Why Did The Nationalists Win The Spanish Civil War? University Essay

3009 words - 13 pages

H1428 Assessment 2: Why did the Nationalists win the Spanish Civil War?
The Spanish Civil war erupted on the 8th of March 1936 between the right wing fascist rebels under the leadership of General Francisco Franco and the left-leaning Republicans who sided with the government of Second Spanish Republic. The war would last nearly 3 years with the culminating Nationalist victory claiming the lives of an estimated half a million people and the establishment of a 36-year fascist dictatorship.
The reasons for the Nationalist victory have been widely debated and dissected since 1939. With the opening of the Spanish Archives after Franco’s death allowing access to a wider range of sources, historians have somewhat adapted there take on events especially regarding the role and ability of Franco himself. The reasons for the demise of The Second Spanish Republic cover a range of diverse factors; such as the strength of respective leadership, troop quality, tactics and foreign military aid. Whilst significant, these components hold arguably less significance in accounting for the success of the Nationalists and are overshadowed by the inherent political disunity of the Republicans as well as the ‘betrayal’ of the European powers, namely Britain. These two ultimately decided the fate of the Republic and the outcome of the war.
The initial weeks of the uprising would prove to be decisive in the outcome of the war. The tactical and military failures of Santiago Quiroga’s government at the outbreak of the rebellion immediately put the Republicans on a backfoot that they would not recover from, arguably making inevitable the Nationalist victory in 1939.
Initially the military balance was not as unfavourable to the Republic as it was in the later stages of the war. The Nationalists still had not yet grouped and coordinated or been bolstered by foreign weaponry.
However, the Republic had failed to put measures in place to prepare for a Nationalist Rebellion that seemed likely. Failure to deliver arms to the revolutionary workers’ organisations and Republican para-military forces seriously hampered the Republics ability to hold regions that would play a vital role in the war. But blame cannot lie solely at the feet of Quiroga as most of the government were against the notion of an armed conflict but the failure to authorise a distribution of arms proved a fatal error and allowed the rebel forces to gain a foothold during the most sensitive stages of the war when they were at their weakest.
Historians, like Christopher Hills, argue that the Republic could’ve defeated the rebels in August 1936 had they acted swiftly and decisively in containing Franco in Morocco and General Nola in Navarre.
Th military balance in terms of troops was roughly equal with Franco’s experienced war hardened African troops holding the balance of power.
They proved vital in the conquest of important food growing regions in the initial stages of the rebellion whilst allowing the Nationalists...

Find Another Essay On Why did the Nationalists win the Spanish Civil war? - University - Essay

Why did the parliamentarians not the royalists win the first British civil war?

1800 words - 7 pages Why did the parliamentarians not the royalists win the first civil war?This essay is directed at not only showing why the parliamentarians won the first civil war but why the royalists lost. Many points shall be examined such as finance, leadership, foreign support, motives for fighting, and regions of control through out Britain and the New Model Army.There were two sides in the civil war; royalists who supported the king, who also known as

Why did the Communists win the Chinese Civil War - GCSE History - Assignment

731 words - 3 pages Why did the Communists win the Civil War? Did they win it; or the Nationalists lose it? Main reason – military · Against Japanese – Communists had learnt how to fight against larger forces · Guerrilla warfare highly successful · In Manchuria – also worked well · Terrain was hilly and large forested areas · 1930s Mao wrote – when fighting a superior enemy communists should establish base areas in the mountains and mount surprise attacks against

Why did the Chinese Communist Party Win the Civil War in 1949?

1297 words - 5 pages The Chinese Civil War, which lasted from 1927 to 1949, was a civil war in China which the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) overthrew the Guomindang (GMD) . As the CCP had always been inferior to the GMD in many aspects, many were shocked and startled by the Communist's victory; although numerous factors show that the Communist's victory was almost inevitable. This essay will examine the factors that lead to the Communists victory, which includes

Did the North Win the Civil War before it Began?

1093 words - 4 pages Did the North Win the Civil War before it Began?      I agree with the idea that the North had won the Civil War before it began to the extent of Lincoln’s conservative political stands. Trying to receive the favor of the South while winning in the North would require Lincoln to take neutral stands in heated political issues like slavery. It wasn’t really wan by the North until he broke away from these stands to enact the Emancipation

Why did the Americans win the War of Independence?

2359 words - 9 pages Why did the Americans win the War of Independence?Before the first shots were fired in the American War of Independence, very few people gave the Americans (also known as the 'colonists' or 'patriots') a chance. Britain had a population of 11 million compared to the patriots 2.5 million of whom 20% were slaves. Furthermore Britain had the most powerful navy in the world, an experienced and well-armed standing army of 48,000 men and the support

How and Why did America 'Win' the Cold War

3457 words - 14 pages hastened its own disintegration. Or, as former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and expert on the USSR Robert Gates encapsulates, "did we win or did the Soviets just lose?" The essay commences with a brief overview of the Cold War.The Cold War was the continuing state of conflict, tension, and competition that existed after World War Two. On one side were the USSR and its satellite states, and on the other were the powers of the

Why Was Isabella Able to Win the Civil War in Castile 1475-1479. - History - Essay

1235 words - 5 pages Olivia Springall Why Was Isabella Able to Win the Civil War in Castile 1475-1479. During the late 15th century in Castile, a civil war took place. This war was between two women who both claimed to be the rightful queen of Castile. These two were Isabella of Castile and Juana La Beltraneja, or Joanna the bastard. In this essay I will argue that the main reason for Isabella’s victory was the fact that her opponent, Joanna, and Joanna’s council

Why Did The Civil War Start?

566 words - 2 pages In this chapter I will try to find out why the Civil War actually started, and what the consequences of the war were. To find out this I need to know a little more about the history of the Civil War. The causes of most wars are often very complex, but in the America civil war it came down to two major issues, slavery and the protection of the Union. In the North, they were growing richer all the time as industry developed fast. The workers

Was It The Contribution Of Foreign Powers That Tipped The Balance Of The Spanish Civil War In Favour Of The Nationalists?

1459 words - 6 pages efforts to prove that the Guernica never happened. Astray used the Catholic Church to promote the Nationalists. Most Spanish priests sided with them, some even fought, and they blessed the flags of the Nationalist regiments, so that the Nationalists appeared the defenders of the Catholic Church.Overall it can be concluded that it was not foreign aid alone that tipped the balance of the Spanish Civil War in the Nationalist's favour although it did play

Why did George.W Bush win the war in Iraq in 2003

1514 words - 6 pages Aylin Kaplan 4272407 Why did George W. Bush decide to invade Iraq in 2003? Explain your answer.When we are asked the question of why did George W. Bush invade Iraq, we can think of multiple reason's. Some of the claim's for the invasion of Iraq were oil, to stop the war of terror, revenge for the event's of September 11 and Saddam Hussein generating weapon's of mass destruction (WMD). Of all of these claims, one main reason can be seen to why

How did the Spanish Civil War contribute to appeasement by Britain?

2036 words - 8 pages How did the Spanish Civil War contribute to the policy of appeasement by Britain?Until 1931 Spain, the poorest country in Europe at the time, was a monarchy however, as a result of deep divisions within society exacerbated by the military rule of Primo de Rivera imposed in 1923, the incompetent King Alfonso XIII abdicated. Following municipal elections a liberal government took power but the ensuing republic was immediately at risk from the

Similar Essays

Weapons Of The Civil War: Why Did The North Win?

1626 words - 7 pages Weapons of the Civil War: Why Did The North Win?      Battles have been fought since the dawn of time. Weapons have gradually become more technological and sophisticated each and every time. People learn from their mistakes, as did the Indians in the late 1700s, as well as the Confederate troops from the Civil War. The Union was victorious in this war for freedom, and to this day, the north is more the heart of the country’s economy

Why Did The Bolsheviks Win The Russian Civil War?

837 words - 3 pages Why did the Bolsheviks win The Russian Civil War? Although Lenin was able to bring an end to Russia's role in World War I, he was unable to avert the happening of a Russian Civil War, a time of great chaos. Towards the start of the Civil War, the Bolsheviks struggled immensely. Their opponents, "The Whites", were made up of any anti-Bolshevik groups: supporters of the Tsar; Mensheviks; Social Revolutionaries; capitalists and the Czech Legion

Why Did Lenin And Trotsky Win The Russian Civil War?

764 words - 3 pages Key points of essay; (for revision purposes)1. Trotsky and the red army2. Weakness of the White armies3. War Communism4. Attitude of the peasants5. Propaganda6. Red terror- Cheka7. Allied WithdrawalJuring the Russian civil war Leon Trotsky played a major role. He was commander and chief of the red army, which fought on the side of the communists. As a much experienced and brave commander he won many battles against the white armies through smart

Why Did The South Lose The Civil War And How Did The North Win?

579 words - 2 pages There are a few reasons why the South lost the Civil War. One reason is that the North not only outmanned the South but also at almost every point, militarily. The South was also outclassed industrially. If it was not for European recognition and military aid the South would have never had a chance to win. Industrially the South could not keep up in out put and in manpower. By the end of the war the South had, more or less, plenty of weaponry