So Why Radicalization? Essay

1558 words - 6 pages

Theda Skocpol defines social revolutions as “rapid, basic transformations of a society’s state and class structures…accompanied and in part carried through by class-based revolts from below” (4). During its course, a social revolution may experience a period of radicalization in which the initial revolutionary regime is overthrown by a more radical one that implements policies which overturn most aspects of the Old Regime and replaces them with extremist new ones. These policies result in a period of widespread Terror during which the state detains and or executes mass numbers of people for crimes that may or may not have been committed. To account for radicalization, which occurred in both France and Russia, one must begin by identifying two fundamental variables. The first, the initial revolutionary seizure of power by a non-radical group, occurred in France October of 1791 and in Russia February of 1917. The second, the failure of radical polities to appease a large majority of the masses, had begun to play out in France by 1793 and in Russia by November of 1917. By tracing the effects of these variables over time, the phenomenon of radicalization can then be explained.
Two prevailing theories that attempt to account for radicalization are the modernization theory, championed by Samuel Huntington, and the aggregate-psychological theory, posited by Ted Gurr. In the modernization theory, Huntington states that a “revolution becomes more radical as larger and larger masses of the population are brought into the political scales” (41). Huntington argues this empowers radical groups by spurring their popularity and in turn allows them to create “a new political order” under their rule (41). Yet, as the cases of France and Russia will demonstrate, radical polities do not need mass support to gain power. In fact, once they have seized it, disapproval, not support, from the masses prompts the radical polities to wield their influence and put down such opposition, resulting in violent radicalization.
In his aggregate-psychological theory, Gurr posits that revolutions will occur “when many people in society become angry, especially if existing cultural and practical conditions provide encouragement for aggression against political targets” (Skocpol, 9). Extending this theory, the angrier people become, the more radical, aggressive, and in turn violent a revolution will grow to be. The issue with this theory is that there is no source of change. Although Gurr argues that people become angry when there is relative deprivation, and that anger leads to revolution, if this were true, states would constantly be revolting, for there is always some measure of unmet expectation and some number of people who are angry (Skocpol, 9). Unless there a variable sparks the angered populace to take action, a revolution will not occur and similarly, unless there is a source of change during a revolution, radicalization will not occur either. Anger and relative...

Find Another Essay On So Why Radicalization?

Western states and Security Concerns Essay

1577 words - 6 pages , ‘states exist in an international system that is characterized by competition and war’ . This principle helps understanding some of the states’ motivations to preserve their integrity and national interests. At the same time, it permits to comprehend why security is so important when it comes to defending the growth and development of the state. Hence, one might think that under the scope of realism, the state is therefore somewhat individualist

Security Breaches in Comunication and Data Systems

4082 words - 17 pages out of the border so that they may catch and disrupt an operation of terrorism against the nation. Detect is just like it sounds, detect threats through any unusual activities, people, stories, and so on. The final D is deal, this means that personnel should be properly trained and strategies should be set to deal with any situation that may occur. The radicalization process of groups and organizations have 4 common interchangeable steps. The

The Russian Revolution at the Kronstadt Navel Base

3517 words - 14 pages traveled to Petrograd during the famous 'July Days' to attempt to force the Central Executive Committee of Soviets to assume power. In Petrograd, the Bolsheviks took over the Kronstadt demonstration, going so far as to place their own banner at its head.25 The base's radicalization continued throughout 1917. The Bolshevik takeover in the October Revolution was heartily endorsed by Kronstadt. In January 1918, Kronstadt Bolsheviks famously led the

How Mass Media Affects the Image of Adolescence

2431 words - 10 pages ” used alone could be seen as a negative connotation in its own right as it’s so rarely used positively. The aim of this paper is to see how the discourses that arise from these political, academic, and media led images effect how young people in modern day Britain are seen. This will be done by seeing how the mass media create this image of youth in western society, through the use of language, labeling and the development of moral panic. The

Targeting Islam and the Reality of Multiculturalism

2501 words - 10 pages it is suggested that the Islamic religion is one of the three main religions in Canada, Judaism and Christianity being the other two; why is the Islamic faith so scrutinized? Canadian society presents itself as being a liberal democratic nation-state, thus securing the freedoms of every individual citizen by limiting the powers of what the government can do. Supporting the liberal notion individuals are granted autonomy and the belief in the

Government Surveillance For The Greater Good

2643 words - 11 pages best resource, so why shouldn’t the government use it against them to protect the nation. If we do not learn to change with time, then we will fall like many of the vast and ancient empires that were prominent thousands of years ago. The topic of government surveillance will always be controversial and there will always be people who oppose it. We as a nation must learn to not only think about our needs and wants, we must also consider

Analyze Lyotard's reworking of the Kantian Sublime.

2559 words - 10 pages realist art reassures meta-narratives, the modern and the postmodern art employ the sublime in order to demonstrate our limits of understanding, and in so doing so point to new possibilities. The postmodern according to Lyotard is a 'radicalization of the modern.' This refers to the fact that in the modern the sublime appears through the missing contents of a work of art, whereas in the postmodern the sublime creates a disruption not only in the

The Cold War 1980’s-1990’s

1865 words - 7 pages had done ‘progress’ correctly and was now going to share the hitherto secret formula with those (nonwhite peoples) who had not “progressed” at all” (McVety 85). So people were focused on providing help to these underdeveloped countries, but why were they needed to begin with? It was events in the late 1970’s that led to the 1980’s conditions in Africa. As in many Third World countries, the withdraw of other countries from Africa created a

Aid to Africa: A Review of the Efficacy of International Aid to Sub-Saharan Africa

2057 words - 9 pages decisively successful, showing that targeted military aid to counter extremist pressure can be an essential first step to stabilizing the region to allow economic and political development. But not all military aid has been so successful. In many cases, military aid has exacerbated instability by inadvertently empowering antagonistic factions. The Malian conflict was a spillover from a 2011 conflict in Libya. “As the U.S.-backed war in Libya

Black Power Influence in West Germany

1998 words - 8 pages population in the U.S at the time and they lacked the rights of the average individual, so it was hard for them to change their economic situation. Sweeping laws of the mid 1960’s prohibited segregation in public places as well as in employment, however, equality was far-off. Dr. Martin Luther King was the most prominent figure of the civil rights movement. He pushed for a non-violent approach to seeking liberation, and the African-American population

"My Son's Story" By Nadine Gordimer: Themes and issues in the novel (when private "affairs" become public)

2276 words - 9 pages , economically vulnerable citizens at the hands of five million people who, so far, have had a powerful modern army at their disposal, not to mention the wealth of a vigorous, advanced capitalist society. To oppose the assumptions and everyday reality of a particular world, yet be among the men and women who enjoy its benefits - those accorded to the substantial upper bourgeoisie of, say, Johannesburg and Cape Town - is at the very least to know and live

Similar Essays

Homegrown Terrorism Essay

1571 words - 6 pages currently 11 documented incidents (HGT, 2011) so far. It is however necessary to account that aggressive anti-terrorism measures may have inflated the numbers because of improved processes to identify and deter the threat. Figure 1 – Homegrown Terror Activity in the United States from 2002 2010 (HGT, 2011) The perplexing issue is grasping the concept of why a citizen born and raised with instilled country’s values and citizenship

Is Al Qaeda Still Alive? Essay

2062 words - 8 pages . For example, Al-Zawahri is a well-qualified surgeon, bin Laden has a degree in business administration (which probably explains why the al-Qaeda is well-organized, run, and structured), and the Hamburg cell which was responsible for 9/11were all enrolled in German universities. This begs the question: why would these individuals become terrorists when they are already so successful in life? Part of the reason according to Neuman is

What Do We Mean By 'radicalism', In Feminism?

986 words - 4 pages the state regulate personal life? Why had homosexuality been outlawed for so long? Why had abortions not been legalized until 1967? Why should young people be forced to dress in a particular way? Why were women denied equal pay and status? Who decided the architecture of public housing? Why not those who were going to live in it? Why were state bureaucrats all over the world so deeply insensitive to the needs and the lives of ordinary people? Why

The Development Of Karl Marx's Critique

2499 words - 10 pages , then what was needed was a philosophy that showed why reality must be changed. The solution for the problems of man was not beyond man. This optimism is characteristic of Marx’s thought in that time, a confidence that a radicalization of Kant’s practical philosophy would accomplish a significant shift in the destiny of humanity. But this notion of humanism, was also a myth of its own, it was something that was posing as true while in fact was