Which Leader Best Carried Out The Ideals Of The Russian Revolution: Lenin Or Stalin?

1329 words - 5 pages

The Russian Revolution as a whole was completely built around Marxism and the Marxist theory. This theory instructs that a perfect political system is reached when every single citizen of a nation has the same amount of property as every one of his fellow citizens. This system can be achieved by creating a Dialectic. A Dialectic is when a thesis (in this case the upper class society) is combined with an antithesis (in this case the lower class society) to form a synthesis (an overall middle class society). This would eliminate every kind of class struggle and make everyone an equal member of a country, both socially and politically. In Marxist terms, this equality is known as "freedom for all". Throughout the Russian Revolution, there were many powerful leaders which tried, through force, to install a new political system based upon the Marxist theory, called Communism. Although the leaders were fairly successful in their undertakings, they sometimes forgot about the basic principles that had been set up to make Communism a total success. In this essay, I will try to distinguish the better communist between the two most famous revolutionary leaders of Russia: Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin.The Bolshevik party was a small party when it seized power. It had to adopt strong tactics to maintain its power. With Lenin as its leader, the Bolsheviks adjusted their policy to solve the needs of the people in order to stay in power. The Bolsheviks changed their name to Russian Communist Party of the Bolsheviks in March 1918 when the seventh Congress of the Bolshevik Party was held. As soon as Lenin came to power, he passed a series of decrees to satisfy the immediate wants of the Russian people. These included giving land to the peasants, giving control of the factories to the workers, the introduction of 8-hour day, repudiation of foreign debts and secret treaties, and the beginning of an effort to make peace with Germany. The decrees that legalized the seizure of land by the peasants and allowed workers to control the factories won most support from the people as their life-long wishes suddenly came true. Lenin understood that many Russians had hoped for the election of a Constituent Assembly. In November, the nation-wide election for the Constituent Assembly was held. The Bolsheviks won only ¼ of the votes in this election. After the Assembly had sat for one and a half day, Lenin ordered the Red Guards to disperse it by force.After winning the Civil War between his "Reds" and the "White" Social Revolutionaries, Lenin saw that Russia was in a deep economic crisis. The first and most important problem facing him was to restore order and wealth out of the immediate social and economic chaos. In agriculture, the peasants did not show any motivation to grow their crops anymore, as their produce was confiscated immediately to feed the town workers and the soldiers. Some rich landowners refused to hand in their crops to the soldiers. From 1918...

Find Another Essay On Which Leader Best Carried Out The Ideals Of The Russian Revolution: Lenin Or Stalin?

Lenin and His Coming of Power after the Russian Revolution- Follows Lenin's Implementation of the April Thesis: Peace, Bread and Land while in Power

896 words - 4 pages Once the Tsar abdicated and the Provisional Government came to power, Vladimir Lenin, leader of the Bolshevik party, immediately adopted general ideas about the future of Russia. He demanded that there should be a worldwide socialist revolution, the soviets should take power and no longer cooperate with the weak Provisional government, land should be given to the peasants and Russia was to end her involvement in the war. By the end of April 1917

To what extent do you agree that it was defeat in the war which was the real factor of the Russian revolution ?

632 words - 3 pages situation was made worse by huge supply problems. Tsarina accompanied by Rasputin has run the country very badly and caused the reduction of Tsar's prestige. Even the person of the Tsar was very unfavorable for the monarchy. He was very indecisive and weak but his greatest mistake was that he didn't want to abandon autocracy and modernize Russian political system. The political system remained outdated still autocratic, very repressive and severely corrupted. Looking at this situation one can say that the revolution was unavoidable nevertheless the author believes that without the war, which had a devastating impact on Russia, the monarchy wouldn't have fallen in 1917.

Why did the 1905 Russian Revolution break out, and how significant was the 1905 Revolution in bringing about political change by 1912?

859 words - 3 pages The 1905 Russian Revolution was the first of the revolutions that took place in attempt to overthrow Russia's Tsarist (or Imperial Autocracy) regime. The revolution broke out in 1905 because of the public unrest and economic depression caused by the Russo-Japanese war in 1904-5; and because of the "Bloody Sunday" of January 9th, 1905. The significance of the 1905 Revolution was determined by the October Manifesto, which was the Tsar's response

Animal Farm, a novella by George Orwell, was written during Russia's height of Communist power and is an allegory whose deeper meaning concerns the Russian Revolution and rule under Josef Stalin

661 words - 3 pages Animal FarmAnimal Farm is a novella by George Orwell that was written during Russia's height of Communist power. The story is an allegory whose deeper meaning concerns the Russian Revolution and rule under Josef Stalin. Animal Farm is about a farm where the animals are abused by their master, Mr. Jones. One night, a wise and elderly boar, Old Major, tells the animals of a dream he had where all animals work together, without human interaction

To find out the optimum pH at which the enzyme catalase would best break down hydrogen peroxide

2844 words - 11 pages legitimise my findings.Write down the factor you are going to vary and say how you will do this (P6b).The factor, which was going to be varied, was the buffer solution. With each experiment, a buffer solution with alternative pH will be used varying from pH3 to pH8.Write down the factors you want to control or monitor (P6a).In order to ensure that a fair test would be carried out, the following factors would be kept constant:-The volume of

Car Ferry Hijacked! - a reflective statement that was written based on the simulation which is carried out during my class section

932 words - 4 pages struggle. But at last I know it wasn't what I think, I was caught by two guys with gun. I tried my best to shout for help and struggled, but it seems to be no much help. They threatened that if I didn't surrender, I might be shot. I had to face the fact that I was being caught, without knowing any reason or what was happening. A thousand of question marks came into my mind, why I would be caught? Did we come across pirates? But it seems to be only

Causes of the Russian Revolution

984 words - 4 pages Causes of the Russian Revolution Consider the following causes of the October 1917 Russian Revolution: Poor Living and Working Conditions Effects of the First World War The Appeal of Lenin and the Bolsheviks The Limitations of the 1917 Provisional Government Was any one of these causes more important than the others to the Bolsheviks’ seizure of power in 1917? Explain your answer. A1

Causes of the Russian Revolution

752 words - 3 pages During the reign of the last Tsar of Russia, Nicholas, the Russian Revolution broke out. It is a revolution which changed the lives of many and left alone a few. Even the ruling class which had ruled over Russia for centuries can't escape from the changes. People are repressed for years and are trying to find a way to escape and the only solution is to rebel. There are big and small events, all reasons which led to the outbreak of the Russian

The Russian Revolution of 1917

1213 words - 5 pages substitution of another by the governed .Activity or movement designed to affect fundamental changes in the socioeconomic situation (Webster Dictionary).”One revolution that is said to have inspired communism was the Russian Revolutions of 1917. A communist revolution is inspired by ideas of Marxism whose main purpose is to replace capitalism with communism also considered socialism. “Marxists believe that the workers of the world must unite and

The Impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian People

1614 words - 6 pages bullet' removed. The operation was unsuccessful and left Lenin paralysed down his right side. Joseph Stalin then became Lenin's mouthpiece. The initial effects of this was the rise of Stalin to become the leader of the Communist party in Russia, this then resulted in Stalin going down in History as a brutal dictator and mass murderer. In 1924 Lenin died and most people presumed Trotsky who had formed the Red Army

Who had greater success in solving the problems of the Russian countryside, Alexander the second, Alexander the third or Stalin?

1422 words - 6 pages Stalin felt the State couldn't wait that long. The peasants were collectivised and grain was extracted by force when quotas were not met. Enforced collectivisation and the seizure of grain created peasant uprising and peasant misery. Successful peasants were blamed for there not being enough grain, labeled class enemies and shot or transported to the gulags. Famine returned on a scale that eclipsed the numbers of 1891-numbers who died in the early 30s

Similar Essays

Which Leader Best Carried Out The Ideals Of The Russian Revolution: Lenin Or Stalin?

1329 words - 5 pages better leader. Lenin cared about his citizens, and he changed to the N.E.P. just in time to prevent Russia from running down the drain. However, it was Stalin, who since his appearance at the head of the Bolshevik party, followed the Communist and Marxist ideals through to the end. In order for a communist country to run successfully, it needs an extremely ruthless and cold-blooded leader. Stalin was this ruthless and cold-blooded leader. It is

Russian Foriegn Policy Under Lenin And Stalin

1082 words - 4 pages I. Overview, What were the aims of Soviet foreign policy under Lenin?- In the new Bolshevik government Trotsky was made Commissar of Foreign Affairs.- Taking Russia out of the First World War had been a major Bolshevik pledge and the Decree on Peace, which called for an immediate truce and a just peace, was issued in October 1917. It, however, brought no response from the major powers fighting the war.- Hence, a separate treaty was signed

Was The Nature And Style Of The Leadership In The Critical Period Of The Russian Revolution Consistent With The Ideals Of The Revolution?

831 words - 3 pages many factors of Russian society, all together creating the unstable political environment which harboured the revolution. The collapse of the army's loyalty towards the Tsar meant that the Tsar was unprotected, and this made it easier for the Bolshevik party to force the Tsar's abdication. The economic and political impact of the War also made it easier for the Bolshevik party to convince the people that the Tsarist system of Government was not

Russian Revolution: Karl Marx And Vladimir Lenin

794 words - 4 pages Karl Marx and Vladimir Lenin were the most important leaders in the Russian Revolution. Their strong beliefs and determination to their convictions motivated both men. They greatly influenced the political and philosophical outcomes of the Russian Revolution. Karl Marx was a brilliant man. He would analyze the thoughts and publications of the philosophers of his time. Intellectuals were not overly impressed by him. It wasn’t until