Why Did Trotsky Not Become The New Leader Of The Bolshevik Party After Lenin's Death?

3990 words - 16 pages

When Lenin died on the 21st of January 1924 many thought that Trotsky was his natural successor as the leader of the Bolshevik party. However, even prior to Lenin's death, Stalin was building his power base, which ultimately would allow him lead the Bolshevik party.

In October 1927, Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev were expelled from the Central Committee of the Bolshevik party of Soviet Russia. Under pressure from the Central Committee, Zinoviev and Kamenev agreed to sign contracts promising not to create conflict in the party by making speeches attacking official policies. Leon Trotsky refused to sign and was exiled to the Turkish island of Prinkipo.

On the 21st of December 1929 Stalin celebrated his 50th birthday as the absolute dictator of Soviet Russia.

How was Trotsky able to be backed by Lenin and considered by most Russians as the clear choice for the next leader after Lenin's death and still not become the leader of the party? Trotsky had substantial power. He was the commissar for war with a considerable level of respect. He was the hero of the civil war; he had a growing cult who had faith in him without question. However, this just fuelled his arrogance and he failed to even acknowledge the threat of Stalin.

I will go onto discuss the reasons and opinions behind one of histories greatest misfortunes.

Trotsky versus the Triumvirate

From 1921 until his death in 1924 Lenin suffered a series of strokes. However, he kept working until a major stroke made him mute in March 1923. In 1923 Trotsky then found himself up against Stalin, Zinoviev and Kamenev (the triumvirate) for the leadership. Trotsky was no longer fighting class enemies as he had been in the civil war. He was now fighting his own members of his party which for someone so devoted to his party and the cause must have been hard.

The triumvirate was an odd alliance in hindsight, as the trust between the three men was very misplaced. Zinoviev thought he was using Stalin to get into power. He was probably the most delusional of the triumvirate because he genuinely felt that he was going to be the next leader of the Bolshevik party. Kamenev was showing his support to his friend Zinoviev and the old Bolsheviks of the party, he just wanted to stop Trotsky, a new and ambitious member of the party, from becoming the leader over the older members who had been dedicated to the cause for longer. Stalin was actually using Zinoviev and Kamenev to defeat Trotsky. Trotsky describes Stalin as "The most eminent mediocrity in our party." John Reed, who recorded the October revolution in his book, "Ten Days That Shook the World", described Stalin as a "grey blur, looming up now and then dimly and not leaving a trace." Stalin was clearly underestimated by everyone.
In 1921 a pressure group within the party, calling itself the Workers' Opposition arose calling for trade union rights. Lenin implemented a policy condemning them. He then went further and succeeded in passing a resolution which...

Find Another Essay On Why did Trotsky not become the new leader of the Bolshevik party after Lenin's death?

Why Stalin Emerged as the Sole Leader of the U.S.S.R. and Not Trotsky

754 words - 3 pages Why Stalin Emerged as the Sole Leader of the U.S.S.R. and Not Trotsky Trotsky was a leading Bolshevik and played a pivotal role in the revolution, persuading Lenin to delay the revolution until the Bolshevik’s had a much stronger place in the country. He also was crucial to the civil war, as he organised the troops and motivated them. Stalin on the other hand was in charge of all the dull jobs within the Bolshevik party

Lenin's Problems after the October Revolution, how did he deal with them?

762 words - 3 pages is affirmed by historians Strayer and Gatzke.Lenin faced complex problems after the initial triumph of the October Revolution subsided. He was left with a foreign war to end, and a domestic one to quell. Both terminated victoriously only on an ideological level. The massive devastation that the new government confronted was aggravated by harsh war communism policy. With the gradual increase of Lenin's New Economic Policy came controversy and some emergency relief. Ultimately at the time of Lenin's death the Soviet Union was still plagued, though perhaps not as severely, by economic and social distress.

Short essay discusses why Socrates did not fear death.

614 words - 2 pages is not at risk, it is hard to determine if they will fear death when the time comes. Generally speaking, people fear what they do not understand. If one does not understand why their life is endangered or must be sacrificed it is likely that they will fear death. If a person has not achieved their goals in life, contributed in some way to the world or impacted the life of another person, they will not be so willing to give their life away

Did the Constitution intend for a multi-party political system, or did this system simply become prevalent in America on its own?

972 words - 4 pages ' presidency hoping to stay in power by silencing some political opponents and ensuring that others would not have the opportunity to vote. Soon after, Jefferson was elected president after an electoral tie with Aaron Burr, and the Acts were repealed due to unconstitutionality. Interestingly enough, the Alien and Sedition acts were actually intended to silence critics of the Federalist party and presumably to support a single-party system within

Princess Diana: an insightful look at the media's involvement in her death how did the media impact her death and how did they handle the after affects

912 words - 4 pages the use of the photo. A letter to the public is on the site, stating "Bild did not buy any photographs of the bodies of Princess Diana and Dodi and does not intend to buy such photographs." Just because the paper denied buying pictures they are still guilty of supporting the paparazziFrench authorities confiscated some film taken by paparazzi, according to reports. Some photographers were arrested after allegedly tailing and then not aiding the

Team Dynamics. Good leaders are made not born. If you have the desire and will power, you can become an effective leader.

898 words - 4 pages Team Dynamics.Good leaders are made not born. If you have the desire and will power, you can become an effective leader. Good leaders develop through an ever-constant process of self study, education, training, and experience. This comes in very handy when dealing with teams due to the fact that the leadership hat is going to change according to each member's region of proficiency. The leader isn't necessarily going to issue instructions

After Kristallnacht, no German citizen could say they did not know what would happen to the Jews.

910 words - 4 pages , regardless of conscience, was able to help. As a fireman in Laupheim during Kristallnacht remembers :"Eventually we were allowed to tale the fire engines outs, but only very slowly. We were ordered not to use any water till the whole synagogue was burned down. Many of us did not like to do that, but we had to be careful not to voice our opinions because 'the enemy is listening'."This forced disregard for Jewish property and Jewish citizens was planned by

"The changing of Mary Willis" in the novel Cold Sassy tree What did she do after the death of her mother? Read about how the timid, immature Mary Willis became bold and helpful.

602 words - 2 pages After the death of her mother, Mary Willis Tweedy was very heartbroken. She went into many weeks of mourning and nobody thought that she would ever recover. Mary Willis was very dependent on her mother. However, Mary Willis did emotionally mature greatly in the course of this novel.In the beginning of this novel, Mary Willis was very laid back. When Grandpa Blakeslee told her to do something, she did it with no questions asked. She rarely voiced

System Failure: Abandoning New Orleans - essay about whether or not it is worth it to rebuild New Orleans after the hurricane katrina.

1117 words - 4 pages . Instead, it would be best to relocate the citizens of New Orleans to nearby cities. Lastly, is the location of the city. New Orleans is in area prone to hurricanes. With the chance of a similar storm hitting it again, why take the risk? Therefore, by abandoning New Orleans, we are assuring ourselves that history will not repeat itself.

Conclusion of wether or not Emily Dickinson believed in life after death...Comparrison of "Because I Could not Stop for Death" and "I Heard a Fly Buzz".

700 words - 3 pages Light after the DarkTwo Poems. Two Ideas. One Author. Two of Emily Dickinson's poems, "Because I Could Not Stop For Death"(940-941)and "I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died ,"(941-942) are both about one of life's few certainties: death. However, that is where the similarities end. Although both poems were created less than a year apart by the same poet, their ideas about what lies after death differ. In one, there appears to be life after death, but

Evaluate the role of Leon Trotsky in Bolshevik success in the period 1917-1924.

2334 words - 9 pages letter to break off all personal relations because Stalin behaved in an offensive manner towards Lenin's wife. However, after Lenin's death Stalin began to manipulate Trotsky and the party, in his favour. It would not be long before Trotsky begins his great downfall in the party by being removed and expelled.In conclusion, Leon Trotsky was a very important in the Bolshevik success. His belief in world revolution resulted in a commitment to

Similar Essays

Why Did Stalin Take Power And Not Trotsky? The Power Struggle Between The Bolshevik After Lenin's Death.

1306 words - 5 pages Why did Stalin take power and not Trotsky?In 1921 Lenin died and a power struggle emerged upon the top members of the Bolshevik party to take over as leader of the Bolshevik party no knowing that in doing so will eventually get themselves exiled out of Russia or Killed by a man largely underestimated and never thought to go to the extremes he did.Lenin had been ill for some time and it was obvious he was not going to live for much longer after

Why Did Stalin Rather Than Trotsky Emerge As The Leader Of The Ussr After Lenin's Death?

1732 words - 7 pages see him as a loyal member of the Bolshevik Party. Due to his very strong views that he refused to back down from he was seen as the most likely to try and establish a dictatorshipAs well as Trotsky's inability in political intrigue he also made multiple mistakes. The fact that he did not appear at Lenin's funeral meant that many saw him as disrespectful to a leader who they were starting to idolise. This factor has been a point of discussion for

Lenin's Contribution To The Development Of The Bolshevik Party

964 words - 4 pages made by Lenin to the development of the party, as Lenin's ideas were the basis for the Bolshevik Party's new slogans, 'Bread, Peace, Land' and 'All power to the soviets' were the messages Russian public wanted to hear, especially as shortages were not getting any less. Lenin encouraged the Bolsheviks to put the message out that the Bolsheviks would give people what they wanted most, the message had not changed, but people

Why Stalin, Not Trotsky, Became Lenin's Successor

613 words - 2 pages Stalin emerged as Lenin's successor for many different reasons. Stalin was a vicious man with many strengths which helped him gain leadership. He was the quiet one in the Bolshevik party, but appeared as Lenin's loyal colleague after his death in 1924.Stalin took on the job of General Secretary and that put him in control of the Bolshevik party. With his position, he promoted his friends and those who supported him and he demoted his opposition