This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Diverting Water From The Great Lakes Region Is A Bad Idea

890 words - 4 pages

Water is the foundational basis of life on Earth. Ecosystems, society and humans are completely dependent on it, and as the world population continues to grow, there will be more mouths to feed, and those people will need water to continue their daily lives. However, shortages and poor management leads to the destruction of natural habitats and human suffering. Desertification of land in China is ever-increasing, turning green, lush land into desert. However, this is due mainly in part, because of human activity, and global warming (Wang, Yang, Dong, & Zhang, 2009). The United States could experience a crisis similarly to China’s, but for now they have averted such a catastrophe, because of heavy regulation of water. Though there are water shortages in many parts of the world, it is unwise to export water from the Great Lakes to those regions. Two major reasons why diverting the Great Lakes is a terrible idea, one: it allows for waters wars to start on the basis of who is allowed to access it and for commodification purposes. Two, diverting water on such large scales could have cataclysmic effects on the local residents as well as the environment.
Water War
United States regions that may have the largest interest in the Great Lakes would be the Southwest and Southeast. The Southwest because the majority of the region is desert and has seen a steady increase of population (Jones, & McCormick, 2010). The growing population has added to the burgeoning overuse of water. This overuse of water has spurred talk to divert water from Canada to the Southwestern United States. According to Tony Clarke of the Polaris Institute, President Bush, in 2001, would like to begin negotiating with Ottawa on water exports from Canada (Clarke, 2008). The Southeast is not as likely to need diverted water because of their green lands, and mountain spring water. However, during 2005-2008 there was an extreme drought in the Southeast. I know this because I was living in Georgia at the time. In Atlanta, where it was the hardest, Lake Allatoona and Lake Lanier supplied the majority of the city’s water, but began drying up. I remember hearing of proposals to pipe water from the North when droughts would hit, which would infer political debate.
Legal battles would ensue if the mass exportation of the Great Lake’s water was allowed. Regions requiring the water would tie up the legal system with lawsuits, vying for the right to divert water. Courts then would need to determine who is allowed access and at what amount. This in itself would be a legal nightmare, not to mention the environmental impact it would have on the lakes. Fortunately a binational...

Find Another Essay On Why Diverting Water From the Great Lakes Region is a Bad Idea

Explaining Wartime Rape In Armed Conflict: The Great Lakes (Sub-) Region

3689 words - 15 pages MSc International Relations and Diplomacy Master Thesis Lab Draft Research Proposal Jana Matejkova 17 March 2014 Draft Thesis Title Explaining Wartime Rape In Armed Conflict: The Great Lakes (Sub-) Region Draft Research Statement Sexual violence in armed conflict and wartime rape has been part of the spoils of war from time immemorial. A long dismissed inevitable consequence of the conflict is now widely recognized as an important problem of

"A Thousand Acres" Analysis: Jane Smiley's Folly - Why Rewrites Are A Bad Idea

904 words - 4 pages In Jane Smiley's "A Thousand Acres", the main focus is one of the family and familial relationships. Smiley presents what at first seems to be a typical American farm family, but is quickly revealed to be anything but. Her message is quite clear (since she stole it from Shakespeare); love in its very nature is something one cannot measure, attempting to do so can only lead to disaster. However, Smiley has put a new spin on the love involved in

The Willandra Lakes Region

677 words - 3 pages when they were full. The top layer is composed largely of wind-blown clay particles heaped up on the lunettes during periods of fluctuating water levels, before the lakes finally dried up. That is why most of the lakes are fringed by a lunette on their eastern shore. Why is the Willandra Lakes Region of environmental importance? Criterion (iii): When the lakes dried up, it allowed the survival of important evidence on the way the indigenous

An Open Campus is a Bad Idea

659 words - 3 pages student misses or skips a class, the information taught that day would not be accessible in the same format which others have learned. One?s academic grades can be effected from lack of information by truancy. Irresponsible students who choose to take the risk of leaving their school after lunch for the remainder of the day will not have this opportunity if an open campus is kept closed.      Local businesses and neighborhoods can be disturbed if

Pollution in the Great Lakes

1232 words - 5 pages pollutants that leach into the waters. When rivers, like the Humber River, become polluted, they eventually run out into the Great Lakes. This is why regular litter from suburban areas is also a factor of pollution in the lakes. There are many ways pollutants can enter lakes and rivers: agricultural and urban runoff, industrial outfalls, migration through groundwater, through the food chain, and many more. Many pollutants do not dissolve, so they


576 words - 3 pages An Essential Question for our students: What are my basic needs? What information is out there that can improve the quality life for myself and my community? Collections of ethnographs from the Nile region will help us understand obstacles that impede the stimulation of water shared initiatives and innovations. To obtain ideas about innovations, we will collect ethonographs from citizens, examine privatization and regulation practices

Medicinal Marijuana is Bad Idea

4425 words - 18 pages Marijuana is a psychoactive drug made from the dried leaves and flowering parts of the hemp plant. It is one of the most strictly classified illegal drugs in the United States. Under the 1970 Controlled Substances Act, marijuana is listed as a Schedule I substance, which defines it as having 'a high potential for abuse'; and 'no currently accepted medical use.'; Marijuana is therefore classified more severely than cocaine and morphine, which

National ID, a bad idea…

1727 words - 7 pages National ID, a bad idea…. In today’s world, we can say that the main danger to privacy, security for people who lives in free democratic societies can come from the system that will create and apply supposedly very high tech national ID card. The main purpose of National ID card system in a country is to develop nationwide security, decrease crime rate, reveal the terrorists, and guard against illegal immigrants. NID system has been used

School Uniforms: A Bad Idea

1330 words - 5 pages themselves and wondering, “Who am I?”. A survey, of 100 random students, conducted at Zapata High School showed that 72% of students reviewed felt that wearing a uniform suppresses their ability to express themselves as individuals. Forcing students to wear a uniform is also going against the first amendment, which clearly prohibits Congress from making laws that violate freedom of speech; it includes freedom of expression regardless of what

Asian Carp in the Great Lakes

982 words - 4 pages used to prevent Asian Carp from entering the Great Lakes as well. What are the plans to stop the Asian Carp? The White House has taken action and a 78.5 million dollar budget has been set. Plans include building new barriers between the Chicago canal and the Des Plaines River. There is already an existing electric barrier there, but the carp may be able to bypass the barrier when water levels are high and the two waterways mix. How do electric

Asian Carp vs the Great Lakes

1343 words - 6 pages of the Illinois River. However, this would not stop the Asian carp from entering the Great Lakes, it would just decrease the population. One of the most expensive, time consuming, and effective solutions is to build a physical barrier to keep Asian carp out of the Chicago River and the Great Lakes ( In order to complete this enormous structure

Similar Essays

First Inhabitants Of The Great Lakes Region

3883 words - 16 pages Great Lakes Region. Shortly following the glacial retreat of the upper Great Lakes region around 11,000 B.C., the flora and fauna in the region began to develop prior to and upon the arrival of the “Paleo-Indian tribe, circa 7000 B.C. to 4500 B.C.” (Quimby 6). Between this time period, in 6000 B.C., the basins of the upper Great Lakes became entirely ice free and moraines and depressions began forming the shapes of the lakes when water from

Water Pollution In The Great Lakes

837 words - 4 pages rivers, like the Humber River, become polluted, they eventually run out into the Great Lakes. This is why regular litter from suburban areas is also a factor of pollution in the lakes. There are many ways pollutants can enter lakes and rivers: agricultural and urban runoff, industrial outfalls, migration through groundwater, through the food chain, and many more. Many pollutants do not dissolve, so they cycle through the food chain, and harm the

Falling Water Levels Of The Great Lakes

1017 words - 5 pages extract salt from the oceans and this is a time consuming and expensive process. Why Care? The Great Lakes have close to 11,000 miles of shoreline and more than 530,000 acres of coastal wetlands according to CBC News. The Basin provides the world's largest source of fresh water supplying such uses as public, domestic, agricultural, industrial and hydro-electric power. In order to preserve this amazing resource required for the survival of every

Why Is Dropping Out Of School A Bad Idea?

727 words - 3 pages PAGE Why is dropping out of school a bad idea?Does someone have a future if they do not stay in school? Education is the only way to someone can get ahead in life. Education is the only way you can better your life in society today. It allows you not only to get a good job and to be respected in the community for what you have achieved. If you want to live the good life, it would be bet not to drop out of school. As the prices of things go up