This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Makes Good Art? Essay

691 words - 3 pages

In this essay I will be discussing what, in my own opinion, makes good art. To justify what I consider to be a good standard of art, I will be analyzing the work of French symbolist Eugene Carriere and contrasting this with artwork I consider to not be 'good art'.
The art piece, by Eugene Carriere, I chose to look at first is The First Communion, due to its significant use of symbolism. Sybolism is often used to provoke emotion in a viewer, an example of how this is used in The First Communion is the inward eyes of the subject. This conjures up a mysterious and isolated atmosphere for the viewer, suggesting the idea of an inner world of thought. I believe that a piece of artwork with symbolic reasons behind its concept does contribute towards creating good art. Symbolism allows artwork to become a means of visual communication beyond what's obvious.
The First Communion was painted during the beginning of the French Symbolism movement. During this time artists were ...view middle of the document...

This is achieved by using his signature monochrome brown under-painting, representing the idea of stability and support found in his commonly painted scenes of domestic life. By placing thin layers of white paint over this under-layer it softens the tones allowing them to gradually blend into one another, creating a hazy form.
The colour white, was also used for symbolic reasons, alike his common use of browns. In The First Communion for example, white is used to echo the religious connotations of purity and innocence. Symbolist artists wanted the use of colour to be more than just a visual function, this demonstrates how much time goes into creating a thoughtful piece of art.
To further explain why I think that Carriere's work is to my standard of what is 'good art' I am going to compare his technique, that I previously explained, with world famous artist Van Gogh. I chose to compare two self-portraits, for Van Gogh I will be looking at his technique in his Self-Portrait with a Bandaged Ear, in comparison to Carriere's Self portrait.
Van Gogh is well known for his bold outlines to create his forms, I think this is a rather naive technique, although this could be the artists intention. The paintbrush stokes are made in a loose and paintily fashion, which all lines are left visible. For me, the illusion of texture is exaggerated and not realistic, each brush stroke is short and leading in the same direction. Where as Carriere's self portrait flows, as every brush stroke echoes the background, making his form further appear as a ghostly presence and the whole piece works in harmony.
Van Gogh's self portrait also appears flat, this is because his use of shadow consists of block colours. Rather than using tone to create a form, Gogh relies too much on the element of line. Carriere however, focuses on light and shadow to create his piece, which is what makes his work appear realistic. Using the formal elements to an acceptable ability helps create exceptional art.

Works Cited

http://www.poetryfoundation.org/learning/glossary-term/symbolist%20movement
http://hellomargot.me/2012/06/17/eugene-carriere-the-first-communion/
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/63.138.5
http://vangogh-is-cool.blogspot.co.uk/2006/07/selfportrait.html

Find Another Essay On What makes good art?

What Makes a Good Leader? Essay

3220 words - 13 pages What makes a good leader? It depends. Most organizations look for individuals that have something to offer when they look at credentials or a great interview but looks can be deceiving does a good manager necessarily mean that a good leader I do not think so. Leadership is a topic that will have to be address by every organization .In my opinion no organization will be able to prosper without good leadership. Even though no two

What makes good people do bad things?

1687 words - 7 pages What makes good people do bad things? There are different types of people in the world, as they all have different behavior, personality, and culture. Everyone has a different view of what makes good people do bad things. It is amazing how such calm and nice people turn into such a bad people. There must be a psychology reason in order for them to turn like this. There are some factors I would like to know and also discuss of why people behave

Expository Essay- what makes a good restaurant?

741 words - 3 pages We have all visited restaurants before, hungry with anticipation of consuming a good meal in return for our precious and cautiously spent money. Eating out is an expensive business and you really want to be sure you get a good experience. Sadly, this doesn't always happen. Who or what is to blame for this?Successful restaurants offer a seamless dining experience. The appeal of the meal to some, is the best part, but there are so many things that

What makes a good American Citizen?

1023 words - 5 pages Volunteer work/charity the average American citizen can become above-average and awesome (in every sense of the word) and can also develop into a righteous, upstanding, convivial citizen. The question of being a good American citizen or not first arose during the creation of the declaration of independence. The ideas that went into that famous document are what should be practiced today, that was in 1776, it's currently 2014 but the values still remain

What makes good User Interface in Games?

1897 words - 8 pages makes good User Interface in Games? Well to answer that, you have to take a look at the games that attempted it before. Even in early games it was pretty standard, just like the game mechanics and systems involved. The majority of the older games had only a few things to keep track of, namely score and lives. Games like Pac-man or Dig-dug clearly followed that scheme. The thing to note about games like these is that all of the information

What Makes a Good Horror Story?

809 words - 4 pages Montresor- the main character- seeks revenge against Fortunato is revealed. You can also perceive suspense when the author introduces phrases like “I vowed revenge” and “at length I would be avenged”. Nevertheless, what the reader actually perceives is the perverseness of a man unable to forget a hostile action from someone he called “friend”; that is why- in his lips- this word has ironical connotation. Also, Montresor is not as good as he claims

What makes the film a good one?

802 words - 3 pages . However, an argument has remained among film companies, directors and spectators. "What makes the film a good one?" Nowadays, lots of high-class films was made and watched but nobody can exactly agree in this question. So I try to answer this question by examining a film, which is named Gattacca and its factors that formed film afflux such as music, casting, and scenario...First of all, i want to start with the summary of the film. Gathacca is about a

What makes "Good" Characters Good in "Dracula" by Bram Stoker

741 words - 3 pages and Lucy Westerna. What makes Jonathan Harker so good is that he will do almost anything to help stop Dracula. He is Mina Murray’s fiancée and a solicitor who became a prisoner of Dracula but finally escaped. He helps the group throughout the whole story doing whatever it takes to stop Dracula and in the end it was him and Quincy who both killed Dracula by Jonathan cutting Draculas throat and Quincy stabbing Dracula through the heart

School and Community Portrait What makes a good school? What makes a good teacher? Does this school help the student to achieve the American Dream?

7898 words - 32 pages work like he would have at any other time.Findings:I will first begin by addressing the question regarding what makes a good school. I will start by laying some guidelines for a good school based on class discussions and readings. After I complete that, I will draw a conclusion on the "goodness" of Pleasantville High School.Earlier in the semester we completed a paper that's focus was to decide what about a school makes it a good school. In that

Oral Presentation for Fantasy Unit (10-12 mins). Focus Question: What makes a good fantasy novel?

1549 words - 6 pages All of us have at one time or another read something we would call Fantasy. Be it when reading "The Hobbit" or "The Lord of the Rings" as a school assignment (or for the more enlightened of us, at our own whim), from wanting to read the stuff that made the world we imagine exist, or more commonly from general love of the genre. But what is fantasy? What makes us pick up a book, read it from cover to cover, sigh and say "This is a good (or bad

What Makes Good Writing?

604 words - 2 pages good reader will be able to tell how much effort was put into a writing from the first couple of sentences. If the reader gets a sense of the writing trying to force words into a sentence or trying to stretch out a page you will lose your reader right then and there. If you honestly believe in what you are writing and have interest in the subject matter the reader will be able to read between the lines and actually have a feeling of being there

Similar Essays

What Makes A Good Nco Essay

871 words - 3 pages responsibilities of an NCO. The knowledge and skills of an NCO are instead acquired through training and experience, the products of which are NCOs of varying quality. A good NCO is one who knows and fulfills the written laws and regulations of Army doctrine, has the character of a good soldier and leader, and is able to strike a balance between written law and doing what is right even if the two seem to contradict one another. Since the Army puts

What Makes A Good Friend? Essay

652 words - 3 pages It's common to say that a good friend should be loyal or respectful because those are the first things that come to mind. Are you thinking of those qualities in terms of the friends you have now or because that is what society states makes a good friend. You'll read it in almost any magazine or newspaper article on the subject. Not too many people actually take time to consider the qualities of their friends. The friendship just sort of happens

What Makes A Good Essay

674 words - 3 pages What makes an essay good? There are many elements that go into a well written comprehensible paper. A quality essay contains elements such as description and detail, thesis statement, exemplification, irony, and knowledge of your audience. A good essay is one that grabs the imagination of the reader. Anyone can write a quality essay following simple guidelines and steps.I think that description and detail are one of the most important elements

What Makes A Good School? Essay

2256 words - 9 pages There are numerous factors that go into deciding what makes a school good, including the staffing of the school, the area of which the school is in, and the amount of money that the school has available to it. It is possible that two people commenting on the same school could have contradictory views on whether or not that school is good. Everyone's high school experience is at least slightly different from everybody else's, which causes these