This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Socrates Proposes “Recollection” And How To Prove It

1218 words - 5 pages

In this paper, I will investigate the reason Socrates proposes “recollection” and the way he proves it. My conclusion is the reason Socrates proposes “recollection” is trying to help Meno understand how to explain virtue, and shows Meno how to prove it. He asks one of Meno’s slave geometry questions to prove that our souls have all the knowledge we need to solve problems. Which means when we are answering questions, we are recollecting the knowledge inside our souls.
First, Socrates talks about some creeds he heard from different religions (Meno, 71). The meaning of the poem I believe is due to some mistakes we perpetrated, the punishment for us is to go through a series of reincarnation. In the meantime, if we behave very reverent, the Persephone will reward us. Prior to this, we have to spend nine years in the underworld, if we perform piously, she will send us to the sun after nine years, to become a monarch, an athlete or a saint, then have lifelong glories of hero. In other words, soul is immortal and reincarnation, therefore, we must live as piously as possible.
Later, Socrates says “Then if the truth about reality is always in our soul, the soul would be immortal so that you should always confidently try to seek out and recollect what you do not know at present—that is, what you do not recollect?” (Meno, 78) Socrates infers “we should piously live” from “soul is immortal”, but here, he infers “we should take the initiative to recall” form “soul is immortal”. Therefore, I assert recollection means to be pious. Through recollection, we can get rid of the pain of reincarnation and get reward from gods.
In conclusion, even piety and recollection are not identical, piety is a form of knowledge, and recollection is a stage of restoration of knowledge. But recollection is necessary to achieve full piety. In other words, recollection is a process of self-salvation form reincarnation.
Socrates says “As the soul is immortal, has been born often, and has seen all things here and in the underworld, there is nothing which it has not learned” (Meno, 71). Because soul has many past lives, experiences everything, this makes it can recollect in future reincarnation. If soul as Socrates says, learns everything in past, then it is certainly that soul learns virtue. Then I distrust “can virtue be learned when the soul is alive?” If so, the significance of recollection will be weakened, because if the soul can learn virtue from past, then it can also learn it now. In Socrates’s argument of “soul is immortal” (Meno, 77-78), he refutes the soul has learned knowledge, he says the soul is in a state of always having knowledge. Which means it is not necessary for soul to learn knowledge when it is alive because it has all knowledge.
So far, I conclude that because our souls is immortal and reincarnation, and they are always in a state of having knowledge, when we are learning, we are just recollecting knowledge within our souls. From this I argue that the purpose...

Find Another Essay On Why Socrates proposes “recollection” and how to prove it

Chronicles 1 and 2: My Continued Struggle to Prove how the Bible is based on Lies

2076 words - 8 pages 1 CHRONICLESI-IX: The first nine chapters perfectly exemplify the endless genealogies that Paul tells us to avoid in 1Tim.i.4 and Tit.iii.9.i.25: Shortest verse in the Old Testament in case you were wondering.i.32: This verse refers to Keturah as Abraham's concubine when Gen.xxv.1 says that she was his wife.i.43: For some reason the editors copied the verse of Gen.xxxvi.31.ii.15: It states here that David was Jesse's seventh son. Given that

'How true would it be to say that Socrates was a sophist?'

1649 words - 7 pages publicly disdained material possessions and was renowned for walking around Athens without any shoes. Socrates believed that the pursuit of the truth was far more important than material wealth and opted instead for a free exchange of idea's and felt it an obligation to share important things with other citizens so that all could benefit. However, it seemed that no matter how hard he tried to distinguish himself from the sophists, Socrates was

Jail Overcrowding, how to fix it and why - CRC political science - research paper

3754 words - 16 pages 07, 2016, from] Overall I believe that proposition 47 is the best because California has one of the highest rates of reaching maximum capacity time and time again. I appreciate that this prop clearly defines which felonies would be reduced to misdemeanors and why. It also explains which felonies won’t be changed. I noted that after the approval of this proposition

Explain Monetary Policy and how/why it is used to regulate Australia's economy

1167 words - 5 pages With today's market becoming increasingly deregulated, privatised and capitalist, the government has seen a dramatic loss of economic control in recent years. Monetary Policy is one of the government's strongest influential tools of the modern economy so that if it may promote:·Stability of the Australian currency·Full employment·Economic prosperityIt is the duty of the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) to use Monetary Policy

Why the Neo-Liberal Economic System Must Change and How to Solve it

1600 words - 6 pages against large corporations and monopolies running the nation-states on greed and vast wealth. As he says in his work entitled The Wealth of Nations, “To give the monopoly of the home-market to the produce of domestic industry, in any particular art or manufacture, is… in almost all cases, be either a useless or a hurtful regulation” (489). Adam Smith also mentions the harmful selfishness of the rich and how their actions affect the poor as well

How And Why Did The Nazis Use Propaganda To Futher Their Aims 1929-33 Ans How Successful Was It????

1065 words - 4 pages How and why did the Nazis use propaganda to further their aims 1929-33 and how successful was it??? Propaganda is a term used to describe untrue stories put about amongst the media and general public to boost something or someone's opinion about a certain thing while it could also in tail degrading something similar or in opposition to you.The Nazis used propaganda to great extreme in the 1929 "“ 33 period to try and make them stand out

Socrates-not perfect- I got a A- at UC Berkeley on it Essay on how Socrates arguments are contradictory and can be proven faulty. This essay proves a few of Socrates arguments faulty

1249 words - 5 pages many of his points due to considering his argument "absolute". Instead of leaving room for plausible error in his theory, he instead chooses to conclude it is "right" and final. Ironically, Socrates preaches the fact that he knows nothing and that he considers himself to be unwise. This said, however, Socrates then gives himself too much credit in The Crito and for someone that admits not knowing everything. He sure seems to deem his argument correct and not needing for correction, which ultimately is why his argument is faulty.

What do we own the animals and how and why do we owe it to them? Kant, Singer

542 words - 2 pages What do we own the animals and how and why do we owe it to them?According to Kant we do not owe animals anything as he puts it "Animals... are theremerely as a means to an end. That end is man."(emp130) I think the way he sees it isthat animals do not have the capacity to understand, to make reason. When a dog istaught something like not to urinate in the house, they understand that doing this will getthem in trouble, but do they really don't

Exclusionary Rule: How, When, and Why Was it Established?

1046 words - 4 pages The Fourth Amendment is the basis for several cherished rights in the United States, and the right to the freedom of unreasonable searches and seizures is among them. Therefore, it would seem illegitimate- even anti-American for any law enforcement agent to search and seize evidence unlawfully or for any court to charge the defendant with a guilty verdict established on illegally attained evidence. One can only imagine how many people would

“Why did the ‘Reconstruction’ of the South prove to be such an all-around failure?”

817 words - 4 pages . Basically pushing the Ten Percent Plan to the Fifty Percent Plan, it proposed that now fifty percent of a state had to take the oath in order to be readmitted as a state. It was a battle between Johnson and the Radical Republicans in Congress. During Reconstruction the thirteenth, fourteenth and fifteenth amendments were passed, collectively known as the Reconstruction Amendments. The thirteenth amendment abolished slavery, the fourteenth

Tikal and How It Came To Be

768 words - 4 pages governmental structure which consisted primarily of kingship. This extraordinary city center played home to the Maya people for many years; why was Tikal made, who made it, where was it made, When was it made are all questions we will delve deeper into. Why was Tikal Made Tikal was built by the Maya people out of necessity of infrastructure. Tikal, located in Guatemala was considered the biggest city that housed people from the Maya early

Similar Essays

How Dose Socrates Prove “Virtue Is Knowledge”

1030 words - 4 pages In this paper, I will investigate the logical progress of Socrates’s proof “virtue is knowledge”. The reason why Socrates shows Meno how to prove “virtue is knowledge”, is because it can answer Meno’s question “can virtue be taught”, if virtue is knowledge, thus it can be taught. In brief, first Socrates proves someone who has virtue, knows what is good, then he proves someone who knows what is good, has virtue. Therefore, virtue is knowledge. I

To Accept Or Not Accept Socrates’ Theory Of Recollection As Sufficient Answer To Meno’s Paradox

1211 words - 5 pages Before addressing the fundamental issues of the Theory of Recollection, it is worth noting that Socrates never addresses the second half of Meno’s Paradox- assuming one has found what it is they are looking for, how is one to know they have found it if they do not know what they are looking for? There seems to lack a method for verifying one’s answer and if you cannot confirm that what you have found is in fact what you were looking for then

Why Did Historians Of Europe Doubt That Africa Had Real History And How Have Scholars Of Africa Attempeted To Prove Them Wrong

970 words - 4 pages and shape the actual concept of racism. With him and others justifiers it was declared that Africa doesn’t have her own history and all required history came just after the contact with Europeans. The African population didn’t know how to develop the country and take care of themselves, and that’s why they needed a leader (more specifically England and France ). The best conclusion to be drawn with it is that the European superiority simply

How Dose Socrates Prove “Virtue Is Knowledge” Saint Paul School/Ancient Philosophy Reseach Paper

816 words - 4 pages then a student of Socrates, a great philosopher. His famous work ‘The Republic’ is still being used in colleges and universities nowadays. In ‘The Republic’, Plato tried to define the word ‘justice’ by laying out his thoughts through the concept of Just or Ideal Society. In ‘The Republic’, Plato firstly discussed the concept of an ‘ideal’ or a ‘just society’ and followed by the concept of a ‘just individual’. Both of these concepts are vital