This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Do We Give? Essay

1461 words - 6 pages

Three Cups of Tea, the story of Mortenson and his extraordinary school-building initiative in a remote part of Pakistan, provokes many interesting lines of inquiry. In this outline it is proposed to address the question of why we give. What compels someone like Mortenson to take on an enormous and selfless act? And how effective are the most effective individual acts of goodness?
Why do we give? First, there is the “humanitarian imperative”; we help because we can. The obligation to assist arises from our ability to do so. Second, we assist because we are conscious of belonging to a single community of mankind. Mortenson gave with no expectation of reciprocity. Third, we make these gestures because they show us in good light, both to ourselves and to others. Fourth, we make this effort because we believe that reinforcing economic and social basis of society promotes peace and stability. There is a whole philosophy of “functionalism” based on the idea that an educated, prosperous society is also a peaceful society. Fifth, Mortenson may not have been aware of this but gestures like his soon attract support from other sources whose motives may or may not be as pure as the original gesture. The motive might be national interest, economic interest, or security or political influence . . . etc.
Each of these five points is subject to serious questioning and doubt. Take the humanitarian imperative. We feel an obligation to help because we can help. If you cannot swim there is no obligation to dive into the water to save someone. But note, often our humanitarian impulse is seriously compromised or constrained by problems of access. The greatest need is in the most remote parts of the world and Mortenson’s achievement is that he was able to overcome, at least to some extent, the problem of access, both geographical and cultural. The international humanitarian response to Haiti has so far been seriously constrained by problems of access.
Secondly, we assist because we are conscious of belonging to a community. But in a real community there is give and take. In all human societies, receiving assistance is made acceptable by the thought that one day we can do the same. In other words, reciprocity is very important. But in most international giving, there is no reciprocity. What can the people of Haiti give us in return? If they cannot, then receiving our assistance gives rise to feelings both of gratitude and of embarrassment and eventually of resentment. It would be good to review Mortenson’s story keeping this point in mind. How much of the resistance that he encountered was due to the fact that he was an outsider wanting nothing in return? The story glides over this point; his motives are not questioned, except by religious bigots.
Thirdly, we give because it is said that giving shows us in a good light: the more disinterested we are the more effective we are. It would be interesting to examine how Mortensen made sure that...

Find Another Essay On Why Do We Give?

Why Do We Sleep? Essay

762 words - 4 pages “Why do we sleep?” is a very popular questions that many humans ask today. Sleep is very sufficient to the human body. If it was not important, then God would not have designed for a third of our life to be occupied by sleep. During this time period, many people are interested to know what is a good amount of sleep and what are the harmful effects to not getting enough sleep. The question “why do we sleep?” is a very difficult question to

Why do we serve? Essay

984 words - 4 pages described his dad as a celebrity amongst his friends while growing up. “The reason why I have chose to serve for the last 24 years is to protect the way of life for those that don’t have the means or ability to do so, and for that I gladly lay down my life.” said Thurmond. Chief Judy Daniel, a woman who served in the Persian Gulf War in Iraq in 1991, remembered many of the U.S. troops who were killed in the SCUD Missile attacks. She said that

Why do we need answers?

891 words - 4 pages friends to find this mystery person. While sitting in front of the computer, I doubt one clear thought went through this person’s head. He or she probably just clicked different links in search of this person, but once they find him or her, they probably do not stop to think why they were searching in the first place. Rabin believes that when we are on the Internet it is hard for us to decipher what is knowledge and what we are actually thinking

Why Do We Have Dreams?

1069 words - 5 pages able to sleep through the night. Scientists have begun to do more studies on the brain while a person is sleeping and have been trying to find a reason as to why we dream. Sigmund Freud's theory about dreams says that the human's mind is made up of three parts: Id, Ego, and Super-Ego. The Id, which we are born with, is the part of the mind that acts on instinct and makes sure that we are satisfied. The Ego, which we develop as toddlers, brings

Why Do We Have Government?

590 words - 3 pages onmajority rules. The "Floaters" are also in-charge of minority rights. This method allowscitizens to be involved in their government while the government knows what the peoplereally want. Devon is our Prime Minister since she was nominated and won the most votesfrom the citizens. Every candidate needs to be nominated and then has to give a speech onhow they believe the country can be improved or managed. After that, voters stand besidethe

Why Do We Love Music?

2601 words - 10 pages Why Do We Love Music?What is music? There's no end to the parade of philosophers who have wondered about this, but most of us feel confident saying: 'I know it when I hear it.' Still, judgments of musicality are notoriously malleable. That new club tune, obnoxious at first, might become toe-tappingly likeable after a few hearings. Put the most music-apathetic individual in a household where someone is rehearsing for a contemporary music recital

Why do we have aggression

800 words - 4 pages Why Do We Have Aggression? Why is it that some people find the need to lash out and others do not? Could we be born with it? Or do we learn it? Lorenz and Zimbardo, two highly qualified researchers when it comes to behavior, take a deeper look into the idea of aggression. Lorenz takes a positive standpoint on aggression saying it is a constructive and necessary whereas Zimbardo says that aggression appears in particular situations. As this essay

Why do we take risks

922 words - 4 pages that affect our decision to whether or not to take a risk.Why do we take risks? Could it be that some people are naturally more likely to take risks than others? What does the need of taking risks depends on? Does it depend on the age? How about personality? Or maybe the social environment that surrounds us? The answers can be varied for each person. In order to know which of this is more likely to be true, we should first know and understand what

Why do we study art

1201 words - 5 pages easier to learn and remember things at a younger age. However, this would not explain why art is required beyond elementary level. What would be the reasoning behind the continued art requirement throughout the rest of years in school? I believe that we study art and other creative things for more of a reason than the fact that it is easiest to learn as a child. I believe that studying art allows all of us to learn to become more responsive and

Why Do We Have Taxes?

2096 words - 9 pages Why do we have taxes? The straightforward response is that, until somebody concocts a finer thought, taxation is the main functional method for raising the income to fund government using on the merchandise and administrations that the greater part of us request. Setting up a proficient and reasonable assessment framework is, notwithstanding, a long way from straightforward, especially for developing countries that need to get coordinated in the

Why Do We Need Accounting?

3408 words - 14 pages Introduction Summon up a mental image: that of a human being with no nervous system. We are probably envisaging an inert blob of protoplasm, entirely powerless to perceive its environment or to act with purpose. The nervous system is what converts that protoplasm to an effective human being. An accounting system is the nervous system of the enterprise that permits it to perceive and act. It converts an inert bundle of assets to a working

Similar Essays

Why Do We Dream? Essay

843 words - 3 pages led to the fact that all dreams are linked with people's fears, emotions, desires and needs. Even though the question "Why do people dream?" probably won't have an exact or proven answer until the distant future, there are still some explanations to why we dream. Such explanations vary from physiological to psychological and prophetic beliefs.The term "physiological" deals with how the body works. Various scientists believe

Why Do We Sleep? Essay

1987 words - 8 pages general health. Currently there is only speculation and theories for why we sleep, and dream. With all the theories out there it is hard to pick out which one is correct, which is why all should be studied. Through this paper I hope to learn more about why we sleep, and what are some possible alternatives. Another question that intrigues me, that I hope to learn more about, is what our brains do during sleep that makes it so vital. A third topic

Why Do We Love Essay

1099 words - 5 pages When we slump in love we sometimes don’t know why we did. There is a copious amount of weird reasons we fall in love and explanations on how and why we do. First, it sounds weird that it may take from two to four minutes to figure out if you love someone, or if your feelings come then and there. You mainly love someone on three things that are; their body language, the way the person talks, and on what the person specifically says to you

Why Do We Dream Essay

1637 words - 7 pages Why do we dream the things we dream? What dictates the content of the movies for one that we watch when we fall asleep? This is a question that nearly everyone has pondered at some point in their lives and humans have been studying in an attempt to answer for thousands of years. Humans spend approximately one third of their lives asleep, and the idea that such a great portion of our time is spent in a state that we do not fully understand is