William Shakespeare's Measure For Measure Essay

1343 words - 5 pages

William Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

The desires of the characters in Shakespeare’s Measure For Measure are not entirely clear, and are made ambivalent and ambiguous by the use of their language. Particularly in 3.1.52-153, when Isabella visits Claudio in prison, ambiguous lines and puns make it unclear whether Isabella desires Claudio’s death and whether he truly desires to be free of sin. These desires were further convoluted by viewing the current Folger Theatre production of the play.

"Trade" (151) is one pun which illuminates ideas about Claudio's desires. Taken to mean an exchange, Isabella insinuates that Claudio's sin and death are like the title of the play, a measure taken for a measure, or rather a punishment that fits the crime. However, Freud's notion of the compulsion to repeat is evoked when the word is taken to mean a habit. Isabella insinuates Claudio's perpetual sinning earlier when she comments that Claudio's freedom would "offend [Angelo] still" (99) by continuing his behavior. The concept of the death drive as a desire to return to the womb also emerges when Isabella warns Claudio that accepting Angelo's offer "Would bark your honour from that trunk you bear / And leave you naked" (70-71), the image of debarking a tree becoming a form of regression.

Claudio's response that he would "encounter darkness as a bride / And hug it in [his] arms" (82-3) is wholly ambivalent and ambiguous. It could be a straightforward admission to his desire for death, also showing that he readily accepts his punishment. Additionally falling under Freud's philosophy, it could instead be an admission of his compulsion to repeat: he would make love to death as his bride, just as he did to Juliet.

Isabella accepts Claudio's statement as a readiness for death. However, another possible interpretation offers the opposite: that Claudio admits his desire to do evil deeds, if darkness is taken to mean evil rather than death. If Claudio is willing to be wed to evil, then he would have no qualms about his sister doing the same, or at the very least fornicating with Angelo for his “devilish mercy” (63). This possibility is bolstered by Claudio’s shift in tone and possible lack of concern for his sister’s soul when he begs “Sweet sister, let me live” (134), and attempts to justify the consequences by appealing to her good nature, calling her sin a potential virtue.

However, this desire to live also stems from a desire for certainty, which he fears he cannot have in death, expressed in lines 118-132. Much like the ambivalence and ambiguity of other lines in this scene, this passage expresses several simultaneous possibilities for the afterlife. In a somewhat Ovidian fashion, the “sensible warm motion” morphs paradoxically into places with both “fiery floods” and “thick-ribbed ice.” Comparing the uncertainty of death to known suffering in life reaffirms Claudio’s desire to live.


Find Another Essay On William Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

Isabella as an Independent Female in Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

1296 words - 5 pages are the ways in which a twenty-first century woman is perceived. In the time period Shakespeare was writing in the abilities and roles expected of women were very different. For women in Shakespeare's Measure for Measure, there are extremely limited roles women can fulfill and all of them centre around sexuality and serving men sexually. A woman is either chaste or unchaste, a wife or a whore, and there is very little differentiating the two. A

Shakespeare's Interpretation of Women in "Measure for Measure"

1339 words - 5 pages Shakespeare's interpretation of women in Measure for Measure very much reflects society's opinion of women at the time, which was that men have more freedom and should be given more respect that women. The society of the time was a patriarchal one, where a male God was the ultimate leader, and below him came the king, then the nobles. However, although the society gave men more rights than women, Measure for Measure demonstrates that they also

Politics, Power, and Purpose in Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

6699 words - 27 pages Politics, Power, and Purpose in Shakespeare's Measure for Measure In Shakespeare's Measure for Measure, Vincentio, Duke of Vienna, observing that his Dukedom has fallen into licentiousness and chaos through his neglectful government, has pretended to leave Vienna and has turned over the government to Angelo, his upright and up-tight Deputy; and that the Duke has resolved to remain in Vienna, in disguise, so that he may observe how Angelo's

The Last Act of Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare

2264 words - 9 pages The Last Act of Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare Works Cited Not Included Measure for Measure is one of Shakespeare's unclassifiable plays. It was written in 1603 and is one of his most enigmatic and unfathomable works. It is normally referred to as a problem play and, up until the 20th century it was

Explain how Shakespeare's portrayal of characters in Act1 of 'Measure for Measure' link with its genre of a problem play.

1433 words - 6 pages Explain how Shakespeare's portrayal of characters in Act1 link with its genre of a problem play.Measure for Measure does not fit neatly into any of the genres of most of Shakespeare's other plays. It contains elements from both genres of tragedy and comedy while having unique aspects that don't fit either. Therefore, it is given the genre of a problem play. I am going to look at the characters of the Duke, Angelo, Isabella, Lucio, and Claudio

measure for measure notes

2097 words - 8 pages end, he is unmasked for his hypocrisy and begs for forgiveness for his misdeeds. Because of the Duke's mercy, Angelo is spared from the total condemnation he deserves. CRITICAL APPRECIATION OF MEASURE FOR MEASURE Critics have diverse views regarding the value of the play. Some consider it very good, filled with wisdom; others consider it one of Shakespeare's weakest plays, filled with unexciting characters. It is important to remember that

Measure For Measure

1008 words - 4 pages Measure for Measure provides less freedom for woman than other Shakespearian plays given no control as an independent woman. The explanation of "Measure still for Measure" (IV.i.414) focuses on punishments and retributions as well as an obedience to transferred power. The Duke’s reign has shaped an atmosphere in Vienna fraught with indulgence and an overall disregard for the law. The Duke wishes to have more order in Vienna but is unsure how to

Exploring Morality in Measure for Measure

754 words - 3 pages decisions. Sources Cited and Consulted Knight, G. Wilson. Shakespeare and Morality. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1967. Leech, Clifford. "The 'Meaning' of Measure for Measure." Shakespeare Survey 3 (1950): 69-71. Shakespeare, William. Measure for Measure. The Arden Shakespeare. Ed. J.W. Lever. London: Routledge, 1995. Thomas, Vivian.  The Moral Universe of Shakespeare's Problem Plays.  London: Croom Helm, 1987.

Measure for Measure Essay: The Virtuous Isabella

1326 words - 5 pages found out of line when in opposition to another's ideals, but this does not lessen Isabella's virtuous character in the least.    Works Cited and Consulted: Knight, G. Wilson. The Wheel of Fire: Essays in Interpretation of Shakespeare's Sombre Tragedies. London: Oxford UP, 1930. Leech, Clifford. "The 'Meaning' of Measure for Measure." Shakespeare Survey 3 1950 Rossiter, A. P. Angel with Horns and Other Shakespeare Lectures

Measure for Measure Essay: The Bed Trick

1926 words - 8 pages The Bed Trick in Measure for Measure        Critics have referred to the concept of Mariana taking Isabella's place in Angelo's bed "the bed trick."  This plan of the Duke's, which is supposed to save Isabella, Claudio, and Mariana, appears to be almost corrupt and shameful, and is one of the reasons scholars consider Measure for Measure a problem play.  What exactly is going on here with all of these characters?  It seems almost

Measure for Measure Essay: The Virtuous Vanity of Isabella

1529 words - 6 pages The Virtuous Vanity of Isabella in Measure for Measure        Shakespeare's work, Measure for Measure, puts the "problem" in "problem play" as it, examines the difference between law and justice, virtue and goodness. It's a case study of abuse of power that has a particularly contemporary resonance.  Isabella is a very intriguing Shakespearean female. She is one of the few intelligent females who are also innocent and holy. Measure for

Similar Essays

Shakespeare's Measure For Measure Essay

1994 words - 8 pages Shakespeare's Measure for Measure Game-playing in Shakespeare's Measure for Measure Thieves for their robbery have authority When judges steal themselves Critics have often seen Vincentio, the Duke in Shakespeare's play Measure for Measure, as performing a function similar to that of Prospero in The Tempest. The reasons for such an assumption is clear in the very first scene of the play, as both characters set the plot into motion by

Shakespeare's "Measure For Measure" The Female Characters

6679 words - 27 pages Introduction and problem definitionIn this essay I would like to state thoughts and answer questions concerning the play “Measure for Measure” by William Shakespeare.This play is called a problem play and this is why I would like to solve one of its problems regarding the female characters. After reading various interpretations of the historical play I thought it would be interesting to evaluate in which way the main females have an

Measure For Measure By William Shakespeare

2503 words - 10 pages Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare The opening scenes of the play are called the EXPOSITION, where the dramatist introduces the most significant characters and themes, so that they can be developed and set up the plot. Describe the means by which Shakespeare had done this in the first act, and judge how successful (or not) he has been. The opening scenes of "Measure for Measure", introduce the most

The Character Elbow In Shakespeare's Play, Measure For Measure

1597 words - 6 pages The Character Elbow in Shakespeare's Play, Measure for Measure In Act 2, scene 1 of the play Measure for Measure the character Elbow, a representation of the "Comedic Constable" often depicted in William Shakespeare's comedies and traji-comedies, gives the director an unusual creative license in portraying this figure to give the audience a rich theatrical experience. (Evans 427) These characters are most commonly depicted as "artless