This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Who Knows What Is Right? Essay

2305 words - 9 pages

Who Knows What is Right?

Everyday humans are flooded with emotions, desires and thoughts, which are often in conflict. In order to understand and realize their roles in our lives we turn to the works of philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle, who pay particular attention to human flourishing. Through their works and discussions we are led towards a path that will help us examine our human nature and all its aspects and capabilities. One discussion that has interested humans for some time is the role of emotions in our lives; what can we learn from them? When should we express them? How should we react to them? It is these questions that have led us to Plato and Aristotle who have both reflected on the role of emotions and even come to some conclusions on their importance and roles.
In "The Republic" Plato recognized that emotion and desire are both aspects of the soul, which are in conflict with the most important aspect of the soul, reason. When our emotions interfere with our ability to reason, it can not be expected for us to flourish. In order for humans to flourish we must understand the role emotions should play and their impact on us. If our emotions become to strong and we display them to greatly we will only hinder what is important and will not be able to have justice within our souls. However, he feels strongly that without proper understanding of our emotions, no matter what our natures are we will not flourish. (P 54). Strong showing of emotion is at no time appropriate and we should instead be turned off by such displays.
Our emotions constrain us and will not allow us to flourish if we do not correctly train them through education, whose goal should be to teach us what, should be pleasurable and what should be painful. Plato does believe that certain emotions are important to life and should be permitted as long as we understand which emotions are permitted and desirable. However, if these emotions are expressed strongly, we will only be distracting ourselves from attaining reason and flourishing, by giving too much attention to our desires.
Aristotle gives emotion a more important role than Plato does; he emphasizes that if emotions are experienced at the right time in the right way they are beneficial to human flourishing. In Aristotle's mind if the context of the emotion is appropriate, then the emotion itself can be construed as being helpful to attaining moral virtue. If we feel pleasure doing the right thing, express it as appropriate to that, then emotion is a good thing, and will help us flourish.
Aristotle also believes that the soul has two aspects, rational and irrational. Under the rational aspect lies contemplative and practical reason; under the irrational aspects lie the vegetative element, desires, and emotions. He believes though, that in the perfect circumstance emotion and desire can be rational, thus allowing individuals the ability to express strong emotions. It is important for the...

Find Another Essay On Who Knows What is Right?

Who Is Doing The Right Thing?

903 words - 4 pages short) is easily accessible through main subway lines and is an easy commute for those who work in Manhattan during the day. Were a person to walk around Bedford now they would acknowledge storefronts of fashionable clothes and several drinking and music venues. Yet, this is somewhat of a new development. Much like the Lower East Side, Bed–Stuy, has not always been a location for leisure of visitation. Early in the 1960's riots were cased by

What is Just is Not Always Right

967 words - 4 pages giving themselves the ability to consider the morals of others and how different people define right from wrong. Once a person is able to recognize these differences, he or she will be able to confront injustices in a more conscientious manner. Also, as a person considers his or her morals and the morals of those around him or her, that person will be able to better understand what an injustice is. As society expands its knowledge in these ways, each

What is Popular is Not Always Right

1894 words - 8 pages of humanity. This faulty ideology gives the individual the perception that they can overstep moral boundaries. Raskolnikov’s reason ing that “the murder of such a woman is an insignificant price to pay for the confiscation of her wealth and its distribution to the needy”, only created disastrous results because this supposed idea of creating universal happiness only led to going against what is morally right (66). Although Alyona may have been a


1421 words - 6 pages that a person has the right to either live or die with dignity and assisted suicide does not count as part of dignified deaths (Parhizgar, Parhizgar and Parhizgar 415). It is also argued that the work of counselors who decide to deal with terminally ill patients and their family members have the mandate of letting their clients obtain the best end-of-life care possible (Werth and Crow 195). This ensures that there is enough support physically

Divine Right Of Kings: What It Is

757 words - 3 pages The Divine Right of kings: What is it? The divine right of kings is the belief that monarchs or rulers received their rights to rule directly from God, so that all of their actions and decisions were supposedly derived straight from God. The wishes of God were uppermost; the consent and wishes of the people and subjects was rarely ever taken into consideration. A monarch was a direct representative of God. It was believed that a king had

What is the Right Response to Terrorism?

1997 words - 8 pages behind the veil of ignorance, but you ground your judgment on your social position. Torture is not the right response to terrorism. As it has been demonstrated, it is less effective and against any moral, legislative, and political value. Surveillance Emotionality and rationality have to be taken into account also to determine whether surveillance is a just mean to respond to terrorism. The ones who deny the use of surveillance fear what they do

What Is the Right Response to Terrorism?

2141 words - 9 pages actions. Also, torture methods can only be supported by the point of view of the most powerful actor, someone who is sure of being right a priori. If we had to use the veil of ignorance proposed by Rawls, supposing that we do not know if either we are a terrorist or a secret agent working the national security, it would never be right to use torture against anyone. In the end, it is relevant to notice that Dershowitz does not propose data about how

Political Correctness: What Is Right in Society?

1212 words - 5 pages initially had no idea what political correctness was. For example, black people are called African-Americans. These types of things are just a part of my daily life and I never knew it was such a large issue. After realizing what this topic was about, I thought it was a silly issue to write a paper about. I had no idea how I was supposed to get four pages from this debate. The only main problem I really know about is with the University of Illinois

The Fight for What is Right

679 words - 3 pages that he did whatever it took and never gave up for him to get back to Ithaca. Winston Churchill also demonstrated his perseverance when he fought for what he believed was right for the government despite what others told him. When Winston Churchill visited Harrow in north-west London he told students at the school to “Never give in, never give in, never, never, never, never-in nothing great or small, large or petty-never give in except to

what is the right drinking age?

2017 words - 8 pages , especially teachers. It?s parents? position to teach children right and wrong- including what is wrong about alcohol (10A).? Teens are going to make their own decisions about drinking and parents need to do whatever they can to maximize their children?s input before hand. Punishments for driving under the influence must be increased and always enforced. An interview done by USA Today had the CEO of Coors Brewery, Peter Coors, also agreeing that

The Controversy of Global Warming: Who Is Right?

684 words - 3 pages Most people believe that the controversy of the existence of global warming stopped long ago. In fact, that is very untrue. The common belief is that, yes the earth is warming, the glaciers are melting, and our atmosphere is being polluted, all due to man-made green house gases. What’s new? Shockingly there are still some scientists who disagree. Global warming; a very controversial phenomenon that is still happening, which already is not

Similar Essays

Sheila As The Only Charater Who Knows What The Inspector Is Doing

989 words - 4 pages Sheila as the Only Charater Who Knows What the Inspector is Doing Notes: Sheila pg 27 "you see...(…)… tell you?" pg 28 "be careful" pg 29 "I don't understand bout you" pg 29 "no mother please" Ms Birling pg 29 "I'm mrs Birling" pg 30 "we all started like that" pg 30 "mother please don't" pg 30 "you mustn't try" pg 33 "no he's giving us the rope" pg 37 "somehow he makes you

Who Is To Judge What Is Right And What Is Wrong?

592 words - 2 pages Since there are so many "moralities" as there are people and cultures, who is to judge what is Right and what is Wrong? Whose morality do we ought to follow and why? To answer this question one must first come to a clear understanding of the meaning of right and wrong- a topic that has become so subjective and distorted that it is practically impossible to clearly define. Individuals have come to create their own morality so that what is

Euthenasia What Is Right? Essay

2055 words - 8 pages case. Euthanasia is when the doctor actively kills the patient and in this case, the doctor is considered a murderer. In January of 1997, lawyers representing terminally ill patients and some physicians, urged the U.S. Supreme Court to allow individuals the right to end his or her own life with the help of a physician. Some medical ethicists point out the not-so-subtle pressure on poor patients to lean toward euthanasia. What they are saying is

Hardball: How Politics Is Played Told By One Who Knows The Game, By Christopher Matthews

1335 words - 5 pages Hardball: How Politics is Played Told by One Who Knows the Game by Christopher Matthews compares politics to a game played by individuals seeking to gain and maintain power. Matthews defines hardball as “clean, aggressive Machiavellian politics. It is the discipline of gaining and holding power, useful to any profession or undertaking, but practiced more openly and unashamedly in the world of public affairs,” (13). Matthews offers maxims to