This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Which Standard Of Review Should The Court Use When Analyzing Race Conscious Affirmative Action Programs?

2009 words - 8 pages

Which standard of review should the court use when analyzing race conscious affirmative action programs? Over the last 35 years, the Supreme Court has attempted to answer this question numerous times; each time clarifying certain parts, while leaving other parts intentionally vague and open to interpretation. The result has been various affirmative action plans being called into question to see if they violate the Equal Protection Clause based on a racially conscious motive. And while the court has ultimately decided the standard of review to be strict scrutiny, the language in the plurality and majority decisions of Bakke and Grutter still leaves wide latitude for educational institutions to practice reverse discrimination. By not implementing any scale or numbering system that quantifies the number of unrepresented minorities in a quota or similar grouping, the court finds that race or ethnicity may be used as a plus factor in the admissions process. It is my contention that the court erred in Bakke in their original application of strict scrutiny to racially conscious affirmative action programs and should have applied intermediate scrutiny, as it provides a more realistic approach when analyzing the detriments of affirmative action and eliminates the need to weaken existing precedent.

Opposition View
In Justice Powell’s one-man plurality in Bakke, he begins by proscribing that “only those racial classifications that would violate the Equal Protection Clause or the Fifth Amendment” can possibly violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Choper, Fallon, Kamisar, & Shiffrin 1375). By doing so, Powell gives credence to the idea that not all forms of racial discrimination are a violation of the constitution, but only those that are prohibited by the Equal Protection Clause or the Fifth Amendment. However, his misguided interpretation of these two laws set the precedent for strict scrutiny to be used in future race-conscious affirmative action programs. It follows from his opinion that Powell believed judicial protection from discrimination was an individual entitlement not restricted to a certain race. Indeed, within the “white population” itself, there are a variety of “minority groups, most of which can lay claim to a history of prior discrimination at the hands of the State and private individuals” (Choper et al., 1375). Therefore, every race should be given the same protection under the law, not simply underrepresented minorities, as all races have been mistreated in some form by the State or a private individual. With Powell’s lone decree the white population became groups of discriminated minorities rather than a single ethnic collective and the court was required to apply strict scrutiny to the case.
With the school having to prove their quota system was both a compelling state interest and narrowly tailored to achieve that interest, the “strict in theory, fatal in fact” mantra held true and the school’s racially conscious...

Find Another Essay On Which Standard of Review should the Court use when Analyzing Race Conscious Affirmative Action Programs?

Supreme Court and Affirmative Action Essay

1617 words - 7 pages Affirmative action has been a widely debated topic for some time. It has been used as a tool to help stop discrimination in many areas such as the workplace, education, and in government; however, some believe that the use of affirmative action is in itself, discriminatory. “Schuette v. The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action…” is a current United States Supreme Court case that is dealing with the matter. The case has been in the making for

Affirmative Action Based on Race? Essay

1430 words - 6 pages caused more problems in the system and it all began with the Civil Rights Acts of 1964. Pursuing this even further, the Civil rights Acts of 1964 makes it illegal for any programs receiving federal financial assistance to discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion or sex (Cohen). This was the beginning of the affirmative action giving more opportunities for minorities. However, it could not solve all the problems of

Affirmative Action Should Reduce Inequality

4464 words - 18 pages membership is determined by those labels. It is empirically argued that affirmative action provokes racial tension due to raising race-consciousness. (Fish 2000) However, the program cannot simply be eliminated because it makes people aware of racial conflicts. A program that attempts to eliminate race and gender inequality without leading people to be conscious of their racial identity is virtually impossible to design. Discrimination and racial and

Affirmative Action Should Not Be Continued

2536 words - 10 pages programs in which unqualified or unneeded employees are hired”. So regardless of race, these men were hired when it was “explicitly prohibited” they were unqualified. Although President Johnson was a firm believer in affirmative action, he made a few points during a speech to Harvard’s graduating class in support of affirmative action, which also seem as a good a way to end it. President Johnson said, “To this end equal opportunity

Why Affirmative Action Should Be Eliminated

1544 words - 6 pages “critical mass” of minorities in order to enhance the school’s character. The Court ultimately voted in favor of the university, but stated, “The Court expects that 25 years from now, the use of racial preferences will no longer be necessary to further the interest approved today” (United). A similar case appeared in October of 2012 when Abigail Fisher sued the University of Texas at Austin for rejection on behalf of race. The case made it all the

Should Affirmative Action Be Rescinded From Law?

799 words - 3 pages In the mid 1950’s Dr. Martin Luther King started a crusade to gain equal rights for his race. Over several years he was able to convince President Kennedy to pass legislation on discrimination. Since then there has been a great debate on whether affirmative action should be rescinded from our laws. In 1964 the Civil Rights Act made discrimination illegal. Two authors, Ward Connerly and Paul Kivel, have taken different stands on this issue for

Affirmative Action. Which employers are subject to Affirmative Action. Compliance Procedures

1087 words - 4 pages (banks, hospitals, etc.). Additionally, a court can order an employer to implement an affirmative action plan to correct past discrimination (Bennett-Alexander, 2007)."If an employer does not meet the goals of an affirmative action plan the employer is reported to the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP). The OFCCP is the agency that enforces federal contracts and subcontracts.If an employer is investigated by the OFCCP and found

Affirmative Action: Michigan´s Law that Bans Use of Racial Criteria in Admissions to Public Universities

1374 words - 6 pages discrimination of any kind that was based on race, religion, color and national origin. Affirmative action programs were designed to establish equal opportunities in education, government contracting and employment in particular for African Americans. With its success other underrepresented groups such as Hispanic Americans, Native Americans and women began to be included in affirmative action programs. At the time of President Johnson’s Executive Order

Why the US Should Implement Bans on Racial Preferences or Affirmative Action for Universities

3229 words - 13 pages Affirmative action or “racial preferences” are a hotly contested issue in the United States. For over four decades many states’ public universities have used race in the awarding of admissions preferences for minority applicants. Ten states have banned the use of racial preferences in university admissions including Michigan where on April 22, 2014 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of a voter approved ban on affirmative action. This

Should Affirmative Action be allowed in medical schools?

1131 words - 5 pages acceptance of college students.Affirmative action has turned out to be contentious. Proposition 209, in California, which prohibits all programs concerning race and sex preferences run by the state, has been voted for but it will not be put into total action caused by some questions of constitutionality. The law will initiate gradually first, ending affirmative action in the schools of California, leading up to the elimination of affirmative action

The essay is about Affirmative Action and If it should be accepted or thrown away with

520 words - 2 pages More Than Just A PolicyBorn of the civil rights movement three decades ago, affirmative action is the nation's most ambitious attempt to reconcile its long history of racial and sexual discrimination. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., in his famous "I Have a Dream" speech, stated that "I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created

Similar Essays

Benefits Of Affirmative Action Programs Essay

1416 words - 6 pages universities while also setting up minorities to fail in the real world. Groups against affirmative action feel that the need for these programs have over grown their usefulness, because of the changing times in which we live in. On the contrary because of past discrimination and segregation affirmative action programs are needed during the admissions process of universities and colleges. Opponents of affirmative action believe that use of affirmative

Race And Affirmative Action Essay

3216 words - 13 pages Bakke decision. The Supreme Court ruled in AFO-CIO v. Weber, 444 U.S. 889 that race-conscious affirmative action efforts designed to eliminate a conspicuous racial imbalance in an employer's workforce resulting from past discrimination was permissible, as long as the actions were temporary and did not violate the rights of white employees. College admission imbalances have resurfaced as a problem for affirmative action. Recently, the Smith v

Race And The Affirmative Action Policies

1700 words - 7 pages Court cases have arisen, University of California Regents v. Bakke and Grutter v. Bollinger, both impacting university admissions policies throughout the country and setting precedent in following rulings. Following the two rulings of these cases, I argue that affirmative action and the utilization of race as a positive factor is desperately needed in higher education. With the changing demographics and the rise of new national needs, the racial

Support For Affirmative Action Programs Essay

807 words - 3 pages . "Thus it is not enough just to open the gates of opportunity. All our citizens must have the ability to walk through those gates."Liberals and Democrats, say that race- and gender-conscious policies are the most effective way to encourage equality.Other SupportGaps between minorities and whites persist in educational and occupational attainment. Ending affirmative action will only ensure that those disparities remain in place and could even