Who Needs Claudio? Essay

1538 words - 6 pages

In Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing two characters stand out more than any others (except for Benedick and Beatrice), not for their dynamic personalities, but for their lack thereof; these two characters are of course Hero and Claudio. Hero and Claudio’s one dimensional personalities are there, I believe, not because Shakespeare got lazy, but because they boost and add dimension to Benedick, and Beatrice, and make the love of these characters truer, stronger, more real, and more believable.
The audience gets its first taste of Hero and her docile character in the first scene, although she only has one line, it is made plain that she is Leonato‘s daughter, and is “like an honorable father,” (I, i, 117) in the way that she behaves in a docile and modest manner. I think Benedick states it best “I noted her not; but I looked on her,” (I, i, 171). This is exactly how we feel as an audience; she said little and does not posses the spirit, or passion to say more: just look to what Claudio says about her; “is she not a modest young lady?” (I, i, 172), and the answer is yes, too modest. Beatrice on the other hand, is fluid and intriguing; we have definitely “noted her,” and not for her modesty. In the opening scene she is portrayed as an intense character full of life and we definitely see the “skirmish of wit between [Beatrice and Benedick],” (I, i, 51).
In reading this scene, we see the “merry war” of Beatrice and Benedick, and feel that these two characters are much more suitable for love, than are Hero and Claudio. Also, we get the first inklings of romance between them; they are both sides of the same coin, and through their fiery discourses we see they are of like mind, and know that they are destined to be together. Through both Branagh, and Emma Thompson’s performance of these two characters we can see that they are more complex and need more inticiment to go for love at first sight.
Claudio and Hero are the complete opposite. They do not talk to each other at all in the first scene, but we are to believe that Claudio has fallen in love with her (or with her estates, being the sole heir to Leonato‘s fortunes) just by looking on her. It is easy to believe and understand Benedick’s skepticism, even though he is a “professed tyrant of love.”
Claudio: In mine eye she is the sweetest lady that ever I looked on.
Benedick: I can see yet without spectacles and I see no such matter…(I, i, 196-99)

We may have said the same, especially if we were Benedick; we do not

even know who Hero is, or what she is like, besides modest, Leonato‘s daughter, and fatherly in her behavior. Beatrice, on the other hand, is a much more interesting character, albeit not the “sweetest” of ladies.
In the film version directed by Kenneth Branagh, he tries to show the apparent spark of love between Claudio and Hero, with smiles and quick fleeting glances. Hero looks smitten, like a little girl with her first crush, and runs off to...

Find Another Essay On Who Needs Claudio?

Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare

3658 words - 15 pages differences between the two texts. The first example of love in the play is the traditional love and romance between Claudio and Hero. Claudio is a young, romantic man, who has an idealistic view of love. As a typical Elizabethan man, he is optimistic about relationships, and indeed falls in love at first sight with a woman who embodies the traditional feminine values. Claudio is attracted to Hero physically, "is she not a

Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare

2503 words - 10 pages him go free. "When she will play with reason and discourse And well she can persuade" Claudio Act I Sc II The third scene in this first act takes place in a monastery, between Duke Vincento and Friar Thomas. The Duke is telling Friar Thomas why he left the country with such haste. He explains that the society has downfallen in the last 19 years and needs someone, to bring some kind of law and order back

"Much Ado About Nothing" : Women's Roles during the Elizabethan Era

1460 words - 6 pages is obvious how much more power the men have compared to the women. After Don Pedro woos Hero for Claudio, her father Leonato tells his future son-in-law, "Take of me my daughter and with her my fortune..." (Shakespeare 20). The reader can understand that during the arranged marriages, women had no say in who they wanted to marry; it was for the men in their life to decide. Furthermore, Benedick talks to Don John about Hero, a wealthy but weak

Much Ado About Nothing- William Shakespeare. Discuss how Shakespeare's original script lays the foundations of Branagh's portrayal of the character Don John.

1686 words - 7 pages like him; devious and shrewd. He makes them a part of his plot to separate Hero and Claudio after Conrade tells Don John to do something with his emotions:'I make all use of discontent, for I use it only.'Conrade encourages Don John to split them up. His intentions are completely different to everyone else's who wish to see Hero and Claudio happy. Don John didn't actually think up the idea to split the two up, Conrade encouraged him to do it.Don

Film How has Kenneth Branagh interpreted Act 2 Scene 3 of Shakespeare?s Much Ado About Nothing?

1667 words - 7 pages to the audience effectively how easily Benedick can be fooled and that at heart he is a lost person who needs belief in himself.After Don Pedro, Claudio, and Leonato go to dinner, Benedick contemplates what has just taken place. Branagh makes a new Benedick, one of no cowardice. You can tell from the tone of his voice that he is now more ?powerful? and more relaxed. . He has changed his mind about women and decides he will win her and marry her

Power Struggles in Shakespeare

1580 words - 6 pages , and that he is unfit to be king. Henry is pushing off his insecurities and doubts of himself on to his son. In the end of the play, King Henry IV part I, Henry also shows his need for power. At the end of the battle, Henry captures and executes all who had rebelled against him. He needs to keep his power and not let any more rebellions happen. Even though the rest of the rebels had run away, Henry still doesn’t feel enough control. He takes his

Measure for Measure Essay: The Virtuous Isabella

1326 words - 5 pages heart and other bits on fire. We see through this carefully controlled man into the roaring pit that he has tried so hard to conceal. He falls a victim to the very passion he is prosecuting in Claudio; in doing so, he comes to represent the conflict between good and evil in Vienna as he struggles with the knowledge that he cannot control his own desires.   When Claudio describes his sister to Lucio in I.i.182-186, he says " . . . in her

Hero and Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare

1628 words - 7 pages along. Their differences and similarities help them becoming friends and eventually wives, and at the end of the play we get the idea that they will forever be friends. Hero's shy and timid nature has become a little more forward and confident; she is growing up as the play continues. By the end, although she has learnt a great deal about the world, she is still just a spoilt child, who needs not speak or act because those

Arranged Marriage Around the World

1995 words - 8 pages Nazneen does not go as far as to physically commit suicide you can say that she eventually killed the person that she once was and was reborn into a woman that discovered how to love herself and how to be loved. Karim is a young handsome man who gives her what she needs to feel alive, something that she never felt being a housewife a big part of her life. “Afghan Woman Jailed for ‘Moral Crimes’ Such As Leaving Arranged Marriages” is an article that

Latin America: A Legacy of Oppression

2113 words - 8 pages “eliminate” them. (Gibson 72) An extremely Christianized view of the natives was formed which viewed them as ignorant pagans. Some accounts reported that, “The natives were so savage and stupid as to be beyond belief. For the say, these early tribes were bestial, and that many ate human flesh; others taking their mothers and daughters for their wives, besides committing other great sins, having much intercourse with the devil, who they served

Food, Population and Environmental Problems: Brazil

3759 words - 15 pages who cannot afford the increasing price of food will occur, creating the existence of food insecurity (Lecture, 4/29/2010). Food insecurity thus directly involves the lowest economic echelons of a country’s society, those who already struggle to subsist. Therefore, it is important to consider the rates of growth of supply and demand within such a developing nation, in order to avoid the possibly of a future famine. Brazil’s demand for food

Similar Essays

Claudio In Much Ado About Nothing By William Shakespeare

2660 words - 11 pages character; he also uses his language to help the audience to understand what Claudio is really like. Claudio is a man who falls in love with a female named Hero who instantly wants to marry. Claudio doesn’t realise he is being deceived as some people don’t want the wedding to go ahead until the truth is uncovered. Claudio is very close friends with Benedick; this is portrayed in the first scene. Claudio is also great

Much Ado About Nothing Essay: An Exploration Of Conformity

960 words - 4 pages could not bridge the gap.               With Claudio the situation is reversed.  Although there is a misunderstanding between Claudio and Don Pedro near the beginning as to who was wooed by who for whom, Claudio has marriage to Hero in the bag.  His pleasure in this is stated and overstated several times.  Yet when Don John, who just recently lied to Claudio about Don Pedro's wooing Hero for himself, tells him Hero has been having sex with

Love In Much Ado About Nothing By William Shakespeare

1724 words - 7 pages . He obviously never loved Hero. It even seems that Claudio is incapable of loving anyone. He could not even woo her! "He is a brash and ambitious would-be sophisticate, who might be thought more likely to ravish a heroine than be speechless," says Bertrand Evans. He is a hero in the war, and he needs Don Pedro to woo the woman he loves on his behalf! It is very obvious to the readers that there is no love in Claudio's heart. At the same

The Components Of Love In Much Ado About Nothing By William Shakespeare

1176 words - 5 pages things Shakespeare revealed was that love makes life complicated. Whether you were a peasant or nobility attending this play; everybody can relate. Love brings struggle but it also brings so much joy in the process. It opens your heart to new beginnings and chances. The same way Claudio opened up to Hero’s doppelgänger or the way Beatrice forgave Benedick and loved him anyway. It opens your heart to new places. Love isn’t a fantasy we all hope exists, it is real. We just have to work to find it and work even harder to keep it. Who do you love?