This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Did A.J.P Taylor’s Analysis Of The Origins Of The Second World War Cause Such Controversy Among Historians?

1043 words - 5 pages

Why did A.J.P Taylor’s analysis of the origins of the Second World War cause such controversy among historians?
It was broadly considered that the Second World War began in 1939 because of Hitler’s plan for world domination; many historians validated this view at the time until A.J.P. Taylor published his book ‘Origins of the Second World War’ in 1961. A. J. P Taylor was the first historian to examine the war with a completely open mind, forcing people to view the origins not as a moral issue but as a political history. Taylor regards the start of the war as a blunder on both sides, stating that “Hitler had no clear-cut plan and instead was a supreme opportunist, taking advantages as they came.” From this Taylor suggests that neither Hitler nor any other Powers want this war. However, because his argument caused such a debate, it led other historians to criticise the methods Taylor used to establish his argument. Hugh Trevor-Roper says that “Mr Taylor hardly ever refers to Mein Kampf...” Mein Kampf is seen as an essential piece of writing when examining the origins of the war. Within Mein Kampf was not a detailed policy of what Hitler planned to do, but the “oracular pronouncement, pointing the way towards the harsh historical path that Germany must tread” argues Overy. Therefore, Taylor’s analysis was so controversial because it forced people to view the origins of the war in a totally new way, not looking at Hitler as a world dominating fascist like everyone thought, but as a normal statesman.

The Second World War was caused by Germany’s desire to revoke the Treaty of Versailles of 1919 and Hitler’s relentless quest for empire. This was considered a valid response to why the war began in 1939, until 1961 when A. J. P Taylor published ‘Origins of the Second World War.’ A. J. P. Taylor’s analysis went against what everyone believed, arguing that Hitler never thought about anything, that there was no master plan for world conquest. Taylor backs this up by stating “this is a war without heroes; and perhaps even without villains.” This shows that he does not regard Hitler to have committed any ‘war crimes,’ he was just a normal statesman. “Hitler did not act alone in the conduct of foreign policy in the 1930’s neither did he dictate its course exclusively.” In the early years of Hitler’s reign Taylor was correct to identify him as an ordinary statesman because during this time there was a different formation of Government compared to the later years in the war. However, it is difficult in retrospect to dispute that Hitler was a normal statesman when looking at atrocities of his domestic policies such as; the extermination of Jews in concentration camps. The war was still in the public memory when ‘Origins’ was published and the myth created about Hitler that he was a madman with brutal policies was strongly embedded in society, therefore to argue against this would obviously create much controversy.

The fact that A. J. P. Taylor does not...

Find Another Essay On Why Did A.J.P Taylor’s Analysis of the Origins of the Second World War Cause Such Controversy Among Historians?

Why did contemporaries engage in such fierce debate over the impact of eighteenth century enclosure?

3383 words - 14 pages Why did contemporaries engage in such fierce debate over the impact of enclosure in eighteenth century England?The eighteenth century carried a number of problems including inflation, the effects of the French wars, the growth of industry and the demand for more food and this compelled farmers to use all available land in a more productive manor. The main obstacle to improvements in agriculture was thought to be the open field system of farming

The Origins of the Second World War

2510 words - 10 pages , causing millions of deaths and changing the balance of power in the world forever. Naturally, the topic concerning its origins is therefore popular, among historians, due to the varying accounts of its origination; while A.J.P. Taylor argues that it was "a war over the settlement of Versailles" , Dr. Ruth Henig contrarily claims that the treaty was "a creditable achievement" . Such is the argument among historians, leaving the causes of the Second

Why did the "Bloody Code" come into such force in the 18th century, and then was largely abolished in the early part of the 19th century?

1957 words - 8 pages Bloody Code. The Bloody Code was not designed to eliminate criminals of all types but rather act as a scare tactic to promote terror into potential criminals. Furthermore, the number of criminals charged and convicted of a criminal offence did not match the number sentenced to death. One statistic indicates that "...only 10 percent of those indicted in London actually received the punishment that they were sentenced to receive."Further analysis also

4. Why did so many Jews remain living in Nazi Germany (including Austria following the Anschluss of March 1938) up to the outbreak of the Second W

1718 words - 7 pages Western countries such as Britain and the United States in particular, and the role Anti-Semitism played throughout the world during this time period, that prevented and severely halted a majority of Jews to emigrate out of Nazi Germany and Austria, after the Anschluss and up until the outbreak of the Second World War. Hitler's vision of unifying and annexing Austria and Nazi Germany into a greater 'German Reich' was represented finally through

A.J.P Taylor’s theories of Imperialism

1330 words - 6 pages the globe”. This concept can be seen in Bismarck’s intention to use colonies to further Germany’s world policy. Nevertheless, Mobley maintains that European imperialism was driven by a combination of factors. These factors were “from a desire of territorial strength, economic opportunities and political prestige.” Taylor’s theories of imperialism were once favoured by many historians, however as time has passed; viewpoints have shifted. A

Why Wind Turbines Have Caused Such Controversy in Puerto Rico

3569 words - 15 pages properly, but according to various articles, when it was first developed it was not an easy process. When the government planned this project, they did not think that it would cause so many controversies that would delay its construction. The main controversy was its localization. Different environmentalist groups took stand and started protests in order to stop the development of the wind farm. According to different articles used in the

WHY DID HISTORIANS OF EUROPE DOUBT THAT AFRICA HAD REAL HISTORY AND HOW HAVE SCHOLARS OF AFRICA ATTEMPETED TO PROVE THEM WRONG

970 words - 4 pages Currently in the XXI century, several researchers are still trying to study and discover more about the history of Africa, which is a huge continent with historical, cultural, linguistic, racial and geographical diversity. However the methods used to discover the history of a continent varies among European or African historians. Such researchers have different ways of seeing what really proves the history of the people, if the best way is by

How and why did the methods used by the PLO to fight for the Palestinian cause change over time?

1574 words - 6 pages advocating the destruction of Israel, the PLO finally conceded Israel's existence because the alternative would have been nothing less than self-inflicted destruction, dislocation, and helplessness.'The new expansion of Israel and the new waves of refugees multiplied the tragedy many times. This is why I have joined the PLO movement. We shall fight for the Palestinians' return'- Ghazi Daniel, Palestinian refugee, quoted in-Bauman M-S, War and

Within the context of the period 1880 -1980, how valid are A.J.P Taylor’s theories in explaining European imperialism in Africa?

665 words - 3 pages colonisation of Africa. In addition, by analysing the colonisation of diverse African countries, e.g. Egypt. It will be possible to see whether his theories of imperialism can validly explain the motives behind European imperialism. The explanation for imperialism changes amongst different historians. A.J.P Taylor’s explanation of imperialism argues that it was European power politics that exported tensions. These European rivalries were played out in

The Origins of the First World War

2048 words - 8 pages release of various diplomatic documents. Many historians then went so far as to place primary responsibility on France and Russia. However, following the Second World War many historians again stressed German responsibility. The complexity of the events surrounding WWI allows for much interpretation and speculation, making a definitive theory virtually impossible. However, the study of contradicting theories allows for some

The origins of the First World War

1010 words - 5 pages individual countries. The book also includes a historical debate about the subject where Ruth writes about many different perspectives and theories of historians. She presents views of different countries which were a part of the war. On this way she gives a really objective analysis of the origins of the First World War and leaves space for the reader to consider all possible causes of the war. - Franc McDonough is a professor of International

Similar Essays

The Social Consequences Of The Changes In 18th Century Rural England Have Caused Controversy Amongst Contemporaries And Historians. Why Have The Changes Caused Such Controversy?

1445 words - 6 pages enclosure cameAnd dreams of plunder in such rebel schemesHave found too truly that they were but dreams"This however being the viewpoint of the villager who can only comment on his own circumstance and of what he envisages around him. There are many conflicting debates that can be had as to why the changes caused such controversy and with all the facts, figures and contemporary viewpoints available then a level debate is in the most part the fair debate, adding to that, contemporaries will hold their views based on personal circumstance and historians will hold their views based on facts, figures and various sources.

Why Did The Second World War Break Out In 1939?

858 words - 4 pages identifying their order of importance to answer these intriguing questions. One factor which contributed to the outbreak of war in 1939 was the Treaty of Versailles. It stated that Germany had to give up large areas of land such as ‘Alsace-Lorraine’ to surrounding countries and pay huge sums of money to the allies (mainly France) as reparations for WWI. It also made sure that they took full responsibility for starting the First World War, and placed

Why Did The Number Of People Migrating To Britain Increase During The Three Decades Following The Second World War?

989 words - 4 pages There are several reasons why the amount of individuals migrating to Britain improved for the duration of the thirty years following the Second World War. Many soldiers from Britain's overseas communities were made to join armed forces. Many men from the Indian sub-continent and the Caribbean islands contributed to the war effort. This therefore emphasised their view of themselves as loyal British Citizens fighting for their country. The

“Why Did The ‘Reconstruction’ Of The South Prove To Be Such An All Around Failure?”

817 words - 4 pages In theory, Lincoln’s plan of Reconstruction seemed an efficient way to redeem the South of its devastation. He was willing to give them a break and do far more for the former Confederates than they deserved. Reconstruction proved to be a failure because Southerners regressive and resistant to change. Because of conflicting viewpoints between Andrew Johnson and congress, the false promises of the Reconstruction Amendments and South’s reign of