use of your name and identifying data by someone else to obtain credit, merchandise, or services". Identity Fraud does not discriminate; it affects all races, ages and classes. The actual number of Identity Theft victims

Analysis of 2 items that relate to "relationships" how it is depicted and the themes involved

1452 words - 6 pages woman in the advertisement by their pose obivously have a loving romantic relationship by their pose, but also there is a hint of sexual tension as well by the way their faces are so close and the way she has her eyes closed, leaning towards him, giving herself to him. Their simplicity and scaricty of their clothing also is a symbol of the bond between the two, for it conveys a sense of vulnerbility in their lack of clothes, yet also a certain

The Crucible, Arthur Miller "How and to what extent does The Crucible show that it is more damaging to deny the truth, than it is to acknowledge it?"

753 words - 3 pages In The Crucible, Arthur Miller gives many examples that show that denying the truth, and lying to do so, is far more damaging than it is to simply acknowledge it. The play demonstrates the potential damage that can occur to a person's reputation and livelihood when false accusations are placed upon them. It shows that when certain individuals are willing to deny the truth in order to avoid the consequences of acknowledging it, that denial forces

What Is Kickstarter And How Does It Work

1551 words - 7 pages the target goal is met, the credit cards that were used for the pledged will be charged. This transaction will be done simultaneously. if the project does not meet the funding goal by the set deadline, none of the people who pledged will be charged. The good thing with Kickstarter is that they practice an all or nothing deal. All Or Nothing The all or nothing practice is what makes Kickstarter different. It enables them to create this feeling

What is Discipline and How Does It Work?

1195 words - 5 pages Sergeant and Cadre. DISCIPLINE can also be hard to have which makes it hard to be successful. What is the true definition of DISCIPLINE? According to Webster’s New Twentieth Century Dictionary Unabridged, DISCIPLINE is defined as “Subjection to rule; submissiveness to order and control; habit of obedience.” The definition states that DISCIPLINE is to follow direct orders and rules. DISCIPLINE plays a big role in the military. Soldiers in basic

What is Cloning and how does it work

1015 words - 4 pages By Jarrah CoeTeacher: Jenifer TrewrenIntroduction:The following report discusses cloning. It will describe what cloning is. How it is carried out on both, plants and animals, why we would clone, and how this technology can be used in the farming industry. This report will also discuss the advantages and disadvantages of cloning.What is Cloning?Cloning is the process of making one or even several organisms that are genetically identical to the

What is the FTAA and How Does It Affect Me?

968 words - 4 pages Agreement was written the draft agreement has grown from nine chapters to twenty-four chapters. Some of the additional chapters are: Tariffs and Non-Tariff Measures, Safeguard Measures and General Expectations.The FTAA is very complicated and governs many different areas so kids my age may find it hard to realize what the FTAA has to do with us. One way the FTAA should be of concern to my piers is this; unless the second proposed clause of the Free Trade

How does charisma relate to effective leadership and what cross-cultural implications might derive from charismatic communication?

1899 words - 8 pages idea of what charisma is; yet putting words to it seems exceedingly difficult, yet a definition is still in need. Sellers claims (1996, pp. 67-74) that "Charisma is the remarkable ability to get others to endorse one's vision and promote it passionately." Put in layman's word, it is the ability to influence and persuade others by seeming to possess exceptional qualities.Effective leadership'Effective leadership is the process of influencing others

How Does Video Game Violence Relate to Violence in Reality?

1002 words - 4 pages How Does Video Game Violence Relate to Violence in Reality?With every action there is a cause and effect; when a child acts out in a violent manner, people usually look back and try to find out what provoked this response. Did the child learn it from home? Do they hang around a bad crowd? Probably the most common response is - they learn it from media. More specifically- video games and fantasy violence. This is a frequent theory adults have on

Similar Essays

What Is Federalism And How Does It Relate To State Governments And Other Forms Of Governance?

1006 words - 5 pages , & Schmidt, 2011). A chose system government gets its powers clearly from a made set out of fundamentals and hindrances, in the United States (US) it is the Constitution. In the US, the conflict for federalism was settled all around the approval of the Constitution, showed in the past portion. In present times federalism has gotten sponsorship as a model because this appearance of government puts a face to powers and brings government closer to the

What Is A Tablet And How Does It Benefit Us?

1065 words - 5 pages . Tablets are great way of doing business on the road, for example, if you are in a bus or a plane, it is easier to bring out your tablet than your computer. Tablet is mostly for travelling and using it to certain limit. If you only have a touchscreen in your head typing will not be as easy as it would be on a keyboard, but there are possibilities to add-on a keyboard if needed.   2 WHAT IS TABLET Computers in general were discovered in the 1970’s, from

What Does It Take To Be A Professional Chef And How Does It Affect The Industry

1794 words - 8 pages What Does It Take To Be A Professional And How Does It Affect The Industry? There are two approaches to becoming a professional in the culinary industry: going through an accredited culinary program or going straight into the field and learning from your experiences. Both of them have their pros and cons, but at the end of the day they both have an expectation to fulfill: to get things done. While identifying these pros and cons of a culinary

Describe One Process Theory Of Motivation Why Is It A Process Theory? What Are The Features And How Does It Apply To The Workplace?

806 words - 3 pages have quite different ideas about the intensity of labour that constitutes 'a fair day's work'. Employers naturally feel that, having paid the wage, they should decide what a suitable level of effort from workers is. Workers for their part fear that if the employer has control of effort intensity he may be tempted to increase it arbitrarily to an inequitable level, which they will resist if they have the power to do so.The theory establishes four