Why Causal Connections Do Not Solve The Gettier Problem

1054 words - 5 pages

The purpose of this paper is to show that Goldman's causal theory of knowledge does not solve the Gettier problem. First, I will reiterate the Gettier problem. Second, I will show how Goldman's theory attempts to solve the Gettier problem. Next, I will show how over determination points out a major flaw for Goldman's theory. Finally, I will demonstrate that Goldman's theory does not work if the world we live in is not one of absolute truth and void of deception.

First, when looking at the causal chain theory it is imperative that we understand the basis of what it is trying to do which is to attempt to solve The Gettier problem. So, in order to continue in the building of my argument I will briefly cover what said problem was in an effort to show how the causal theory of knowledge fails to solve the problem that Gettier proposed. In brief: the Gettier problem pointed out that knowledge requires more than a true justified belief. An example that Gettier provides is one where a man: Smith, is told by a potential employer that the man that will be getting the job has ten coins in his pocket, Smith then is justified in believing that Johnson: another man who interviewed for the same position, will be the one getting the job as Smith knows without a doubt that Johnson has 10 coins in his pocket. However Smith ends up getting the job as he unknowingly also had ten coins in his pocket. Smith was justified in believing that the man that has ten coins in his pocket will be getting the job, however we cannot say that Smith truly had knowledge based on this account because he wrongly assumed that Johnson would be getting the job. Hence Gettier said that there must be more to knowledge than true justified beliefs. (add citations and direct quotes from gettier, one or two)

Next, I will show what Goldman proposed to solve the Gettier problem so that I could argue against it later in the paper. Goldman's solution to the Gettier problem fell on the idea that what was missing from the equation of knowledge was a causal chain of connections. Goldman then provided us with two basic patterns in which he attempted to prove that a causal chain of connections would solve the Gettier problem. The first of the two patterns paid focus to perceptual knowledge, knowledge through memory, knowledge through inference, and knowledge through testimony. When one examines Goldman's paper, they see that he divides these four subsections up and provides decent arguments for each one of them.

For perception, Goldman creates a simple example of a man perceiving that there is a vase in front of him claiming: "A necessary condition of S's seeing that there is a vase in front of him is that there be a certain causal connection between the presence of the vase and S believing it present." which Goldman briefly explains, but does not go into too much detail as he...

Find Another Essay On Why Causal Connections Do Not Solve the Gettier Problem

Do you think that the monster in Frankenstein deserves our sympathy? Why or Why not?

1069 words - 4 pages all. But me as a reader do not hate him for wanting to murder, only sympathize.As the story continues, the monster secretly observed the simple family living in the cottage, and for the first time, experiencing the marvelous nature of the human kind. He longed to join the human society and hopes that others would accept him, but as time passes, he learnt more things from them and finally realizes that the human society would never accepted others

The Gettier Problem: A Marathon Essay

1238 words - 5 pages . Erica’s original claim made the generalization true as if it were true. Though Erica’s belief was justified and true, the truth was not stable because her reason for holding the belief true has nothing to do with why the belief is true. In a way, it was a matter of coincidence and probability, or luck – not knowledge. Many philosophers responded to Gettier’s problem – one of them being Alvin Goldman with his Casual Theory of Knowledge. Goldman, a

Do you think that the concept of organisational culture is a useful one in the real world? If so, why? If not, why not?

3912 words - 16 pages initiated (either deliberately or inadvertently) as a reactionary response to problems and this, Bate (1994:8) proposes "may explain why so little is known about the cultural change process in organisations". Bate observes that there is an assumption "that an understanding of the cultural process is not absolutely necessary before an attempt is made to change it".Anthony (1994, in Fulop & Linstead 1999) argues that every cultural change process

Why I do not enjoy living in America

1538 words - 6 pages /goodbye/fd32bc047c46c8228091c758c5f411e3e97bf3e4.html2) http://www.noaa.gov/lautenbacher/ams-broadcasters.htm3) http://democrats.senate.gov/dpc/dpc-new.cfm?doc_name=fs-109-1-1254) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Arabism5) http://64.233.161.104/search?q=cache:LRkUSYutQ9QJ:www.medact.org/content/communique/iraqupdate.PDF+the+estimated+number+of+persons+living+with+a+chronic+health+problem+directly&hl=en≷=us&ct=clnk&cd=1 **This is an essay that I wrote for a sociology class. The topic was: Why you enjoy or do not enjoy living in America. CLB

Why does Insurance Companies Do not Cover Vision Therapy

2346 words - 9 pages images don’t line up” (Wade). Vision therapy attempts to solve this and help people who “‘have trouble making sense out of what they see’” (Press). Awareness of these problems from parents is one of the most crucial components in ridding of the problems. One of the issues with installing vision therapy is at a young age, is often times parents do not understand what is best for the child’s overall eye health. Parents sometimes associate their

Why Driving and Cell Phones Do Not Mix

1993 words - 8 pages their brakes with twenty-three percent more force (“Drivers on cell phones”). The conclusion of the study found that drivers talking on a cell phone and driving are just as impaired as those driving drunk. Driving while distracted is a growing problem and anything that causes you to lose focus and not pay attention to the road while driving should not be done. While talking on your cell phone you are required to have one ear covered by the

Why so Many Job-Seekers Do not Find Work?

947 words - 4 pages is it? You don’t know? If you do not know the answer, then you did not have the most important thing - that which guarantees your success - with you last time you went job hunting. Without it you’ve lost the race before even getting out of the starting block. Do not wonder why you cannot find a job. You are doing something wrong all the time! Unless you empower yourself with this one thing, you are going to have a very tough time finding work

Why Some Students Succeed and Others Do Not

1321 words - 6 pages student’s character? How many really know how or why these differences in character cause one student to shine and one to be lackluster? Most people do not realize that the kind of student they choose to be does not just affect the grades they will receive, but also indicates to others key traits about their character. Before we discuss the differences between students that excel and mediocre students there are, in fact, some similarities

The obstacle to live. Clarifies a lot of issues that the international students face and Americans do not notice. Refers to the language problem

534 words - 2 pages . Every daythey come to the school and enter an American way of lifeand English language; every day they come back home in theirown culture and traditions, speak their mother tongue withtheir families. All of them are put in the limits ofhelplessness and difference. Imperfection in English lacksany practice of this. They are not able to communicate withthe people that are around them now, and therefore cannot becompletely free in their

Why Do Some Children have Foetal Alcohol Syndrome and Some Do Not?

1557 words - 7 pages For many years the questions has been raised as to why not all children are affected by Foetal Alcohol Syndrome even if the mother was drinking alcohol during her pregnancy. The theory that genetics plays a role in whether a child will have FAS first came about through studying twins. In a sample size 16 sets of twins, which were all exposed to alcohol while in the uterus, out of the 5 sets of identical twins, in each set both children were

not turning out, voter apathy and why people do not vote - alevel gp - politics

954 words - 4 pages Not Turning Out This article depicts a key element to low turnout statistics in general elections, referendums and by-elections; Young people are not turning out. The author expresses how voter apathy in under 25’s is increasingly common, pulling on the different aspects as to why there is such a lack of interest in voting. The author highlights how we as ‘millennials do not see voting as a duty and therefore do not feel morally obliged to do it

Similar Essays

Does The Causal Theory Of Knowledge Solve The Gettier Problem?

686 words - 3 pages of storage, but it is also a product of your perception. Goldman believed that evidence, along with previous knowledge causes beliefs. Also, you do not need justification in order to know a true justified belief in which there is causal relation. In other words, the way in which you come about a belief determines whether it is justified or not. Goldman's explanation of the Gettier problem does not solve it. He is only redefining the terms that Gettier set out to define. He focuses on what you can perceptually tell appart rather than on what sorts of justified belief you have.

Why Guns Are Not The Problem

1059 words - 5 pages the problem that should be taken care of. But this paper is here to tell why it isn’t the guns fault for the deaths we have today. What if every year guns were used about 80 times more to save a life than to take one. Well, they do, guns save roughly 2,400,000 lives each year! So imagine the 30,000 deaths, (homicides, accidents, and suicides) and then multiply that by 80. That is roughly the amount of lives saved each year compared to being

Why Great Men Do Not Become President

1427 words - 6 pages Why Great Men Do Not Become President Over the course of history America has been electing the most popular not necessarily the best-qualified men as president. The office has become a strategic component vital to each political party. Parties sacrifice a great leader for the man that will win the most votes. History is a record of how we have always had had this practice. The office is full of corruption because money and influence run

Why Muslims Do Not Eat Pork?

990 words - 4 pages My research question is Why do Muslims do not eat pork? It is about forbidden rules of Islam religion to the followers, or to the Muslims. It is about resistance from eating pork. I said "resistance" because in our modern life there is temptation to eat meat of pig: every where you can meet ordinaries and restaurants where pork is sold, and a lot of people eat it and wish to taste it appear. In this time Muslims ask themselves "can they taste