Who Owns The Body Essay

1336 words - 6 pages

Before one can answer the question of “Who Owns the Body?” it must be defined what the body is. The spiritual route of defining the body is to encompass the “soul” or “spirit” inside of the body. This is a deeper form of ownership in that an individual’s integral being is controlled as opposed to simply their physical form. Merriam-Webster defines the body as “a person's or animal's whole physical self” (Merriam-Webster). The physical form of the body is a factual, concrete definition of the body, giving it more merit in society, and in law institutions.
There have been several court cases that have dealt with the issue of body ownership. Court cases are the main component to the history of ...view middle of the document...

In the case of Mohr v. Williams, self-ownership was challenged by medical sciences. According to Lawnix criminal Case index, “Mohr arranged for Williams, an ear specialist, to perform surgery on her right ear. After Williams began performing the operation he decided that Mohr’s left ear rather than her right ear required surgery, although the condition was not life threatening. Williams operated successfully on the left ear without having received permission from Mohr.” (Mohr). This prompted the question “If a patient gives a physician specific consent to operate, does the physician have general consent to perform other surgical operations undertaken to treat other problems” (Mohr)? This is a controversial subject if an individual has given consent to be operated upon in a specific area, does that give the right to the temporary “owner” to do what they wish if it is for the better? The court deemed that this is acceptable only if this case is an emergency. “However, this does not allow the doctor a free license to attempt to remedy all problems found that are not life threatening” (Mohr). This case, like that of Roe v. Wade, gave the title of ownership to the individual.
Another case of self-ownership against medical sciences is Moore v. Regents of the University of California. This case involved Moore, a man being treated for hairy cell leukemia by Dr. Golde. During his treatment of Moore, Golde removed “blood, bone marrow, Moore’s spleen, and other tissues” without informing Moore that he had planned to research his cells (Moore). Along with this, Golde also used Moore’s cells to patent his own cell line, from which he gained royalties and stock options (Moore). This case challenged whether a medical practitioner has the right to use an individual’s bodily possessions without his consent and then profit off of them as well. This manipulation was deemed unlawful in court with the verdict that stated, “Under the duty to obtain informed consent, a doctor must disclose his intent in using a patient for research and economic gain” (Moore). This case again proved that an individual has the right to their own body against science if they fight for it.
These cases are all essential parts in the history of body ownership. They show that throughout history individuals have had to face challenges from different medical/scientific fields to maintain ownership over their bodies. These are not the only fields that challenge the individual; there are several other forces with ways of manipulating their influence over the human body.

Works Cited
"Body Dysmorphic Disorder." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 02 Feb. 2014. Web. 03 Feb. 2014.

“Celebrity Plastic Surgery: 8 People Who Have Had Extreme Operations To Look Like Their Favorite Stars.” Huffington Post. 24 Nov 2013. 24 Jan 2014

"11 Extreme Body Modifications You Won’t Believe." RooGirl. 03 Feb. 2014.


Find Another Essay On Who Owns the Body

The Who What When Why of Urban Essence Salon & Spa and our journey into the Bath & Body Products industry?

957 words - 4 pages discovered that opening a Salon & Spa was not going to be easy. We needed to raise capital and I came up with the idea to sell baskets with lotion, soap and body spray. Me being the person that I am, I wanted those products to bear our name. I did a extensive search on the internet and found several companies that did private labeling. We ended up having a full line of bath & body products and at the time I was very happy with the private label

If you know you have Alzheimer's, how do you regard the person who will inherit your body? Is that person you? How is this case connected with philosophical theories of personal identity?

769 words - 3 pages I discover that I have Alzheimer's and that within the space of a year I will lose all my memories and all my character traits. I regard the person who will inherit my body during this time as one and the same person, numerically identical to the person who has been present in my body for my whole life previous to Alzheimer's, but with a high level of qualitative identity. I believe that it is not my memories that make me myself nor is it my

Dr. Harold Glucksberg vs. The State of Washington

967 words - 4 pages of adult years and sound mind has the right to determine what shall be done with his own body.? A matter of law? The 14th amendment states that we have a right to ?life, liberty, and property.? This poses a question: who owns our bodies? The answer to this question should be obvious: you own your body (unless you are religious and believe God owns your body.) These two points bring up 2 perspectives. If you own your own body because the law

Embryo Ownership: Men's and Women's Rights

1306 words - 5 pages been much argument and debate about ownership of embryos, especially under certain circumstances, such as death or divorce. The absence of laws regulating what is to be done in such conditions is causing many problems, and tiresome debates about who owns an embryo. The persons in which the egg and sperm was extracted from should have equal say and control over what is to be done with the embryo. Laws should be introduced to clarify and

My Experience in Medical School

648 words - 3 pages officer for about 4 months after my internship under Dr. Kish Bani (M.B.B.S, M.D.) who is an internist in India. He owns a hospital of 32 beds and I was glad to work with him as he has great skills of patient care. He insisted me that I can sharpen my knowledge and skills very easily by doing residency in the USA. I had a strong will to get some clinical experience in the USA before the start of my residency. It was achieved by getting a chance

Steven Murray Truscott Case

547 words - 2 pages Lawson (the farmer who owns the property where Harper's body was found), and several others. Most of the witnesses called were helping determine Harper's time of death, which is a key detail that could either incriminate, or rule out Truscott.Many pathology and entomology experts were called for both the prosecution and the defense. Five well known pathologist experts strongly doubted Penistan's methods of determining the time of death, and it's accuracy. The trial is expected to continue until January 2007.

Is There a Moral Case for Socialism?

2570 words - 10 pages is the money which it reaps. The profit from the services of all members is distributed by the "community", which is the effective governing body.Who owns your life? Who owns your actions? Who has the right to decide what path you may take in your life? Slavery, we can all agree, is immoral. Each man3owns his own life and right to do with it what he pleases. That is the fundamental human right, equal to all, which we have fought to preserve the

What is the federal government’s strategy to support its claims to sovereignty in the high Arctic?

1641 words - 7 pages scientific evidence needs to be presented. There are many disputes of who owns what but the treaty states that a country can claim the seabed up until the end of the continental shelf. To do that a government must scientifically map and prove where the continental shelf is. Also, if the shelf juts out a country will be entitled to claim that area as well. If the UN scientifically approves claims of 2 or more countries in the same area the States

The Effects of Media on Dieting

1719 words - 7 pages the current situation of people. Media influence on body images had been a controversial topic for a number of years in the world; many blamed the media for promoting unrealistic slim body figures (Stice, 2004). A number of studies were performed in the UK looking into the effect of media images on young people. Body dissatisfaction and eating disorder study (2006) noted that concern over body shape was widespread in female in the UK and

Data Mining and the Social Web

1717 words - 7 pages privacy policy. It makes two distinct categories of its user’s data. One category is labeled “content and information” which is the category you own and “data” which the information Facebook owns and sells to advertisers. This data includes your name, e-mail address, birthday, and other personal information (Jessica Reyman “User Data on the Social Web: Authorship, Agency, and Appropriation.) In a Jessica Reymen research paper it states that a

Human Tissues in Medical Research

1899 words - 8 pages by God, said Robert Nozick [ Bjorkman et all, 209]. A man stubborn effort in raising his body is now being well thought out as valuable objects created by God giving to all human races. There is only man who owns his body, who responds to it and lives with it. Human tissue enters the research by two ways, from donors or from collecting and storing materials left over from medical procedures, which from either death or alive patients. Despite the

Similar Essays

Who Owns The Body Essay

1364 words - 6 pages The human body is a complex system. It is known how the body works and functions, how to take care of it when it’s unwell, and how to dispose of it when life is gone. It has not been however, established who owns the body. Society owns the body because it limits the availability of procedures, influences how individuals view themselves, and defines what a body “should” look like. There are various medical procedures that have limited

Terrorism: Who Owns The Term? Essay

1195 words - 5 pages ” the courts would use the Holy Bible as a swearing oath. "We do not consider ourselves a Christian nation or a Jewish nation or a Muslim nation, we consider ourselves a nation of citizens who are bound by ideals and a set of values." (President Obama) Who Owns the Term Terrorism? Or who is involved in terrorism? All terrorism acts involve violence or the threat of violence. Terrorism goes beyond Islam, Christianity, religion or country. I

Who Owns The U.S. National Debt?

980 words - 4 pages .: Congressional Budget Office, n.d. Web. 28 Mar. 2013. . Surowiecki, James. "Smash the Ceiling." The New Yorker. N.p., 1 Aug. 2011. Web. 28 Mar. 2013. "Who Really Owns the U.S. National Debt?" Townhall Finance. N.p., 21 Jan. 2013. Web. 28 Mar. 2013. Herbert Hoover Quote http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/keywords/national_debt.html#SP3YaWVBGy0KE3ET.99

A Report On Anita Roddick, (The Woman Who Started The Body Shop), Written For A Contemporary Leadership Class

1238 words - 5 pages Anita Roddick - This Woman Has Changed Business ForeverInnocence, passion, simplicity, vision, honesty; these are just a few of the words that describe Anita Roddick's method that has been so successful in taking the reputation and operations of The Body Shop to the standard it adheres to today. The previously mentioned traits of Anita Roddick's management style are clearly the first thing that does/should stand out to readers, but there is