This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Is The Right To Die Movement? Essay

1421 words - 6 pages

According to Ullmann-Margalit (51) while dealing with the subject the agony of doubt deliberates that it is among the most confusing issues to deal with. Most people do not want to die, at least not now, and the debate of holding on to the inevitable and that of letting go heats up. Questions arise concerning the social, religious and ethical factors that have to be taken into play while considering end-of-life or right-to-die and thus bringing complexity to an otherwise easy decision. But the most crucial question to ask is: are those in support of the right-to-die justified in their movement? This will be the question that will be addressed in this argumentative essay.
Why oppose the right-to-die movement
For those in opposition of the right-to-die movement (Ullmann-Margalit 73), there are a number of issues that they raise. It is often argued that most of those involved in right-to-die decisions engage in such decisions because they are not given enough information (Samanta and Samanta 218, 219). This results in anger and frustration among family members for that decision (Health Commission n. pag. qtd. in Samanta and Samanta 219).
Legally, the law provides that each individual has the right to live until such a time when life terminates naturally (Parhizgar, Parhizgar and Parhizgar 415). It is also argued that a person has the right to either live or die with dignity and assisted suicide does not count as part of dignified deaths (Parhizgar, Parhizgar and Parhizgar 415).
It is also argued that the work of counselors who decide to deal with terminally ill patients and their family members have the mandate of letting their clients obtain the best end-of-life care possible (Werth and Crow 195). This ensures that there is enough support physically, socially, emotionally as well as spiritually (Werth and Crow 195). This however does not come without a cost for both parties since the family will have to incur the expenses and the as to struggle with self determination during critical decision making (Werth and Crow 195).
It is also clear that while making these decisions, the decisions ought to be made based on informed consent (Werth and Crow 195). Sometime, the patient may be experiencing dementia, clinical depression or delirium for which they may be affecting the patient’s decision making capabilities (Werth and Crow 197, 198). If such a person is allowed to make their right-to-die decision, this may be done without the patient having comprehensive information before consent and thus should not be encouraged (Werth and Crow 198).
For those who profess to be born-again, their personal autonomy to make the right-to-die decision is surrendered to rabbi, or mullah or other religious heads claiming that the will of their Head be done over their lives (Ullmann-Margalit 69). Davila in his 2006 journal article notes that there are five predominant issues that lead people to seek futile healthcare which include psychological,...


The Right To Die Essay

1121 words - 4 pages or her request is not the most pleasant way to die. Once the decision to allow death has been made between physician, patient, and family, what is the ethical difference between giving a more painless death? Where is the abuse once the decision has been made to permit death to occur under controlled circumstances? People often ask why is it normal, and completely appropriate, for a veterinarian to put an aged, suffering animal to sleep with a

the right to die Essay

1481 words - 6 pages the comfort with which we ourselves are comforted by God" (2 Corinthians 1:3-4). In conclusion we read how both women endured much pain and sorrow for love. Mrs. Mallard endured because it was the right thing to do, and Maldiv because her love for Mrs. Bourengs' son surpassed her suffering. In both instances we can relate to the love of Christ and how much torment and scorn he endured on account of loving us. If we stay steadfast and persevere, we will know what true freedom is and we will be given abundant life.

Euthanasia, the right to die

909 words - 4 pages Euthanasia is a very controversial topic. People argue as to whether or not a person who is terminally ill, or handicap, should have the right or not to ask their doctor, or relatives to die by euthanasia. People say that dying by euthanasia is to die with dignity, instead of living an artificial life on respirators and other life support machines. My personal feelings on this topic is one of the minority. If a person is terminally ill, and

Suicide The Right to Die

1512 words - 6 pages By: WD E-mail: The Right to Die, Physician-Assisted Suicide 6/3/99 History " I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody if asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect" -- The Hippocratic Oath Physician-Assisted suicide is one of the most controversial issues in our society today. During the 1990's, assisted suicide has become the subject of public debate and legislative action across the nation. Even the U.S

What Is the Right Response to Terrorism?

2141 words - 9 pages Terrorism response, like any issue concerning domestic politics and international affairs, can be faced analyzing either causes or effects. Terrorists are usually motivated by political beliefs. Even if terrorists can take advantage of other particular situations such as economic difficulties and religious beliefs, the main purposes are always political. That being said, the right response to terrorism is prevention. Solving the problem at the

What is the Right Response to Terrorism?

1997 words - 8 pages behind the veil of ignorance, but you ground your judgment on your social position. Torture is not the right response to terrorism. As it has been demonstrated, it is less effective and against any moral, legislative, and political value. Surveillance Emotionality and rationality have to be taken into account also to determine whether surveillance is a just mean to respond to terrorism. The ones who deny the use of surveillance fear what they do

Do People Have the Right to Die?

2661 words - 11 pages family have the right to make the decision to end her life, when she cannot make that decision herself? Who does have that right? Do people have the right to die? This incident started many people thinking about what they believe about the issue of the right to die and physician assisted suicide. The story of Nancy Cruzan is only single scenario out of many that people have to decide where they stand on the issue. There are so many

Do People Have the Right to Die?

2405 words - 10 pages . The fight for the "right to die" is reflected through opposing organizations and even in particular cases in communities. Recently, the Florida band "Hell on Earth" began planning to have a terminally ill fan undergo euthanasia on the stage during a concert in St. Petersburg on October 4th (Kaufman). The 2003 Florida Statutes declare that one found guilty of assisting self-murder will be guilty of manslaughter and a felony of the second degree

Euthanasia: We Have the Right to Die

1056 words - 4 pages What is euthanasia? The dictionary defines euthanasia as the act of putting to death or allowing to die painlessly, a person or animal from a painful incurable disease. Euthanasia is also known as mercy killing. The word euthanasia comes from the Greek word eu- meaning good and the Greek word thanatos which means death. There are two types of euthanasia: active euthanasia and passive euthanasia. Active euthanasia is the practice of ending the

The Right to Live or Die

1939 words - 8 pages as follows: 1.Compassion is the first--author Weir states, "people in favor of it consider physicians to have amoral obligation to relieve pain and suffering using medicine. For some people, relief only comes through death, so if a patient wishes to die, they should have the freedom to do what they wish. Furthermore, it is considered moral because a person had the right to do what they choose with their life, therefore, they can choose when to

The Right to Die in Assisted Suicide

2878 words - 12 pages terminal ill patient is voluntary and actually suffering from the pain is very important. I feel the following questions would be the most difficult questions for the governments to answer: who is eligible for performing assisted suicide and how cautious should the selection of physicians be? Also, as for the doctors, what if the patients change their mind and do not want to die anymore while being assisted with suicide? Should the physicians stop, or

Similar Essays

The Right To Die Essay

2226 words - 9 pages . Americans now believe that if life is miserable one has the right to get out, actively and with help if necessary. It has been fashionable for some time now and in many aspects of American public life for people to demand what they want or need as a matter of rights, hence the claim of the “right to die”. In defining the meaning of the word ‘right’ certain questions come up, and to clarify, define, explain, and decipher, these claims of

The Right To Die Essay

1215 words - 5 pages death by one’s own hand, or a controlled death in which the family can say their goodbyes? Simon Jenkins illustrates this well when he says, “What cannot be right is for me to deny those whose unfettered judgement has reached a wish to die, the freedom of this, the last of life’s great dignities.” This statement poetically describes how no man has the right to prevent another many from dying if he is determined. In time, society and the

The Right To Die Essay

2398 words - 10 pages to die should be a fundamental right of all people. Nowhere in the Constitution does it state the government has the right to stop a person from committing suicide. In fact the Ninth Amendment states ‘the enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.’ However, in 1997 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that physician-assisted suicide is not a constitutional right but

The Right To Die Essay

1709 words - 7 pages progression of a fatal disease or the prognosis of living for years with incurable pain would be able to end their lives with dignity before their suffering became unbearable. Dr. Harry Chen, Vermont's health commissioner and a former emergency room doctor in Rutland, asks for others to "Understand that this is a terminal patient who is going to die, [that] this is as much as anything helping them to decide under what circumstances they want to die