This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Does Plato Argue That Divine Commands Can Never Be Genuinely Moral Commands? Do You Agree?

823 words - 3 pages

From the Euthyphro dilemma, Plato argues that divine commands can never be genuinely moral. The divine commands are those belonging or coming from God. This argument stems from the idea that because God is omnipotent, omniscient that he will punish us when he detects any failures. Thus suggesting that the fear that motivates us to follow such divine commands is not a suitable motive to a certain moral action. Another argument that Plato presents is that God sets such divine commands because they are moral which raises the idea that morality exists as an entity separate to God. Both these ideas suggest that the divine command is not genuinely moral as they are acted upon in the interest of the individual and questions the motives of moral actions.In Plato's argument, he addressees the motives of our moral actions. Since God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omni benevolent he presupposes that the relationship between humans and God is based fear. He suggests that fear is what motivated humans to follow in God's divine command thus showing that such commands are not moralistic but on the other hand is a crude kind of politics where status and power dominate the more insignificant.Through this argument, it is evident that God is seen as a cold and distant figure. Yet within the Bible, it often talks about God being holy. It may be said that God is the source of all holiness and embodies all that is holy. Holiness is intrinsic to God's nature. Holy is derived from Hebrew to mean separate showing his purity and cleanliness from that of imperfect humans. From Psalms 99:3, it reads, "Let them laud your name. Great and fear-inspiring, holy it is." From this, we can see that this fear is not one of morbid dread rather it is a profound sense of reverential awe, respect in its most ennobling form. It is fitting to think this way, as God is brilliantly clean and glorious in comparison to us. Thus, we see that our fear motivates us to respect God and feel inferior in the sense that we want to please him.God's holy nature can also be used to argue against Plato's idea of morality existing independently of God. Plato suggests that God is able to detect our failures and our wrong doings and thus we treat him as an instrument. For example, God condemns murder because it is immoral which shows that...

Find Another Essay On Why does Plato argue that divine commands can never be genuinely moral commands? Do you agree?

Many Linguists argue that the way we use language is sexist. What evidence is there for this and do you agree?

654 words - 3 pages substitute for this. Although this is politically correct it is not grammatically correct. When writing and we are unsure of someone's sex you can put s/he or he/she, but speaking presents difficulties in this area. Many people have suggested various gender-neutral pronouns, some of these include:Thon, co, E, tey, hesh, and hir.Another argument that language is sexist is based on the Mrs/Miss/Ms argument. When men give their title we do not know

Why does Plato believe that philosophers should rule?

1342 words - 5 pages that for Plato a well ruled state is a just state aiming the good of the whole and that, accordingly, those who will have the best notion of what is justice will be the most able to rule.Secondly, Plato argues that there is a skill to rule and illustrates his point through the so-called craft analogy (488a-489d). As there is an aptitude to navigate a ship or to treat an illness there is an ability to rule a polis. If you were ill would you ask

It has been suggested that “stress is in the eyes of the beholder?”. What does this mean? Do you agree?

2262 words - 10 pages to time. Some people may cope with stress more effectively or recover from stressful events quicker than others. There are both healthy & unhealthy ways that people deal with stress. Learn healthy ways to manage your stress and avoid the negative consequences of stress. Therefore, I do agree that stress is in the eyes of the beholder as it can be managed and coped differently. First and foremost, we should understand that not all stress is bad

Capital Punishment does not serve a purpose in society today. As such, it should be abolished. Do you agree?

924 words - 4 pages questionable. Should society have the power to decide a man's fate? Furthermore, religion also believes that a person can turn over a new leaf if they were given the opportunity, through counseling and rehabilitation.Yet, this does not hold much claim, as religion should not have a hold on the secular system. Everyone is entitled to his or her own moral values and principles in which they adopt. Therefore, they were in the right frame of mind to

Do You Agree With The Contention That The Mixed Ec

832 words - 3 pages Yes, I agree with the contention that the mixed economy is the best among all the economy systems. The mixed economy has been defined as an economic system that answers the What, How, and For Whom questions through a mixture of traditional, command, and market systems. Not a single nation in this world practices a pure traditional, command, or market economy. They may concentrate on one of the economic policies but they can?t avoid from adding

Do You Agree With The Contention That The Mixed Ec

832 words - 3 pages dictates answers to the three basic economic questions. The command economy system has its own advantages. Firstly, this system can be defended. So the central authority can decide to ignore the customs and order new ways of doing things. Another advantage is the controversial belief that the government will provide the economic security and also equity. It is assumed that the central authorities make sure that everyone is provided food, clothing

there will always be Wars. do you agree?

1174 words - 5 pages beliefs. Jesus has taught that Christians should be against war and violence, ‘If someone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also,’ this means not take action against someone who does something to you; do not take revenge. So, people who follow Jesus’s teachings will know that violence is immoral and they would live peacefully even if there is a war going on because they have faith in God. Therefore, the world was made to be a

Ipods should be banned from schools. Do you agree?

543 words - 2 pages keeps me calm," Nick Stubbs, 16, said. "It's an individuality we have. The type of music we listen to says who we are.". Nobody can negate. For this reason, the best way for parrents is letting children use iPods anywhere, except schools.In short, banning Ipods from schools is a sound and necessary measure. However, while banning Ipods is a nagative way, why don't teachers and parents show students the disadvantage of using musical gadgets in schools or apply other appropriate precautions? I believe that students will understand and observe schools' discipline spontaneously and strictly.

"Revolutionaries were successful in putting their ideas into practice." Do you agree with this statement? Argue your case

1416 words - 6 pages increased production in Russia to the stage where it was almost at pre-revolutionary levels after only 3 years of being introduced. The problem with Lenin doing this was that he now showed the Russian people the splendors received from a capitalistic economy. He became ill in late 1921 and died soon after so never saw Communism the way he had envisioned.France's revolutionaries were highly political; however the lack of doctrine meant they could be

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

1929 words - 8 pages The saying that “crime does not pay” lies at the heart of a great deal of literature and many films. It appears in a large number of fairy tales and children’s story. This is to teach children from an early age that it is wrong to commit a crime, no matter how small, and that every criminal is eventually punished. Of course this is not true, many crimes, especially smaller crimes, are never punished. This can either be because no

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

618 words - 2 pages in organised crime depends just as much on who you know as on what you're prepared to do or what talents you might have.It's all very well knowing that you can buy a kilo of cocaine in Colombia for £2,000 and sell it in London for nearer £40,000 but unless you have the connections to buy the stuff and bring it into the country, it's a business idea that will never get off the ground. So at aged under 30 most criminals are still doing

Similar Essays

Divine Command Theory. Are People's Moral Standards Right Because God Commands Them, Or Does God Command Them Because They Are Right?

1624 words - 6 pages they believe them or know of them. These ultimate moral standards exist in commands given by God. God commands only things that are good, and he would never command a person to act immorally. God is all-powerful, all knowing, and all loving. God commands these things in order to do what is good for us as humans, and his commands are automatically morally right.The opponents of the Divine Command Theory do not believe that God has that much control

Program That Creates A Shell And Executes Some Shell Commands

709 words - 3 pages /* myshell.c Description: Program that creates a shell and executes some shell commands */ #include #include #include #include #include #include #include extern char **getln(); // Function used to check the file input direction command int inputFile(char **args, char **fileIn) { int i,j; //go thorough the command line arguments for(i=0;args[i] != NULL;i++) { // check for the input

"There Is Every Reason To Believe That Resources Can Be Developed Sustainably". To What Extent Do You Agree With This Statement?

758 words - 3 pages A resource can be defined as a means of supplying a want/stock that can be drawn on/country's collective means for support and defence. A resource can be either renewable or non-renewable. A renewable resource is one which the use of will not deplete the Earth's supply of fossil fuels, whereas a non-renewable resource is a natural resource that cannot be re-made or re-grown. Oil, coal and natural gas, despite regenerating over time, do not

Why Did You Do That? Essay

962 words - 4 pages Do you ever wonder why people do what they do? Does it surprise you that your friends or your siblings react so differently to the same situation? Some people tend to be friendly and open-minded. Some prefer to keep to themselves. Some are very careful in putting things together while some care less about how things are arranged. In a typical social setting, people’s different attitudes can be easily observed. While some people are busy making