William Of Ockham's Involvement In The Controversy In The Franciscan Order

1945 words - 8 pages

This paper briefly outlines William of Ockham’s life and taking a historical approach, special focus will be on his involvement in the controversy in the Franciscan Order. This will involve the background and circumstances at the time he thrived, the gist of the matter at hand, how he handles the issue, Outcome and consequences. General Observations will be outlined leading to the conclusion.
William of Ockham was born at around 1287 in the village of Ockham in Surrey, East London in England. At a tender age of around 9 or 13 years Ockham was given to the Franciscan Order. William studied and later taught at the Oxford University. He was later controversially denounced by Pope John XXII for dangerous teachings as served a House detention in 1324 to 1328. William sided with the Franciscan General against the Pope. In 1328, he fled to Munich and was excommunicated. He died at around 1347 in Munich at Holy Roman Empire. As a Western Philosopher, he belonged to the Medieval Philosophy in the school of Scholasticism. William of Ockham’s notable ideas are Ockham’s Razor, Nominalism (Spade; Kaye).
It is noteworthy that William of Ockham was the most important schoolman after Thomas Aquinas. He was Duns Scotus’ student at both Oxford University and at Paris. Scotism and Scotus’ writings in general heavily influenced William but he later rivalled Scotism which was a realist approach by rejecting realism. He did this by being the greatest exponent of the Nominalist school, the leading rival of the Thomist and Schotist schools. As an English Philosopher and Scholastic Theologian, William’s intellectual life is replete with confident redefinition of existing philosophical concepts. William of Ockham is considered one of the most prominent figures in the history of philosophy during the High Middle Ages/ Late Medieval Period together with Thomas Aquinas and John Duns Scotus. Ockham is usually considered in the patter of declining Scholasticism (Russell; McInery; Shand 67-8).
Among the things that greatly influenced Ockham is the keen Franciscan – Dominican rivalry that existed in the medieval times between the two orders. The Franciscans were less impeccably orthodox than Dominicans consequently the Franciscans were not inclined to accept the authority of Thomas Aquinas (Russell 463). For example on the incarnation, Scotism or the Franciscan thesis believes that Christ would have been made incarnate even if Adam had not sinned. Thomists (Some), on the other hand, believe that there would have been no need for Christ to have become incarnate if Adam did not sin. Scotism is Augustinian; differences from Thomism came of a larger admixture of Platonism (via Augustine) in their philosophy (Russell 466).
Shifting focus, how did William of Ockham end up getting involved in the Franciscan controversy? Ockham rose to prominence and quickly replaced Lutterell as Chancellor of Oxford University. Lutterell, a keen Thomist, set off to Avignon to blot Ockham’s name to...

Find Another Essay On William of Ockham's Involvement in The Controversy in the Franciscan Order

The Involvement of Computers in Future Jobs.

1219 words - 5 pages who don't know much about computers,you will be lost in the future. You should learn what you can while youstill have the chance, because things will develop to quickly for you andyou will not be able to cope with new technological events. Computerconsulting is a job, I have chosen long before the advances of technology.And now it has paid off. I now have a business of my own, working as acomputer consultant. I assist others in learning about

Essay on Order and Superstition in the Tragedies of William Shakespeare

1644 words - 7 pages Order and Superstition in the Tragedies of Shakespeare     The concept of order was an extremely important one to William Shakespeare, and to Elizabethans in general. We in the existentialist atomic age have little trouble conceiving of an individual man or woman as the only beacon of light in a world gone irrevocably and irredeemably mad, but this would be inconceivable to Shakespeare and his audience. Shakespeare staunchly followed the

No Regrets: An Examination of Static Morality and the Disruption of Normal Order in the History Plays of William Shakespeare

2368 words - 9 pages In a scholarly journal article authored by Robert Y. Turner the writer notes that "the major figures in [William Shakespeare's] Henry VI undergo no moral change of character" (241). In the series of plays these major figures, all of whom are nobilities, serve as archetypal representatives of the disorder that disrupts the normal order of the noble society. In his article Turner refers to a host of characters possessing stagnant moralities and

Controversy in the Louisiana Purchase

1083 words - 4 pages eventually congress did approve the purchase.The other controversy with the Louisiana purchase occurred in Jefferson’s head. He had to compromise many of his personal beliefs in order to buy the land. Since the American Revolution, Jefferson knew our debt must be eliminated, and he knew it must not be in the hands of foreigners. How could he justify being indebted another $15 mil to France? This issue brought up several problems. One problem is

The Increased Involvement of the End User in Innovation Process

1877 words - 8 pages User According to the innovation based research, has been found to play a significant role in determining the success of new product research (O'heocha and Conboy, 2010). Users and consumers have been believed to play an overriding role in innovation process across wide range of industries. Literature has highlighted the varying role of user involvement related to different sectors. Slow moving sectors involve a great user involvement contrary

"Explain the nature of Australia's involvement in the Vietnam War"

714 words - 3 pages Australia's played a small but vital role in the Vietnam War to counter-act the domino theory of the 1950's and 60's. Australia's involvement led to the establishment of a strong inter-continental relationship with the United States of America, which can be seen today with the involvement in conflicts with Iraq and terrorism. Australia's involvement created political turmoil within the Australian Government but in the final decision to assist

The Involvement of Great Britain in the Colonies

930 words - 4 pages and their European state. At the beginning of the French and Indian war, from its start in 1754 to about 1758, France savored numerous victories over the British, who could simply not find the correct tactic to win. However, when William Pitt, who had been directing the war effort against the French, came into the realization that discord between colonists and their commanders was caused by their belief that they were harboring all the financial

The Involvement of Unfree Labor in the Coffee Trade

635 words - 3 pages In the 18th century, Europe's coffee demands were met by plantations in the Caribbean. Plantations were large farms run usually by one rich family on which worked many slaves that cultivated the land and provided all of the labor. As the native population of the Americas were greatly reduced by disease, Europeans imported slaves from Africa to work on the plantations. Taken against their will by slave ships across the Atlantic, they were bought

The Influence and Controversy of Comics in the 20th Century

627 words - 3 pages main mutant character in the series, was the world's first black superhero. The theme of diversity can be seen throughout the history of X-Men comics. Shadowcat was the first obviously Jewish character, Nightcrawler was a German who was a devout Catholic and there were also Presbytarian, Native American, Baptist and Greco - Roman characters.During the 1970s there was a lot of controversy surrounding homosexuality and gay rights. The writers of X

Parental Involvement in Early Education: A Review of the Literature

2282 words - 10 pages volunteers, encouraging involvement in at-home activities, including parents on important school decisions, and coordinating with business agencies to provide resources all as helpful ways school can engage parents in the educational process. In a study conducted by William H. Jeynes of California State University Long Beach, it was found that parental involvement in school was significantly connected to greater academic achievement. The primary

Consumer Behaviour in the purchase of High and Low involvement

3401 words - 14 pages IntroductionConsumer behaviour is defined as the behaviour that consumers display in seeking, purchasing, using, evaluating and disposing of products and services that they expect will satisfy their personal needs. Consumer behaviour includes how consumers think (their mental decisions) and feel, and the physical actions that result from these decisions (the purchase). [7]Abraham Maslow's "hierarchy of needs" theory identifies the higher-order

Similar Essays

The Controversy Of William Shakespeare Essay

2274 words - 9 pages of immense mystery. There are many blanks left unfilled about his life due to lost records. William Shakespeare was born in Stratford-upon-Avon, Warwickshire. His most widely accepted date of birth is on April 23, 1564. However his actual date of birth still remains a mystery. A record from the parish register of Holy Trinity Church in his hometown was found, which states that he was baptized on April 26, 1564. Based on this record, and

The Light In Controversy Essay

595 words - 3 pages acceptable. Then Stravinsky’s ballet and music started riots because it discarded tradition western style and instead use ancient rituals. They may have started controversy but through there similarities in their works they made a vital impact on the 20th century. Both “Rite of Spring” and “Les Demoiselles d’Avignon” expressed the abandonment of conventional artistic standards. “Rite of spring” started buzz because it wasn’t the usual ballet and

The Involvement Of War In British Literature

1217 words - 5 pages you may perhaps see anguish and defeat or maybe perhaps triumph in victory. No matter what war takes a part of you and you end up losing something in some way. Putting it that way no one truly wins in a war. The British authors, George Orwell, William Shakespeare, and John Milton involved war in their novels and showed the result in different ways with the good winning, the bad winning, and a never ending battle. Works Cited English Standard

Impact Of The U.S. Involvement In

778 words - 3 pages IMPACT OF THE U.S. INVOLVEMENT IN WORLD WAR I World War I, a military conflict, began as a local European war between Austria- Hungary and Serbia in 1914. It was transformed into a general European struggle by declaration of war against Russia, and eventually became a global war involving 32 nations. Twenty-eight of these nations, known as the Allies and the Associated Powers, and including Great Britain, France, Russia, Italy, and the