This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Is The Catholic View On Genetic Engineering?

1279 words - 6 pages

Prior to in depth investigation it was assumed that Catholicism was ‘old fashion’ and against scientific technologies, leading to the hypothesis of Catholicism being against Genetic Modification. The hypothesis was produced on the fact that Catholic deliberations find their origins in Natural Law and Kantian Ethics. (NATURAL LAW - Catholic Culture: Online; 29/05/14) The hypothesis additionally assumed that Islam ethics welcome scientific advancements for the benefit of the human race.

Genetic Modification was brought to further understanding through the comprehension between Gene Therapy and Gene Enhancement. Determining the goals of assisting genetically disadvantaged individuals of the ...view middle of the document...

One of the highest held beliefs in Islamic ethics was presented to be the significance of human life. After primary and secondary research has been conducted, it can be deducted that Gene Therapy is permitted in Islamic Ethics, this is shown in the common theme prevalent in Islamic ethics which is “The ends justify the means.” or “The probable benefit outweighs the possible harm.” This claim is supported by a diverse range of secondary sources analysed by the author. A divergent viewpoint partially agrees with this claim. The opinion of the Islamic interviewee Johann Silva poses that genetic flaws may be destined in our world. Whilst understanding the significance of human well being, the interviewee believes individuals with bearable genetic flaws are a sign of how gifted individuals with full wellbeing are. The interviewee’s perspective illustrates traces of Situational Ethics, Ethic of Jesus, Common Good, Social Conscious and interconnectedness.

After the author has conducted diverse, decisive research from both primary and secondary sources, analysed and applied these results to the hypothesis, it can be concluded that both Catholicism and Islam share partially equal views on the topic of Genetic Modification. The two religions share the same opinion on Gene Enhancement being immoral and unethical, however their views differ moderately when Gene Therapy is considered. Catholicism is typically based in origins of Natural Law and Kantian Ethics, but also shows signs of Situational Ethics and the Ethic of Jesus in the field of Gene Therapy. The Catholic opinion diverges between Gene Therapy being a permissible technology and being immoral. Islamic Ethics supports Gene Therapy on the basis the process follows moral guidelines, however a divergent viewpoint explains that our world is destined to have individuals which possess genetic flaws which pose no risk of death. These individuals are symbolically a reminder to all human beings to show gratitude for their well being and life. In conclusion, the wide range of research and analysis conducted, along with application of ethical frameworks and concepts, proved the hypothesis, “The rigid archaic, uncompromising position of the Catholic Church pertaining to the ethics of human genetic modification differs greatly to the progressive Islamic position.” to possess partial correct and incorrectness in its claim.

Works Cited

BBC - Ethics - Introduction to ethics: Duty-based ethics. 2014. BBC - Ethics - Introduction to ethics: Duty-based ethics. [ONLINE] Available at:http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/introduction/duty_1.shtml. [Accessed 29 May 2014].
Coesyd. 2014. . [ONLINE] Available at:http://www.ceosyd.catholic.edu.au/Parents/Religion/Documents/Bioethics_in_Islam.pdf. [Accessed 20 May 2014].
Dictionary : NATURAL LAW - Catholic Culture. 2014. Dictionary : NATURAL LAW - Catholic Culture. [ONLINE] Available at:http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/dictionary/index.cfm?id=35060. [Accessed 29 May...

Find Another Essay On What is the Catholic view on genetic engineering?

What´s Genetic Engineering? Essay

1626 words - 7 pages few years, the line separating “god” from “mortal” may become nothing more than an afterthought. In doing so, this paper shall also elaborate on genetic engineering’s history and current advances along with its potential misuses and limitations. What is genetic engineering? Any medical dictionary will loosely defines it as “the group of applied techniques of genetics and biotechnology used to cut up and join together genetic material and

Genetic Engineering: Is the Human Race Ready?

1491 words - 6 pages onto the ground. Genetic engineering has been used to make plants that are pest-resistant so that less of the crops are destroyed. These pest resistant plants yield higher quantities of food. Manipulation of plants has also made it possible for food to last longer. But just because there is more of it and it lasts longer, does not mean that it is better. Many people are concerned about what genetic engineering will do to the food that they eat

Catholic View on the creation and fall

1056 words - 4 pages technology and no longer looking upon the moral or the holy, we are no longer liberated as humans beings but crushed by the technological age we live in. "There is no single all-embracing formula from which everything necessarily derives", Monod goes on to claim humans are a result of chance. On the contrary, the Catholic view deems that humans are not the product of chance and error but they are products of a creating Reason and a creating

The Effects of Genetic Engineering on Agriculture

1678 words - 7 pages The Effects of Genetic Engineering on Agriculture Agribiotechnology is the study of making altered agricultural products. Agribusiness is trying to alter the genes of already existing products to try to enhance the biocompetitiveness and adaptability of crops by enhancing plant resistance to drought, salinity, disease, pests and herbicides. They are going to try to enhance their growth, productivity, nutrient value, and chemical

Genetic Engineering is Unethical

1135 words - 5 pages disregarded the risks of genetic engineering (Bereano 19). In 1979, he wrote the following about possible diseases that might be inadvertently created through genetic engineering: “I would not spend a penny trying to see if they exist'; (Bereano 19). The above statement clearly shows that society cannot depend on the “high priests'; of science to make ethical decisions (Bereano 18). Too much is at stake. Unfortunately, many scientists choose to ignore the

The Genetic Engineering Debate

1694 words - 7 pages In recent discussions of genetic engineering, a controversial issue has been whether genetic engineering is ethical or not. In “The Person, the Soul, and Genetic Engineering,” JC Polkinghorne discusses about the moral status of the very early embryo and therapeutic cloning. J. H. Brooke’s article “Commentary on: The Person, the Soul, and Genetic Engineering” comments and state opinions that counter Polkinghorne’s article. On the other hand John

Genetic Engineering Is Not Safe

988 words - 4 pages Genetic engineering is the intended modification to an organism’s genetic makeup. There have been no continuing studies on this topic or action so there is no telling whether or not it is harmless. Genetic engineering is not safe because scientists have no absolute knowledge about living systems. Given that, they are unable to do DNA surgery without creating mutations. Any interference on an organism’s genetic makeup can cause permanent damage

Genetic Engineering Is Not Ethical

1469 words - 6 pages produce what the patient lacks. The second method involves completely obstructing genes that cause disease (Grace). The first method could be used to greatly increase the strength of a person’s immune system or instill an immune system in a person that lacks one. The second method can prevent a disease from expressing itself in a person because the gene is stopped in its dormant state before it can express its harmful effects. Genetic engineering

Human Genetic Engineering is Bunk

1342 words - 6 pages Imagine a world in which everyone is identical and reared to process, act and perceive every little thing the same way. If someone chooses to stand out, then the entire society becomes unstable, unsafe and brings unwanted fears that the civilization will decay into rubbles. The longevity and quality of life primarily depend on what the controller feels like creating, either an elite or a second-rate. The life of one human being is dictated and

The Human Genetic Engineering Debate

2276 words - 9 pages whether or not one feels fixing what is naturally occurring, is natural at all. As a result of all three positions, new questions have begun to arise, including how genetic engineering will affect the human race, how the science will be tested and implemented, how the economics of genetic engineering will affect the population, and whether or not it is something that can be controlled. The overall concern in the debate over human genetic

The Dangers of Genetic Engineering

723 words - 3 pages different? After all, we have had many problems with discrimination before such as racism? Genetic engineering may have some positives such as creating stem cells to heal someone but that is one of few positives. There are too many negatives such as flaws where babies develop diseases or syndromes, such as turner's syndrome. This draws attention to Frankenstein in the way of how people would view what he did and how similar it is to what we are

Similar Essays

Islamic And Catholic Views On Genetic Engineering

1804 words - 7 pages Primary and Secondary sources found that Gene Enhancement had no place in the religions of Catholicism and Islam; both believe it is selfish, unnecessary and unethical. It is an embellishment to human vanity and additionally, insults human integrity when the offspring is affected by the technology. (What is the Catholic view on genetic engineering? - Mary Meets Dolly. 12/ 05/ 2014.) The Catholic Church In 1983, Pope John Paul II mentioned in

Genetic Engineering The Church View Essay

1505 words - 6 pages , consequently, respect the fundamental dignity of men and the common biological nature which is at the base of liberty, avoiding manipulations that tend to modify genetic inheritance…" However, the Catholic Church is rather ambiguous when time comes for taking a stand on certain other issues. The vagueness of the Catholic Church comes in genetic engineering-no literature was found that details the point of view of the Catholic Church regarding

Genetic Engineering Is The Future Essay

2002 words - 8 pages " their power when dealing with genes. And to some extent I can believe that is correct. I will only ask the question of who is more to blame: genetics or the politicians who fail to put restraints on how people use science to make money? Can you blame the scientist who is getting a million dollar grant from a CEO for listening to what his sponsor wants? Regardless, to me the economic treasures made from genetic products completely overshadow the

The Catholic View On Polygamy Essay

2401 words - 10 pages with the people and the Catholic Church all have different views on polygamy. Most people view polygamy as wrong because it is degrading woman or humans in general. Even though polygamy is degrading to women in some people’s eyes to others it is a part of their religious beliefs and therefore some people look past the fact that it is wrong and degrading to women. According to the different governments around the world, it seems like half of the