Why The Dutch Failed To Save Their Jews During World War Ii

3988 words - 16 pages

Synopsis
A single telegram ended the peace. This small piece of paper meant the death of thousands of people. It was the Nazis declaration of war on the Netherlands. One of the most anti-Semitic regimes in recent history now occupied a country who had housed Jews for the last few centuries. Critics have blamed the large amounts of Jewish deaths on the lack of Dutch resistance to the Nazis. However, it was not the lack of moral responsibility amongst the non-Jews, but the insufficient finances and food supplies that caused the decimation of horrific amounts of Dutch Jews during World War II. The gentiles attempted to save the Jews, but the cost of hiding them was too extreme, leaving no choice other than letting the Jews be deported.

Introduction
The Netherlands is famous for being one of the most resistant countries during World War II. Yad Vashem has honored more “religious gentiles” from the Netherlands than any other country. However, of the approximately 140,000 Jews in the Netherlands, 107,000 were deported. Only 5,000 of those Jews returned, and of the Jews in hiding, only 30,000 survive. This meant that 75% of the Dutch Jewish population was eradicated, the second largest amount after Poland.
Many question why so few Jews survived while so many people tried to save them. My hypothesis is that the limited amount of food and money made hiding the Jews to difficult and expensive for the non-Jews, giving them virtually no choice but to let the Jews be deported.

The Buildup
Initially the Netherlands attempted to stay neutral during World War II, as it had been in the First World War, however, the Nazis still attacked. The final Nazi-free moments for the Dutch were those on May 10, 1940, the day Hitler invaded the Netherlands. Heavy fighting continued for the next five days. Only after the Nazis had bombed Rotterdam, and massacred hundreds of soldiers, did the Dutch finally surrender. By now, Parliament, Queen Wilhelmina, and the Dutch Royal family had fled to England, leaving the government positions vacant. This allowed the Nazis to implement a civilian government by imposing their own officials in the unoccupied government, instead of the military government as they had in other countries such as Serbia and Poland.
At first, the Nazi government was very lenient on the Dutch population, since they saw them as perfect Aryans and wanted the Netherlands to become part of Nazi Germany. As the months progressed, the Nazis started to pass legislation against the Jews. Starting in October 1940, every government official was required to sign a document stating neither he nor any of his close family members were Jewish, thereby forcing almost all Jews out of the government. Four months later, in January of 1941, the Nazis demanded all Jews to register with the German authorities. They used this data to make maps of were all the Jews lived. The following month, the Nazis sectioned off and converted part of Amsterdam into a Jewish ghetto. This led...

Find Another Essay On Why the Dutch Failed to Save Their Jews During World War II

Playing for Their Country: Baseball During World War II

1856 words - 7 pages , managers, and the game itself. As with anything else that stands the test of time, baseball has turned itself into a tradition of American culture, thus living up to its nickname, “America’s national pastime. The question then remains, can an American foundation, like baseball, allow citizens to maintain some sort of normalcy during troubling times? The answer to this question is yes. During World War II, the sport of baseball was used

Why developing nation-states failed during the 20th century

2086 words - 9 pages and affects that have been made to them and their nation by the greater power that they were ruled by. In this paper some of the reasons of the failure of nation states during 20th century will be mentioned and discussed with regards to Somalia as an Example. In regards to the third world and according to fund for peace a failed institution; state failure has many multidimensional indicators, which are: socially which are; high rate of Mounting

Why were the Habsburgs unable to consolidate their power in Hungary during this period?

2092 words - 8 pages period 1600-1700, the Habsburgs were unable to cement their rule in Hungary due to factors listed above. Works Cited E. Pamlényi, History of Hungary (Budapest, 1973) D. Sinor, History of Hungary (London, 1959) R. A. Kann, A History of the Habsburg Empire 1526-1918 (Los Angeles, 1974) C. M. Kortepeter, Ottoman Imperialism during the Reformation (New York, 1972) M. Cook, A History of the Ottoman Empire to 1730 (London, 1976) C. V. Wedgwood, The Thirty Years War (Yale, 1939)

This essay is about the rescuing of Jews in the Holocaust and how the Jews hid and the trials and tribulations they went through during their hiding

1393 words - 6 pages some positive nature to an otherwise horrific event.Despite the consequences and danger in being caught, the rescuers chose to help the Jews in their time of need.There were two types of people who were involved in the rescue process, the ones who rescued, and the Jews, the people who were rescued. Being rescued was a commitment to survival; therefore, the people being rescued could not be passive, but needed to be very active. Going into hiding

The Japanese Internment during World War II

1332 words - 5 pages With Liberty and Justice for All?The United States Misuse of Power over Japanese Americans during World War IIThe internment of Japanese Americans during World War II has long been a topic of debate. The government of the United States has claimed this action, after the surprise attack on Pearl Harbor, was a "military necessity", taken as a means of national security. Hirabayashi v. United States and Korematsu v. United States were two of the

The Suffering Of the Jews in World War II according to the book Night by Elie Wiesel

783 words - 3 pages human being to an animal is outlandish. While riding from camp to camp seeing the crematory's flames bursting from the top of the buildings in the night skies, to moving multiple tons of stone during the day, they could only hope that they were not the next to be put in the flames. 'As the train stopped, we saw this time that flames were gushing out of a tall chimney into the black sky.'It is worth nothing that their sufferings ran the gamut from

Warfare during World War II

745 words - 3 pages Technology and the kinds of savage warfare conducted by the American and enemy forces during World War II both played a crucial role in determining the outcome of the war. The war began with most armies utilizing technology that had changed little from World War I, and in some cases, had remained unchanged since the 19th century. The war began with cavalry, trenches, and World War I-era battleships, but within only six years, armies around the

The Events and Happenings During World War II

1141 words - 5 pages world war, both opposing forces promised that they would improve their equipment in World War II, so they did. The Germans and the Americans had the nuclear weapons that can destroy half the world and they would use them as their trump card, but the Germans made it their planned first wave of attack.The Germans had the most heavy infantry automatic weapons and the Americans had the most troops to send. Both opposing forces had the same

Women in the Work Force during World War II

630 words - 3 pages that did hire women reclassified them to a lower rank with lower pay, using their lack of experience as an excuse for the demotion. (Gregory 194). Majority of the women who worked were young and single before the Second World War, and after the war, women workers were older and married. Even though there was a provisional shift during the war, traditional outlook regarding women’s roles as wife and mother never lost its appeal, but World War II set the road for women and their rights in society.

The Policy of Evacuating Children During World War II

849 words - 3 pages The Policy of Evacuating Children During World War II During World War 2 many children and other vulnerable civilians such as pregnant women and mothers with young children were evacuated to the safer country areas. In this essay I will look at the reaction's of many of the many different people involved with the evacuation such as the children evacuated, mothers and the clashes they had with the other parents in their

Crime rates in the United States during World War II

4594 words - 18 pages to the rise of crimes such as aggravated assault, which jumped from 46.5 in 1939 to 54.8 in 1945. This was most likely caused by overconfidence of the criminals. "Improved economic conditions usually lead to an increase in crimes of violence, such as assault and manslaughter. " (historians.org)"In the United States at least 90 percent of the recorded crimes are the work of males." (historians.org) This statistic did not change during World War II

Similar Essays

The Hungarian Jews During World War Ii

738 words - 3 pages Powers. The Nazi Party helped regain land that was lost in World War 1 gaining some of Hungary’s trust (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum). German told Hungary to enforce anti-Semitism laws and degrees. Hungary followed the command not knowing that Germany was slower turning up the heat on Hungary. At this time Hungary has the population of 825,000 Jews, a large portion of their population (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum). During

Persecution Of Jews During World War Ii

761 words - 3 pages Persecution of Jews increased during World War two as Nazis invaded more countries; which contained thousands of Jews. The increased number of Jews meant that the problem increased greatly. The ways in which the Nazis dealt with the Jews gradually changed throughout the years. First it started by isolating them from society, then exportation out of Europe, then ghettoisatiion;which failed because of the mass number of people. Later on they

The Holocaust: Genocide Of Jews During World War Ii

1481 words - 6 pages The Holocaust, what is the true depth of the word? As sad as it may seem, it had the most damaging effects on the human mind in history. Many horrific events consisting of genocide of Jews during World War II came to play during the Holocaust. Accounts of life during the genocide of the Jewish culture emerged among of which are Elie Wiesel’s memoir Night, Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower’s Letters to George C. Marshall, Mein Kampf and The Jewish

The Sniper. A Story About Two Brothers During World War Ii. One Brother's Struggle To Save The Other, And Then Ultimately Save Himself

957 words - 4 pages This was World War II. Countries on both sides of the globes were fighting each other, while the less able and less powered countries were deciding on which side to choose. Like many of the other nations who sided with someone of their liking, Finland too joined up and became an ally of the Russian Federation.Ines, who was 25 years old, had gone off to Russia sometime before to train and prepare with the red army for the impending war. He was