This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why The Battle Of The Somme Is Regarded As A Great Military Tragedy

1170 words - 5 pages

Why the Battle of the Somme is Regarded as a Great Military Tragedy

On 1st July 1916, General Haig prepared the battle plan for an
offensive on German lines, designed to relieve the strain on French
forces at Verdun and break through a strong line of German defences.
While Haig would have preferred an attack further north, he was
hopeful that the operation should be successful in drawing forces away
from Verdun and killing as many German troops as possible as part of
the “war of attrition”. The location was the Somme River.

The details were worked out by General Haig and his deputy, General
Rawlinson. The focus of the battle plan was a huge artillery
bombardment, backed up by mines, collapsed beneath enemy territory
with the aim of devastating German positions. The bombardment would
effectively cut through the enemy’s barbed wire, while smashing
fortified positions and dug-outs. Haig placed so much faith in the
power of British guns, that he expected men to be capable of walking
across no-man’s land, carrying heavy packs with provisions and trench
repair equipment to rebuild the captured territory upon arrival. The
final piece of the plan saw cavalry forces, kept in readiness, to
charge through gaps in the German front line and cause a mass-retreat
of enemy forces.

In hindsight, we can see that the offensive very much failed to live
up to expectations. Such terrible failure is possibly attributable to
poor tactics and leadership on the part of Douglas Haig and his
advisors. Haig certainly knew of the masses of barbed wire separating
the German forces from his men; however the General grossly
overestimated the ability of his artillery to destroy German defences,
eventually spelling doom for the attacking infantry. Numerous factors
would also appear to have been overlooked by Haig, such as the
position of the defenders on high ground, with a good view of any
attacking forces. The strength of German defences was also
underestimated, seeing as the Germans had been in place since 1914 and
had set about placing their dug-outs deep underground and fortifying
them with concrete. The barbed wire had been stretched out more than
thirty metres wide, making it almost impossible to penetrate,
regardless of artillery. It was not only poor forward-planning that
resulted in such terrible losses however. For example, the shells
supplied to British forces were not as Haig had envisaged, many of
which were of low quality, or failed to go off at all.

Over confidence resulted in the offensive’s first major flaw; it’s
timing. The infantry attack began at 7.30 am on 1st July, rather than
at dawn when no-man’s land would be covered in a thick mist which
would naturally make the task of the German gunner much more
difficult. Such a time was chosen by Commanders who were confident
that there...

Find Another Essay On Why the Battle of the Somme is Regarded as a Great Military Tragedy

Battle of the Somme Essay

1148 words - 5 pages , the British lost more men than on any other single day in the history of the empire, more than in acquiring Canada and India combined.”(Raico). The British went into the Somme with a mixed attack plan, which led to an unsuccessful first assault resulting in a battle of attrition. The opening day of The Battle of the Somme resulted in near 60,000 casualties for the British, the largest in British military history for a single day. Originally the

Battle of the Somme Essay

860 words - 3 pages The second battle of 1916 was the Battle of the Somme. In this the British and French armies tried to break through the German defences in the valley of the river Somme. The battle started on the first day of July 1916 as huge guns bombarded the German trenches. Then thousands of troops charged across no-man's land to press home the attack.The trenches of the British ran for 20 miles from the village of Hebuterne south across the Ancre to the

The Battle of the Somme as a Victory for the British

2168 words - 9 pages Somme had started. General Douglas Haig had been criticised widely by the British people and Woodrow Wilson for flaws in his plans. I think that the British government is at fault since they appointed a general like Haig in command of the Battle of the Somme. The reason is because Haig had very little experience in fighting battles against a strong side. He was placed as general of the British army when fighting against

What is meant by the derived demand for labour why is the labour market regarded as a factor market?

766 words - 3 pages changes at a macroeconomic level include the total level of economic activity, productivity of labour, general wage rate, government industrial relatio9ns policies and the level of industrial disputation.If economic growth is high there will be an increased demand for labour as spending and output will rise. The rate of unemployment will tend to fall over time as those unable to find work are employed. If there is a decline in economic activity then

The Battle of the Somme in 1916

2480 words - 10 pages their offense. Greatwar.co.uk states that the heavy losses of men restricted the British from aiding or strengthening any war objectives (Legg 2). Not only did they lose many soldiers, but they also lost any firm grasp on land gained. July 1st took a devastating toll on both the Allies and Germany. During the Battle of the Somme, smaller battles took place such as the Battle of Flers-Courcelette. Flers-Courcelette is commonly known because of its

Evaluation of the Battle of the Somme

1941 words - 8 pages article published by The Daily Chronicle on the 3rd July which is explaining the events of the first day of the battle. At about 7 . 30 am this morning a vigorous attack was launched by the British Army. The front extends over some 20 miles north of the Somme. The assault was preceded by a terrific bombardment, lasting about an hour and a half. It is too early to as yet give anything but the bearest particulars, as the

Was the Battle of the Somme Justified?

2181 words - 9 pages them a hard time that led to this failure. At the end of the battle the British and French forces had not even reached the line they set themselves for in the beginning of the battle. The battle of the Somme is remembered as the bloodiest battles in the First World War and its first day is known as the worst day of the British military history. Despite its failure and destructions the fighting of the Somme was characterized by incredible

The Realism of the Film The Battle of The Somme

1904 words - 8 pages The Realism of the Film The Battle of The Somme The film 'The Battle of The Somme' was released in Londonon the 10th of August 1916, it was a famous documentary that was filmed by Geoffrey Malins and J.B. McDowell. They were one of the first groups of cameramen to film the British soldiers on the Battlefields of the Western Front. They helped the government to produce a video, to show people that War wasn't as bad as it

General Haig's Role in the Battle of the Somme

1516 words - 6 pages there during the battle called him a murderer. Another view is that General Haig was not the Butcher of Somme. Some argue that he was being very supportive during the war, he showed great interest in wanting to help defeat the Germans as source 10 talks about how the war was flawless (perfect) and that his general-ship was excellent. The origin of this text is from a Lieutenant in Yorkshire infantry (writing a letter to the daily express

Why is perfect competition sometimes regarded as an ideal market structure and why does Samuelson write that it doesn't faithfully represent the facts about modern industry?

545 words - 2 pages Perfect competition sometimes is regarded as an ideal market structure because itsupports the actual ideology of a free market economy where, for example there is no government intervention. The entrepreneur in perfect competition works independent of other entrepreneurs and each individual buyer or seller does not influence the market, there are perfect substitutes for all goods and the demand is perfectly elastic, hence there is no price rise

Military, Army and War - Military Down Sizing and the Fall of a Great Nation

1289 words - 5 pages Military Down Sizing:  The Possible Fall of a Great Nation     America is one the most powerful nations in the world.  Being a strong nation includes having a strong military as well as economy.  As one can observe, the U. S. economy is growing by leaps and bounds.  However, the military is being down sized, and if we do not do something about it, it will continue to be down sized until we have an armed force that will no longer be capable

Similar Essays

Why Was The First Day Of The Battle Of The Somme A Failure?

1065 words - 4 pages battle plans were not properly prepared, as there had been little fighting prior to the battle.The Battle of Somme was a dreadful failure. The main reason for this seems to be Sir Douglas Haig. He was the one who cam up with all these plans, and refused to listen to Rawlinson. He also disregarded so many reports during the battle of the number of casualties, yet he refused to listen to them. He was stubborn and had to have it his own way. He

Battle Of The Somme Essay

1053 words - 5 pages states that the “wrong attitude” and “loss of courage,” is what caused these men to flee the battle (Wilson 245). This resulted in the loss of outstanding men, that continued to fight the battle, because they were full of bravery and were “by nature to lead men,” (Moran 246). Lastly the Battle of the Somme resulted in political consequences. After a great defeat many of the countries had gotten into arguments and repercussions within each other

Battle Of The Somme Essay

619 words - 2 pages This battle is known as the bloodiest battle because over 300,000 men died, with wounded and killed combined the casualties were over 1 million. This battle was fought between the British and German armies. Casualties on the first day were already the worst in the history of the British army. This battle took place from July 1st 1916 to November 18th 1919. There was no clear winner in this battle. Both armies were very badly hurt and neither of

The Battle Of Somme Essay

1932 words - 8 pages . on July 1. John Buchanan thought to symbolize it as a horror of warfare in World War I. He also states that it is “the supreme moment without heroics and without tremor.” The Battle of the Somme started with the French and British climbing out of their trenches and plummeting right into the war. Haig’s troops were all lined up in windows ready to fire their machine guns. It was a total massacre. Men were already dying and heavily wounded. Although