What The Butler Saw, By Joe Orton

1045 words - 4 pages

In order to effectively display a certain discontent with society, an author must have the ability to illustrate the specific flaws that exist within that mainstream society. In What the Butler Saw, Joe Orton does an excellent job in illustrating how abuse of authority can have a subversive effect on an individual’s personality. Throughout the play, Orton uses authority as a tool to illustrate how it has the ability to alter a patient’s personality and provoke madness through psychiatric practice. Regarding Sam Shepard’s True West, Shepard is able to illustrate the exchange of personality traits between two brothers. Comparatively, it is evident that both authors effectively display their discontent with mainstream society. However, Joe Orton is more effective in displaying his discontent because his play illustrates a greater degree of personality shifts that exists between the characters. In essence, both plays exhibit traits that do not belong in mainstream society. These traits include the exchange of personality between characters and identity confusion. However, each of these traits is driven by a social catalyst introduced by the authors to illustrate the evolution of the characters involved.
In What the Butler Saw, Joe Orton places a strong emphasis on authority and how it plays into the characters development. The perception of abused authority is central to his play since it gives him the opportunity to illustrate the influence it has on the characters and the level of madness it provokes. Being set in a psychiatric clinic, Orton is able to submit each character under different trials of authority and allow the readers to observe the effect it has on them. In Orton’s society, psychiatrists are viewed to possess absolute authority. To challenge that, Orton attempts to subvert that authority. This is accomplished when the readers observe Dr. Rance and his examination of Geraldine. This examination is viewed to be unconventional since it ridicules proper psychiatric methods. Dr. Rance is convinced that Geraldine is a victim of incest prior to even examining her. He asks her if her father has ever sexually assaulted her, but Geraldine replies with a “No” (382). However, Dr. Rance refuses to acknowledge her responses and retorts by saying “She may mean ‘Yes’ when she says ‘No’” (382). As a result, Geraldine feels helpless in this situation since there is nothing Geraldine can say that will change his mind.
Orton uses this scene to illustrate how authority can be abused. In our society, a psychiatrist will listen to the patient and provide a response that will benefit the patient. Instead, Dr. Rance is portrayed as someone who interprets others words to fit his preconceived theories by asserting his authority over them, “The vehemence of her denials is proof of positive guilt” (382). Orton ridicules this psychiatric method as it leads neither to truth nor understanding.
In addition, Joe Orton uses Dr. Prentice’s attempt at seduction...

Find Another Essay On What the Butler Saw, by Joe Orton

Touching The Void by Joe Simpson

1704 words - 7 pages As two experienced climbers gazed upon the majestic snow packed, Peruvian Andes, with the sun glistering off the icy peaks, the possibility of the mountains being their snowy graves never crossed their mind. Touching The Void was written by Joe Simpson; publication of this memoir was by Harper Collins Publishers on February 3, 2004. Not only will young and old adults enjoy this book, anyone with sense of adventure can be captivated with the

Defy The Darkness by Joe Rosenblum

737 words - 3 pages works, he eventually found a family that owned a farm. This family were the Zbanskis. They let Joe work for their farm, cleaning the animals and feeding them. Every so often, Joe snuck out to his family, giving them bits of bread and cheese. Then one day, Rosenblum’s family were captured by the Germans. He discovers that only his father had escaped and survived the boxcar trains. Eventually, he learns that his father died. Joe decided to quit

"Leda and the Swan" by William Butler Yeats

1430 words - 6 pages Analyse William Butler Yeats's "Leda and the swan", paying particular attention to the poem's argument, but also focusing on the way meaning is conveyed and modified by rhyme scheme, meter, rhyme and stanzaic form. In the course of your discussion of this text, you must discuss what extent the texts genre has affected your analysis, given your knowledge of that genre's conventions and history. 1500 words maxW.B. Yeat's mythological poem "Leda

Among The School Children by William Butler Yeats

1445 words - 6 pages Among School Children by William Butler Yeats First Published 1927; collected in The Tower, 1928 Type of Poem Meditation The Poem William Butler Yeats' "'Among School Children'' is written in eight eight-line stanzas that follow a precise rhyme scheme. Along with the straightforward title, stanza I establishes the immediate context of the action in deliberately prosaic language. The speaker is visiting a schoolroom, and "'a kind old

Significance of Organizational Change in Robbins' Awaken the Giant Within and Gladwell's What the Dog Saw

914 words - 4 pages I’ve been reading two books during the past couple of weeks, “Awaken the Giant Within” by Tony Robbins and “What the Dog Saw” by Malcolm Gladwell. Whenever I read a book, I read it with an eye towards lessons or insight I can use in organizational change. Robbins’ book is full of insight; Gladwell’s has its moments. These disparities of insight stem from the difference in construction and intent of the two books. Robbins wrote his book as a

I Saw Abigail Williams with the Devil in the Crucible by Arthur Miller

731 words - 3 pages . Though, in the film this phantom part is actually depicted. This succeeds in showing that Abigail is the central antagonistic girl. During the play, Abigail is exerting her tyrannical grip on the town girls of Salem; she explains to them the situation as she explained to reverend Parris about what happened in the woods: that they had only danced. Thusly, there is a change in the actions taken by Abigail, to get Betty Parris to be quite, in order

"Leda and the Swan" by William Butler and "The Iliad" by Homer

1139 words - 5 pages By The viewpoint of both stories where the Gods are described as being impersonal is just a manifestation that God's see humans as play things.In the Iliad, most of what the Gods do to humans have in large part have to do with their respect for fate. Fate is the predestined end for all mankind which Zeus chooses for everybody. If a God has a grudge against a human for not supplicating to ask him for assistance the God cannot help his enemy to

Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe vs. The Second Coming by William Butler Yeats

506 words - 2 pages which happen during their time. We can be more specific and see what the poet and writer exactly talk about. It is better to focus on the poem first as it was written before the novel. In his poem William butler Yeats is shocked by the events which were happening during the First World War. “Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world, The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere the ceremony of innocence is drowned…”, he tries to picture the dark ages

Comparison Between Things Fall Apart by Achebe and The Second Coming” by William Butler Yeats

1054 words - 5 pages When people and scholars read “The Second Coming” by William Butler Yeats, many are shocked by the stunning and frightening description of what he perceives will happen during the “second coming”. He describes violent and terrifying images, describes the world he lives in, as well as the judgment it will receive. While the purpose and meaning of Yeats’ poem has never been fully understood, a connection can be made between “The Second Coming

Forever War by Joe Haldeman and Halo and The Fall of Reach by Eric Nylund

1262 words - 5 pages The presentation and use of military personnel in the “Forever War” by Joe Haldeman and “Halo: The Fall of Reach” by Eric Nylund illustrate how science fiction depicts these individuals as disposable and replaceable. The negative treatment of soldiers can result in various mental problems and unnatural relationships if conditions remain the same. Although the characters in these stories are fictional, the mistreatment of military personnel can

An Analysis of the Poem A Prayer for My Daughter by William Butler Yeats

1553 words - 6 pages "A Prayer for My Daughter" is a poem written by William Butler Yeats in 1919. This poem is a prayer-like poem. And it generally tells about the poet's ideas about his daughter who is sleeping at the same time while the poem is being told. Throughout the poem Yeats reflects how he wants his daughter's future to be. This essay will analyze the poem in three sections: 1- What does this poem mean?, 2- The poetic devices, imagery, rhyming, figures

Similar Essays

What The Dog Saw Essay

1037 words - 5 pages What the Dog Saw: and other Adventures Malcolm Gladwell is an English-Canadian journalists who wrote an extraordinary piece of work called “What the Dog Saw: and other Adventures.” In this book there are 19 stories, two specifically have a common theme these two stories are called the Ketchup Conundrum and True Colors. The Ketchup Conundrum discusses how diverse mustard is compared to ketchup

"In What The Shepherd Saw" Text Analysis

967 words - 4 pages of each one is that that there is a wife who belongs to the elite and she is beautiful. Her husband as a man of high position feels jealous about her and decides to take revenge against the one who is thought to be her lover because of the disgrace caused to him as a result of such an illegal relationship. This idea is tackled differently however in the three texts. This is supplemented by critical reading of the three texts as below. In What

The Second Coming By William Butler Yeats

640 words - 3 pages The Second Coming, written by William Butler Yeats, could only be interpreted in one way. First you must take into consideration, the state of Yeats' motherland at the time when this was written. Ireland was in the state of civil war and the idea of The Second Coming of Christ was a desperate cry in the form of a poem. The New Testament illustrates The Second Coming as a period of tribulation. Yeats wished that The Second Coming would purify the

"The Second Coming" By William Butler Yeats

1171 words - 5 pages William Butler Yeats wrote his "The Second Coming" in January of 1919, three years after the Easter Rebellion of 1916 and after the First World War had ravaged Europe from 1914 until 1918. Chinua Achebe wrote Things Fall Apart, his first novel, in 1958, just two years prior to the establishment of an independent Nigerian state. These two seemingly unrelated pieces of literature are actually more related to each other than just the title.All of