This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Were The Commonalities And Differences Of Zionism And Arab Nationalism In Palestine? The Israel And Palestine Conflict Essay

1818 words - 8 pages

Zahraa Choudhury
History of Israel and The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Tutor- Fadi Mansour
Zahraa Choudhury
What were the commonalities and differences of Zionism and Arab nationalism in Palestine?
In order to fully considerate the commonalities and differences between Zionism and Arab Nationalism a clear definition of both needs to be understood. A general definition of Zionism is; a movement that supports a Jewish national homeland in Palestine (Motyl, page 604, 2001) while Arab nationalism can be explained as an ideology that promotes the unity of Arab people and calls for rejuvenation and political union in the Arab world (Dawisha, 2003). As this essay focuses on Palestine it is important to note that while Palestinian nationalism is somewhat similar to Arab Nationalism, it largely focuses on self-determination for the Palestinian people and for self-determination in and sovereignty over Palestine ( Waart, page 223, 1994).
The most important period of development for Zionism and Arab Nationalism in Palestine was laid in the nineteenth and twentieth century and although they began independently, it can be argued they developed and evolved as a response to each other which has led to both movements becoming intertwined and having inherent similarities and differences. As the nineteenth and twentieth century were the most significant era of development for Zionism and Arab Nationalism this essay will focus on these periods.
There are many commonalities and differences of Zionism and Arab Nationalism which cannot all be explored, but in this essay I will research how the roots of both movements are similar as well as how western influence largely supported Zionism and how fundamentally it allowed the success of the Jewish national home movement.
The first and main similarity between Zionism and Arab nationalism is the belief that their origins is in Palestine. Many Jewish Zionists state that their homeland is in Palestine as some intellects argue ‘Jewish nationality is inseparable from the inheritance of its ancestors, the holy land, and the eternal city, the birthplace of belief in the divine unity of life’ (Seltzer, page 688, 1980). From a Zionists point of view, Palestine belongs to the Jewish people and the creation of Israel was just the recognition of this. Khalidi writes that Palestinians believe that the land belongs to them as they have ties to the land, local loyalties’ and a religious history; all these factors in culmination created the Palestinian national identity (Khalidi, page 27, 1997).This similarity is important to note as the two national identities’ are rooted in this particular area and to put it simply, their belief that Palestine/Israel is their home is one of the main causes of conflict in the Middle East.
One of the commonalities that Zionism and Arab nationalism share is the circumstances that fuelled the creation of both movements. Both movements ‘asserted their identity without the trappings of an independent...

Find Another Essay On What were the commonalities and differences of Zionism and Arab nationalism in Palestine? - The Israel and Palestine conflict - essay

Media Manipulation and America's Favoritism of Israel in the Israel-Palestine Conflict

4065 words - 16 pages % of victims have been… women, and the elderly… and that over 80% of Palestinians killed for “curfew violations” have been children” (Calm). The final tool used by biased newspapers is to use true facts to draw false conclusions. Many journalists in American media conclude that the killings of the Israel-Palestine conflict are tragic and reaching enormous amounts. Yet, these numbers are often presented without a realistic ratio comparing

The Question of Palestine and Israel

1321 words - 5 pages birth of Israel and on into the foreseeable future, with new groups and tactics and with outside influences weighing in on the conflict, the question of Palestine and Israel is not likely to be answered soon. K.B Nasr (as cited in White, 2008, pp. 199) states that as the Ottoman Empire was crumbling, the Zionist Movement was just beginning. With the downfall of the Turks, the Arabs embraced nationalism for the former Turkish lands

The Peace Process of Israel and Palestine

2391 words - 10 pages -Palestinian conflict is a classic example of disharmony created by the lack of "fit" between nations and states. There are two traditional solutions to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict: a two-state solution and a one-state solution. This doesn't mean the "statelet" that has been created in Palestinian Authority, but rather Israel and a larger Palestinian entity in the West Bank and Gaza. For the Jews who contend that the land of Israel was

Israel and Palestine

1757 words - 7 pages Israel and Palestine The Arab-Israel conflict is a story which has taken place over a century. In order to understand the conflict between these two cultures their collective histories must be taken into consideration. It was a long and hard path for the Jewish population to get a piece of land they can call their own. A land free of religious persecution. I think that history has shown that these two states can not and will not be able to

Israel and Palestine

723 words - 3 pages the accords. This was the first step towards peace in a long time between the warring nations, and one that many people believed was going to bring an end to the fighting. These accords were significant because it was the first time that Israel ever recognized the Palestinian Liberation Organization as representatives of Palestine.      The purpose of Oslo was to pull out all of the Israeli troops from the West Bank and

Palestine and Israel

1257 words - 5 pages kill innocent Palestinians on streets and bomb and destroy their buildings as well. In the case of Israel and Palestine, both of them claim that they are right. However, both are equally guilty of terrorism. This is demonstrated when the Palestinians send suicide bombers into Israel and Israel strikes back at the Palestinian army and civilians. They both believe God is on their side, so they think that what they are doing is right. In addition

Palestine and Israel

1472 words - 6 pages Israeli athletes were murdered by Arafat’s forces that were now the heads of the PLO (Palestine Liberation Organization). After the Attack Arafat made a UN appearance and showed evidence towards peace. Finally in 1977 Egypt and Israel make peace with each other. Other Arab nations were infuriated by the Egyptian peace treaty and made separate treaties with Israel. Even after the few years of peace Israel continued to define its borders by

Palestine and Israel

2510 words - 10 pages Palestine and Israel Our views of world conflicts such as war are influenced by the part of the world in which we live. When exploring media coverage of discord, it is important to think about where the author is from and how it has influenced the way he/she has portrayed disharmony. Reports on a world conflict can express extremely different views depending on the social values and understandings of the writers. One must read articles

Conflicts Between Palestine and Israel

1060 words - 5 pages Introduction The conflict between Israel and Palestine is on going. Through different issues like border security and control of Jerusalem, but the major issue is the religion issue. In this report, there are two unresolved issues about the Palestine refugees and Israeli Security Concerns. Palestine is on the east coast of the Mediterranean Sea, to the west of Jordan and to the south of the Lebanon. The total surface areas of Palestine are

Israel Palestine Conflict

1272 words - 6 pages when it became a conflict between Israel and the Palestinian Arab people. In 1956, there was an Israeli attack on Egypt, in collaboration with France and Britain. Then around 1967 was when the Arab-Israeli War started. This was when Israel launched an air attack on Egypt, Jordan, and Syria in response to the request by the Egyptian President, Nasser, that the UN withdraw its forces from the Egyptian territory and the buildup of Arab armies along

Isreal and Palestine Conflict in the Film Occupation 101

908 words - 4 pages Israel, Israel was born in 1948 and has been at war with the palestine on and off since and i don't see an end to the conflict anytime soon, the danger for israel isn't outside of its borders its on the inside with constant threat of suicide bombers.On one street in jerusalem there were 3 bombers in one day cause they would set the first on off and then wait for the paramedics then blow up the other the last 15 years there had been 34 terriost

Similar Essays

The Israel And Palestine Conflict Essay

1443 words - 6 pages forcible exiled from their land, the people kept faith with it throughout their diaspora and never ceased to pray and hope for their return…. By virtue of our natural and historic right… we hereby declare the establishment of a Jewish State in the Land of Israel.” --Israel’s Declaration of Independence, May 15, 1948 “Palestine… is where the Palestinian Arab people were born, on which it grew, developed and exceled…. [Its] willed dispossession

The Conflict Between Palestine And Israel

2143 words - 9 pages Zionist from Vilna Poland on his journey to Palestine in 1926. Jews already began moving to Palestine because of the trouble they were having in Europe. Their settlement in Palestine was highly organized and began to expand at a quick rate. The Jewish developed a fund that helped them purchase large amounts of land. 9 That is what ultimately began the conflict between the Jews and Arabs. After being conquered by the Ottoman Empire for a long

The Israel Palestine Conflict Essay

1210 words - 5 pages Arab nations have continued to denounce Israel and their right to exist, or worked towards destructing Israel by hatred and funding terrorist operations. Upon thinking about what the Palestinian's views were on the hope and aspirations of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, I decided to contact the Palestinian Consulate personally. I spoke to Nabil Abuznaid of the Palestinian Consulate in Washington D.C. I asked Mr.Abuzanaid what Palestine's hopes

The Israel Palestine Conflict Essay

1523 words - 6 pages The Israel-Palestine Conflict The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a part of the greater Arab-Israeli long-running conflict in the Middle East. The main point of this conflict is the existence of the state of Israel and its relations with Arab states and with the Palestinian population in the area. The idea and concept of Israel was born in the mid 19th century. Jews of Europe and America wanted a