This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

(Wilfred Owen) Compare "Mental Cases" And "Disabled" And Explain The Differing Feelings Which Owen Expresses And What Your Reactions To Them Are.

1078 words - 4 pages

Both "Mental Cases" and "Disabled" are anti-war poems evoking vivid and sometimes shocking emotions. Owen shows a less pleasant side to "The Great War" in his typical fashion. "Disabled" paints a vivid picture of a young man's misfortune and shows the contrast between his old life - full of hope - and his new life, in which he has no hope. "Mental Cases", on the other hand, outlines the mental effects of the war, with strikingly vivid images.~"Disabled" begins with a description of a man in a wheel-chair. He is described as wearing a "ghastly suit of grey" which is "Legless, sewn short at the elbow". This bluntly makes apparent the fact that this man has lost his legs and parts of his arms. He hears the "Voices of play and pleasure" but he is far removed from them. He has no pleasure, now.On lines 11 and 12 Owen describes how the man used to experience girls - "how slim // Girl's waists are or how warm their subtle hands". That was, however, "before he threw away his knees." This is another blunt remark - a little detached and objective but straight to the point. Now, girls "touch him like some queer disease." He is now no longer an attractive young man but he seems almost like a repulsive old man. While last year he appeared "younger than his youth", "Now he is old". The irony in him now being the disgust of girls now is that he actually went to war to impress the women - "to please his Meg"."Someone said he'd look a god in kilts"Now he looks like anything but a god.The vivid image of the man being horribly wounded in the trenches is conjured by the metaphor of how he "lost his colour":"Poured it down shell holes till the veins ran dry"His bleeding is described as a "leap of purple" which "spurted from his thigh". Both these images of heavy bleeding are very powerful, as are the emotions stirred in the reader.By contrast, the man use to think that blood on your leg was manly when it was gained as a consequence of actions for ones side. However, now he has no legs to have "a blood-smear" on, thanks to his contribution. "[H]e liked a blood-smear down his leg" "after football" - but that was only a game. Now, he has discovered that injuries can be much more serious when sustained in what one might call: The Ultimate Game. He underestimated the opposition - "Germans he scarcely thought of" - and has paid the price. Before, he had "no fear // Of Fear" - he though not of death or danger. He though only about the spirit of fellow men - "Esprit de corps" - about the uniform ("daggers in plaid socks") and about the "drums and cheers" as he marched of to war.The only one who "cheered him home", on the other hand, was "a solemn man who brought him fruits". He was not welcomed back as a hero but "not as crowds cheer Goal". This is another reference to sport and to how different war is. Only the man with the fruits, who we may assume to be a vicar or similar holy man, actually thanked him for his sacrifice. Of course he did not go to make a sacrifice for his...

Find Another Essay On (Wilfred Owen) --- Compare "Mental Cases" and "Disabled" and explain the differing feelings which Owen expresses and what your reactions to them are.

wilfred owen Essay

827 words - 3 pages beliefs. This is ultimately what makes Owen's poetry unique and allows it to stand on its own for the contemporary audience.Unlike authors of his time, Wilfred Owen highlighted the false glorification of conflict and the waste of the lives associated with war in his poem Futility. This continues to resonate with modern audiences as Owen vividly depicts the innocent victims of pointless wars and expresses a sense of melancholy through the use of

Wilfred Owen Essay

3859 words - 15 pages a turn for the worst when severe frost struck, affected many men. On the 15th of March Wilfred Owen was evacuated from the front line due to concussion he experienced after a fall. He was later returned to the line, but only for twelve days as he was evacuated with Shell Shock and sent to Craiglockhart Hospital just outside Edinburgh. In July Siegfried Sassoon arrived at Craiglockhart, which was a hospital for Generals who had become mentally un

Wilfred OWEN

1276 words - 5 pages war. He then metaphorically describes them as `drunk with fatigue', `men marched asleep', to highlight their exhaustion and their physical status, unable to keep up. Owen descriptively says that they `limped on' cause of `blood shos' which highlights the graphical image. In result these images convey the pitiful concerns about the youth, by use of descriptive techniques. Similarly in "Mental Cases", Owen conveys the

Wilfred Owen

963 words - 4 pages It could be said that all of war poet Wilfred Owen 's work has a discernible purpose; this being the destructive capacity of war, and its ultimate futility. What remained constant throughout Owen 's career as a war poet was his ability to communicate his purpose successfully to the reader, through his style and technique. Some of his poems like Dulce et decorum est demonstrate Owen 's initial purpose in protesting against the war by means of

Wilfred Owen

1002 words - 4 pages choice of the word 'children' is significant; as impressionable young men are almost lured to war by the promise of 'desperate glory'. In conclusion, Owen breaks from the pretty language prevalent in the poetry of his era to show his society the awful images of real and not romantically heroic war. Finally, Owen juxtaposes the idea of war as devastating and the idea of war as heroic to illustrate the poem's ultimate irony - "The Old Lie: Dulce Et Decorum Est, Pro patria Mori", which translates from Latin as “it is sweet and right to die for your country,” a concept Owen strongly denied. Works Cited -

Wilfred Owen

1018 words - 4 pages . Sassoon's emphasis on realism and 'writing from experience' was not exactly unheard of to Owen, but it was not a style which he had previously made use of. Sassoon himself contributed to this by his strong promotion of Owen's poetry, both before and after Owen's death. Thousands of poems were published during the war, but very few of them had the benefit of such strong patronage, and it is as a result of Sassoon's influence, as well as support from

Comparison of "Recalling War" by Robert Graves and "Mental Case" by Wilfred Owen

3521 words - 14 pages Although the poems Recalling War by Robert Graves and Mental Cases by Wilfred Owen are both concerned with the damage that war does to the soldiers involved, they are different in almost every other respect. Owen's poem examines the physical and mental effects of war in a very personal and direct way - his voice is very much in evidence in this poem - he has clearly seen people like the 'mental cases' who are described. It is also evident that

Compare Dulce et decorum est by Wilfred Owen, and Before Agincourt

1408 words - 6 pages powerful poem about a man dying from a gas attack during the First World War, whereas Shakespeare writes a rhetoric poem about the honour and pride found in battle. ¡Dulce et decorum est¡, and ¡Before Agincourt¡ are two poems so incredibly far away, in meaning, from each other, that it is very difficult to compare them. The one big difference is their attitude towards war. Wilfred Owen has actually been in a war. He saw what he wrote

Not So Hidden Agendas, Wilfred Owen and His Early Editors

1621 words - 6 pages Susan Owen (Wilfred's mother) and told her,I wrote to Captain Sassoon, to ask him if he couldhelp me about them. He came to see me; and told meit would have been your son's wish that (Sassoon)should see to the publication of the poems, becausethey were such friends. In the circumstances I could donothing but offer to hand them over to him (Sitwell:20).Then in a letter from late January 1920, Sitwell tellsSusan Owen that Sassoonhas suddenly gone off

War Poetry by Wilfred Owen and Other Poets

905 words - 4 pages ; the fake rhyme still creates rhythm. The two main components of a poem are the content, meaning the subject and emotion, and the technique which is things like structure, rhythm and imagery. The six war poems I chose have a very similar content because the topic is common to all of them. Large differences come in the technique, because this defines the way a poem is written, not what it is about. Owen’ s poems, ‘Anthem for Doomed Youth’ ‘The

Wilfred Owen: Not Your Typical War Poet

2287 words - 9 pages . Owen had different views on war, which is why he started to create poems to express his feelings and speak out to what he believed in. Since Owen was not a typical war soldier all his poems relate to how he is against war and how some actions in war are simply inhumane. Due to the fact he protests against war and inhumane acts, Owen received a saintly reputation as if he was a kind man and he could do no harm to civilization; however Owen is also

Similar Essays

Rupert Brooke And Wilfred Owen Essay

1141 words - 5 pages followed by "doom", it takes away the glee and puts a feeling of misery, implying an inevitable death, in replacement. "Youth" also used in the title adds to the horror, as these are men with their whole lives in front of them. Full of solemn comparisons, it is a poem about the traditional funeral being substituted by the one that war has created. Owen writes" What passing-bells for these who die as cattle?" This is an effective simile

“How Does Wilfred Owen Present The Horror And Pity Of War In The ‘Anthem For Doomed Youth’ And ‘Disabled’?”

1289 words - 6 pages Owen presents the horror and pity of war by his use of visual and auditory images. They help to heighten the sense of brutality and graphically describe the fear that soldiers felt. His poems are strongly influenced by that fact that he served in the armed forces and personally witnessed some of the situations expressed in his poems. Throughout the poem Wilfred Owen uses visual descriptions to create sympathy and pity towards those both

Poetry Analysis: "Disabled" By Wilfred Owen And "I Was Only Nineteen" By Redgum

776 words - 3 pages Poetry Analysis: "Disabled" by Wilfred Owen & "I Was Only Nineteen" by Redgum Great poets are able to draw intense and unforgettable images in your mind, using only words that are carefully chosen for the particular purpose. They are able to create the mood and build it up throughout the poem. You are led into the lives of others and you feel what they are feeling, and experience the same things as they are. The surroundings will have risen

A Comparison Of "The Charge Of The Light Brigade" By Alfred Tennyson And "Disabled" By Wilfred Owen

819 words - 3 pages The Crimean war in the 1850s and the Great War in the early 1900s have both been an inspiration for great prose and poetry. Two such examples are "The Charge of the Light Brigade" by Alfred Tennyson inspired by the famous attack of the 1854, and "Disabled" by Wilfred Owen written following the Great War. They both portray a vivid image of war, but the poets give the impression of having completely opposing views on the subject.The Charge of the