Why Might Freudian Therapy Be A Waste Of Time And Money

2527 words - 10 pages


In his book Des Bienfaits de la Depression, Pierre Fédida wrote a chapter called 'Il Faut Etre Deux Pour Guérir' in which he explains why it is useful to talk when you are depressed.20 Patients usually believe that talking is not the solution but that the only way to cure is to bring back the lost person/situation whose absence initially caused the trauma. Psychological pain is a human particularity and therapy is meant to heal it. Fédida uses the example of drug addicts who go on detoxification. Addiction to drugs often reveals an alarming state of depression and the fact of undergoing treatment for drug addiction is the sign of distress and will to be saved. Freud used to underline how human beings have created for themselves an interior metaphorical discourse to express extremely violent issues such as love, hate, life, death, sexuality...21 Analytical cure sight-reads this metaphorical language.
Patients have the tendency to try and cure themselves alone but therapy helps substract the patient to his own influence, free his from his own desease. Therapy requires the participation of two actors and recovery cannot take place if the therapist does not understand his patient's psychology and resistance to healing.22 Freud focused on studying the opposition to healing and resistance to treatment when increasing his knowledge about unconscious forces. The therapist defines healing as the goal creating the patient's resistances. Thoses resistances to therapy can be explained as follows : the fact of being cured corresponds to a change of state. Negative reactions to treatment are thus explained by a fear of losing internal integrity and eventually disintegrating. The fear of modification is extremely strong.
In 1904, Freud explained he had given up suggestion since eight years because he despaired of making the effects of suggestion effective and lasting enough to lead to once and for all curing. Comparing Leonardo da Vinci's vision of painting to Freud's vision of therapy appears logical : painting proceeds, per via di porre – by putting on – by applying color on a plain and white surface prepared to receive it. The image created by the application of color symbolises order born from initial chaos. With sculpture however, Freud gave a different comparaison as sculpture operates per via di levare – by removing – taking away all the raw stone covering the statue it contains.23 The metaphor is aristotelian : proceeding per via di levare lets the sculpture be born from the raw material that contains it. If curing is similar to sculpture, it is not born from the erasing of symptoms as the symptoms themselves contain a knowledge of yourself used by the therapist. Curing by suggestion is no more than a Platonic pharmakon whose therapeutic effects are illusionary as long as they are not procuded from the patient's inner reflexion. Nothing lasting is achieved unless it is bred from the inside, endogenous, to provoke a deep transformation. Per via...

Find Another Essay On Why Might Freudian Therapy be a Waste of Time and Money

Why Do Poor People Waste Money on Luxury Goods?

1263 words - 6 pages is a necessity to have the latest item that's better than the old thing we already bought. Deprived individuals waste money on pointless assets to feel as though they are still a part of the “normal society” that is depicted as being able to have everything, when they are at a time when they have almost nothing. Nonetheless, in her article “Why do poor people ‘Waste’ Money on Luxury Goods?” Cottom McMillan argues that status symbols matter and

Is Space Exploration a Waste of Money?

1625 words - 7 pages exploration really isn't that extreme because of the many countries involved, technological improvements and the communication benefits, that result from the NASA program and its partners.The kings of Portugal, France, and Britain all refused to help Columbus in his expedition to find an alternate trade route to the Indies. They thought it a waste of time, money, and resources. Ferdinand and Isabella, the king and queen of Spain, who after much

School Is a Waste of Time

1982 words - 8 pages do not pertain to the day’s assigned material, thus distracting themselves and all of the students. Bells and events sometimes interrupt learning times. A class period that required substantial amounts of lecture might be interrupted or end as the teacher answers questions and assigns homework. Most commonly, engaged and academic learning times occur at the end of the allotted class time when bells and events are more likely to occur, resulting in

Is traditional grammar a waste of time?

3184 words - 13 pages Is traditional grammar a waste of time?The Times for Wednesday 19 January 2005 contained an article entitled "Traditional grammar teaching is waste of time, say academics". Is this what really academics say? If so, are they right?The teaching of grammar in schools has been around for a long time and has consistently been at the centre of debate over the course of history. Recently, The Times for Wednesday 19th January 2005 contained an article

Sleep: Not a Waste of Time

2050 words - 9 pages 8 hours a night appears to be the best amount of sleep, although some people may need as few as 5 hours or as many as 10 hours of sleep each day. Having been deprived of sleep for a single, or multiple, nights, requires one to sleep a greater amount of time within the following days. We don't seem to adapt to getting less sleep than we need; while we may get used to a sleep-depriving schedule, our judgment, reaction time, and other functions are

Medical waste: Why incineration is a waste of resources

940 words - 4 pages to Martini is the reason why 80% of a hospital's generated waste is incinerated. Proposed Research Question and Significance Further assessment and increased study's on incineration is suggested by the literature in order to grasp the attention of the public of the infectious risks associated with this treatment method. The more research is done on the emissions arising from the incinerators, the more efficiently the message can be conveyed

Sports is a waste of time, Do you agree?

756 words - 3 pages partake in the sport fairly.In conclusion, a sport will give us health benefits and improve our attitude and character. Therefore, doing sports will have positive on impacts on us which is why sports is not a waste of time. Imagine a world with more and more people taking up sports, how many more people would be fitter, and be able to persevere, face whatever obstacles life throws at them and be resilient?

Cultural Credits: Are they a waste of time?

1165 words - 5 pages time for a student to spend on school work and studying. These events usually average about two hours per event. Since five credits are required each semester, an average of ten hours is taken away from the time a student could be studying or doing homework per semester. For most students, 10 hours of studying could be all they spend a week, which if they lose this much time from cultural credits, it is essentially like not studying for a week of

Random Drug Testing is a Waste of Time

1601 words - 6 pages be much smaller, because they Dwiggins 3 fear the consequences (Drug Testing in School Activities 2). The risk of being discovered might be enough to deter some young people from experimenting with drugs, but this small danger will not be enough to scare off a true addict. Those who are truly addicted are supposed to be the target for the most serious help.      If a student is determined to use drugs and not be

Time, Money and Morality

1428 words - 6 pages There exists a considerable amount of research on the correlation between self-reflection and morality, however Gino and Mogilner (2014) attempt to examine this relationship through priming time and money, two means by which self-reflection can be manipulated and controlled. They found that allusions to time often elicit morally correct behaviour from individuals as they reflect upon how their decisions will impact their identity, whereas

A Freudian Reading of Hamlet and Titus Andronicus

2506 words - 10 pages A Freudian Reading of Hamlet and Titus Andronicus      In 1900 the eminent Austrian psychologist Sigmund Freud produced a seminal work entitled The Interpretation of Dreams which contains the idea that dreams allow psychic exploration of the soul, that dreams contain psychological meanings which can be arrived at by interpretation. Freud states that “every dream will reveal itself as a psychological structure, full of significance, and one

Similar Essays

Twilight: A Waste Of Time And Money

1050 words - 4 pages than their vampires. All in all if you’re looking for a great movie to watch, Twilight is not it. With its dreadful actors, sparkling vampires, and atrocious special effects, Twilight was a complete waste of my time and money. I’m sure it will be for you too. I cannot begin to fathom how it was one of the year’s greatest hits, nor how its popularity continued to soar as the Twilight Saga installments continued to emerge. Works Cited

Caroline Bird's College Is A Waste Of Time And Money

1695 words - 7 pages , if she herself is a graduate? Not only that, she graduated with a masters degree. I would understand if she only had a bachelors, her argument could have been that as long as she started college, she should at least get her bachelors. But if college is such a waste of time and money why would she go on to get her masters degree. Furthermore, some points which she uses in her argument are not enough to pursued me. One example would be when she

General Education Courses Are A Waste Of Time And Money

2024 words - 8 pages money. College is basically composed of two parts: general education classes and major specific classes. General education courses are the source of wasted time and money, and should not be required of students. A few of the problems associated with general education classes are that they are basically a repeat of high school, unfortunately they can be the demise of students, they are costly, and they waste time. The transition from high school

Response To Article College Is A Waste Of Time And Money

1028 words - 4 pages , now in college she is always asking questions in all of her classes instead of sitting back and not understanding the assignment. For example, Alexie’s drive started young, he didn’t want to become a label in his society. “If he’d been anything but, an Indian boy living on a reservation might have been called a prodigy. But he is an Indian boy living on a reservation and