When Students Grade Teachers Essay

922 words - 4 pages

When Students Grade Teachers
When it comes to evaluations in education, usually the teacher evaluates the student. Although in certain college level courses, the weight is shifted to the students, allowing them to have the power to evaluate their own professors, possibly affecting their careers. It seems odd enough that a student should grade their teacher, but even stranger is that technically students have the ability to control their teachers’ positions, only by filling out a single form. Of course the forms may have excellent remarks from the students, but usually when students are given the chance to anonymously share their opinion, this does not always occur. In these situations, the teachers are put on the spot, being evaluated by their very own students, leading to various negatives which exemplify that student evaluations of teachers should not be a major consideration in the rehiring or promotion of a teacher.
Many may disagree in my opinion due to the fact that there is a large percentage of students who like their teachers and grades received, all being fair reasons to be opposed. Certain students may favor a professor and the class that they teach, causing them to positively evaluate them, which allows for the possibility of the professor be promoted. This clearly explains why these students see student evaluations of teachers as a good thing. Even with this being said, I find myself disagreeing in that student evaluations of teachers will only lead to negative events such as specific teachers
Tishman 2
who are undeserving of a promotion receiving one, as well as numerous judgments being made from one piece of paper.
Oftentimes students find themselves disliking their teacher or professor because of their grades, causing them to evaluate their teacher in a demeaning manner. In order to prevent students from depicting their educators as the antagonists, it is important to only use the student-teacher evaluations for purposes irrelevant to promoting. Dr. Charles Ross, Dean of the Cook-Cole College of Arts and Sciences says, “If somebody gets a low score on that, then you can actually talk to them about how to make their presentation clearer and more organized." (). For instance, if the headmaster of a school notices that a certain professor is receiving negative remarks, this should be a clue for him or her to inspect the classroom, other than jumping to conclusions. According to Justin Pope’s article titled “Tables turn on college profs when students grade teachers”, studies have shown that professors who give good grades get better reviews. (). Students often dislike teachers because they do not have the grade they desire, although this has nothing to do with the...

Find Another Essay On When Students Grade Teachers

Departmentalization in Elementary Schools Essay

1599 words - 6 pages . Students who have what they need in school have a better attitude towards learning and are more optimistic. One of the splendid effects about departmentalization is the flexibility for gifted children and learning disabilities. Students can switch between grade levels when they need to. This is especially helpful since there are teachers who specialize in certain subjects and can be a help the child in their quest for fulfilling the optimal

The Use of Code-Switching in Teaching English as a Second Language

1267 words - 6 pages sometimes it does not work. One more problem occurs when we know that every single student has a different linguistic competence. The implication of this problem is teachers have to be really careful in choosing TT that they use in the class. The problems above make the teachers have to explore their proficiency in explaining, asking, or giving instruction to the students. Some difficulties in using TT make the teachers apt to use some language

Creative writing

879 words - 4 pages gives, the easiness of his tests, the leniency of the marking, their appearance, temper and such other things that appeal to the students and make the teacher a "favorite" among kids but do not generally reveal his effectiveness. But such an attitude is not good for the students in the long run. The grading may threaten the teachers and they may even change their attitude to score good with such students as their grade may be likely to spell the

The Effects Of Grade Retention

972 words - 4 pages . Statistically, with as many as 15% of all American students held back each year and 30-50% held back at least once before ninth grade, the rate of retention has increased by approximately 40% in the last 20years (Wu et al, 2010). This paper will give the reader an overview of the effects grade retention has on students academic performance, socialization and how it eventually leads them to dropout of school. A number of scholarly articles will be used to

Basic Reading Skills Analysis Report Concerning the Learners

1094 words - 5 pages to the number of students that are on free or reduce lunch. The school has around 500 students with grades K-6. The school also has a developmental preschool. There are 3 to 4 teachers in each grade level 1-3 and 2 to 3 teachers in grades 4-6th. In third grade there are 75 students. Due to our district policy I was unable to get the complete ethnicity makeup of the school. Learner Group Attitudes Most of the students have a positive


2234 words - 9 pages this system needs to be a shared responsibility amongst every part involved. An administration cannot accept credit when the program is a success, and deny any culpability if the students begin to do poorly. This leaves the teachers as scapegoats for the process if accountability is not shared by all.ProfessorsProfessors are credited with the much of the blame when it comes to grade inflation. In an interview conducted for the article "Faculty

Curriculum Mapping and Alignment, NCATE Assessment

1195 words - 5 pages teacher confidence when sharing instructional strategies. Feedback and support from ones peers are important motivators and can help keep the focus on student learning. As a school leader, the principal can help teachers develop processes for identifying a starting place for individual students when it comes to the taught curriculum. (Jackson, 2010) Teachers cannot simply use the curriculum as a checklist without accounting for individual

Mandatory Retention: Good or Bad?

1013 words - 5 pages mandatory retention policy. Holding a student back a grade has a host of negative affects on the student’s life. Most serious, is the chance of dropping out of high school, massively increases when a child is retained. A study by Melissa Roderick in 1994 shows how retention influences dropout rates. The percentage of students who were retained once in kindergarden to eighth grade was about 21% and of those students almost 70% dropped out. The

Co-teaching: A Service Delivery Model Using Two Teachers

2098 words - 8 pages ). Solo teaching is defined as one qualified teacher plans, teaches, and improves student education and learning (Cook & Friend, 2004). The problem I identified at the beginning of my research was that (at my school) co-teaching ended when students entered middle school. 2nd-5th grade received co-teachers in their core classes: math, science, reading and social studies. Once they hit sixth grade, it was one teacher per subject (except P.E.). However

Fear in Today's Schools

968 words - 4 pages . When I was in school, the students ran the school by spreading fear into the teachers' hearts. They would torture the teachers they didn't like by putting laxatives in their coffee or water in their gas tank. There was one student who didn't turn in an assignment all year but had good grades on tests, so he was passing. At the end of the year he turned in all of his assignments to the principal to show the teacher's failure to grade homework and

Crucial Methods In Order to Achieve Successful Teaching

1113 words - 4 pages The purpose of this paper is to review three peer review articles on excellence in teaching a first grade class and or an elementary level class. In order to be successful in a classroom a teacher must be up to date with the latest methods for enhancing their lessons and abilities for students to learn. It is important for teachers to have supportive interactions with their students in order for the student’s achievements to be successful. It is

Similar Essays

Perception Of 4th Year Ece Students To The Implications Of The Proposed Abolishment Of The Retention Grade

1687 words - 7 pages Over the years, there is a need to improve the quality of education. Schools are encouraged to adapt grade retention to set academic standards. Moreover, when a student has failed to meet grade-level competencies, retaining the child is one of the considered solution for development. And more understanding of the set of courses of the retained grade that will help the students to be prepared to attain the academic and social standards of the

Grade Inflation: What Seems To Be A Dream Is In Reality A Nightmare

1220 words - 5 pages (Dictionary.com, 2014). As a result, students receive a huge surprise in university, as their grade drop significantly compared to their high school grades. Grade inflation stems from many sources, such as influences of parents, teachers, students and even from competition between schools. Regardless of the reason, grade inflation has a huge impact on current and future students, as grades for the most part act as a golden ticket into their desired

Teachers' Attitudes Toward Inclusion Essay

597 words - 2 pages successful, where as in-service teachers were less agreeable. Pre-service teachers reported a belief that inclusion is academically effective for special needs students. Teachers generally rely on classroom experience rather than formal theory when making decisions about practice. Pre-service teachers rely on what they are currently learning in school since their experience is limited. This study confirms the need to combine both experience and

Ethics In An Academic Environment, Grade Inflation

2262 words - 9 pages the concept that most have in mind when referring to formal education. Goldman feels that grade inflation is "The upward shift in the grade point average (GPA) of students over an extended period of time without a corresponding increase in student achievement." This can be due to a number of reasons according to Coplin, teachers are doing better jobs teaching than they did in the past, Universities have become lax, because they pay more attention