Where Process Improvement Projects Go Wrong Essay

709 words - 3 pages

The article, “Where Process-Improvement Projects Go Wrong,” by Satya L. Chakrvorty, WSJ.com, January 25, 2010 (http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000), offers a great example of how and why many Six Sigma and other process improvement projects fail. He examines what happened at an aerospace company that initiated a number of process improvement projects, half of which ultimately failed.
I chose this article because I have been involved in process improvement projects that were quite successful. However, upon examination of the same company several years later the process improvement projects had faded away, and bad habits had returned.
In this article, teams from the various aerospace company’s departments were set up to examine their processes and seek ways to become more efficient. At the beginning, the team members were excited and were exceeding their goals for improvement. Upper management watched the project carefully, and team members were rewarded and praised for achieving their set goals. Management was convinced that the project was going well.
However, hidden within the project’s success were the seeds of failure.
With teams trained and all processes in place, the Six Sigma expert moved on to other projects, and the responsibility for reporting to upper management was left to the team leaders. Without the help of a trained process improvement leader, some teams became confused when analyzing their progress. Others committed so much time to the process improvement project that their work suffered. The middle management leaders soon were reporting only their successes, and began to emphasize what they intended to do rather than what was actually happening. Upper management, assuming that the project was going well, focused elsewhere, leaving the teams to fend for themselves.
It is obvious from this article, and my own personal experience, that when management does not give continued support and encouragement to a project, that it is likely to lose its original purpose. In the case of the aerospace company the teams began to regress to the old processes and habits. Team members began pushing their own personal goals. Management continued to receive positive reports, though little progress was...

Find Another Essay On Where Process-Improvement Projects Go Wrong

WGU Task 2 - Organizational Systems

2631 words - 11 pages member of pharmacy who will be participating in the verification of the orders, a nursing manager from the unit who will be responsible for their staff being trained and practicing the new procedure and a member of risk management who is knowledgeable in the process of performing a FMEA. C2. Pre-Steps The FMEA looks at what could go wrong (failure mode), why would failure happen (failure cause), and what would be the consequences of failure

Quality Improvement Organizations Essay

1165 words - 5 pages Quality Improvement Organizations and Healthcare Consumers Our nation’s healthcare system requires constant monitoring for quality and innovations and guidelines for increasing the quality of care. This process is difficult and complex and requires many separate organizations with differing approaches and objectives in order to be effective. Fortunately, there are many such organizations that strive to continuously increase the health care

The Deming Wheel

891 words - 4 pages Decision Making Tools and Techniques.There are several different tool the aide in the decision making process. The Deming Cycle is just one of the techniques. The Deming Cycle is used to control improvements to projects and the required outcome.The Deming Cycle is a process used for continuous improvement efforts. The Deming Cycle increases the long term solutions to processes versus the reaction approach to problems. See Appendix A Figure 1.0

Fix investment and Monetary Investments

2435 words - 10 pages investment. Maintenance or repairmen. Supplementary investment. Expansion investment. Change investment (e.g. rationalization, diversification). Certainty investment. Making the right decision to invest or not is not a simple process. Without a sound and clear image of the future of the opportunities, companies may go on bankruptcy. Another point, a lack of proper information about the investment may lead to wrong decisions, and therefore a

How to Use Self Reflection to Achieve Your Goals

986 words - 4 pages highlight of what is not working without regard to what is actually going on beneath the surface because we do not fail or mess up in a vacuum; its important to note that life doesn’t always transpire as originally planned, nevertheless it is beneficial to understand why or how events go wrong, because a moment of failure is an opportunity to learn to better yourself and to take a different and more effective course of action. Much Needed Time-Out Self

What is Project Management in the Construction Process?

1842 words - 8 pages the development was accelerated along with the delivery. The workers of the Maasvlakte 2 project were also hugely supportive of Prince2, as they saw the regular maturity assessment as part of the annual process of optimization and constant improvement, rather than an intrusion. The use of PRINCE2 encourages, through a common approach for governance, successful delivery of projects. It also provides a benefit to the staff/workers involved who are

TQM Initiatives in Optimising Software Development Life Cycles

3566 words - 14 pages budget, are also key internal customers.Further to this, it was agreed that the external customer (client) is only an end customer of the process under one situation: if the estimates are so wrong that the project runs over time. To date, no projects have run over time and as such there is no way to measure the clients' satisfaction of the estimation process. However, as discussed earlier, there are grave concerns that the process is beginning to

Assessments: Formal or Alternative?

1628 words - 7 pages To test or not to test or how to test has become an ongoing debate within education. With the implementation of No Child Left Behind, schools have been pressured to have all students on grade level and increase test scores. Society has become obsessed with measuring and comparing students. Society has become competitive with other countries test scores. Schools are graded with Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP), a way to measure the improvement

Business Management - Pacific Airlines

6595 words - 26 pages addition to improvement process methodologies. A blend of Value (VA) and Quality Function Deployment (QFD) techniques are used in a structured process that quantifies and prioritises customer requirements. Improvement efforts are focused on the most important features of your product / service and the most important parameters of your processes.A structured approach such as Activity-Based Costing to determine the areas of the business where quality

DPL/AES Project Management Process Improvement

2585 words - 11 pages demands take time away from duties 18. Staffing a. Engineering supervisor: only two or three for DPL so not all jobs/ projects are looked at b. Many employees performing too many functions (hats) – stretched to far/ cannot perform at best performance level c. Real Estate services d. Work distribution among regions 19. Company mail to districts a. low process time Info not reaching areas in timely manner slows process time Process Improvement

Principles of Leadership Portfolio

1023 words - 5 pages see a lot of room for error, serious consideration to that should be given. Clark (2014b) tells us that when leaders are involved in the decision making process they are more motivated to do it correctly. Involving people in decisions will help projects flow correctly, as well as motivate them to do things correctly. Conclusion Looking back at a failed project makes it easy to see many things that went wrong. In this project many people were

Similar Essays

Total Quality Management: Six Sigma Application In Courier Industry

2280 words - 9 pages includes change management, more detailed tactical Six-Sigma training, Kaizen events, and conducting improvement projects to reduce process variation and streamline business processes. The final phase, Perpetuation, is focused on rolling out the Six-Sigma initiative to the entire organization and striving for continuous improvement.Achieving six sigma at TCSNot all implementations succeed. Failure results from weak leadership, slack goal setting, poor

Six Sigma: A Data Driven Approach And Methodology For Eliminating Defects In Any Process

1791 words - 8 pages Six Sigma Methodologies: MAIC was developed, and this evolved into DMAIC, where D stands for define, M stands for measure, A stands for analyze, I stands for improve and C stands for control. Experience shows that D is the essential phase for achieving dramatic improvement quickly, and C is the most critical phase for realizing return on investment in six sigma projects. The define phase requires the implementation of many tools, and the control

A Study Was Carried Out To Try And Understand, What Make It Projects Different And Complex Than Any Other Projects

2940 words - 12 pages Projects", 4). This can be said to be caused by lack of leadership, lack of knowledge at top level, poor risk management and so on.However, further development and improvement in the method and tools to support the design and delivery of IT projects could increase success rate of IT projects. Most importantly, more research is needed to facilitate better management of increasing complex IT projects been doneThe main stakeholders are people

The Samie Process Model Essay

2328 words - 10 pages Development, mission is what you do best every day and vision is what the future will be like because you deliver on a daily basis on the mission. There are key requirements you need to identify when working on the Select phase. Know who your customer is and where do you need to focus your improvement efforts. Brainstorming the requirement areas will help you identify what’s important to the customer. For my process improvement, the customer is