Why Plato Says Recollection Essay

1571 words - 7 pages

Usually, when we are learning something, we achieve a state of understanding by learning something we consider we do not know. However, this common-sense contains a very irrational factors if we think one more step. That is, if a person have no idea of something exists, then for this person, that kind of things does not exist, hence the person will not emerges a desire to acquire that kind of things, and cannot behave like discovering or learning. If a person emerges a desire for something, that person must already know it in past in some way. Only in this way, it will make sense.
However, when people are learning something, in common-sense is to learn, to discover things that they do not know, in other words, because they do not know, they precisely need to learn. But how to learn, to discover something we do not know? People are learning or discovering, but they do not know what they are learning or discovering, this is impossible. And then again, if people already know what they are discovering or learning, there is no need for them to learn or discover. In this way, people either know or do not know what they are learning or discovering, learning and discovering are impossible or unnecessary. The essential start point that Plato proposes “recollection” in Meno is to refute this argument about learning and discovering problem that exists logical dilemma. In other words, through “recollection” Plato reveals that there is a cognitive state between “know” and “do not know”, named “forget”, to solve this logical dilemma. Briefly, people currently forget things that they already know in the past, then through learning, they can recollect knowledge about that kind of things, this is so called learning. Therefore the meaning of learning is not knowing something people do not know completely, but something they already forget. Thus, Plato says “a process men call learning—discovering everything else for himself, if he is brave and does not tire of the search, for searching and learning are, as a whole, recollection.” (Plato, Meno p71, 81d)
The purpose Plato mentions “recollection” is to solve the logical dilemma about discovering, but its essential intention is to reveal the meaning of Socrates’s pursuit of true knowledge. Such as, in Meno, the discussion between Socrates and Meno about virtue is the most representative example of Socrates’s pursuit of true knowledge.
In Meno, it begins discussion with the question “can virtue be taught?” Meno confidently cited what a man’s virtue is, what a woman’s virtue is, and even a child’s and elder’s virtue, when Socrates asks “what virtue is”. However, the answer that Meno consists he knows about virtue, is only a part of virtue’s properties. It is obviously just answering “how virtue is”, does not meet Socrates’s requirement for “what virtue is”. Because men’s virtue, women’s virtue, children’s virtue and elders’ virtue are examples of virtue, in other words, they are the form of virtue limited to a...

Find Another Essay On Why Plato Says Recollection

Recollection: Fact or Fiction? Essay

1103 words - 4 pages Brief essay on disagreement with assertion that knowledge is kept through recollection. Cites Phaedo by PlatoIn Phaedo 73b to 77, Plato argues that learning is in fact recollection of knowledge because that since the soul existed in previous lives, it contains knowledge from previous lives. This argument is weak because of how most people learn, what age they learn it at, and how they are taught.In the dialogue between Socrates and Simmias, they

Philosophy Essay

3067 words - 12 pages in no need of inquiry, nor again can he inquire about what he does not know, since he does not know what he is to inquire." (Plato 80E) This theory of recollection may explain why we often say that we had certain knowledge before we leaned it or heard it for the first time. It is often said that we are born with concepts and it is these concepts that structure our minds, beliefs, and

Plato's understanding of what the essence of knowledge

1563 words - 6 pages body and the mind, the mind contains the knowledge deep in the memory. According to Plato, true knowledge in this world is made up of remembering, in reminiscence or recollection. The essence of knowledge is recollection. This thesis gives a man the ideas that he later becomes conscious of by recollection. The theory of recollection may explain why people often say that they had certain knowledge before they heard it for the first time.In simple

History of Philosophy Meno's Paradox

1101 words - 4 pages previously know, viz., the answer to that question.The argument for Meno's Paradox is therefore flawed: it commits the fallacy of equivocation. But beyond it lies a deeper problem. And that is why Plato does not dismiss it out of hand. That is why in response to it he proposes his famous "Theory of Recollection."5.The Theory of Recollection1. Concedes that, in some sense, inquiry is impossible. What appears to be learning something new is really

Meno's Paradox

3078 words - 12 pages perform.' This shows that Plato does not regard reincarnation as a mere theoretical speculation - as Vlastos says, `he chooses to relate it to rites of worship and invests it with that intense religious feeling that it to pulse through the myth of the Phaedrus.' Knowing that Plato's religious beliefs play such a part in this theory of recollection, we must ask ourselves - without this special perspective of reincarnation, would Plato have ever

Philosophical Discussion Regarding Socrates' Theory Of Recollection

997 words - 4 pages from experience but is all innately given, experience from a previous life could not have given us knowledge of Equality either. Perhaps Plato would suggest that when our soul is first created, and has its first life, it is created with knowledge of Forms. But this raises another question that Plato does not answer: when and how does the cycle of birth and death of the soul begin? And if it has a beginning, why can't it have an end?Socrates asserts

what is knowledge

641 words - 3 pages through a series of geometric proofs to show that the slave already possessed this knowledge and, therefore, that “learning” is not acquiring but recollection. Plato continues, and says that the slave is simply recalling knowledge learned in a former life. I believe that there are two views to consider when debating this issue. Firstly, there is the possibility that Socrates merely asked the right questions, bringing the knowledge that was

The example of the slave boy in Plato's meno

1039 words - 4 pages . However Plato believes our souls have seen everything and learned everything in previous lives;''Given then, that the soul is immortal and has been incarnated many times, and has therefore seen things here on earth and many things in the whole underworld too-everything in fact-there is nothing that is has not learnt.''Plato also brings self belief into his theory of recollection. He shows that the slave does not know that it will be produced by


1581 words - 6 pages United States government in reference to the chain of succession if the President of the United States becomes injured? Do the Forms interact in a way more similar to the hierarchy of a corporation, with a more branched organization pattern? Plato prefers the latter to the former. One example that Samuel Stumpf uses is the one in reference to the animal kingdom. What he says is that there is a Form for animal but at the same time there is a Form

The Immortality of the Soul

1558 words - 6 pages and soul, in saying that when the body dies and decomposes our soul will continue to exist in another world. Since the soul is immortal it has been recycled many times, and has also experienced everything there is to experience, for Socrates and Plato this idea of recollection is much deeper than remembering something once forgotten. Socrates views knowledge as something that cannot be learned but the soul recalls it as it is being recycled

Outline Plato’s Arguments For The Distinct Existence Of The Soul

1235 words - 5 pages experienced learning but rather from recollection i.e. a previous knowledge gained of ideas. This is an allusion to Plato's theory of forms, which suggests that we all recognise concepts such as equality because we all have knowledge of absolute equality or as Plato called it "the perfect form of equality". Returning to the Phaedo Socrates sums up the argument from recollection like this. Firstly knowledge [of equality] cannot be based on bodily

Similar Essays

Plato’s Theory Of “Recollection” Essay

1678 words - 7 pages completely, but something they already forget. Thus, Socrates says “a process men call learning—discovering everything else for himself, if he is brave and does not tire of the search, for searching and learning are, as a whole, recollection.” (Plato, Meno p71, 81d) The purpose Plato mentions “recollection” is to solve the logical dilemma about discovering, but its essential purpose is to reveal the meaning of Socrates’s pursuit of true knowledge. Such as

Plato's Theory Of Knowledge Essay

1276 words - 5 pages discourse only through the weaving together of Forms". Plato doesn't mean to say that all Forms are related to each other only that significant things use some Forms and that just knowing that includes understanding the relationship between Forms. Plato says there are three ways to discover Forms: recollection, dialectic and desire. Recollection is when our souls remember the Forms from prior existence. Dialectic is when people discuss and

Aristotle Vs. Plato Learning Is Recollection

650 words - 3 pages What alternative does Aristotle offer to Plato’s claim that learning is recollection? Where would Aristotle locate the mistake in Plato’s argument in The Phaedo? In his dialogues The Phaedo and Meno, Plato, through the form of Socrates, puts forth the idea that all learning is recollection. In The Phaedo, to prove that the soul is immortal, Socrates asserts the view that all learning is recollection and we simply need to be reminded of facts

This Is An Argument Depicting The Different Theories Of Philosophers Descartes And Plato. ; ) Enjoy!!

710 words - 3 pages which they know best. He does not believe that God doesn't allow people to be deceived.Plato's method of recollection seems to me to be a little easier to understand. Plato simply states that the things and ideas that we've learned through life, we already knew before they were taught to us. He says that instead of us learning them, they were simply recalled or recollected by an agent, the agent being a teacher or parent, etc. These things are