Which Art Historical Method I Would Use

1373 words - 6 pages

As an aspiring art historian who has been exposed to a variety of diverse methods for analyzing art, there are two techniques in particular that stand prominent amidst the others: the ideas of Erwin Panofsky and Adrian Piper. It is not invalid to say that both art historians share a similar view of interpreting works of art, however, they also manage to complement one another perfectly. An integration of both Piper and Panofsky's points of view would result in an impeccable approach to delving into the minds of the artists and determining the significance of the works of art that they constructed.
Erwin Panofsky introduced and labeled a tripartite structure of analyzing art; he argued that practicing this tripartite method would produce a more profound and satisfying result. If one chose to apply Panofsky's method, one would be granted access into the mind of the artist¬¬¬, which would in turn produce the intrinsic meaning of the artist's creation.
Step one of Panofsky's method, the natural subject matter, requires only one's innate ability to recognize form. This step does not demand intellectual labor or cultural knowledge from the historian or appreciator of art. The natural subject matter merely requests of the viewer an immediate comprehension of figures. Step two, the conventional subject matter, calls for a deeper understanding of the work of art. This step insists that the viewer be acquainted with the subject of the art. Knowledge of a particular theme requires a respective cultural background. If one is not familiar with the theme of a work of art, then one must venture outside of the painting's frame and into educated sources that will provide the information that is needed in order to proceed to Panofsky's third step, the intrinsic meaning. The third step introduces the iconology of the painting; this step will urge the viewer to perform detective work in order to determine why the artist chose to depict aspects of the painting in a certain way. When the viewer engages with this level of analysis, he or she must rely on outside sources and text. Panofsky advises the viewer to seek information by way of scholarly and religious text, journals, legal documents, other paintings from the same artist, as well as from the artist's contemporaries, and other various sources that may be able to provide the viewer with an understanding of the culture that surrounded the artist. By immersing oneself in material of the period, one is then able to recognize and trace connections, therefore revealing the intrinsic meaning of the painting.
Defending Erwin Panofsky's method to those who have doubts seems as though it should be nonsensical, because it is clearly the path that art historians must take. One simply cannot eliminate his method while simultaneously retaining the title of art historian. The omission of Panofsky's ideas transforms art history into art appreciation. By use of what other method should one endeavor to find the meaning of...

Find Another Essay On Which Art Historical Method I Would Use

This is an article which describes the history and art. It is only the begining of the journal, I just feel it is interesting. Thus, I post it here.

625 words - 3 pages 1.) The Neolithic and Industrial RevolutionsThe two changes in the use of the earth resources that had the greatest effect on the world population werethe neolithic and the industrial revolutions.The neolithic revolution (a.k.a. agricultural revolution) was a change in the way of life of our ancestors. Ittook place about 8000 years ago among various tribes in Asia and the Middle East. It included a transitionfrom foraging and hunting to the

How can Art be Defined Essay

1304 words - 5 pages of the traditional philosophical categories (such as those of imitation, beauty and taste) on which the Aesthetics tradition had been founded, or at least it questioned the possibility of use in the arts. The so called “analytic philosophers” have taken the task of trying to redefine the concept of Art and among these, is the name of Beardsley C. Monroe, one of the most important, in the field of Aesthetics. Beardsley (1983, 2004), proposed a

Changes in Art History with Emphasis on the Mid-Twentieth Century

3759 words - 15 pages own movement which would span the 1940’s and the 1950’s. One of the most important artists in abstract expressionism was Jackson Pollack (see appendix A). Pollack’s work runs throughout the span of the movement. The famous method of “action painting” which Pollack developed was much like the times he, and the other artists who practiced this method, lived in. “While there appears to be chaos in the erratic and loose placement of paint and

Salvador Dali

1350 words - 5 pages represented.Based on the idea of the 'innocent eye', emphasized by the dying Surrealist Movement, Salvador Dali would develop the paranoiac critical method, revolutionizing and resurrecting the Surrealist Art Movement. The paranoiac critical method, itself, was not a new concept. In layman's terms, the paranoiac critical method simply involved seeing different shapes and visages within an already existing object. The most common example of the basic use

The Value of Art

2453 words - 10 pages start by personally researching some Christian art, and explain the historical significance of the paintings to my family. This would help them become more receptive to learning about art. Once they became more interested in art, then I would help them by asking them to evaluate the painting for interesting and significant details. Once my family begins to appreciate the value of art, then I can teach them how to personally evaluate a painting. I

The Kingdom of Benin

1528 words - 6 pages the artwork to the world next to countless other historical artefacts from other countries and the Africans who want their cultural sculptures back within their territory due to the provocative method in which the art of Benin was originally taken and for the dismissal in the acknowledgement of their right to have a decision on what happens to the Bronze pieces. In the early years of the nineteenth-century, Western Europeans believed that much

MARCEK DUCHAMP- Readymades- The Bicycle Wheel

1214 words - 5 pages the revolutions occurring in art at the time, this artwork would have been intended to shock its audience. Duchamp seems to have created the piece Bicycle Wheel for his own personal experiments and enjoyment.Quote from Duchamp: "...when I put a bicycle wheel on a stool the fork down, there was no idea of a 'readymade,' or anything else. It was just a distraction. I didn't have any special reason to do it, or any intention of showing it or

The Relationship Between Art and Philosophical Ethics

1520 words - 6 pages fictional character upon his doing something we understand as morally wrong; for instance, I became upset at Harry Potter once he began to use forbidden spells in the final book. Example: systematic desensitization This designation of art as a moral agent allows for the emergence of several other philosophical difficulties, particularly with regard to the extent of ethical responsibility that ought to be assumed by an artist. There are situations

Altering Reality

1236 words - 5 pages . Shakespeare begins his historical references with the use of well-known historical characters. Two of the play’s main characters are two rivaling Scottish kings, Duncan I and Macbeth. Shakespeare does an excellent job in using contrasts of the actual kings, in The Tragedy of Macbeth. Shakespeare’s Duncan is a well-loved king. He is very kind to his fellow countrymen and is very gracious towards those of his men who Duncan feels have served him well in

'Explore how mechanical reproduction in the twentieth century has altered the way in which art is perceived and understood.'

1505 words - 6 pages peering through a camera lens.Photographer Cindy Sherman stated once that due to the ease of photography she felt her limitations were less.‘There was nothing more to say through painting. I was meticulously copying other art and then I realised I could just use a camera and put my time into an idea instead.’Photography eventually evolved into the development of film, which provided further explorations in relation to mechanical

Classical Roman Art Vs. Early Christian Art

1027 words - 4 pages Hellenistic world, which had spread to southern Italy and Sicily through the Greek colonies there. The Etruscans and Babylonians can also be seen as inspirations. “With the founding of the Republic, the term Roman art was virtually synonymous with the art of the city of Rome, which still bore the stamp of its Etruscan art” (Honour and Fleming,1999). During the last two centuries, notably that of Greece, Roman art shook off its dependence on Etruscan art

Similar Essays

Would I Use Open Source Software Over Free Commercial Software?

1623 words - 6 pages threats to be negligible. Would I use Open Source Software over commercial software? The next question is whether I would use open source software over commercial software for which I have to pay. There are many examples of this: Linux OS or Windows OS, OpenOffice or Microsoft Office, Thunderbird or Outlook, Winamp or Windows Media Player, Gimp or Photoshop. The answer for this question is that it depends, and it depends on a couple of things

Assessing The View That Practical Issues Are The Most Important Factors In Deciding Which Research Method To Use

2138 words - 9 pages not affect an experiment as much as a problem practically would, which means that practical issues are much more important as they affect whether research actually goes ahead whereas theoretical considerations wouldn't stop research from continuing. In conclusion, a researcher should take practical factors, ethical issues, and theory into consideration before choosing which method to use in conducting their research

Compare The Play "Pygmalion" By George Bernard Shaw With Its Film Version "My Fair Lady". Which Do You Find More Effective Work Of Art And Why. Use Quotes

1908 words - 8 pages to her in the future “where am I to go, what am I to do…” which Higgins without any kind of respect throws her options like working in a florists shop or marrying someone. However none of these options satisfy Eliza. Then on the next day, it seems like it dawns on Higgins because he says “where will you go, in Heaven`s name?”, giving a sense that he realized that he would miss Eliza as shown in the song “grown

Culminating Assignment For Civics Which Details How I Would Creat Awareness To Change The Outdated Law Of The Sex Offenders Act.

584 words - 2 pages society free of these paralyzing crimes.What factors surrounding this issue I would like to see changed:Factor One: Public Information/ Communication* Sexual registry information should be made available to the public.* Local residency of a dangerous sex offender should also be public information.* Residents of a neighbourhood where a dangerous sex offender resides should receive some sort of an alert/ information directly from the police.Factor