Why Do We Trust The Testimonial Account Of Others?

961 words - 4 pages

Why do we trust the testimonial account of others?

Firstly, I briefly wish to outline the parameters of trust and testimony that Zagzebski refers to in her book Epistemic Authority: A Theory of Trust, Authority, and Autonomy in Belief and then outline the reasons she also rejects the reductionist account, before examining the ways in which she suggests are reasons as to why we trust the testimonial account of others.
For Zagzebski, there is an important distinction between asserting that something is the case, and telling you that something is the case. The latter invokes the doctrine of trust, and involves an implicit contract between speaker and hearer- an interpersonal contract between ...view middle of the document...

So, for Zagzebski trust in testimony doesn’t seem to be based on rational assessment of other people’s truthfulness, nor any other reasons. To argue this, she first discusses different types of ‘epistemic egoism’ in which the demands of consistency push the epistemic egoist into weaker and weaker forms of egoism forcing her eventually to reject egoism and adopt trust:
a. Extreme epistemic egoism: What Zagzebski calls extreme epistemic egoism holds that the fact that someone else has a belief is never a reason for her to believe it, not even when conjoined with evidence that the other person is reliable.
b. Strong epistemic egoism: it holds that one has no obligation to count what another person believes as relevant to her own beliefs, but she may do so if she sees that given what she believes about them, they are likely to serve her desire for the truth.
c. Weak epistemic egoism: It holds that when one has evidence that someone else’s belief reliably serves one’s desire for the truth in some domain, one is not only rationally permitted, one is rationally require d to take their beliefs into account for forming one’s own belief.
Zagzebski argues that the demands of consistency push the epistemic egoist into weaker and weaker forms of egoism forcing her eventually to reject egoism. The extreme epistemic egoist trusts only her own powers and previous beliefs as a means to getting further true beliefs and knowledge. But, by using her own powers (perception, inference etc.) she can find out that other people are reliable source of knowledge. So, by using her own powers she sees that she is permitted to trust the powers and beliefs of many people and she begins to accept some beliefs on testimony. Trust in her own powers requires her to weaken her extreme...

Find Another Essay On Why do we trust the testimonial account of others?

Why Do We Give? Essay

1461 words - 6 pages Three Cups of Tea, the story of Mortenson and his extraordinary school-building initiative in a remote part of Pakistan, provokes many interesting lines of inquiry. In this outline it is proposed to address the question of why we give. What compels someone like Mortenson to take on an enormous and selfless act? And how effective are the most effective individual acts of goodness? Why do we give? First, there is the “humanitarian

Why Do We Dream? Essay

843 words - 3 pages three most common responses to why people dream include facts on how the body works, relations with someone's thoughts and emotions, and the ability to tell or warn someone of the future. And so the final thoughts of today's paper are: Do dreams provide us with insightful messages from our unconscious, sleeping minds or are dreams prophetic messages sent to us from divine being? Or are they just empty, meaningless visions that we create on our own?

Why Do We Sleep?

1987 words - 8 pages of interest, to me, in this field is the science of dreaming, why we do it and what they can tell us. Although tons of research has been conducted in the field it is still considered to be a major gray area in science. Several colleges now offer classes that explore the mysteries of the sleep world. Many scientists say that sleep is one of the biggest untouched gold mines in science today. Further progress could lead to an increase in

Why do we serve?

984 words - 4 pages described his dad as a celebrity amongst his friends while growing up. “The reason why I have chose to serve for the last 24 years is to protect the way of life for those that don’t have the means or ability to do so, and for that I gladly lay down my life.” said Thurmond. Chief Judy Daniel, a woman who served in the Persian Gulf War in Iraq in 1991, remembered many of the U.S. troops who were killed in the SCUD Missile attacks. She said that

Why Do We Sleep?

762 words - 4 pages “Why do we sleep?” is a very popular questions that many humans ask today. Sleep is very sufficient to the human body. If it was not important, then God would not have designed for a third of our life to be occupied by sleep. During this time period, many people are interested to know what is a good amount of sleep and what are the harmful effects to not getting enough sleep. The question “why do we sleep?” is a very difficult question to

Why Do We Fight?

1067 words - 5 pages finally realized this was a war we should have fought to win and wondered why we didn’t. People believe it was because of how the media reported the war. It was said that “during the Vietnam war, journalism and news media unintentionally caused a massive shift of American citizens viewpoint of the war.” The reason for this was because it was the first time people could write and report to the American citizens about the happenings of the war

Why Do We Dream?

2357 words - 9 pages others including awareness of their mental states”. Kajita Valli (2011) has become one of the most recent researchers to argue that dream conscious cannot be sufficiently explained on a single level, Valli argued that if we are to ever develop an adequate explanation, we really must identify a single definition of what dreaming really is. Reconciliation must be reached on very opposing views, allowing researchers from very different academic fields

Why do We Stress?

655 words - 3 pages deal with personal crises. Cost of living, loans and delayed general economic uncertainty is the most common cause of stress people around the world. 2. Excessive work In this era of modern technology with laptops, tablets and Internet everywhere, never-ending work obligations. You can relax on exotic beaches, but you have to send an email. If you do not, one of your competitors will take your client so that you lose customers. Shrinking free time

Why We Do What We Do?

1035 words - 4 pages : Informality I am from a very informal family. We do not have a formal dining room, big dinner parties, or wear fancy clothes. I think that the casual environment of my family lends to a very casual kinship terminology system. Forty of the fifty-nine kin on my list are people I address solely on an informal, first name basis. This is true even of my husband's family, whom I feel just as close to as my own family. Unlike most families, age does

Brief account of how capitalism in the modern world has affected how we do business in America

1566 words - 6 pages Disclaimer: This is only a brief recounting of key events that have affected the way we conduct business in America throughout the last century. If I had gone in depth with any one subject, I may have written a novel.Capitalism is one word no one takes for granted anymore. As early as the 18th century, forms of Capitalism have co-existed with other economic structures, such as democratic socialism. The idea of the common mans' desire to own and

The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business by Charles Duhigg

926 words - 4 pages The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business(2012), is a book written by the award-winning The New York Times contributor and journalist, Charles Duhigg.This book is about all kinds of good and bad habits in people’s lives,even when on the job. I think this book appeals to me, because I experienced all kinds of good and bad habits from childhood to adulthood. I might do what people do in business and do it right. I think

Similar Essays

The Power Of Habit: Why We Do What We Do In Life And Business

1593 words - 7 pages The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business (2012), is a book written by the award-winning The New York Times contributor and journalist, Charles Duhigg. This book is about all kinds of good and bad habits in people’s lives, even when on the job. I think this book appeals to me, because I experienced all kinds of good and bad habits from childhood to adulthood. I might do what people do in business and do it right. I

Organizational Behavior. In Studying Motivation We Are Interested In Understanding Why People Choose To Do Certain Things Rather Than Others,And Also Why Different People Put Different Amounts Of...

3051 words - 12 pages the other hand,are external to the person.In studying motivation we are interested in understanding why people choose to do certain things rather than others,and also why different people put different amounts of effort or intensity into the activities they engage in.Attitudes:An attitude refers to the way a person feels about and is disposed towards some "object".Attitudes are relevant to our understanding of individual motivation and behavior

Why Do We Love Essay

1099 words - 5 pages When we slump in love we sometimes don’t know why we did. There is a copious amount of weird reasons we fall in love and explanations on how and why we do. First, it sounds weird that it may take from two to four minutes to figure out if you love someone, or if your feelings come then and there. You mainly love someone on three things that are; their body language, the way the person talks, and on what the person specifically says to you

Why Do We Dream Essay

1637 words - 7 pages Why do we dream the things we dream? What dictates the content of the movies for one that we watch when we fall asleep? This is a question that nearly everyone has pondered at some point in their lives and humans have been studying in an attempt to answer for thousands of years. Humans spend approximately one third of their lives asleep, and the idea that such a great portion of our time is spent in a state that we do not fully understand is