This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Which Epic Has Most Relevance To A Twenty First Century Reader, Virgil's 'aeneid' Or Homer's 'odyssey'? Examines Themes In Both Epics (From The English Translations) And Compares The Two.

1969 words - 8 pages

Which epic has most relevance to a twenty first century reader, Virgil's 'Aeneid' or Homer's 'Odyssey'?The very fact that I am studying both Virgil's 'Aeneid' and Homer's 'Odyssey' at A Level immediately proves to me that both epics must have contemporary relevance, else they would have been buried with the bones of their authors rather than being the subject of this essay. However, choosing which epic has the most contemporary relevance is not an easy task.To begin with, both epics were written at different times, in different languages, in different countries, for different purposes. 'The Odyssey' was written by Homer, a Greek who possibly lived in Ionia, an island off central western Turkey. It was probably written between 750-700 BC. The epic is of the oral tradition: it was designed to be sung by bards as entertainment, hence the fact that numerous 'standard' descriptions of events are repeated for ease of memory. Virgil on the other hand was born in Italy in 70 BC and composed 'The Aeneid' in the ten years before his death in 19 BC. Unlike 'The Odyssey', 'The Aeneid' is a written epic, designed to be read. It was written in honour of Augustus Caesar as an account of the Emperor's descent from the Gods, and Rome's great history. Virgil used Homers Odyssey', and his other oral epic, 'The Iliad', as inspiration.As a result, many of the themes in Homer's 'Odyssey' and Virgil's 'Aeneid' are similar. I will therefore begin by examining some of the issues found in both epics that have contemporary relevance. The reason why both epics have retained their popularity over the years, except for their graphic detail and tales of heroism, is undoubtedly because as well as being fantastic story tellers, both Homer and Virgil had a profound understanding of psychology. This comprehension of human behaviour sustains our interest because although cultures and technology may change, the way in which men and women act in certain situations and relationships remains fundamentally the same.Both 'The Aeneid' and 'The Odyssey' deal with a development from boyhood in to manhood. 'The Odyssey' begins with four books often called the 'Telemachid' which chart Telemachus' coming of age, establishing his reputation; 'kleos', in the absence of his father, Odysseus. 'The Aeneid' begins with Aeneas' son, Ascanius as a boy, but by his father's absence in Book Nine, he has begun to establish himself as a young man.Perhaps of even more relevance to a twenty first century reader, both epics examine the complex relationship between father and son. 'The Odyssey' shows how Telemachus has grown up without his father, and how he gains the strength to overpower the suitors when he Odysseus returns and gives him his support, but without trying to take his father's place. Although in less detail, Homer also deals with the relationship between Odysseus and his father, Laertes, in particular their reunion. The Aeneid also deals with several father and son relationships, but most...

Find Another Essay On Which epic has most relevance to a twenty first century reader, Virgil's 'Aeneid' or Homer's 'Odyssey'? Examines themes in both epics (from the english translations) and compares the two.

Consumer Culture in the Twenty First Century

1350 words - 5 pages has changed from the 1950s to the twenty first century. In the 1950's the wealthy upper class people were the ones who had the luxury items and they could flaunt what they had. But if you were a middle class person who had luxury items you had to be very subtle about it. If you flaunted what you had you were frowned upon by other people in society because luxury items were lightly tainted with shame. In the 21st century it is completely the

Racism in the Twenty-First Century Essay

1040 words - 4 pages Rim Mekonnen Racism in the Twenty-First Century 1. Throughout the history of the United States, whites dominated society by making laws that limited the power of minorities such as Hispanics, African Americans, and Asian Americans. For hundreds of years, whites controlled minorities using laws and mind games to make sure these minorities never rose to threaten their control. In the 1950s and 60s, Congress passed laws to protect the civil

Communication in the Twenty-first Century

1694 words - 7 pages to the democratic ideals upon which this nation was founded. In fact information is so important to this democracy that the Bill of Rights begins with the axiom of a free press. In countless countries throughout the world where fledgling democracies have attempted to flourish, those that would suppress freedom of speech, attack newspaper offices first because it is the intrepid newspaper reporters and editors who bring the news to the people. Now

Systems Thinking in the Twenty-First Century

2688 words - 11 pages humankind learn to avoid the mistakes that destroy our best undertakings by misleading us from the right track and threaten our very existence. But in order to do that, a systems paradigm itself should find harmony. Changes of a Paradigm of Knowledge in the Twentieth Century The thirties and fifties of the 20th century marked a turning point in science and philosophy. Many outstanding intellectuals realised the mounting crisis. Numerous

The Twenty-first Century Woman

1168 words - 5 pages built for such pressures. But the twenty-first century women had something to prove. Until recently women were not allowed to be doctors (Stone 1). In the medical field women usually would not surpass being a nurse, and that itself was a hard position for a women to withhold. With the recent push from women to get out the house and into the work place there has been a slight change to the game plan. More and more women are pushing their minds a

The Twenty-First Century Distraction

3413 words - 14 pages it? Because technology rapidly reinvents the world, changing people, culture, and society, individuals have been able to be more efficient and productive with their work time, therefore making time to engage in leisure-related activities. In the twenty-first century; however, technology is a “doubled-edged sword” slicing through once time-consuming tasks, but also distract people from responsibilities. One of the most profound negative

Economic Globalization and the Law in the Twenty-first Century

7734 words - 31 pages (Blomley, Delaney, and Ford, 2001). The early years of the twenty-first century witness a startling variety of new legal forms and regimes which sometimes differ substantially in nature, content, scale, and operation from the largely state-based system of governance of the past several centuries. A multiplicity of other sites of governance complement, supplement, or compete with the state, hence the term "governance" instead of "government." While

Spiritual Growth in the Epic of Gilgamesh, Homer's Odyssey, and Dante's Inferno

2026 words - 8 pages order to learn the secret of eternal life (IX.7) In contrast, the Odyssey introduces the reader to Odysseus' son, Telemachus, who is a timid young man and has not yet learned how to be an effective leader. After twenty years, his father has not returned from the Trojan War and the palace has been overrun by suitors trying to win his mother's hand in marriage. He tells Athena, "They continue to bleed my household white. / Soon--you wait--they'll

A Hero's First Death, an essay on Homer's The Odyssey

830 words - 3 pages A Hero's First DeathDavid Blumenthal In two of the founding stories of our culture, there seems to be a requirement that peoplewho have experienced something horrible cannot establish a proper home. In the Bible, theIsraelites wandered through the desert for 40 years to ensure that an entire generation passed andnone of the people who were slaves in Egypt saw their homeland. The same is true in Homer'sthe Odyssey. Odysseus and his men

Homer's Odyssey as a Moral Epic

2561 words - 10 pages captures the moral values of the ancient Greek society. One such value is 'xenia', which means guest friendship and has its connections with the God, Zeus. In the poem, great emphasis is placed on treating your guest well. When Athene first comes to Odysseus's palace disguised as Mentes, Telemachos's heart is 'scandalized that a guest should still be standing at the doors'.21 Similarly, when Odysseus and his men are in the cave of Polyphemos

Compare the ways in which the authors of two texts use stylistic features to position the reader to respond to ideas common to both texts

1163 words - 5 pages use stylistic features to position the audience to respond to ideas common in both texts. Within a society, non-conformity and individualism are conveyed in a negative light, which is explored through the institutions of both texts. In Kesey’s novel, characters are controlled by the hospital system but there are also those who do not conform to such order and disrupt the enforced demand. Kesey’s Randle McMurphy, conductor of rebellion, introduces

Similar Essays

Tying Homer's Iliad To Virgil's Aeneid Through The Theme Of Warfare

1608 words - 6 pages Warfare is a common thread that ties Homer's Iliad to Virgil's Aeneid. However, the way warfare is treated in the two epics is different. This can be attributed to many factors including the time between the composition of the pieces, the fact that pieces were written by different authors, and the fact that the pieces were written in different places. We can use these pieces to get a view of what the society that produced them thought about

The Odyssey Of The Twenty First Century Society

773 words - 4 pages Foresight is an amazing ability. The following text will examine Stanley Kubrick’s film 2001: A Space Odyssey released in 1968 with our current society in the twenty-first century. Comparing and contrasting his foresight on the evolution on mobile computing, communications and space travel as seen in his film. Stanley Kubrick began writing his script in 1964 during the space race between the United States of America and Soviet Russia. The film

The Analysis And Comparison Of The Themes Of "Beowulf", "The Odyssey" And Other Related Epics

2553 words - 10 pages identity, battles, recognition and homecomingrelated to "Beowulf" and "The Odyssey", but they are also linked to other epics as well."The Odyssey" is best described as "a guide to the Greeks, a guide to literatureand a guide to the complexities of society, identity, and home". There were many themes, both universal and timeless that thoroughly revealed the main ideas and issues of this legendary epic. The first and more stressed theme in "The

"The Epic Of Gilgamesh" And Homer's "Odyssey". For Both Texts, Comparison Of The The Cultural Value,"Heroism"

912 words - 4 pages In this essay I am going to deal with the two epic texts called: "The Epic of Gilgamesh" and Homer's "Odyssey". For both texts, I will discuss the cultural value of "heroism"In order to make a good analysis of both texts we have to know what "Epic" means. Webster's defines it as "a long poetic composition, usually centered upon a hero, in which a series of great achievements or events is narrated in elevated style" (Webster's Universal College