This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Will Grade Approach Facilitate Decision Making In Insufficient Evidence?

1203 words - 5 pages

Evidence based medicine underscores the importance of evidence in health care decision making, but what strategies health care professionals should take when there is insufficient evidence to guide the practice is still unknown. This project aimed to answer this question by summarizing the current strategies, policies as well as investigate the viewpoints of guideline developers and test the influence of different strategies.
The aspects leading to insufficient evidence summarized from guideline manuals were also addressed in GRADE downgrading criteria for quality of evidence.[69] Other aspects related to insufficient evidence considered the appropriate format of evidence, stating without randomized controlled trial, the evidence was insufficient.[19] Nevertheless, different types of evidence were also factors to consider in the GRADE approach. These facts supported what GRADE working group had claimed that with GRADE approach “guideline panels may choose to rate the quality of evidence as low or very low”.[14]
This study noticed there were variations in the description and definition of insufficient evidence, which might produce a misunderstanding in communication among different guideline groups.
In addtion, there is neither agreement on clear cut-off point or shresholdthreshold for insufficiency to determine which the minimum requirement was for being insufficient, nor agreement on whether the importance or weight of different criterion was the same.[16,18-21,23,25,26,28,33,34] Determining evidence is insufficient or not cannot be made without judgment. Thus, transparent and structured framework for assessing the quality of evidence could be helpful. The reasons or basis to be insufficient should always be made clear in the guideline development process.
There were variations also variation in strategies to cope with insufficient evidence. Guideline developers might restrict their recommendations: no recommendation at all, or recommendation against use, or recommendation for use in a restricted condition, or recommend further studies on this research question. They could also gathering more information, including studies or other factors to facilitate the decision making process. USPSTF was the only guideline group which provides a specific framework for insufficient evidence, and they suggested 4 domains to consider in guideline development process, which could provide more background information in facilitating decision making.[13] However, similar but unstructured considerations of these factors in decision making process were also proposed by many guideline groups. [15,25] Variations among strategies could possibly lead to different inteprations, inconsistent or even opposite recommendations for the same evidence. Agreement on the definition or strategies is expected to be necessary and helpful in reducing inconsistency and misunderstanding.
Phase I and Phase II studies both studied definition of insufficient evidence. In...

Find Another Essay On Will GRADE Approach Facilitate Decision Making in Insufficient Evidence?

The Real Options approach to investment decision making

1604 words - 6 pages flexibility or the traditional method that usually judges projects over the cash flows they will produce? In reality neither of the two is superior all the time and can be applied in all cases. In an industry where there is lot of uncertainty about the future quite commonly financial managers tend to use the Real Options method, and in a stabilised industry the NPV approach comes in to play. As noted in section 3.1, Real options can be of great value

Vulnerability of evapotranspiration to urbanisation: a multi-criteria decision-making and artificial neural network approach

1450 words - 6 pages in urbanisation. Taking this finding one step further, we were interested in establishing the most important parameter influenced by urbanisationthat also causes the greatest rate of change in PET. A multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM)and artificial neural network (ANN) approach was used to achieve this aim. After first introducing MCDM and ANNs in more detail in section 2, as well as the specific methodology of the study,the results and discussion are presented in section 3.Finally, theconclusionof the study is given in section 4.

Decision Making in Action

900 words - 4 pages with creative solutions, they will feel empowered to contribute and facilitate change in the workplace.ReferenceThe Manage Mentor (n.d.) The Decision Making Process. Retrieved April 14, 2004 from the World Wide Web at:'s Collegiate Dictionary Online (n.d). Decision. Retrieved April 14, 2004 from the World Wide Web at:

Strategies in Decision Making

1372 words - 5 pages degree. More intricate problems will require complexed decisions and trivial problems will require minimal thought processes to determine the decision. Nevertheless, the person encountering the problem and making the decision will go to through various degree of complexity in the PDCA cycle depending upon the nature of the problem.Having the ability to think critically and make rational decisions is the key to successful problem solving and

Decision Making in Nursing

945 words - 4 pages states that RN assessment of patient care needs must be completed before any delegation takes place”, she would have noticed the pressure ulcer and address it. (“Decision-Making Model Algorithm”, 1999) This example clearly shows that one seemingly small decision on nurse’s behalf might in a long run bring harmful consequences and put the patient at risk of infection and other complications. As nurses, we will witness good and bad decision

Emotions in decision-making

579 words - 2 pages follow in the steps of their leaders.The emotions in decision making that was learned from this movie is that emotions are a very powerful to deal with in situations. Emotions are a mental state that arises spontaneously rather than through conscious effort and is often accompanies by physiological changes. It is also a state of mental agitation or disturbance. It is the part of the conscious that involves feeling.The employees of Enron emotions

Decision Support Systems in Organizational Decision Making

880 words - 4 pages Systems Decision Support Systems (DSS) help with time management. All groups of DSS enhance reduced time circle involved in the decision making process. At, DSS enhance the productivity of employees and facilitate timely acquisition of information that is necessary for the decision making process. DSS facilitate enhanced interpersonal communication among those responsible for decision making. Communication-Driven Decision Support

Decision Making in Thailand Culture

1333 words - 5 pages on some occasions about the domineering nature of the strategic and tactical decision-making in family-owned or controlled enterprises. Thus, teamwork will be seemed not an easy event to be accomplished due to the patronage and hierarchical system with the Thai organizations.In the late 1980s and early 1990s, such approach to the management was not as challenging due to the fact the Thailand was able to enjoy the large amount of foreign

Bad Decision-Making in Hamlet

789 words - 3 pages Polonius. Then, Laertes should have identified his alternatives of the decision. Laertes did not explore alternative in the play. He immediately met with the king and decided to kill Prince Hamlet without looking at different ways to approach the situation. After exploring alternatives, Laertes should have weighed the evidence of the situation. The only evidence that Laertes had was the king’s word that Hamlet killed his father. Laertes should

Conscience In Ethical Decision Making

1435 words - 6 pages environmental factors such as upbringing and childhood experience have an impact upon an individual's perception of what is regarded as right and wrong, in terms of ethical decision-making, Aquinas' perception of morality would justify and provide reasonable evidence to conclude that conscience alone is a viable moral authority, as it combines both innate sense and an individual's conscious thought in the process of decision making. This perception

Conscience In Ethical Decision Making

1410 words - 6 pages ' perception of morality would justify and provide reasonable evidence to conclude that conscience alone is a viable moral authority, as it combines both innate sense and an individual's conscious thought in the process of decision making. This perception of our conscience discriminating good from evil or right from wrong is shared amongst religious viewpoints such as Islam, where scripture derived from the Qur'an shares similar views.According to

Similar Essays

Will Grade Approach Facilitate Decision Making In Insufficient Evidence?

2139 words - 9 pages Phase II Study. Systematic review on Insufficient Evidence Research Question Compared with non-GRADE approach (USPSTF approach), is the use of the GRADE Evidence to Recommendation approach to make recommendation in insufficient evidence scenarios more effective in facilitating the process of decision making for guideline developers? Methods Participants Guideline developers would be considered eligible participants. Guideline developers were

Effective Leadership, Ethics In Decision Making, And The Systems Approach

1138 words - 5 pages one built on the systems approach. Conclusion An organization should consider their ethics and their leaders when they are deciding upon their future of the organization. The effectiveness of the leader and organization will depend upon the approach taken to ensure the organization’s environment is open to learning and being successful. Works Cited Chmielewski, C. (2013). Values and culture in ethical decision making. Retrieved from

Feminist Approach To Moral Decision Making

1475 words - 6 pages difference between a justice and care approach to moral decision making. One series is based on Aesop's Fables. In it, a group of moles has worked on a comfortable burrow for the whole summer. When winter's cold begins to creep in, a porcupine begs to join them for the winter. If they let the porcupine in, they will be less comfortable, have less room to move around, and the sharp porcupine quills will poke them. In the first scenario, the

Evidence Is Always The Primary Basis For Making A Decision

3006 words - 12 pages ' reviews or other owners' opinions and evaluate the different sources to reach a decision.So far, we have looked at elementary, linear 'tame' problems, but the same framework, as we will discover, has been applied successfully to many different industries that are more 'wicked' in nature.In order to see whether evidence is the primary basis of making a decision within a more 'wicked' context, we must first explain how this model is used when adding a