This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Stalin Emerged As The Sole Leader Of The U.S.S.R. And Not Trotsky

754 words - 3 pages

Why Stalin Emerged as the Sole Leader of the U.S.S.R. and Not Trotsky

Trotsky was a leading Bolshevik and played a pivotal role in the
revolution, persuading Lenin to delay the revolution until the
Bolshevik’s had a much stronger place in the country. He also was
crucial to the civil war, as he organised the troops and motivated
them. Stalin on the other hand was in charge of all the dull jobs
within the Bolshevik party and In Lenin’s last Testament, he was
referred to as rude and he needed to be removed. So why did Stalin,
and not Trotsky emerge as Lenin’s successor. It’s a mixture of
Stalin’s luck and skill, and Trotsky’s misfortune, which will be
explained in the following paragraphs.

Stalin had a good run of luck following Lenin’s death, as firstly
Lenin’s testament was published, which stated he was rude, and needed
to be removed. It wasn’t published because it criticised other leading
party members. Also Trotsky couldn’t attend Lenin’s funeral, which
gave Stalin the chance to name himself “Lenin’s disciple” this was a
big misfortune on Trotsky’s part.

There was also the power struggle. In this there were 4 main factors
that Stalin manipulated. These Were:

· Factionalism

· The N.E.P.

· Socialism In One Country/ permanent Revolution

· His Power Base

Factionalism was the Idea that if a member of the party discusses
ideas which did not have the majority vote by the party.

There were 2 main Ideas about the N.E.P. , these were the left wing
and the right wing. The left wing said it should go and the right wing
said it should stay as it would aid Industrialisation, as it allowed
free trade to sell goods on the open market which would give money
into the open market.

Stalin’s powerbase was due to him being the general secretary, who was
in charge of recruiting people, so when the Lenin...

Find Another Essay On Why Stalin Emerged as the Sole Leader of the U.S.S.R. and Not Trotsky

Why Stalin was Able to Win the Power Struggle with Trotsky

2213 words - 9 pages even acted pleasantly towards Trotsky, and when others would snub him as he entered the Party Congress, Stalin welcomed him warmly . Stalin watched all of this happen from the sidelines, and was not only able to slowly build support for himself, but gain a plan of attack, one in which he could chose his most optimal allies, and eliminate Trotsky from the possibility of succession once and for all. Stalin had allied himself with Zinoviev and

Trotsky and Stalin Essay

1372 words - 5 pages Bolsheviks a little bit of respect. If Trotsky hadn't contributed to the Bolsheviks I don't think that the revolution would of happened. Trotsky played a vital part in the revolution and his sneaky plans worked and he had everything planned secretly from everyone. B I think the reason that Stalin and not Trotsky emerged as Lenin's successor because Stalin was a strong Bolshevik believer from the beginning

The Life and Success of Leon Trotsky

1565 words - 7 pages marked holidays at the local synagogue. However as the family grew wealthier, their already thin Jewish identification vanished almost completely. When Lev was seven, he was sent to live with Uncle Abram and Aunt Rachel in the nearby village of Gromokley. Here he attended a Jewish heder (a school for Jewish children). In his autobiography, Trotsky claimed “ I had no intimate friends among my classmates, as I did not speak Yiddish.” Still, he was

Why did Lenin and Trotsky win the Russian civil war?

764 words - 3 pages Key points of essay; (for revision purposes)1. Trotsky and the red army2. Weakness of the White armies3. War Communism4. Attitude of the peasants5. Propaganda6. Red terror- Cheka7. Allied WithdrawalJuring the Russian civil war Leon Trotsky played a major role. He was commander and chief of the red army, which fought on the side of the communists. As a much experienced and brave commander he won many battles against the white armies through smart

Joseph Stalin, The Leader of USSR from 1922 to 1953

1294 words - 5 pages , he executes five million agriculturists, and imprisons five percent of Russia's peasants. This does not leave enough farmers to produce the vast quantity of food necessary. Stalin however demands that the remaining peasants account for all of their work as well as the missing peasants. This is an impossible task. Many peasants die of hunger and exhaustion. More so, with the lagging production of food many people go

Profit maximisation is not the sole objective of business

1090 words - 4 pages work and location or relocation of premises. The state government provides an underlying framework for the operation of the company. Legislation on taxation, the environment, consumer protection, health and safety at work, employment practices, solvency and many other issues forces companies to behave in a way in which they might otherwise not do in an unregulated environment. The consumer, through organizations such as the Consumers' Association

Bentham’s Principle of Utility and its Shortcomings as the Sole Basis for Morality

2018 words - 8 pages the principles of asceticism and the principles of sympathy and antipathy which allow for bias. While Bentham does provide a compelling explanation and argument as to why the consideration of utility should be the sole legitimate basis for morality, he ultimately provides a moral framework that is too rigid to deal with the complexities of actual human life. Bentham describes a system which he believes should be universal and impartial. He claims

From 1790 to 1857, the Supreme Court emerged as the most powerful branch of our government

1139 words - 5 pages From 1790 to 1857, the Supreme Court emerged as the most powerful branch of our government.I agree with the above statement. The US Supreme Court started slowly as a branch of our government, but by 1857 it emerged as the most powerful branch. The Presidency and the Executive branch certainly can create things, implement new ideas and have a large impact on all the citizens' lives. The Congress as the legislative branch can establish or change

When and Why Communism Emerged

1827 words - 7 pages expansion of our Red Army and the mobilization of the masses for the revolutionary war?" But even the best still make mistakes, and Mao did make some big mistakes in his time, he admitted them though, later on in his life. Communism arose in other countries as well, but not on such a scale as in Russia or China. We saw that communist ideas came about at a time of great change- the industrial revolution, and that it emerged because of human nature

Identify the contractual principles which emerged from the decision of the court in Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893) and explain why lawy

2980 words - 12 pages the guidelines that the company had suggested, Mrs. Louisa Elizabeth Carlill contracted Influenza, a disease listed as one which would be eradicated by the use of the product. Subsequently, Carlill attempted to claim her compensation, however she was refused the payout and decided to take the company to court. The company, in court, argued that their claims were not serious, that is was simply ‘trade puff’ and that it was impossible to contract

Which Leader Best Carried Out The Ideals Of The Russian Revolution: Lenin Or Stalin?

1329 words - 5 pages of strokes and at the beginning of 1924, he died.After Lenin's death in early 1924, there was a struggle for power among the top-level members of the Communist Party - Trotsky, Stalin, Zinoviev, Bukharin and Kamenev. In his will, Lenin did not mention anyone to succeed him as the leader of the Party and the country. Trotsky remained in the Caucasus to recover from an illness and failed to attend the funeral in Moscow. Stalin immediately opened a

Similar Essays

Why Did Stalin Rather Than Trotsky Emerge As The Leader Of The Ussr After Lenin's Death?

1732 words - 7 pages ' verses the 'right'. And lastly I will look at the effects of luck which played in his victory.'Trotsky could fire masses of men to acclaim and follow him. But he had no talent for leadership among equals' (Carr)This is a key factor of why Stalin had become dictator. Trotsky's weaknesses lead directly to his own downfall and his underestimation of Stalin is also a key part of Trotsky's arrogant nature. Trotsky was not scared to speak his mind and his

Why Did Trotsky Not Become The New Leader Of The Bolshevik Party After Lenin's Death?

3990 words - 16 pages saw Trotsky as his main competition not Stalin, due to the friendship between Trotsky and Lenin. Lenin's funeral The cult of Lenin emerged after the civil war (1918-1920) from a grateful country. However, the cult was never really acknowledged by Lenin and definitely not promoted by him. The real cult began at Lenin's funeral. This is where Stalin gave a long oration about how great and holy the former leader was. From the view of the peasantry

Why Stalin, Not Trotsky, Became Lenin's Successor

613 words - 2 pages who was determined to get his own way. He mixed his own ideas with Lenin's and manipulated those who did not support him. Stalin was man of many personalities; being kind to his opposition whilst plotting to kill them. Trotsky was always seen as the weaker opposition. He was to ambitious for the Russian people and was feared because of his control of the Red Army.

Why Did Stalin Take Power And Not Trotsky? The Power Struggle Between The Bolshevik After Lenin's Death

1306 words - 5 pages Why did Stalin take power and not Trotsky?In 1921 Lenin died and a power struggle emerged upon the top members of the Bolshevik party to take over as leader of the Bolshevik party no knowing that in doing so will eventually get themselves exiled out of Russia or Killed by a man largely underestimated and never thought to go to the extremes he did.Lenin had been ill for some time and it was obvious he was not going to live for much longer after