This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Whistle Blowing In Auditing Essay

2426 words - 10 pages

Question 1

At the start of this century, unprecedented collapses of Enron and WorldCom have sparked heated world discussions over corporate whistle-blowing. In light of this, legislations and professional codes of conduct are implemented to provide framework on ethical and financial decision-making particularly for auditors. This essay covers prerequisites for an effective corporate whistle-blower hotline, measures to avoid potential pitfalls, as well as analysis on benefits and drawbacks of having a whistle-blower hotline.

Whistle-blower Hotline
What is it?
By incorporating the concepts of whistle-blower of Alford (2001, p.17) and Bok (1980, p.277) into auditing, whistle-blower hotline is a communication system which allows individuals to sound an alarm within the framework of the organization, aiming to spotlight suspected accounting frauds, mismanagement or internal control failures which threaten public interests with convincing evidences.

Why is it necessary?
Whistle-blower hotline helps alleviate the impact of fraudulent acts before it is too late. When Cynthia Cooper revealed US$3.8 billion of fraud in internal audit, WorldCom declared bankrupt with US$45.98 billion of liabilities, 20,000 employees became jobless and investors lost over US$180 billion. (Soltani 2007, p.560) If there had been a hotline, outcome would have been less devastating to stakeholders.
It also provides a platform for employees to voice out. Newcomers worry that seniors will neglect their opinions due to lack of experience. Ethical dilemma is “a situation where a decision must be made about appropriate behaviour”. (Michael 2011, p.131) Employees facing ethical dilemma fear to risk their career for truth. Hence, a hotline provides encouragement to raise concerns and promotion of transparent organizational culture.

Prerequisites to the Audit Commission
Engaged in Whistle-blower Hotline
Uphold Qualities of Internal Auditors
Under Rule 101 of American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) Code of Professional Conduct, and A Conceptual Framework for Auditor Independence issued by Independence Standards Board (ISB), auditors have to be independent in fact and appearance. (Soltani 2007, p.206) Independence in fact implies that auditors have to maintain impartiality. Independence in appearance relies on how confident the public regards work and performance of auditors as independent.
In addition, Rule 102 of AICPA Code requires auditors to uphold integrity and objectivity in professional work. Auditors with these values avoid conflicts of interests during investigation on whistle-blowing claims. Hence, internal auditors, particularly interviewees, should attend trainings to understand how to apply their qualities in performing appropriate procedures.
Monitor and Evaluate Periodically on the Hotline
Regular evaluations should be carried out to ensure the hotline complies with objectives and standards of Audit Commission. (Grant...

Find Another Essay On Whistle-blowing in Auditing

This essay is about whislteblowing in the Canadian Government. It gives the good the bad and the ugly about whistleblowing

1236 words - 5 pages The matter of whether or not to provide protection to whistle blowers in Canadian Government Organizations has been discussed for many years. However, to date, there has not been a bill passed to give whistle blowers full protection.Whistle blowing is defined as "an act of a man or woman who, believing that the public interest overrides the interest of the organization he serves, blows the whistle that the organization is involved in corrupt

Whistle Blowers Essay

1099 words - 4 pages WHISTLE BLOWERS We all know that honesty is the best policy, but a few courageous folks among us learn that this policy can come with a lot of struggles. These people act according to principals and facts of life. They know that if they do not present the truth many individuals in the society might suffer and they (as honest people) might live with guilt for the rest of their lives. These people that are willing to undergo all costs to

A Look Inside The WorldCom Scandal

1024 words - 4 pages allows employees to “report infractions that the company will then investigate” without fear of retaliation. Whistle-blower tips should then be reported to the board for them to investigate. Whistle-blowing takes a lot of courage, therefore those that report infractions should be commended if they choose to make their report public. The whistle-blower in WorldCom’s case was Cynthia Cooper. Cooper was nominated as one of Time magazine’s “Persons of

SOX Paper

940 words - 4 pages breaking of any code has to be reported to the SEC, and what steps will be taken to remedy the failure. Section 406 will definitely yield some positive results in the business environment. Most companies will not only create a code of ethics, but train, document and ensure compliance within their ranks. Failure to comply would cause them to be under much scrutiny from the SEC and public opinion of the company would be negative. Whistle blowing is

Biography of Edward Joseph Snowden

1215 words - 5 pages unethical doing of his government which is called the best governance in the world. So, he blew the whistle and he did not try to blow the whistle internally because he would be held captive or nobody would trust him and he would never be able to put the information out in the public. Also if we see that after this whistle blowing act, the government was trying to introduce some procedures to stop the NSA from collection these huge amounts of data

Effectiveness of Regulatory Reforms as Deterrent to Frauds and Unethical Actions

1924 words - 8 pages sensitivity, moral judgment, moral motivation and moral character. (Flavell and Markman 1983, pp.556-629) By education, one can accomplish the first three stages. Regarding to a whistle-blowing issue, education can hardly achieve the last stage – to withstand pressures and be courageous to act whistle-blowing. It takes a long time for one to be courageous enough to take action in ethical reasoning. Conclusion Over years, scandals have

An Ethical Analysis of Enron - BUS323 - Case Study

888 words - 4 pages executives could have argued that they took a utilitarian approach by attempting to benefit everyone involved, but their actions truly only benefited themselves. By performing their duties in a transparent and forthright manner, Enron could’ve continued to operate for many years. Conclusion and Recommendations Jerry Hays and Donald Ariall (2013) stated that “fraudulent accounting is a high priority risk, and whistle-blowing is the number one

Does Blowing The Whistle Violate Company Loyalty?

813 words - 4 pages : tell us what you know, and we'll pay you. Corporations aren't ruled by people--they are ruled by money, and lots of it. This may be a depiction of a small time in the United States' history, but its themes can be interpreted for any time. I believe in blowing the whistle isn't a good thing because as you can see in the movie Wigand lost his family, his job, and he lost a lot of money "blowing the whistle". Wigand knew what he was getting him

Ethics and Diversity Management Policies

1602 words - 6 pages and communicated to employees immediately (Lopez-Fernandez & Sanchez-Gardey, 2010; Mathew, 1998; Stoner & Russell-Chapin, 1997; Bleijenbergh, Peters, & Poutsma, 2010). Policies for Monitoring Unethical Behavior and Injustice in an Organization Policies for monitoring unethical behavior and injustice in an organization consist of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, whistle blowing, monitoring of email and computer activities. The Sarbanes-Oxley

Ethics and Diversity Managment Policies

1347 words - 5 pages and communicated to employees immediately (Lopez-Fernandez & Sanchez-Gardey, 2010; Mathew, 1998; Stoner & Russell-Chapin, 1997; Bleijenbergh, Peters, & Poutsma, 2010). Policies for Monitoring Unethical Behavior and Injustice in an Organization Policies for monitoring unethical behavior and injustice in an organization consist of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, whistle blowing, monitoring of email and computer activities. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act

The Business Software Alliance

885 words - 4 pages is a risk of being fired, which is why the Bsa's whistle- blowing scheme exists; it will have to pay for the legit- mate licenses an will bw named and shamed by the Bsa. The Bsa is also likely to undertake a full audit of all software, which may result in further fines and license fees to pay should more discrepancies be indentified. The Best Defense Is a Good Offense CYBERSECURITY ATTACKS have been in the news alomost weekly this

Similar Essays

Organizational Justice For Whistle Blowing And Harassment In The Public Personnel Sector

1814 words - 7 pages than social technology. While some interventions may be less successful on some occasions or in particular contexts, none is likely to be harmful, and at the very least they will promote a sense the organization is concerned about fairness. Conflict between administrative efficiency and individual rights can result perceptions about an organizational justice procedures. Despite whistle blowing and sexual harassment are largely two separate bodies

Problems Faced By Whistle Blowers Essay

2481 words - 10 pages With an aid of appropriate examples, discuss the problems that a whistle-blower is likely to have to consider in deciding whether or not to speak out. Whistle blowing is an attempt by a former or current employee of an organization to disclose illegality or any other wrongdoing in or by an organization. Whistle blowing can be divided into two types namely, internal and external whistle-blowing. When wrongdoing is reported to someone with a

Whistleblowing Essay

2012 words - 9 pages people think that whistle blowers should be protected by the law. Others think that whistle blowers should not be protected by the law. Ethical theories can be guidelines to help people understand if the act of whistle blowing should be done or not. Two different journal articles question the act of whistle blowing as a whole. In today's society, whistle blowers can face extreme public. This happens because they tell the public of the harm an

State And Federal Systems Essay

981 words - 4 pages remain silent. The employees may feel that it's not their concern; that nothing they could do would improve things, or they can't afford problems at work. Other workers may choose to speak out. They "blow the whistle" on unethical and illegal conduct in the workplace. Whistle blowing means disclosing information that a worker believes is evidence of something illegal, wasteful, mismanagement, abuse of power, or substantial and specific danger to