What Would Aristotle Have Thought About A State Lottery? This Essay Uses Aristotle's Views On Justice To Evaluate The Morality Of A State Lottery.

688 words - 3 pages

One aspect of justice, which Aristotle elaborated on, was that which was concerned with a fair distribution and proportionate equality. These aspects are directly related to the debate about whether a state lottery would be unjust toward those citizens of the state who are the least able to afford it. For the sake of argument we will assume that a lottery is a disproportionate tax on the poor, who are more inclined to play hoping of financial rescue. Aristotle would have agreed with the side of the argument thinking this is unjust, because he thought that what is harmful as well as choice worthy should be distributed proportionately. This applies to our debate in that the poor people who play the lottery more often than the rich would foot a large amount of tax money. This is harmful to the poor in that since they are poor they should not be throwing away money to such a high-risk endeavor. It would be beneficial to the rich in that a large portion of the tax burden would be pushed onto someone else.Justice, Aristotle said, "is the virtue in accord with which the just person is said to do what is just in accord with his decision, distributing good things and bad, both between himself and others and between others." (1134a 3-5) The lottery would clearly not fit into this description because the poor class would suffer the majority of the bad distribution. Aristotle would have argued that the advocates of the lottery are not just because "the just is in some way proportionate." (1131a 30) Aristotle also said, "he does not award too much of what is choice worthy to himself and too little to his neighbor (and the reverse what is harmful, but awards what is proportionately equal.)" (1134a 5-6) The rich would not be as tempted to play as the poor would because financial problems are not as much of a concern to them. Even if the rich did play it would not do any noticeable harm. Since the lottery would be harmful to the poor and...

Find Another Essay On What would Aristotle have thought about a state lottery? This essay uses Aristotle's views on justice to evaluate the morality of a state lottery.

Chivalry, Politically Incorrect? <Tab/>Who would have thought that chivalry, a sense of justice, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system?

782 words - 3 pages Chivalry, Politically Incorrect?Who would have thought that chivalry, the idealization of virtue, military courtesy, a sense of justice, unconditional devotion, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system? Who would accuse the medieval King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table principles as unjust or thought of as an object of scorn? Present day American society, that's who would dare to attack such a

Criminal Justice In Saudia Arabia: A State Of Secrecy

1761 words - 7 pages Criminal Justice in Saudi Arabia: A State of Secrecy Forms of criminal justice vary throughout the world. They vary in procedures of law, punishments, and treatment of prisoners. Saudi Arabia is one country that deals with criminal justice very differently than most. Saudi Arabia practices some appalling acts on its prisoners, along with discriminatory practices against women and other minorities. Saudi Arabia has committed itself to

Interpretation of "The Lottery" by Shirly Jackson-A tale of pointless violence, inhumanity, and senseless adherence, while unintentionally enlightening the readers with a morality lesson.

1093 words - 4 pages hurry to get through this deadly crime. The very detail of the timing shows the town's nonchalant outlook on the tradition of murdering a beloved neighbor for a routine sacrifice. "We better get started, get this over with, so's we can go back to work." Mr. Summers announced to the immersed crowd. The villagers accept this practice with out thinking about the seriousness and brutality of the event. With the custom being so common to the people

Explore the way Shirley Jackson uses symbolism in "The Lottery" to develop theme.

613 words - 2 pages is an application of symbolism introduced by Shirley Jackson to reveal the necessity for people to examine traditions.The story commences with a false innocence: A beautiful summer morning, a tiny little uncivilized village. Everyone in the village knows each other well. In such a peaceful atmosphere, an annual lottery activity takes place on the 27th of June as a ritual of the village. Superficially, this lottery activity is recognized as a

How to Have a Cooperative Relationship Between State and the People

1152 words - 5 pages Joel S. Migdal defines uses an ideal-typed definition of the state as an organization, composed of numerous agencies led and coordinated by the state’s leadership that has the ability or authority to make and implement the binding rules for all the people as well as the parameters of rule making for other social organizations in a given territory, using force if necessary to have its way. He claims that a state’s ability to survive depends on

Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement: "It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any...

517 words - 2 pages International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller

Hobbes' views on humanity. Is this conception of humanity accurate, that is, is man a self-preserving and anti-social machine? Are humans ultimately selfish and perpetually in a state of conflict?

2561 words - 10 pages fearful of others, whether it be of what they thought or said.By now, one begins to wonder about volunteers and organ donors. Is one left to believe that they too have some selfish thought? Hobbes' states two (2) things about man, that they are selfish, which means wanting only their own good and care nothing about others, and that they are an anti-social machine. Hobbes' definition of selfishness might be a bit extreme when comparing it to

The Ghost in Hamlet.What people in Shakespeare's England would have known and thought about ghosts.

2939 words - 12 pages offenses committed in this life as do notmerit eternal damnation, or in which they fully satisfy the justice of God for sinsthat have been forgiven. After this purgation from the impurities of sin, the soulsare believed to be received into heaven."The Catholic religion was demanding of its believers in that they must follow the word of the bible at all times. Refraining from using foul language and basically being as pious as a monk or priest would

Critically Assess the Pluralist and Marxist Views of the State

1753 words - 7 pages . The pluralist view of the state came about as an objection to state sovereignty, out of fear that the state would remain totalitarian if power was only exercised within the state as opposed to distributed amongst society as a whole (Schwarzmantel, 1994; Smith, 2006). Pluralists ‘are said to have a naive theory of how the state behaves ‘neutrally’ in a liberal democracy’ (Dunleavy and O’Leary, 1987:41), as it is impossible for the state to

Gay Marriages...My teacher asked us to write an essay on gay marriages, and if we thought they would be legalized all over the US. Because of the "full faith and credit act" states have...

561 words - 2 pages major problem is that if states do choose to recognize a gay marriage as legal, such marriages may not be valid in those states because of the full faith and credit act. This presents a number of problems and a tremendous amount of opposition within the fifty states. On top of all that, there would be the question of what to do about federal rights like immigration, Social Security, and federal tax law. Our nation has enough problems as it is; it

Conflicting Views: Separation of Church and State

537 words - 2 pages dramatic increase of crime and a general drop in students' grades I feel a large part has to do with a traditional upbringing. Religion has almost completely vanished from today's schools and in the general public. With the federal government funding relatively everything today, one can litigate almost anything in regards to "state-sponsored religion." The question some are asking now is where will this stop? In the end, I agree with those who favor the non-separation of church and state, and the people who wish to express their religious views around the world.

Similar Essays

Essay On The Lottery And What A Thought

988 words - 4 pages after World War II, however it is unknown as to when Jackson wrote "What A Thought".               "The Lottery" and "What A Thought" follow Shirley Jackson's usual scheme of shock value. Both stories show of how quickly, no matter what length of time people have coincided together and bonded together, one can turn on another. "The Lottery" showed of how a small everyday town will do anything to hold their traditional

Tennessee State Lottery Essay

972 words - 4 pages , Alabama and South Carolina are all states that have passed a lottery and have had test averages triple since they have been initiated. Theoretically Tennessee schools would find themselves higher on the scale of nationwide public institutions, making Tennessee a more respected state and ultimately stripping it of the stereotypical collection of rednecks and illiterate people. Tennessee could be recognized as another admirable place to live and

This Paper Argues That Aristotle's High Minded Personality Would Not Make A Good Friend, And Examines The Works Of Aristotle.

1547 words - 6 pages In this paper, I will argue that Aristotle's high-minded person will not make a good friend. By identifying that a high-minded person will not befriend an inferior one, there is no dispute that Aristotle would not make a good friend.Friends are mirror images of themselves. They will reflect back what is good as well as what is not good about each other. This is why the high-minded Aristotle would not make a good friend to most people. High

The Lottery, A Response To The Short Story 'the Lottery' Written By Shirley Jackson (1919 1965) Thesis Statement: The People Of The Community Have No Real Knowledge Of This Barbaric Ceremony.

617 words - 2 pages The LotteryThe community has no real knowledge of this ceremony. It seems ridiculous that a community would cling to such a barbaric tradition, especially when they don't even know the correct way to do it. It becomes apparent this community is very weak-minded. Even the way they congregated at the lottery was done systematically in a sexist way. This community could be convinced to do anything. There are so many points in the story that show