This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Moral And Ethical Obligations Do Humans Have To Animals

1887 words - 8 pages

The exponential rise in earth’s human population since the industrial revolution has put a heightened pressure on food production word wide. The global population reached approximately 7.2 billion in 2013 (United Nation News Centre, 2013) and consequentially the requirement for eggs and poultry has also substantially increased (Pluhar, 2010). As a result of this elevated demand for food, there has been a shift in the way agricultural practices operate to produce the large quantities of meat and eggs necessary to feed the population. The intensive farming method of animal husbandry has become quite a controversial issue and caused apprehension amongst many different factions of society. These concerns relate to how high density farming practices result in dangers associated with environmental impacts, human health and non-human welfare. Animal welfare/animal rights groups argue that the conditions in which the animals live are cruel and abhorrent. This notion of cruelty invites debate surrounding the complex and multi-faceted issue of the moral and ethical obligations humans have in respect to other animals. The issue of battery hen farming is further confounded by economic, social, political, and food security issues. For these reasons the issue warrants further investigation. The main focus of the essay is to explore the moral and ethical issues which humans have towards non-human animals using battery hens as a case study to highlight the topic. Ultimately concluding that public opinion seems to be growing in favour of the banning of battery hens.

Animal welfare philosophy:
Philosophers and scholars have long debated the human moral and ethical obligations towards non-human animals. The opposing paradigms of animal ethics are formed by numerous underlying belief systems. The major viewpoints on the issue can be summarised into three categories. Firstly there are indirect theories which reject awarding a moral right to animals on the basis that they lack autonomy, conscience or reason. This side of the argument includes notable subscribers such as Aristotle and Kant. Aristotle views describe a certain pecking order amongst biotic organisms within the natural world. This idea of a pecking order is determined by the abilities present in an organism due to its nature. Aristotle argued that despite plants, animals and humans all being capable of subsistence and flourishing, only humans and animals have the capacity for cognizance. Aristotle therefore reasoned that plants are at the bottom of the pecking order and therefore there purpose is to serve the needs of those higher in the hierarchy. As part of this ideology he theorised that since humans have the endowment of conscious reasoning whilst animals are solely reliant upon instincts, human beings are consequentially superior to non-human animals. Aristotle claimed therefore that it seemed justifiable that the purpose of animals is to serve the needs of humans (Regan and Singer, 1989).

Find Another Essay On What Moral and Ethical Obligations do Humans Have to Animals

Do Animals Have A Say?: Comparative Analysis of Animal Rights, Human Wrongs and Proud to be Speciecist

1437 words - 6 pages Speciesist” by Stephen Rose talk about the concerns of animal rights but display the opposite viewpoints on the use of animals. Regan's argument has a more broad concept to the matter while Rose takes a deeper dive into exacts with an opinionated personal vibe. As the authors continue writing it is obvious that Regan opposes the use of animals for humans and declares it is not justified, and Rose’s contradiction is the idea of humans’ well-being and

What do You Understand by Recombinant DNA Technology? Discuss the Moral, Ethical, Social, Economic and Environmental Issues Associated with the Technology, giving your views

1671 words - 7 pages What do You Understand by Recombinant DNA Technology?Discuss the Moral, Ethical, Social, Economic and Environmental Issues Associated with the Technology, giving your views.There are two essential substances found inside bacterial cells required before the process can begin. Present in the cytoplasm of a bacterial cell are a number of small circular pieces of DNA known as plasmids. Also present within the bacterial cell are restriction enzymes

Do Animals Have Rights and, If So, Should They Be Protected?

696 words - 3 pages people. As a result of killing them and capturing them, many animals are now extinct.One wonders what gave man the right to treat his fellow inhabitants of the earth in this shameful way. Surely animals have rights too. They have a right to live on earth which is also their home. They have a right to breed and to multiply and live with their families; just like we do. It is strange that man has - for a long time - preached that we (humans) must

Assisted Suicide Paper-The need to have an understanding of the moral, legal and ethical issues facing clinicians dealing with end of life issues. .

2100 words - 8 pages Assisted Suicide PaperFebruary 26, 2004AbstractThe need to have an understanding of the moral, legal and ethical issues facing clinicians dealing with end of life issues. Those who treat patients approaching the end of life often face moral, ethical, and legal issues involving shared decision-making, futility, the right to refuse medical treatment, euthanasia, and physician-assisted suicide. This paper will address the following; An overview of

Free Will: Do Humans Have Total Control Over Their Lives?

2514 words - 10 pages Ashworth argues that autonomy is a vital principle in criminal law: “that each individual should be treated as responsible for his or her own behavior” and that “individuals in general have the capacity and sufficient free will to make meaningful choices” . He goes on to suggest that “the principle of autonomy assigns great importance to liberty and individual rights in any discussion of what the state ought to do in a given situation

Do non-sentient entities have moral consideration or standing?

712 words - 3 pages evaporation, and when its water level decreases, it retreats, decreasing evaporation. Another example, when a plant is scratch or its blades are cut after a certain time we observe that the plant compensates for their "injuries".As a conclusion, deciding if any non-sentient entities could have a moral considerability or not could be a difficult task. However many points were discussed that might help speculating an answer for this dogma. We have to be more aware of moral concern boundaries, and see what the criterions to establish those boundaries are.

Moral Obligations and Duties

1881 words - 8 pages to do, not have to do. Duties give people an option and free them from punishment and criticism for not doing what is thought they should have done. Moral obligations states that one is required and bound to meet an obligation. An individual can also be punished for the failure to meet a moral obligation. A witness is not required to report as they are not bound to anyone in the situation or have anyone to be bound to, and, for these reasons, it would be inappropriate if that particular individual were punished externally by third parties. Therefore, when an individual reports cheating, they are fulfilling a duty.

Ethical And Legal Obligations

1694 words - 7 pages Ethical and Legal Obligations Ethical and legal obligations apply to all members of society. As one in society, the obligation to act in an ethical, law abiding manner on a daily basis is vital to the integrity of daily life. Many professions have their own code of ethics. Financial reporting is not exempt from such ethical and legal standards. One’s lively hood depends on decisions made in the business world. Business transactions are

Accounting and Ethical Obligations

1553 words - 6 pages accounting that have ethical implications. 3. Develop "a sense of moral obligation" or responsibility. 4. Develop the abilities needed to deal with ethical conflicts or dilemmas. 5. Learn to deal with uncertainties of the accounting profession. 6. "Set the stage for" a change in ethical behavior. 7. Appreciate and understand the history and composition of all aspects of accounting ethics and their relationship to the general field of ethics.What are

Ethical and Legal Obligations

998 words - 4 pages The FASB (Financial Accounting Standards Board), the SEC (Security and Exchanges Commission), and PCAOB (Public Company Accounting Oversight Board) all work together to decide and determine which standards and concepts are necessary to resolve accounting problems and create a framework for companies to operate within. This allows investors, the government, and other organizations to have a standardized method of financial reporting that allows

How and to what extent does language make humans distinctive from other animals?

1888 words - 8 pages it would be prudent to consider the criteria that categorises human language.Physically speaking, humans require a certain anatomy in order to create speech. The larynx is situated further down the throat which allows us to intonate clearly and produce different sounds. However, this physicality poses a greater risk of choking as food passes directly across the trachea. Other animals do not have this anatomy so therefore physically cannot speak

Similar Essays

Moral And Ethical Obligations To Animals

2304 words - 9 pages having issues comprehending what the NHRP is actually trying to achieve (, 2014). At this point in time, the potential bodily rights of these nonhuman persons is hanging in the balance of the courts. To ensure we as a race are fulfilling our moral and ethical obligations we must minimise the suffering of any living being. Amending the guidelines and codes of practices to be a globally recognised set of strict regulations is

Ethical Obligations To Circus Animals Essay

1000 words - 4 pages humans do in fact have an ethical obligation to circus animals, and that these animals should be afforded similar ethical rights to humans. If this is the case, then, due to the demonstrably lacklustre physical, legal and psychological treatment of circus animals, humans have blatantly violated these rights and neglected to fulfil said obligation in contemporary times. Cumulatively, it is evident that humans have several ethical obligations to

Do Animals Have Emotions? Essay

1289 words - 5 pages week went by and Rocco still didn't want to eat or do anything. We were getting worried because we felt like Rocco was killing himself, and that's what happened. Rocco died one week after my grandfather and we knew that was because he got sad or maybe depressed. The dog could live without my grandpa; the dog felt lonely and that's what killed him.Many people say that animals don't have emotions or feelings. Some people say that animals are just

Do Animals Have Thought? Essay

2019 words - 8 pages communication. Humans are able to talk with complex syntax, creating and understanding novel sentences that they may have never encountered before. Apart from rare laboratory manipulations, non human- animals do not communicate with syntactical complexity; but that does not mean that they do not have thought. Thoughts can still be there without a human- like language (Hauser). This philosophy counters that of Daniel C. Dennett, who believes that although