This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Be Critical? Essay

4429 words - 18 pages

I. INTRODUCTIONSince critical thinking is evidently more difficult, more troublesome, than ordinary, garden-variety thinking, the question that naturally arises is, why bother. Why not just say, "Forget it...I'll think (and do, and be) what I want?" This kind of question is not anything new -- Plato, for instance, has Socrates raise a similar question in the Republic, namely, "Why be just?"In this paper I will consider several issues that I take to be related to the justification of critical thinking. The first issue is whether or not the common conceptualization of critical thinking as a dispositional trait possessed and displayed by the critical thinker is correct. The second issue is whether there is indeed some value to the critical thinker in thinking critically, and if so, what sort of value. The third issue is whether there is a relationship between critical thinking, rationality, and morality, and if so, what that might be.I will argue, first, that while rationality is best construed as dispositional, critical thinking is not. Rather, critical thinking would be better understood as episodic. I shall argue, moreover, that this difference is an important one pedagogically, for while it is possible and desirable to teach, and to test for, an episodic critical thinking, it is neither possible nor desirable to attempt to do the same for the students' dispositional rationality.Second, I will argue that critical thinking does have a value, but that, contra Siegel, that value is an instrumental one. That is, one should think critically simply because that sort of thinking is efficacious.Third, I will argue that, although critical thinking per se is episodic and justified instrumentally, it is to be hoped that a person ultimately will develop the disposition to regularly and habitually think critically, for that disposition is directly related to rationality. Moreover, the person's disposition to think critically, that is, his or her rationality, is a necessary condition, and, for problems in the moral realm, a sufficient condition, for that person's morality. Hence, if it is true a) that (episodic) critical thinking is necessary for rationality (the dispositional tendency to think critically), and b) that rationality is in turn necessary for morality, then critical thinking, and the teaching thereof, would be justified not only instrumentally, but would also be justified on moral grounds, provided that morality itself is justified. The question, then, returns to approximately that of Socrates, namely, "Why be moral?"II. IS CRITICAL THINKING A DISPOSITIONAL TRAIT?Despite their differences, many of the interpreters of critical thinking, for example, Ennis, Siegel, and McPeck, seem to accept that a full interpretation of critical thinking must recognize in the concept a dispositional element. Siegel, for instance, in Educating Reason, argues that critical thinking is not properly conceived as merely a set of proficiencies (which he terms "the pure...

Find Another Essay On Why Be Critical?

What Is Ethos and Why Is It Critical for Speakers?

1433 words - 6 pages which ethos is constructed. Louie Giglio is able to establish ethos before he even begins speaking, due to his reputation. Reputation refers to the audience’s knowledge of your understanding of a subject ("What Is Ethos and Why Is It Critical for Speakers?"). Giglio has established a solid reputation due to his educational background. Giglio received a Masters of Divinity at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, and then furthered his

Why is Strategic Recruitment Critical to the Success of an Organization: Case Analysis

980 words - 4 pages Case Analysis: Interviewing, Hiring, and Selection Raymond Buckingham Kaplan University   Why is Strategic Recruitment critical to the success of an organization in meeting its goals and mission? Heidrick & Struggles International, Inc. Heidrick & Struggles International, Inc. is an executive search firm whose primary business model is strategic recruitment for high level executive placement for clients. Companies will need to have

A critical summary of Deborah Tannen’s “The Power of Talk: Who Gets Heard and Why

794 words - 3 pages A critical summary of Deborah Tannen's "The Power of Talk: Who Gets Heard and WhyTannen, D. 2001 " The Power of Talk: Who Gets Heard and Why". From Linguistics at Work: A Reader of Applications, edited by Dallin D. Oaks 242-259.There is no particular way to communicate according the Deborah Tannen as communication is not just saying what you mean but how one communicates the meaning. Situation varies from one person to another. Language

Why It Is Critical For the United States to Enforce a Maximum Wage Ratio

1435 words - 6 pages For Every Minimum, There Should Be A Maximum: Why It Is Critical For the United States to Enforce a Maximum Wage Ratio Across the ages, socioeconomic inequality has been an issue that has plagued civilizations. From the age of the Pharaohs in Egypt, to the Feudal Lords of Medieval Europe, all the way to present day caste-like groupings of lower, middle and upper-class income brackets, segregation has beset itself upon societies, dividing them

"Why We Must Invade Iraq," by Ron Marr, Critical Analysis Paper

2011 words - 8 pages that the other "powers to be" would not attempt, as they are not equipped, to stand in the way of the liberal United States of America. In his conclusion, Marr states that some wars must be fought and he makes an appeal to US citizens to renew the message that the US is a nation that is firmly dedicated to liberty both at home and abroad.Marr's argument/thesis is driven by a claim of policy stating why the United States must invade Iraq. His

Define critical practice in essay writing and explain the differences between a critical style and a descriptive style of essay writing.

986 words - 4 pages Does critical writing style enhance an essay more so than descriptive writing and if so why? These are the questions that will be looked at through this essay as well as defining what critical practice or being critical in academic works really is as well as how it relates to essay writing. The word critical is defined as “involving skillful judgment as to truth, merit, etc… a critical analysis/ of or pertaining to critics or criticism: critical

Critical Thinking Application Paper

823 words - 3 pages evidence where it leads, and are concerned with finding the best explanation.This paper will discuss three following questions:1.Who is a critical thinker?2.Why critical thinking is so important?3.What are the benefits of critical thinking?Who is a Critical Thinker?A critical thinker is a person with an attitude of desiring to avoid nonsense, to find the truth and to discover the best action. A critical thinker needs to be fair and open-minded

Critical Thinking and its Links to Success

921 words - 4 pages not usually clear. Therefore, they can not be solved by programmed decision unless we are able to find another appropriate decision through critical thinking. And these are the main reasons why this is an objective of Management Decision and Control System refers to “apply and critique decision and control models of real world business scenarios.” Here is an example, we have learnt the basic frame of accounting systems, but ‘…there is no

Methods for Critical Thinking

2164 words - 9 pages concept of critical thinking has played a prominent role in intellectual circles throughout history. An exact definition to be agreed upon by educators and intellectuals alike, has eluded these great thinkers since historical records revealed the idea of critical thinking. The literature doesn’t seem to offer one consistent definition for critical thinking. Plato, the ancient Greeks, Francis Bacon, and countless other great

Critical Thinking Is More than Common Sense

1291 words - 5 pages fragmented responses at best; few students would be able to provide clear and concise answers. This simulated example clearly underscores some of the current flaws in the education system across the nation. Instructors teach students, and expect them to learn; they do not teach them how to learn. Many educators have taught students well how to compile trivia and miscellaneous facts, but few have truly embraced the method of critical thought in the

What is critical thinking

1008 words - 4 pages employees to take critical thinking class, why is that? It is because everyone realizes the importance of critical thinking. What is critical thinking? Critical thinking is a complex set of cognitive skills employed in problem-solving and intellectual consideration and innovation. In another words, critical thinking is thinking that proceeds on the basis of careful evaluation of premises, evidence, and information and draw conclusions as objectively as

Similar Essays

Critical Analysis Of How And Why Controversial Issues Could Be /Has Been Included In Your Teaching, With Specific Reference Made To Curriculum Req

1316 words - 6 pages Teachers in every subject area face the challenge of teaching content that may be controversial in some way. The global origin of Language, for example, allows teachers to explore not only different cultures and traditions but also contentious issues as environment, sustainability and historical or current event such as immigration. As a Lote teacher, I personally believe that such issues are a perfect vehicle for students to grapple with their

Critical Analysis Of Dulce Et Decorum Est If You Were Asked To Choose A Poem To Be Included In An Anthology Of Great Twentieth Century Poetry, What Would It Be And Why?

1375 words - 6 pages If you were asked to choose a poem to be included in an anthology of great twentieth century poetry, what would it be and why?If I were asked to submit a poem for an anthology of great 20th century poetry, I would choose 'Dulce et Decorum est' by Wilfred Owen. The reason that I chose this poem is because the reader gets a clear picture of what the western front was really like during world war one. Owen creates this picture by using vast amounts

Critical Rhetorical Analysis: “Why Vampires Never Die”

834 words - 3 pages in this essay verify their notion that the essential core of the appeal of vampires has never changed, and that is why they are a mainstay in today’s pop culture. The use of similes in the essay is critical. Most (if not all) comparisons were made within multiple similes. This is exemplified when they state the similarities between vampires and angels, two profoundly different creatures that have particular qualities in common. Another simile

Critical Thinking: What It Is And Why It Is Necessary

2299 words - 9 pages Critical thinking is associated with various methods and the definition will vary. A business student will look at critical thinking differently from a psychology student. The definition has changed quite a bit over the years; it can be simple and direct, as looking at a situation and asking specific questions and coming up with a conclusion. Educator Diane Halpern’s definition, “Critical thinking is the use of those cognitive skills