What Is Wrong About Donald Black's Theory Of Law?

1242 words - 5 pages

What is wrong about Donald Black's theory of law?

     In his book on ?The Behavior of Law? Donald Black attempts to describe and explain the conduct of law as a social phenomenon. His theory of law does not consider the purpose, value, impact of law, neither proposes any kind of solutions, guidance or judgment; it plainly ponders on the behavior of law. The author grounds his theory purely on sociology and excludes the psychology of the individual from his assumptions on the behavior of law (Black 7). The theory of law comes to the same outcome as other theories scrutinizing the legal environment, such as deprivation theory or criminal theory; however, the former concentrates on the patterns of behavior of law, not involving the motivation of an individual as such. In this respect, Black?s theory is blind for social life, which is beyond the behavior of law.
Law, ?a governmental social control? (Black 2), is a quantitative variable that changes in time and space and can be defined by style: penal, compensatory, therapeutic or conciliatory (Black 5). The brief description of law and its interrelation with social control and deviant behavior can be encapsulated in the following scheme. This concept of law put into the context of social life gives a framework of the behavior of law.

Donald Black breaks social life into several variables, such as stratification, morphology, culture, organization and social control. All these aspects are quantitative variables in time, space and across the settings. In contemporary social life they intertwine between each other and relate to law and deviant behavior.
     According to Black?s definition, stratification is ?the vertical aspect of social life?, ?any uneven distribution of the material conditions of existence? (Black 11), in other words the discrimination of wealth. Stratification can be measured in quantity, delineated in style and viewed from two perspectives, as a ?magnitude of difference in wealth? (Black 11) and as the level to which the setting is stratified. Moreover, stratification explains not only law, its quantity and style, but also other aspects of social life. The relationship Black is mostly interested in is the positive correlation between stratification and law, meaning the more law, the more stratified the setting is. When utilizing this proposition by inserting other variables of social life, such as etiquette or privacy, the quantity and style of law in a given context is predictable and explainable.
     Another central variable of social life is morphology, the allocation of people in comparison to each other. It also has dimensions such as differentiation and intimacy, which can be connected in the same way as stratification to the behavior of law, however, resulting in the curvilinear correlation (Black 39). The more law, the more differentiation and intimacy exists in a setting; however, this positive correlation continues until there is some kind of interdependency...

Find Another Essay On What is wrong about Donald Black's theory of law?

What is wrong with Stereotyping? Essay

950 words - 4 pages According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary stereotyping is defined as, “an often unfair and untrue belief that many people have about all people or things with a particular characteristic” (Cite). Meaning that stereotyping is a conditioned method of thinking based on the looks, religion or way of life of another person or group. This sounds like a bad and close minded act, but is it? Stereotyping can be used, in certain situations, as a

What is the instiutional theory of art?

1987 words - 8 pages essay will unfold in the following manner: an examination of the views of the Institutional Theory of art (looking in particular at Dickie and Danto), a study of Wollheim’s criticisms and finally, an attempt to reconcile Wollheim’s problems. What is the Institutional theory of Art? There is a distinguished tradition of trying to define the term ‘art’- to create a definition that is able to encompass what exactly makes something ‘art’ rather

What is Kanatianism Theory?

1897 words - 8 pages – according to Immanuel Kant – people possess value. In addition to the following, Kant also talks about the two types of good and what is considered good in the aspects of Kantianism. According to Kant, there are two types of good: intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic good means that the good must be good and of itself whereas extrinsic is good that is good but not good and not of itself (Page 71…). Lastly, are the imperatives that Kant

What is a Theory?

530 words - 2 pages contain evidence and results that can be reproduced.A theory is more than an educated guess, or hypothesis, that people can make in a matter of a few moments. It is a tested and confirmed idea that is backed by reproducible data. A guess is something people can make without knowing anything or very little about a subject. A theory is not simply a hypothesis, it is an explanation made at the end of experimentation that will attempt to explain the

What is Wrong with Slavery?: Utilitarian Thought

880 words - 4 pages In Philosophical Ethics, Utilitarianism is the doctrine that our actions are right if the outcome of our actions generate the greatest happiness amongst the majority. However, in “What is Wrong with Slavery?” some objectors of utilitarianism have tried to dismiss this moral reasoning as to having any importance by blaming the awful actions of slave traders and slave owners on utilitarianism. They attack this doctrine by saying that

What is wrong with beauty Children Pageants?

1006 words - 5 pages Society has set certain stereotypes to girls and women about what it is considered to be beautiful that girl’s focus more in their appearances than in their internal selves. Every girl deserves to feel beautiful because they all are, but how can girls think that they are beautiful if there is always that constant reminder of what being considered beautiful is. It is often seen on TV various shows where little girls are being judged by the way

Puritan Law as Hawthorne Views it What is Hawthorn trying to say about puritan law? The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorn

769 words - 3 pages ; this part is fine. What is not fine is the fact that if this is true, then natural laws should take pretence over any other law not already established, and the Puritans attempted to establish a culture in which it is taught that some of those natural laws are flat-out wrong. For instance, God instilled in human nature for humans to be forgiving of sin while Puritan culture teaches that public shame atop a pillory, which is "…the framework

What is useful in Freud's theory of dreams?

1705 words - 7 pages Strachey, (Penguin Books : 1991) p 132 ** * Freud's theory of dreams appears to be very useful in understanding when and why dreams occur, what is their meaning, why they are beneficial to psychoanalysis but also to explain what are dreams and how they are created. Identifying the processes of dream creation, wish fulfilment, repression and recognizing the meaning of dreams through interpretation allows a better awareness of the patient's

What is the Stakeholder Theory?

1170 words - 5 pages Stakeholder can be defined as “any group or individual who can affect or is affected by the achievement of the organization’s objectives”. This theory focuses on wider aspect rather than only focusing on just the shareholder. Stakeholder theory is a fundamental theory about how business works at its best and how it could work. It is concerning on the value creation and trade on how to manage a business effectively. A consequences of focusing on

What Is Meant By The Term Structuralism? What Is Saussure's Structuralist Theory Of The Sign?

1903 words - 8 pages What is meant by the term 'structuralism'?What is Saussure's Structuralist theory of the sign?It must at first be stated that the term 'structuralism' is not only applicable to literature, but also philosophy and psychology, and many of the social sciences. It is important to acknowledge this since thorough out the essay references will be made to as many of these disciplines as possible where appropriate. 'Structuralists' will look at 'surface

This essay tells about the views of cloning and how it is wrong to play God and create another life

1222 words - 5 pages to get this bill to become a law? If you were toban human cloning, at what stage would cloning become illegal? There are birthsbeing done today that require eggs to be taken out of the female uterus andfertilized, and then place back into the uterus. This stage also takes place inthe process of human cloning, only the egg is combined with a cell from anotherhuman being. If a ban is proposed on human cloning it should be done

Similar Essays

The Theory Of Evolution Is Wrong

2119 words - 8 pages proclaim the work of His hands” (Bible: The New International Version, Psalms 19.1) Finally, we will apply math to creation and see how the Fibonacci Sequence and Phi show how we must have been designed by an infinitely wise God. To begin, the woodpecker is an amazing example of how the universe must have been created by God and could not have come about by random chance. Speaker and author Dr. Jobe Martin, in his book The Evolution of a

Tort Law In Canada And What This Area Of Law Is All About

1111 words - 4 pages Tort law is an area of law which gives an injured person the chance to receive compensation from the person who caused the injury. Tort is taken from a Latin word tortus which means wrong. In French, "tort" also means a "wrong." It is very hard to get the truth in tort law due to the fact that it is one person's word against another's. There different ways to look at tort law because of how it can be an advantage to society and how it can also

What Is Wrong With President Goodluck Jonathan Of Nigeria?

1400 words - 6 pages can’t any right thinking Nigerian who has the interest of the country in their heart, partner with this president and work judiciously towards the betterment of our country, Nigeria? Instead of vowing for destruction, we should aim at peace, unity in diversity and social – political and economic developments of the country. I heartily call my fellow Nigerians to wake up from the slumber and ask themselves – rather honestly - What is wrong with President Goodluck Jonathan?

What Is Wrong With Bribery? Essay

1966 words - 8 pages argue that bribery is wrong regardless of whether the bribe has any impact upon the actions of the recipient, for the motivation that underlies an action is as important as the action itself. Only when one knows institutional corruption to rife can bribery be deemed common practice; in this case, one has a moral right to violate the duties of their position, for their duties require them to engage in corrupt practise. Bribery poses difficulties on