What Makes The Supreme Court’s Decision In Citizens United Versus The Federal Election Commission A Controversial Decision

1432 words - 6 pages

In the wake of 2008, a non-profit oriented organization (Citizens United), composed and produced a documentary movie known as “Hillary: The Movie.” The documentary criticized the suitability and competency of Hilary Clinton (the senator at that particular period) to run as a presidential candidate. The organization aimed at distributing the documentary via different outlets that included theaters and Digital Versatile Discs (DVDs). Later on, the corporation realized that in order to reach a large public audience, it needed to avail the documentary using the video-on-demand portal. The initial steps of public awareness concerning the documentary involved the adoption of ...view middle of the document...

Additionally, those who prepare the coverage aim to either tarnish or polish the image of the candidate publicly. The ways of distributing such information includes cable, broadcast and satellite channels. The United States constitution prohibits electioneering statement (2 U.S.C. § 441b and 11 CFR § 100.29(a) (2)); moreover, when Citizens United realized that 2 U.S.C. § 441b blocked its intended actions, it decided to challenge the limits of the article through a judicial system. This research paper aims at analysing the proceedings of the case and its effects on the nation. It takes a controversial research into the authenticity of the case and establishes the appropriation of the verdict based on the constitutional providence. The case takes a controversial verdict, moreover; it defines the future of electioneering in the United States; therefore it needs a close-up analysis to discern both its short-term and long-term benefits and misgivings.
Summary of the court proceedings
The corporation filed a case against the Federal Elections Commission. The judicial proceedings took place in the federal district court. The aggrieved in late 2007 sought injunctions to prohibit the application of the article on Hillary: The Movie. It argued in court that the restrictions of the article towards the documentary represented an outright unconstitutional restriction. Unfortunately, the federal district court refused the injunctions and passed the judgmental synopsis to the Federal Elections Commission. Furthermore, the corporation stressed that the extent of coverage of the BCRA’s laws should exempt its documentary because the article’s disclosure and disclaimer necessities seem unconstitutional in this context. Moreover, it said that the BCRA’s regulations present an absurd situation in the advertisement and promotion of the documentary.
Under the amended act, the BCRA § 311states that an electioneering speech airing on the television and focusing on a particular candidate needs to show a plain, readable disclosure (disclaimer) accompanying the program for a period of about four seconds. The advert needs a separate source of funding other than the vying candidate. The disclaimer serves the purpose of identifying the either the corporation or the person liable for the television commercial. Another additional information required includes the address of the responsible entity and a clear statement which exempts the involvement of the candidate whatsoever in the electioneering statement. Also, the BCRA § 201 requires the party that finances the electioneering statement by spending more than ten thousand dollars in a given fiscal year to sign the terms of the disclaimer statement with the Federal Elections Commission under article § 434(f)(1).
The terms involve quoting correctly the party that finances the electioneering statement (the source of finances), the required amount of money, the vying candidate targeted by the statement and associated auxiliary...

Find Another Essay On What Makes the Supreme Court’s Decision in Citizens United Versus the Federal Election Commission a Controversial Decision

Highlight The Main Advantages And Disadvantages Of Individual Versus Group Decision Making. Discuss The Main Factors Affecting Decision-making Processes In Organisations. How Can Managers Ensure...

3831 words - 15 pages Highlight the main advantages and disadvantages of individual versus group decision making. Discuss the main factors affecting decision-making processes in organisations. How can managers ensure effective decision-making? January 2001, Word Count: 3113.¡§Decision making is the process of making a choice between alternatives¡¨ Rollinson (1998).Decision-making is almost universally defined as choosing between alternatives

To What Extent Did the Zimmerman Telegram Influenced the United States Decision to Enter WWI on the Side of the Allies

2337 words - 10 pages A. Plan of the Investigation This investigation will analyze the extent to which the Zimmermann Telegram influenced the United States decision to enter World War I on the side of the Allies? To accomplish this, the investigation will look at attempts made by the U.S to avoid involvement in the war and how the German government responded to such attempts. What the Germans hope to achieve by sending the telegram and how American opinion about the

The federal Reserve and the Beige Book: How information might affect the decision to raise interest rates

1080 words - 4 pages Established in 1913 as per the Federal Reserve Act, The Federal Reserve System (Fed) was first designed to stabilize and regulate monetary and fiscal systems. As the national bank of the United States, the Fed is an independent component of the government. Although it regularly communicates and is advised by many parts of the economic system, the Fed operates and makes world-affecting decisions without the consent, oversight, or regulation by

The Difficult Decision for the United States to Enter World War Two

1850 words - 8 pages Entering the war was a tough decision for political leaders during the 1930s. There were many different opinions from a variety of people. Many americans didn’t want to join the war because of what happened during World War One. Many Americans lost loved ones, during World War One and did not want to go through losing more family members again. Also there was a various amount of people saying that the war did not connect with them. Since the war

The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms

1464 words - 6 pages Untitled The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use

How issues such as immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning have divided American society and how decisions or comprimises have been reached

682 words - 3 pages In recent years, there have been many issues that have divided American society. Opposing sides have presented strong arguments to support what they believe in, and attempts have been made to come to a solution or compromise for the decision. Such issues include immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning.From 1967-1990, American immigration underwent dramatic changes. The Immigration Act of

The Role of the Election Commission in Indian Democracy

2189 words - 9 pages was required to provide. With this introduction the report would act as the blueprint for the Election Commission, with taking up majority of the intricate which aid in its functioning. INTRODUCTION: Our country was reared by a constitution which explicitly states India as a Sovereign, Secular, Socialist, Democratic, Republic. To maintain the essence of our supreme provider of law, we need to act according to the words enshrined in it. The

The Controversial 2000 Presidential Election in the US

891 words - 4 pages began to make changes in the entire voting process in hopes of preventing further controversies such as this election. The process in Florida as just the beginning of the longest president election decision in the history of the United States. “A month of tumult followed, until the U.S. Supreme Court, voting strictly along conservative/liberal lines, ordered the recount stopped and let Bush’s victory stand” (Henretta & Brody). Many, including

The Decision

1021 words - 5 pages Red Scarf Girl by Ji-Li Jiang is an inspiring true story about a young girl who is forced to make an agonizing decision of country versus family. In her story of joy, sorrow, lament, resentment, and countless other perplexing experiences, she must decide whether she is her family's child or Chairman Mao's. In Red Scarf Girl, Ji-li is faced with the heart-breaking decision of her future, and finally after years of confounding peer and family

The Decision of a Lifetime

1010 words - 5 pages Once chance, one choice, one shot to get it right, and if you're wrong, I'm sure you could chose again, but no one would want to go through that pain again, so for now, one choice, one chance. You know it will pay off in the long run, but it's something that sounds so unappealing to you that you would do anything to get out of it. That "something" can be as simple as not wanting to do your chores, or something a little more of a life decision

Controversial Issues in the United States

990 words - 4 pages Throughout history, especially when a new country is formed, there are many controversial issues. These issues come up when not everyone agrees on how the country should be run. In the United States, especially in the early years, there were various issues. These issues split the United States into 2 political parties. In the early 1800’s, these 2 parties were the Democratic Republicans and the Federalists. Democratic Republicans believed in a

Similar Essays

Who Makes The Final Decision? Essay

1849 words - 7 pages emotional level, citing examples of both positive and negative death experiences. There are no detailed descriptions of what happens to the body as it dies, just discussions of how the dying person might feel and how they might want to experience their last moments of life. Sherwin Nuland takes a much more scientific approach with his book How We Die. In chapter seven, Accidents, Suicide and Euthanasia, Nuland describes in great detail the

Decision Making In A Democracy: The Supreme Court As A National Policy Maker

967 words - 4 pages The significant impact Robert Dahl’s article, “Decision-Making in a Democracy: the Supreme Court as a National Policy-Maker” created for our thought on the Supreme Court it that it thoroughly paved the way towards exemplifying the relationship between public opinion and the United States Supreme Court. Dahl significantly was able to provide linkages between the Supreme Court and the environment that surrounds it in order for others to better

Miranda Vs. Arizona. The Supreme Court Decision Detailed The Principles Governing Police Interrogation: The Miranda Rights

1505 words - 6 pages in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation" (Amar). Simply stated, the Fifth Amendment outlines that anyone who is arrested in the United States has certain rights and privileges that should be spelled out for them at the time of the arrest.On June 13, 1966, the U.S. Supreme Court, in

The Supreme Court Decision Allowing Large Corporations To Run Their Own Political Ads

856 words - 3 pages regulated. However, just before the crucial 2010 midterm congressional election period, this law was partly upended by the United States Supreme Court. In the case of Citizens United versus Federal Election Commission, the Supreme Court, by a 5-4 votes, ruled that corporations and unions were constitutionally allowed to spend as much money as they can on campaign ads supporting particular candidates (Francia, 16). However, the corporations were