Why Was Isabella Able To Win The Civil War In Castile 1475 1479. History Essay

1235 words - 5 pages

Olivia Springall
Why Was Isabella Able to Win the Civil War in Castile 1475-1479.
During the late 15th century in Castile, a civil war took place. This war was between two women who both claimed to be the rightful queen of Castile. These two were Isabella of Castile and Juana La Beltraneja, or Joanna the bastard. In this essay I will argue that the main reason for Isabella’s victory was the fact that her opponent, Joanna, and Joanna’s council, predominantly the King Alfonso of Portugal and the Marquis of Villena, were weak in terms of military and political leadership.
In the War of Succession each woman felt that she was the rightful ruler of Castile. Joanna felt that she should be queen as she was the daughter of the King, as that was how lines of succession worked. However it was disputed, at the time, that Joanna was really Henry IV’s daughter as she was the only child that he had fathered, thus she earned the name Juana la Beltraneja. This nickname was earned because many people of the time believed that Joanna was not actually Henry’s daughter. However now many historians believe that Joanna was legitimate and that the rumours that she wasn’t Henry’s daughter were false. Isabella used the fact that many people saw Joanna as illegitimate, to further her own claim to the throne as the king’s half-sister.
There were many reasons for Isabella’s success in the War of Succession, and lots of people have differing opinions on this topic. Some people would argue that the main reason for Isabella’s victory was her’s and Ferdinand’s strength as leaders. The couple, although having never met before their wedding day, worked well together. Ferdinand’s prowess in military affairs was useful for Isabella, as many battles were fought in this war, due to the fact that it was not socially acceptable for a woman to lead the troops into battle. Ferdinand was an excellent military leader, which was shown in his battle against Alfonso of Portugal, who was Joanna’s Fiancé. This battle, the battle of Toro in 1476, was a humiliating defeat for Alfonso and Joanna. Ferdinand also worked effortlessly to gain support from the nobles to support Isabella, due to the fact that it was these nobles who controlled the land and the industry.
During the war of succession the throne of Castile officially belonged to Isabella as Henry IV had pronounced her his heir before his death. This meant that Isabella had the power to promise certain luxuries and grants to the nobles. Joanna did not have this luxury because she was unfamiliar with the inner workings of the Castilian kingdom. Isabella, to win support in her favour, said that once she had won this war that she would let the nobles keep collecting the financial grants called, mercedes, and that all grants of nobility conferred by Henry IV would be confirmed. She also promised to investigate complaints about the fact that only a small percentage of the tax collected by the tax farmers reached the nobles. These promises by...

Find Another Essay On Why Was Isabella Able to Win the Civil War in Castile 1475-1479. - History - Essay

Weapons of the Civil War: Why Did The North Win?

1626 words - 7 pages Weapons of the Civil War: Why Did The North Win?      Battles have been fought since the dawn of time. Weapons have gradually become more technological and sophisticated each and every time. People learn from their mistakes, as did the Indians in the late 1700s, as well as the Confederate troops from the Civil War. The Union was victorious in this war for freedom, and to this day, the north is more the heart of the country’s economy

Why did Lenin and Trotsky win the Russian civil war?

764 words - 3 pages solders on the front lines. The rest of the food was rationed among the Russian people and was given depending on each person's contribution to the economy. Although War communism achieved its aims of winning the civil war it caused great suffering among the Russian people. Cut backs in grain production by peasants who resisted the policy led to a famine which killed 5 to 7 million people.The Cheka, an organisation set up by Lenin to protect

Why did the Chinese Communist Party Win the Civil War in 1949?

1297 words - 5 pages The Chinese Civil War, which lasted from 1927 to 1949, was a civil war in China which the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) overthrew the Guomindang (GMD) . As the CCP had always been inferior to the GMD in many aspects, many were shocked and startled by the Communist's victory; although numerous factors show that the Communist's victory was almost inevitable. This essay will examine the factors that lead to the Communists victory, which includes

"Why was Mussolini able to get to power in 1922?"

1474 words - 6 pages "Why was Mussolini able to get to power in 1922?"By 1900 the process of unification in Italy, the Risorgimento, had largely been completed territorially, but not in any other respect. The vast majority of the population still felt no real attachment to Italy at all, as a result of "Italy's continuing weakness as a cultural, industrial, military, and colonial power compared to older European states"(Essays in 20th Century World History).This

Why the American Civil War Was Necessary

1762 words - 7 pages desperately, so the Congress decidedly to aid them. On March 3rd, 1865, the Freedmen's Bureau. This was a program set up to newly freed men and women. The main assistance it provided was in education. "By 1870 there were more than a thousand schools in the South for freedmen" (Freedmen's Online).A second reason why the American Civil War was necessary was because our country needed both the South and North regions to survive. Each region relied on one

Why Stalin Was Able to Hold on to Power in the Soviet Union

1017 words - 4 pages Why Stalin Was Able to Hold on to Power in the Soviet Union Stalin was ruthless in order to stay in power, there are many reasons that helped him hold on to his position. Through the Purges Stalin was able to eliminate or clear out all opposition within the party. Anyone who threatened his position, or disagreed with some of his policies, was purged. They were purged in great Show Trails, in order for

The role played by John Pym ensured that Parliament was always likely to win the first Civil War of 1642

896 words - 4 pages they were fighting justly, for God and what he would want.Pym further helped Parliament to win the first Civil War as he neither sided with the 'war' or 'peace' groups, meaning that he stayed neutral in the middle and was able to manipulate both sides and bridge the two extremes meaning there was less division within Parliament's side.However, as mentioned it is not fair to give John Pym all the credit of Parliaments victory of the first Civil

Why did the parliamentarians not the royalists win the first British civil war?

1800 words - 7 pages Why did the parliamentarians not the royalists win the first civil war?This essay is directed at not only showing why the parliamentarians won the first civil war but why the royalists lost. Many points shall be examined such as finance, leadership, foreign support, motives for fighting, and regions of control through out Britain and the New Model Army.There were two sides in the civil war; royalists who supported the king, who also known as

Why did the South lose the Civil War and how did the North win?

579 words - 2 pages There are a few reasons why the South lost the Civil War. One reason is that the North not only outmanned the South but also at almost every point, militarily. The South was also outclassed industrially. If it was not for European recognition and military aid the South would have never had a chance to win. Industrially the South could not keep up in out put and in manpower. By the end of the war the South had, more or less, plenty of weaponry

Why was Hitler able to rise to power in Germany in 1933?

1305 words - 5 pages created a unique situation for Hitler's rise. Hitler was in part a product of German culture. German culture at the time stood out as particularly aggressive and racist. The values and ideas found in this culture's history inspired Hitler to do many things that he did and can explain in part why he felt the way he did on certain issues. For example there were talks of the master race in the past history of Germany by the German philosophers, which

The following are equally important reasons why Stalin was able to hold onto power in the Soviet Union:

1493 words - 6 pages The following are equally important reasons why Stalin was able to hold onto power in the Soviet Union: The purges and show trials The secret police Propaganda and the cult of personality Stalin’s economic policies. Explain how far you agree with this statement. Stalin used to methods to hold onto power in the Soviet Union these were fear / coercion and persuasion / consent. If people were not

Similar Essays

Why Stalin Was Able To Win The Power Struggle With Trotsky

2213 words - 9 pages Why Stalin was Able to Win the Power Struggle with Trotsky The Bolsheviks, the ruling party of the Soviet Union, was lead by the Lenin. When Lenin died in January of 1924, he left behind no clear successor, and vague indications of his intended plans for the Bolshevik party. A power struggle for control of the party ensued, one in which many historical figures arose. Within this plethora of names, two of the most important names in Soviet

Why Did The Communists Win The Chinese Civil War Gcse History Assignment

731 words - 3 pages Why did the Communists win the Civil War? Did they win it; or the Nationalists lose it? Main reason – military · Against Japanese – Communists had learnt how to fight against larger forces · Guerrilla warfare highly successful · In Manchuria – also worked well · Terrain was hilly and large forested areas · 1930s Mao wrote – when fighting a superior enemy communists should establish base areas in the mountains and mount surprise attacks against

Why Did The Nationalists Win The Spanish Civil War? University Essay

3009 words - 13 pages wider Europe provided the final death blow to the Republics war effort. Bibliography Franco and the Spanish Civil War | History Today. 2018. Franco and the Spanish Civil War | History Today. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.historytoday.com/julius-ruiz/franco-and-spanish-civil-war prezi.com. 2018. Why did the nationalists win the spanish civil war? by Will Schlegel on Prezi. [ONLINE] Available at: https://prezi.com/ljkzyrgnt3n3/why-did-the

Why Did The Bolsheviks Win The Russian Civil War?

837 words - 3 pages Why did the Bolsheviks win The Russian Civil War? Although Lenin was able to bring an end to Russia's role in World War I, he was unable to avert the happening of a Russian Civil War, a time of great chaos. Towards the start of the Civil War, the Bolsheviks struggled immensely. Their opponents, "The Whites", were made up of any anti-Bolshevik groups: supporters of the Tsar; Mensheviks; Social Revolutionaries; capitalists and the Czech Legion