This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Problems Have You Identified In Making Connections Between The World Described In The Homeric Poems And The Archaeological Evidence You Have Stud

1890 words - 8 pages

What problems have you identified in making connections between the
world described in the Homeric poems and the archaeological evidence
you have studied? How far do you think it is possible to resolve these

In this essay I shall demonstrate that it is not currently possible to
resolve the problems I have identified in making connections, between
the world of the Homeric poems and the archaeological evidence I have
studied. This essay will deal with two specific areas, the first is
that of the problems associated with the citadel of Troy while the
second, will deal with the problems posed by, Homers descriptions of
the armour and the weapons used by the hero’s of the Iliad.

In book six of the Iliad Homer mentions a series of features in
relation to the citadel of Troy. These range from the description of
the hero’s houses, such as Hektor’s ‘well established dwelling’ in 370
and Paris’ ‘high house’ in 503, to the descriptions of the defences of
the city as found in lines 327 where he mentions ‘the steep wall’, and
in line 386 the ‘great bastions of Ilion’. When looking at the
archaeological evidence that remains at the site of Troy (known today
as Hissarlik), we find that there are several related problems which
make its interpretation and therefore its connection to the world
described by Homer in the Iliad difficult. The first problem
relates to the history of the site in terms of its habitation. First
settled in 3000BCE, evidence from archaeology suggests that there are
a total of 50 settlement layers that makeup the mound on which the
citadel was built, (These have subsequently been subdivided into nine
sections i.e. Troy I to Troy IX for ease of reference). This raises
problems in that each successive settlement built upon the remains of
the previous, re-using their materials. And in the case of the Romans
(who built the settlement known as Troy IX), completely removing the
top of the mound, and thus the centre of the 13th century BCE
settlement known as Troy VI. This is a major problem as Troy VI is
generally accepted as the settlement which corresponds to the period
in which the Trojan war of the Iliad is set. Another problem relating
to the citadel is the damage that was caused to the site by Heinrich
Schliemann, Troy’s first excavator. Working on the assumption that
Homers Troy lay at the bottom of the mound, Schliemann dug a series of
trenches through the site, an action which resulted in the loss of a
great deal of evidence.

Despite these initial problems, some material evidence relating to
Troy VI does survive on the site. Such as parts of its defensive
walls (the remains of which are fifteen feet high and six feet thick),
and an eastern bastion, there are also just behind the walls the
foundations of a number of large buildings. The...

Find Another Essay On What problems have you identified in making connections between the world described in the Homeric poems and the archaeological evidence you have stud

Do you have the right? Essay

2152 words - 9 pages Americans are a people of tradition. We celebrate holidays throughout the year to honor people, to commemorate certain events, and even to cheer for a team we want to win the Super Bowl. Traditions like these helped to form the very basis of the great United States of America. We hand these traditions down to our children, just as they have been handed to us by those who came before. We learn what it means to be an American. This can range from

The Obsession with Weight in the Entertainment Industry.         Have you

1530 words - 6 pages The Obsession with Weight in the Entertainment Industry. Have you ever looked at the cover of YM, People, or Cosmopolitan and seen a model at or above their ideal weight? At the same glance, have you ever seen even the slightest blemish in their skin? Did u know that Marilyn Monroe wore a size 12? In today's entertainment industry, the emphasis seems to be on being "thin". It is amazing how in such a short amount of time we can go from

What have you found interesting about the presentation of the central female characters in An Inspector Call and Macbeth?

3265 words - 14 pages is interesting is what Macbeth calls Lady Macbeth. For example, In Act 5 Scene 5 Macbeth says ‘Therein the patient’ and ‘she should have died hereafter’. This is interesting because in the Jacobean era, the husband would usually call his wife ‘My lady’. However, in this situation Macbeth is calling her ‘patient’ and ‘she’. This is very surprising because in beginning of the play we say how close they supported each other, now Macbeth is

Texts across time have portrayed women in terms of a dichotomy between "good" and "bad", but to what extent are the composers of the texts you have studied ambivalent towards their female characters?

2007 words - 8 pages Composers throughout the ages have often used dichotomy as a tool to depict the rift between "good" and "bad" women, but their exact intentions are often unclear. Examples of this ambiguity may be found in "Vanity Fair", a BBC television mini-series set in nineteenth century England, Fay Weldon's eighties novel, The Life and Loves of a She-Devil, and Chocolat, a single mother's integration into a rural French community, by Joanne Harris. No true

What aspects of change are discussed in the texts you have studied this year?

2023 words - 8 pages that implores the reader to take a chance, to leave their comfort zone and take on the outside world. The italic word "maybe" shows the uncertainty and unpredictability of the consequences after the person had gone and opened the door. "A tree, or a wood, a garden, or a magic city", these images open our minds to change and start to make us think to ourselves about what is really out there in this "magic city" of ours. This subtle use of

Discuss the subjects in which you excel or have excelled. To what factors do you attribute your success?

785 words - 4 pages   The subjects I excel in are math and science. Every since I was adolescent, I have always had a keen sense of numbers. This undoubtedly helped a lot with the variety of science classes that utilize math skills. Science, though, is, without a doubt, the subject I excel in the most, and I have my extraordinary great-grandmother to thank for that. Around when I was eight, I found out my great-grandmother had cancer which was gradually making her

The Fine Line Between Good and Evil in Where Are You Going? Where Have You Been? and A Good Man is Hard to Find”

1138 words - 5 pages me. Of course…’” In this quote it is showing that the Misfit is comparing himself with Jesus, as if his actions are justified the same way, Jesus’s actions were. The ironic part about him being compared to Jesus is, the Misfit thinks he can help the people of the world, not by changing the world, but removing them from the world. In conclusion, the short stories, “Where Are You Going? Where Have You Been?” by Joyce Carol Oates and “A Good Man

Discuss the subjects in which you excel or have excelled. To what factors do you attribute your success?

688 words - 3 pages tells me of things that happened when she was growing up- she was born in 1924, so she has told me stories about the great depression and stories of World War II. When I started studying American & world history, I could recall what my grandmother had told me about the things that had gone on- like the women working on the planes, and exact dates of certain strikes. And you know what? My grades turned out to be great in that subject. But I didn’t

How the discoveries and culture of the Renaissance have directly benefited you in some way

1514 words - 7 pages have a direct tremendous effect on businesses , they at times could have a course changing defining moment affect, between success and failure of an enterprise. One such story sums up the power of what a great sign can yield and produce. I had received a call, on an inquiry of an individual needing a sign, it was a usual visit, like so many other appointments, just a small restaurant going through difficult times, the shop owner was an a family

Many poems explore the idea of hopelessness. To what extent do the poems you have studied create a sense of hopelessness?

1618 words - 6 pages Justin Cheng 11G1 Section 2Many poems explore the idea of hopelessness. To what extent do the poems you have studied create a sense of hopelessness?The poem 'Once Upon a Time' can be read with a range of meanings very similar to 'Prayer before Birth'. The meanings of this poem also further emphasize the idea of hopelessness the present is however in contrast the past. One way to interpret the meaning of this poem: it is about the artificiality

The Devil in Joyce Carol Oates' Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?

1612 words - 6 pages The Devil in Joyce Carol Oates' "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" Her name is Connie, and she is not unlike many girls of the time she lives in. She is vain, she is constantly at war with her family, and she is in an incredible rush to grow up. Her race to maturity is the trait focused on in Joyce Carol Oates' "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been." It splits Connie into two different personalities: 'One for home, and

Similar Essays

What Connections Have You Found Between The Ways In Which Duffy And Pugh Write About Social Problems? In Your Response, You Must Include Detailed Critical Discussion Of At Least Two Of Duffy’s Poems.

2115 words - 8 pages Amy Asher AS Poetry Mrs LawrenceWhat connections have you found between the ways in which Duffy and Pugh write about social problems? In your response, you must include detailed critical discussion of at least two of Duffy's poems.Education for Leisure, ridicules the government and education. Writing during the 1980's employment rates were exceedingly high and Duffy talks of society in a critical way. Another poem by Duffy, Making Money, is a

What Have You Understood To Be The Relationship Between Innocence And Experience In Blake's Songs? Support Your Discussion With Appropriate Illustration From The Poems

2786 words - 11 pages , it may be considered as a single poem opposing the whole of Songs of Innocence. Tirzah is one of the five daughters of Zelophehad, also the name of the capital of Israel, which is in opposition with Jerusalem, the city of God. The first stanza begins with the well-known fact that "Whate'er is born of mortal birth" dies. And ends with the question "Then what have I to do with thee?", it seems it is directed exactly to that mortal part of humans

How Does Ovid Describe The Experience Of Being In Love In The Poems You Have Read?

660 words - 3 pages Each of Ovid’s Amores presents a slightly different view of love. Many of his poems have links between them, for example 3.4 and 2.19 (which both involve a custos and puella), but they also differ hugely (3.4 and 2.19 present almost opposing arguments). This leads to the conclusion that perhaps Ovid is highlighting how love changes according to the situation. In 3.2, we see Ovid using his rhetorical skill to woo a lady at the races. This poem

What Have You Learn In This Assignment? Do You Get Any Information And Gain Knowledge Regarding The Issue?

641 words - 3 pages I learn from this assignment is that I can learn how to answer questions correctly case study, and I was able to learn the case assignment oriented computer systems failure in a company will have an adverse impact on their management. Also, what can I learn from this case study is in terms of skill reading and writing case study with good. Then, I learn how to answer the question correctly, I will also use information from this case study to be