What Might Christians Think About The Use Of Animals In Medical Research?

1070 words - 4 pages

What Might Christians Think About The Use Of Animals In medical Research?One of the questions facing society today is whether animals should be used in scientific experimentation. In the midst of this controversy, many ideas about nature, primarily animals, are formed. Each side has different arguments, each one posing questions on the place of humans with respect to animals and the rest of the natural world.Many people argue against using animals for scientific experiments based on the human and nature relationship philosophies of Peter Singer, that humans are not completely above nature, focusing primarily on animals. Singer calls many of the attitudes human beings have toward other animal's speciesism, a concept that can be found throughout history.Aristotle held the view that nature is a hierarchy in which those with less reasoning ability exist for the sake of those with more reasoning ability. Therefore plants exist for the sake of animals, and animals for the sake of man. He based his belief in slavery on the concept that humans with less reasoning ability existed for the purpose of serving more rational humans. Although the view that less rational humans exist to serve rational ones has been rejected by society.Speciesism is practiced by Jews and Christians who base their superiority on God's words in Genesis. They believe that man alone is created in God's image, and man alone is given dominion over all the animals on earth.The scientists of today who lock up chimpanzees in research centres, sometimes under horrendous conditions, to be used in experimentation, practice speciesism. These same scientists, however, would never consider doing that to any human being; even one whose intelligence level was below that of the chimpanzee. The only reason for this difference is that the chimpanzee is not human, no matter how smart it is; but a human, no matter how unintelligent, is still a human. The concept of speciesism is considered by Singer to be as indefensible as racism. Singer bases part of his argument on the utilitarian philosophy of Jeremy Bentham, who stated, "The question is not `Can they reason?' nor `Can they talk?' but `Can they suffer?'" All animals feel anger and fear, pleasure and pain, just like humans, and their equality comes from their ability to feel pain.Those in favour of animal experimentation argue that if animals are not on equal moral status with humans, we are under no moral obligation to restrain from using them. Since anything that is not morally wrong is morally acceptable, then it is morally allowable to use animals in experimentation.Most people supporting the use of animals in experimentation do not feel this means that we are free to harm or abuse animals whenever we wish or that we lack grounds for having moral concerns over animal suffering, especially when caused by humans, but if either a human or animal is to suffer, then it is better for the animal to suffer, because human suffering is generally of more...

Find Another Essay On What might christians think about the use of animals in medical research?

Use of Animals in Biomedical Research

2235 words - 9 pages still up to us. Works Cited Cohen, Carl. "The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research." The Norton Reader. Ed Linda H. Peterson, John C. Brereton, Joan E. Hartman. 10th ed. NewYork: Norton, 2000. Frey, R.G. "All Animals Are Not Equal." Animal Rights: Opposing Viewpoints. Ed Andrew Harnkack. Sand Diegy, 1996. Kluger, Jeffrey; Cray, Dan; Kher, Unmesh. "What Mother Nature Teaches Us About Motherhood." Time 155.19 (8 May

Conducting Medical Research on Animals Essay

1448 words - 6 pages exactly the majority of these medicines are approved and who are the testing dummies that are used to come up with these medication. Conducting medical research with animals has caused break out of legal, scientific, and ethical dilemmas concerning that topic. In this paper I will try to give an unbiased understanding of the research experiments animals have to undergo and the ethical issue that arise supported by Peter Singer. It has been

Wuthering heights: What do we learn about Hindley in the first half of the novel? What do you think about his character and role in the whole novel?

3125 words - 13 pages Wuthering Heights Essay.I)What do you learn about the character of Hindley in these pages and how is he presented.II) Some readers see Hindley as an odd mixture of strength and weakness, of femininity and masculinity. What do you think about his character and role in the whole novel?Hindley is a pivotal character in Wuthering heights and features throughout the novel revealing a number of different aspects to his character. Initially presented

Investigating What Synoptic Gospels Can tell Christians about the Nature of Discipleship

1063 words - 4 pages Investigating What Synoptic Gospels Can tell Christians about the Nature of Discipleship The synoptic gospels not only tell Christians about the nature of Jesus, but the nature of discipleship. The word Synoptic means, "presenting a summary of the principal parts or a general view of the whole". When relating it to the fact that it is a general view of the whole, the Synoptic Gospels show a view of Jesus' life though their

Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman (lens - in literature an author might reveal more about what is bad in the human soul than what is good)

724 words - 3 pages Often times in literature an author might reveal more about what is bad in the human soul, than what is good about the human soul. This can often be a necessity in order for the specific message of a literary work to be conveyed in an accurate manner. One literary work, that could further exemplify this statement is a drama known as Death of a Salesman by Arthur miller. In this fine example of a classic American tradgedy, we get the opportunity

The Use of Mathematics in the Medical Field

1099 words - 4 pages small bag, a nurse would have to convert the original cubic centimeters to milligrams. Just as important as conversions, ratios and proportions also play a huge role in the medical field. Nurses use ratios and proportions when giving medication based on their patient’s weight and height. A doctor may give the order 25 mcg/kg/min. If a patient weighs 114 pounds, how many milligrams of medication should he/she be given per hour? To figure

Should Animals Be Used For Medical Research?

1441 words - 6 pages accelerated by the Medicine Act, 1968, which provided a guide to the use of animals in safety testing. This expansion reflected a growing medical field. In 1986, in UK the Animal Welfare Act was approved, ensuring higher animal care in laboratory. Scientists improved better tests, using less animals and making sure that none received intentionally a fatal dose. Thanks to animals research the 20th century made many medical discoveries, to state few

Use of Animals in Japanese Fables

1572 words - 6 pages Japanese Fables The influence from within and everywhere else. Think back to when you were a child and to when your parents read you stories. Chances are pretty good that some of the stories you encountered were fables. For those people who do not know what a fable is, it is a story that uses animals in the place of using human beings. In researching Japanese tales, I did not have a hard time finding an abundance of fables. In relating fables

How the Example of Jesus Might Help Christians Facing Persecution Today

1103 words - 4 pages How the Example of Jesus Might Help Christians Facing Persecution Today The reason why Jesus is such a help to Christians facing persecution is because he sets the ultimate example through being the virtuous son of God by behaving in a manner that people could look up to. He was intensely persecuted but also a very controlled person. I am now going to analyze three of the stories in Mark's gospel which show that Jesus

The Deplorable Treatment of African Americans in Medical Research

1824 words - 7 pages procedure, medications or lack of treatment. The use of individuals who are poor, uneducated, and lack medical insurance in combination with prestigious university research institutions and the white coated, well-educated researchers motivated by discoveries of cures on the scientific frontier results in abuses of individuals. The ethicacy of human medical research must be brought into question when the studies such as the Tuskegee syphilis and

Concern for the Treatment of Animals Involved in Scientific Research Illustrated in Suzuki's Article, Pain of Animals

598 words - 2 pages that process killing millions of these fruit flies without a single thought. He studied their behaviour on the basis that the fruit flies’ neurophysiology was similar to that of humans and other animals. It is evident in the article that the author struggles to find the balance between research and animal rights. He raises questions that are hard to answer for any human, such as, what gives us the right to alter with our species and organisms

Similar Essays

The Use Of Animals In Medical Research.

993 words - 4 pages medications that prevent death, spare pain, and make life productive and enjoyable have been developed through animal research.Animals, too, benefit vastly from animal research. According to scientists, humans are not the only ones to benefit from animal research. Many of the surgical techniques, diagnostic procedures, and medical treatments developed for humans can also benefit animals. In addition, animal research helps scientists learn more about

The Use Of Animals In Research

808 words - 3 pages battles for the ethical treatment of animals. PETA believes that they are the voice that the animals do not have and stand up for animals used in research. The opponents believe that the use of animals in research is critical to human and animal health as stated by Joy Mench, “According to the National Association for Biomedical Research, ‘virtually every major medical advance of the last century has depended upon research with animals’” (41).The

The Teachings And Beliefs Of Christians About Death And What Might Happen Afterwards

3007 words - 12 pages The Teachings and Beliefs of Christians About Death and What Might Happen Afterwards There are many varied views on the afterlife that Christians hold. Depending on denomination there are many different teachings. The fundamental teaching is that when we die God judges us and depending on that judgement many believe we will either go to heaven or hell. The timing and the manner in which this is done is what varies. Most

The Use Of Non Human Animals In Psychological Research

825 words - 3 pages . Replacement involved using other research methods such as more scan and use of computer simulation instead of using animals. The final R is refinement which involves using procedures that minimises animal suffering. The three Rs has proved to be very successful , for example in the Netherlands over 5000 monkeys were used to produce polio vaccines in the 1970’s during 1990 this number had dropped to about 10 monkeys