Why Affirmative Action Should Be Eliminated

1544 words - 6 pages

Imagine waking up tomorrow and reading in the local paper that the government was giving tax breaks to minorities in order to prevent discrimination. Congress insists that the deductions will “help level the playing field” in American society, claiming that diversity is necessary in creating an ideal nation, but is this attempt to prevent disparities and racism not an act of inequality in itself? By putting this policy into place, the government is giving advantages to minorities without showing the same generosity to Caucasians of the same economic backgrounds. Protests would be taking place around the country as citizens argue that the plan violates their Constitutional right to equality. Yet this is exactly the type of scenario seen in universities across the country. Colleges use race as a large factor in admissions in order to create “optimal diversity” among the students. However, this attempt at variety often comes at the expense of white and Asian students. For these reasons, affirmative action policies in college admissions should be eliminated in the United States.
Affirmative action policies were created to help level the playing field in American society. Supporters claim that these plans eliminate economic and social disparities to minorities, yet in doing so, they’ve only created more inequalities. Whites and Asians in poverty receive little to none of the opportunities provided to minorities of the same economic background (Messerli). The burden of equity has been placed upon those who were not fortunate enough to meet a certain school’s idea of “diversity” (Andre, Velasquez, and Mazur). The sole reason for a college’s selectivity is to determine whether or not a student has the credentials to attend that school. Therefore, it should be based only on merit, not hereditary traits (Messerli).
The University of Notre Dame’s point system for determining acceptance is simple: the higher the score, the more likely an acceptance. Unfortunately, race can also be a defining factor in the process. Applicants belonging to a minority received more than double the points than whites and Asians with the same credentials (Messerli).
Moreover, the United States Constitution itself gives all citizens equal rights. Amendment XIV is a prime example of this:
“All persons born or naturalized in the United States…are citizens of the United States…. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States…nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction to the equal protection of the laws.” (U.S. Constitution)
In recent years, the severity of this issue has begun to come to light. The Supreme Court case of Grutter v. Bollinger in 2003 illustrates this. According to Barbara Grutter, a white woman with a 3.8 GPA and 161 LSAT score, The University of Michigan Law School denied her acceptance because of their use of race as a “predominant factor.” Seeing the injustice in this, Grutter took her...

Find Another Essay On Why Affirmative Action Should Be Eliminated

Affirmative Action Should Reduce Inequality Essay

4464 words - 18 pages membership is determined by those labels. It is empirically argued that affirmative action provokes racial tension due to raising race-consciousness. (Fish 2000) However, the program cannot simply be eliminated because it makes people aware of racial conflicts. A program that attempts to eliminate race and gender inequality without leading people to be conscious of their racial identity is virtually impossible to design. Discrimination and racial and

Why the US Should Implement Bans on Racial Preferences or Affirmative Action for Universities

3229 words - 13 pages minorities from California’s Proposition 209, which banned the use of affirmative action in admissions at the enormous University of California system and why states ought to adopt similar measures. It is the author’s sincere desire to influence state policy makers to ban the use of racial preferences, ideally through voter referendums, in public universities vis-à-vis admissions and that preference points should be awarded based on a

The essay is about Affirmative Action and If it should be accepted or thrown away with

520 words - 2 pages More Than Just A PolicyBorn of the civil rights movement three decades ago, affirmative action is the nation's most ambitious attempt to reconcile its long history of racial and sexual discrimination. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., in his famous "I Have a Dream" speech, stated that "I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created

Which Standard of Review should the Court use when Analyzing Race Conscious Affirmative Action Programs?

2009 words - 8 pages or ethnicity may be used as a plus factor in the admissions process. It is my contention that the court erred in Bakke in their original application of strict scrutiny to racially conscious affirmative action programs and should have applied intermediate scrutiny, as it provides a more realistic approach when analyzing the detriments of affirmative action and eliminates the need to weaken existing precedent. Opposition View In Justice

Why Did Weber Suggest That Sociologists Should Study Social Action?

1193 words - 5 pages The general theme that surrounds the ‘Social Action’ approach is the rejection of the idea that society is seen to be a well oiled mechanism that influences individuals to behaviour in a pre-defined manner, though it cannot be denied that a ‘social structure’ does exist, but Weber and various other social action theorists, argue that its whole existence, that is society, stems directly from the interventions of the individuals that are at the

Should the YCJA be eliminated

721 words - 3 pages . Even if there are many controversies behind the YCJA, I do not think it should be eliminated. Since the YCJA was enacted in April 2003, the youth crime rate have been decreasing. According to the Youth Court Statistics, the number of cases decreased 32% over the past decade. The most evident decrease occurred in 2003/2004 and 2004/2005, years after the YCJA was proclaimed. The total cases include violent, property, administration of justice and

Sports Violence: Should It Be Eliminated?

1335 words - 5 pages With the increase in society taking a stance against violence by many people, sports has become an area where some feel that the violent acts such as the hitting and fighting that occurs should be eliminated. You can not change something that has been around for so long because it would change the aspect of the game to something completely different. The elimination of violence should not be done in sport because the violence is a part of the

Against Affirmative Action by JumboMoos Why AA hinders the non-minority and the minority by putting them in a job they are less/not qualified for

596 words - 2 pages many cases affirmative action has set quotas for a certain amount of a certain minority. This is highly discriminatory against those that are more qualified but did not get in because the college had to meet a quota. This is unfair; one should be accepted into a college based on their academic merits, not their race. Using race as a judge of things all throughout history has proven disastrous, why is affirmative action any different?

Why should we examine the technique of non-violent action? What is the possible relevance of this technique?

3356 words - 13 pages . The idea that peace can be established with war just doesn't make sense. But for peace to come of peace is a logical conclusion and a philosophy that has been preached by Gandhi, Jesus Christ, the Dalai Lama and many other wise men throughout history. 'Do unto others as you would have them do unto you'.Why should we examine non-violent action?Violence is not the answerA violent response to violent political situations cannot possibly result in

Affirmative Action, this is a position paper on affirmative action. It would be most useful for someone trying to say affirmative action is wrong

594 words - 2 pages cannot be repaid. Overall, despite the good intentions, affirmative action causes more problems than it solves.Preferential treatment does not teach skills, or educate, or motivate people. It just gives people rewards for being minorities. Instead, people should focus on improving education and conditions for minorities. If people took responsibility for the problem and not just try to skip to the solution, then strides could be made. Moreover, affirmative action, while seemingly a good idea, is a pipe dream that cannot solve our problems.

Why Marijuana Should Be Legalised

1183 words - 5 pages Why Marijuana Should Be Legalised There is no denying that the drug problem in our country today has reached epidemic proportions. The problem has gotten so out of hand that many options are being considered to control and/or solve it. Ending the drug war may not seem to be the best answer at first, but the so-called "war on drugs" has actually accomplished very little. Different options need to be considered

Similar Essays

Why Should School Sports Be Eliminated?

1179 words - 5 pages out one game. That’s about as useless as making a 20 year-old stand in the corner. Attendance is another reason school sports should not be allowed in schools. “Oh they had a late ballgame last night and they’re tired. They get to come in an hour late to school tomorrow.” Wah! Hello people! You’ve also got another student working an almost full-time job who didn’t get off work until 12 a.m. last night! Are they excused to come in an hour late

Affirmative Action Should Not Be Continued

2536 words - 10 pages . Affirmative action was a good jump start to get our nation to where it is today. However, affirmative action should not be continued because it is a form of discrimination, it is more harmful than helpful, and it supplements race or gender for one’s qualification. The government thinks that implementing affirmative action will repair inequality, but it cannot. In the midst of tying to promote equality, they are promoting discrimination

Should Affirmative Action Be Rescinded From Law?

799 words - 3 pages In the mid 1950’s Dr. Martin Luther King started a crusade to gain equal rights for his race. Over several years he was able to convince President Kennedy to pass legislation on discrimination. Since then there has been a great debate on whether affirmative action should be rescinded from our laws. In 1964 the Civil Rights Act made discrimination illegal. Two authors, Ward Connerly and Paul Kivel, have taken different stands on this issue for

Should Affirmative Action Be Allowed In Medical Schools?

1131 words - 5 pages perfect and still racist. Proven that if abolishing affirmative action would be a negative effect to the work place and in higher education, why should we go back to the days of segregation, why not move forward until we can create unity. President Lyndon B. Johnson put it best at Howard University's commencement ceremony in 1965; "we seek not just equality as a right and a theory, but equality as a result." Maybe the world hasn't exactly found