This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Who's Got The Power? Essay

1188 words - 5 pages

William Kadash 5 Oct 2014 Dr. Bertram, HUM 300
Whos 'Got the Power?
My essay is comparing the theme of masculinity being an indicator of the power a
woman has in a relationship. In both the short story by Hemingway, and the poem by Adrienne Rich, the reader can see that when a man has "masculinity" he controls the power in the relationship during the era in which these are written.
Masculinity can be defined as the possession of the qualities traditionally associated with men. These qualities are typically defined by a society's norms and gender roles. In the early 1900s the role of women was that of the weaker sex, which in turn led to women being dominated by men. SInce women were seen as a weaker sex, men had to express "masculine" qualities in order to keep their dominance over women. What would happen if a man expressed cowardliness qualities in a relationship or marriage? Would he lose that dominance over the woman? Would the woman have more power in the relationship? The theme in both the short story The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber by Ernest Hemingway and the poem Aunt Jennifer's Tigers by Adrienne Rich answer these questions. Both are written in the early to mid 1900s, and both present this idea that masculinity has a profound consequence on the power in relationships. These authors are both suggesting that a women's power in a relationship and/or marriage is heavily influenced by the husband's level of masculinity.
In the early reading of Hemingway's short story the reader gains the knowledge that the main character, Francis Macomber, showed "unmasculine" or "cowardly" character traits while on a hunt in the plains of South Africa. During the hunt, a wounded lion needing to be killed lingered in the high grass. Upon the emergence of the charging lion, Macomber sprinted away in fear of the lion attacking him. This cowardly action was met by disrespect, and utter rudeness by his wife Margot. Due to this action of cowardliness, Macomber lost all respect and dominance over his wife. This can be seen through her actions and attitude towards her husband Francis throughout the story. These actions and this attitude shown towards Macomber become evident to Robert Wilson, their hunting guide, quite early in the story, "So, Robert Wilson thought to himself, she is giving him a ride, isn't she? Or do you suppose that's her idea of putting up a good show? How should a woman act when she discovers her husband is a bloody coward? She's damn cruel but they're all cruel." (Hemingway, 5). The cruelness and disrespect of Margot to Macomber resulting from Macomber's cowardly actions becomes blatant enough for other characters in the story to notice. These attitudes towards Macomber is contradictory to the "prototypical" marriage hierarchy during the time this story was written. During this era, the husband had much power over his spouse, and if the spouse acted in the way that Margot acts in this story, there would be consequences. However,...

Find Another Essay On Who's Got the Power?

The Irish Trinity Symbol Essay

737 words - 3 pages the colors of nature; red stands for power and blue for faith. Its mystic-ness continues to enchant people of all cultures. What are Some Common Misconceptions About the Irish Trinity Symbol? The controversy regarding "who's" on first may never be solved. The Christians staked their claim based on Irish Monks creating the Trinity symbol to aid them in converting Pagans to Christianity. Celts and Irish believe the Irish Trinity symbol

Book Report on Animal Farm

607 words - 2 pages to what they call the "animal farm." The animals rejoice and self governing of animalism begins.Napoleon was really greedy and wanted all the power to be his, so he got the animals to turn on Snowball and make him leave the farm. After Napoleon took over, the pigs started disobeying the commandments that the pigs, as well as all the other animals, organized and wrote down at the beginning of their take over. Soon the pigs have disobeyed, and

Wilfred Owen Dedicated 'Dulce et Decorum Est' to Jessie Pope. How successful was he in exposing her ignorance of the grim realities of war as expressed in her poem 'Who's for the Game'

766 words - 3 pages Although both 'Dulce et Decorum Est' and 'Who's for the Game' were written during the great war, both poem had opposing view points. Both Wilfred Owen and Jessie Pope were inspired to write due to the war but Wilfred Owen fought in the western front while Jessie Pope stayed in the comfort of the home front. 'Who's for the Game' gave young men false impressions of war while 'Dulce et Decorum Est' showed readers the grim realities of war.Jessie

Learning How to Fear

845 words - 4 pages trial that 50 Cent must pass to be a member of the 'pimp legion of doom.' Initially, 50 Cent is considered to be "fresh game to the table," due to having a uniqueness to him because "he don't drive a Cadillac, he don't got a perm." However, 50 Cent elaborates that he has achieved fast progress because of this unique lifestyle and his 'magic stick,' a symbol of power and skill. In terms of gender ideologies, this scene suggests that masculinity is

Parent and Teenager Relationships

838 words - 3 pages matter of control, and the power struggle over "Who's in charge" and "Who's right" begins. Conflict often arises when parent and teen disagree over whether or not the teen has acted responsibly enough in the past to make certain decisions more independently in the future. One reason that the struggle for control continues or heats up is because both parents and teens are human. Parents give up control and then take it back. Teens act

The Present Unhappiness Of Man

542 words - 2 pages According to John Milton's Paradise Lost, the present unhappiness of man is the result of Satan's actions. While in the Garden of Eden, both Adam and Eve were warned of an evil power who was secretly working to destroy their innocence. Because Adam let Eve work alone in the garden, Eve was more vulnerable of being approached by this evil power which is probably Adam's biggest mistake. Once Adam and Eve ate from the tree of knowledge which was

Chapter 3: A Culture-full Mutt

641 words - 3 pages By Lee A. ZitoSix PM. The night starts off with a loud and clear yell from my mom."LEE ANGELICA!!!""WHAT!!!""DINNER!!!""OOOOOOOOOOOKAAAAY!!!""HURRY UP!!!""FINE!!!""STOP YELLING!!!"People might honestly think this is crazy, but sometimes I think I hear my mom yellin' at me, and I yell back, but she never called me in the first place... Ok so I'm nuts and you know it. It could be my parental paranoia. Ever since school got serious, like in the

Comparing And Contrasting "Who's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf" And "Taming Of The Shrew"

1876 words - 8 pages beginning of every tale and story, the women will have the winning hand, but however as we come closer near the end, the males are the ones that always come out triumphant. "The Taming of the Shrew", a play written by William Shakespeare in the year 1592 is a supporting work of literature of the theory started above. Another supporting play will be "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf" written by Edward Albee in the year 1962. The theme of both plays is the


1288 words - 5 pages the mechanics of the car. The illusions of power, of anonymity, of self-containment pile up. You are the master of your domain. Actually driving the car is the last thing you need to worry about. So you can pick your nose, break wind, fantasise to your heart's content. Who's going to know?Jack Levin a Sociologist at Northeastern University's program for the study of violence says "There is a real illusion of anonymity combined with potency

Goodness Essay

1274 words - 6 pages called witchcraft, in which it has said that witchcraft is used by witches, who use this power to abuse others, and cause chaos to the world, and it is only given to witches by none other than the Devil himself. Now, most of the people in Salem didn't believe in this witchcraft, and went on with their daily lives. But when a group of young girls, along with a black slave-woman, committed a ritual to get in contact with the Devil in some way, the

The Field

1563 words - 7 pages at him. " Yes. I love football. Who's ask?" He sits next to me on bus bench. " I got a team, but, no quarterback. You got out of prison today about a job as a football player?" The man stands up from the bench. " Well. I do need the job--wait how do you know I used to football?" He turns his head toward me. " School record, Brandon Thompson" as he walks to his car door. Open it. " What do you say Champ?" as I stand you. " Yes. But, I don't have a

Similar Essays

We've Got The Power To Change The World!

1635 words - 7 pages We've Got the Power to Change the World! It is a daily event that students contemplate spending their hard-earned dollars on everything ranging from necklaces and lingerie to DVD players and video games. Perhaps it is time to reconsider the value of $1. Each student should take a moment to ask him or herself, ''How far can $1 go?'' or, ''What can $1 buy?'' In answering such a question, I expect many students to respond that a dollar has

I Got The Power Essay

980 words - 4 pages Power is the ability to control a person’s life in a way in which the person being controlled has no say. Power is earned rightfully, sometimes. Most of the times, people use wrong ways to earn power which is never theirs to begin with. "Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men." (Acton). This quote is a representation of the story Macbeth, and how the character Macbeth is corrupted by

Analysis Of 'witness' Directed By Peter Weir

969 words - 4 pages win.Ford's performance as a lover is even better, when you consider how miscast the role of Rachel Lapp is; it's got to be difficult to make love to someone who's so far off the mark as Kelly McGillis. She isn't a bad actress, really, but she's way outside her range here; she makes of the respectable and confused Rachel Lapp a naturally slutty woman who, in the real Amish society, would be shunned on general principles. Her performance is so one

Who's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf Essay

1079 words - 4 pages Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? Power Struggles are very common is many marriages. In Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, by Edward Albee, the relationship or marriage between George and Martha is based in power. The power struggle between George and Martha has become the basis of their relationship. Their love has turned into hate. The only connection they have is through their insults and the series of games they play. The power struggle