This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Who Would Rule? Essay

1531 words - 6 pages

Who Would Rule?

In the book, The Spiral Road, author, Huang Shu-min makes an observation during his stay in Lin Village. The comment ignites a counter-response from his counterpart, Party Secretary Ye. Little do they know, this comment ignites a debate between the writings of many authors accredited with thorough political knowledge. Alexis de Tocqueville of the 19th century had the most accurate insight on the relationship between human economic and/or and human liberty. The writings of the remaining authors also fuse together to form a generalized theory about the freedom of less-developed societies in China.
Huang Shu-min made observations in the eighth chapter of his book entitled "Prosperous Years." He had mixed feelings as such: "I was impressed by the progress being made in rural China in comparison with other developing nations. It seemed that villagers, as far as I could see, were provided with basic necessities, such as food rations, health care, and elementary education. The other side of the coin, however, was the ever-presented political control, ideological regimentation, and coerced conformity to whatever Party lines were in command. It seemed to be a stiff price to pay for the material improvements the villagers enjoyed" (Huang 132). His observations were purely subjective and bias in terms of the values and beliefs of the villagers he was discussing. The key comment that he made that ignites this whole debate followed these observations. He approached P.S. Ye with these observations thus the argument begins: "The fundamental contradiction then is between economic development and human liberty. In order to achieve quick development, sometimes citizens of less-developed countries, such as China, may have to forgo some of their individual freedom. The problem I weigh is how to draw the delicate balance between collective interests and individual freedom." The argument cannot continue without clarifying precarious words like "freedom", "development", and "liberty"; all words that could make or break the discussion on developing nations.
Freedom can be defined as the absence of necessity, coercion or constraint in choice or action. In close relation this definition, Tocqueville applauds the following definition of freedom: "There is a civil, a moral, a federal liberty, which is the proper end and object of authority: it is a liberty for that only which is just and good; for this liberty you are to stand with the hazard of your very lives. . .This liberty is maintained in a way of subjection to authority; and the authority set over you will in all administrations for your good be quietly submitted unto, by all but such as have a disposition to shake off the yoke, and lose their true liberty, by their murmuring at the honor and power of authority." This definition emphasizes positive liberty, which is maintained through subjection to the authorities, which have liberty as their goal. Implicit in this...

Find Another Essay On Who Would Rule?

Laws of Life: The Golden Rule

709 words - 3 pages ethical conduct referring to Matthew 7:12 and Luke 6:31: do to others as you would have them do to you“. Anyone who has had troubling experiences in the past knows how important a supporter can affect your life. The golden rule involves the lives of people worldwide, and will always remain my most beloved ‘’Law of Life”. Whether it comes to economic, social or political issues, the golden rule will always remain present. Socially, the golden rule

It Isn't What God is, But What God is Not

1594 words - 6 pages Let's play a game; I will give you an example of my rule, and your objective is to guess what my rule is. You may propose other examples to test your hypothetical rule and I will confirm if it agrees with my rule or not. Let's begin; my one and only example of my rule is this: 2, 4, 6. Now, if this question was asked to a sample population, the average answer would be a multiplet of 2 (e.g. 8, 10, 12 or 5, 10, 15). Although, these answers fit

Irish Home Rule

2287 words - 10 pages fighting power in Europe’”.5 Because of this fear, when Gladstone proposed Irish Home Rule Reform Bill in 1886 he inadvertently made certain that the liberal unionists would leave the rest of the liberal party. Gladstone must have felt that his agenda for Irish Home Rule was worth the loss of so great a number of parliament members who decamped from the liberal party at his actions. Party politics certainly factors into why Gladstone chose this

Mapp vs Ohio

1670 words - 7 pages violation of the Federal Constitution is inadmissible in a criminal trial in a state court.” [1]. Ms. Dolree Mapp’s charges were overturned. In consequence of the decision of the Ohio state Supreme Court the exclusionary rule now applied to all cases throughout the United States. Giving every citizen the right to the exclusionary rule in most circumstances, the exceptions to which were covered previously. This would be a victory for many who believed

The Meaning and Constitutional Significance of the Rule of Law

2130 words - 9 pages The Meaning and Constitutional Significance of the Rule of Law The rule of law means different things to different people. The meaning of the rule of law is a state of order in which events conform to the law. The rule of law often is stated to be one of the fundamental doctrines of principle of the UKconstitutional. Generally it has been seen as a characteristic feature of western liberal democracies. A widely-assumed

The Business Judgment rule: A Balance of Two Concepts

673 words - 3 pages A. The accountability Concept Academics have made numerous propositions that would modify shareholders derivative suites by switching the balance more in the direction of accountability. The most impressive case is Professor Gevurtz suggestion to eradicate the business judgment rule . He analyzed the different formation methods that courts had established to the rule, his findings on the business judgment rule different explanation can be

The Cab Rank Rule

1920 words - 8 pages abolishing the rule argue that the ethical duty of the lawyer, as a representative who must facilitate access to the law, would sufficiently ensure lawyers are still accepting briefs and providing access to justice. I disagree, as I believe that the abolition of the rule would be detrimental to every citizen’s right to a fair hearing inherent in our law. Even with the cab rank rule in force we still see some cracks in fair access to justice. It is


1566 words - 7 pages eremitical system or hermit life style living out in the desert, while St. Pachomius was the founder of the second less solitary and more community based way of life. The rule of St. Anthony or the Antonian system left the monks way of life up to his own discretion. This contrasted the Rule of St. Pachomius who were almost all living as a community yet without the stability brought by the rule of St. Benedict. The two rules would rival each

Why is there so much disagreement about the meaning of the rule of law? Illustrate your answer with reference to at least two rule of law theorists

1886 words - 8 pages action." Official rules are not always applied to the actual operation of the legal system. Thus the opportunity cost of a formal definition of the rule of law is accuracy, if we have a formal definition of the rule of law we would lose it?s accuracy as the system becomes rigid and not open to interpretation.One of the approached in defining the rule of law is through the substantive approach where the rule of law is examined in it?s ability to

No Separation of Powers in the UK

1698 words - 7 pages result of the ordinary law of land. There is no clear meaning of the rule of law; therefore it is essential that the government maintains the basic principles of the rule of law that were established by the philosophers who feared the concentration of power in one’s hands, on order to prevent tyranny. Rule of Law cannot exist without a transparent legal system, the main components of which are a clear set of laws that are freely and easily

What Does Unjust Mean to You

1606 words - 7 pages sitting in front of the bus. To treat the blacks how they would like to be treated in their shoes. He added this bit to his speech “Heart of the question is … whether we are going to treat our fellow Americans as we want to be treated.” The earliest reference to the golden rule dates back to about c. 2040 BC ancient Egypt “Do for one who may do for you, that you may cause him thus to do.” – The Tale of the Eloquent Peasant. I

Similar Essays

Society Must Be Governed By Rules

1719 words - 7 pages Utilitarian principle to define the rules that regulate society. Many of the rules of modern society have derived in this manner. For example, it would not benefit the most people if murder were allowed by society. No matter how beneficial a murder might be for one individual, society would not benefit from murder being allowed, and therefore Rule Utilitarianism supports the idea that murder is wrong. However, society does benefit from murdering

Being Rules Under Rule Of Law

1071 words - 5 pages other foreign countries. At the very beginning of our country the Constitution was not meant to be read as a collection a suggestions rather as a way to get men away from their old tendencies. Those were the days where the rights of the average man were the top priority of the government. Today however we need to remember that the rule of the law is supposed to focus on the rights of the citizens and not on who is wearing what in

The Rule Of Law In America

1066 words - 5 pages foreign countries. At the beginning of our country the Constitution was not meant to be read as a collection a suggestions rather as a way to get men away from their old tendencies. Those were the days where the rights of the average man were the top priority of the government. Today however we need to remember that the rule of the law is supposed to focus on the rights of the citizens and not on who is wearing what in Hollywood. Over the years

Health Insurance Portability And Accountability Act (Hipaa)

1793 words - 7 pages the involved entities went into effect on April 14, 2003 (Rothstein).Rothstein (2005) noted that the passage of the HIPAA regulations has caused much confusion among the health care community; he blamed some of this confusion on the lack of resources and the lack of education that needed to be directed to those who would be involved in the implementation of the new rules. Rothstein explained some of the misconceptions regarding the Privacy Rule and