This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Winning Hearts Essay

1082 words - 5 pages

The obvious use of plagiarism in college students’ assignments has become a major problem in today’s education system. Due to this, instructors are trying to find ways to teach their students about the ethics involved in writing so that they will stop plagiarizing. However, in order to do this, instructors must first understand how students view plagiarism and understand the best ways to put an end to student plagiarism. In “Winning Hearts and Minds in War on Plagiarism,” Scott Jaschik effectively persuades his audience of college level English instructors to prevent students from plagiarizing by using rhetorical choices such as irony, an appeal to authority, and jargon.
One rhetorical choice that Jaschik uses in order to enhance his purpose by shining a light into the minds of students is irony. Jaschik begins the article with a story about English instructor Kate Hagopian giving her students an assignment that they were required to turn in one version that was plagiarized and one version that was not plagiarized. Jaschik goes on to reveal, “Given the right to do so, they turn in essays with many direct quotes without attribution. Of course in their essays that are supposed to be done without plagiarism, she still finds problems -- not so much with passages repeated verbatim, but with paraphrasing or using syntax in ways that were so similar to the original that they required attribution” (Jaschik 262). The reason Jaschik uses this ironic story as the introduction to his article is because it directly relates to the purpose of the entire article. The story specifically shows the audience of instructors that students sometimes plagiarize without actually intending to. This connects to the purpose of the article because it effectively enlightens college level English instructors about how their students interpret plagiarism. Jaschik gives this knowledge to the instructors so that they will be persuaded to find ways to stop their students from plagiarizing, which is Jaschik’s ultimate goal.
In order to seem credible to his audience, Jaschik uses the rhetorical choice of appeal to authority. One reason this type of rhetorical choice is used is due to the numerous accounts of English instructors that often experience plagiarism firsthand. These college level instructors often have strong opinions about students plagiarizing. One example of this is when Jaschik explains, “R. Gerald Nelms, an associate professor of composition and rhetoric at Southern Illinois University at Carbondale, spoke of how plagiarism must be seen as ‘an educational problem that requires an educational response’” (Jaschik 264). By Jaschik referencing R. Gerald Nelms, he gives his audience an opinion that they can easily relate to and makes them realize he understands the problems they encounter with plagiarism. This ultimately makes his audience more interested in the article and therefore, are more likely to be persuaded by Jaschik. Another example of appeal to authority...

Find Another Essay On Winning Hearts

The Three Types of Athletes Essay

939 words - 4 pages the game (if they weren't, then they were doing something wrong). These all-or-nothing players constantly appear determined, give one-hundred ten percent to the game, and play their hearts out. They are all volunteers, there was no hesitation in their choice to play. They step up when others are lacking and their emotions are tied to the same fate as the outcome of the game. The phrase, "Winning isn't everything" is rebutted with "It's just

Film Review - "Wag the dog."

540 words - 2 pages nothing to do with the deployment of the B-3 bomber," helping setting the stage for war letting people believe it has everything to do with the B-3 bomber. During this phony campaign, the Hollywood producer (Dustin Hoffman) had the president win the hearts of the people by paying attention to an Albanian girl and giving his coat to the mother. This is to help the president win votes for the up and coming presidential election. Another scheme to

Rhetorical Analysis

1239 words - 5 pages The obvious use of plagiarism in college students’ assignments has become a major problem in today’s education system. In response to this issue, Scott Jaschik wrote “Winning Hearts and Minds in War on Plagiarism” to persuade college writing instructors to try new ways to teach their students about plagiarism, urging professors to consider teaching the ethics involved in writing as a way to stop plagiarism. However, in order to do this

Graduation Speech: Listen Carefully

571 words - 2 pages Listen carefully, Class of '2012, for the sounds you hear tonight will last a lifetime. Store them up and save them in your hearts, for they are priceless. Each whisper, each tick of the clock is a reminder of something you've gained here. Pay attention, so when you hear them later in life you will remember. When you hear a bell ring, remember our first day of school, back in September of 2008. The coolness of the desks chilled our sun-tanned

Slumdog Millionaire: India's Social Classes and Love of Money

820 words - 3 pages life in the Mumbai slums. As the riots between the Hindi and the Muslims break out, police neglect to respond to a man aflame before their eyes. The policemen’s inaction within a crisis sears the hearts of the viewers with the discrimination of India’s social structure. Additionally, the police officers commit heinous offences toward the hero, Jamal, when questioning him. They torture him various ways, such as electric currents, waterboarding

Play Fairly, an Essay about the harsh terms imposed Germany in the Treaty of Versailles

698 words - 3 pages hearts." Their land was shred apart, along with their hearts. They were left defenseless and penniless, with their money eventually being worth nothing. Their one hope of having an acceptable life after the war was their government, which was thrown out because of the power that later brought them down again. The terms of the Treaty of Versailles led to the downfall of Germany, twice, unfairly so. Oscar Wilde said "One should always play fairly when one has the winning cards," and in no way was the Treaty of Versailles fair.

War in Afghanistan

1047 words - 5 pages though has problems in the country and has been having these problems since the invasion. Training Afghan forces and fighting the Taliban has not been working and is not efficient. We are trying to win the hearts and minds of the people but when the Taliban are blowing up schools and hospitals, winning those hearts and minds is a challenge. “Americans are used to be successful and these wars are not” announces Mark Lytle (Hampson). Americans are

An Essay About Sandra Schmirler

794 words - 3 pages great. When we think of Sandra Marie Schmirler, we are impressed not only with what she did in her pursuit of athletic excellence and how she defined herself as a winner, but what she contributed to others beyond just winning world championships and gold medals. Sandra Schmirler helped us understand that life is precious and we must appreciate it every day because it can be taken away in an instant. While Sandra only lived to the age of 36, she


704 words - 3 pages I've been a swim coach for five years now. My coaching strategy for this sport differs greatly then it would for a team-oriented sport like basketball or football. Few meets are swum against other teams, but are rather large competitions of at least a half of dozen teams. The old saying goes, "Its not whether you win or lose, but how you play the game" is not farther from the truth in so many sports. Winning is everything. If you lose, you

Beauty Isn't Pretty

957 words - 4 pages , depression is hard to seek because their whole life revolves around their parents’ dream of winning a beauty pageants and children aren’t necessarily focused on their wants and desires thus making change in behavior thought to identify. Cited from Villiers, “Crash dieting… teaches children unhealthy approaches to food” is an unhealthy habit that can affect the child in the long. Crash dieting is designed for children to gain energy and enthusiasm by

Explain why the Americans withdraw its forces from Vietnam in 1973?

1475 words - 6 pages Explain why the Americans withdraw its forces from Vietnam in 1973?The USA, with Nixon as there president at the time, withdraw from the war in Vietnam in 1973 even with them having the highly developed weapons at their disposal. There were many reasons in the hidden weakness of the Americans and in the surprising strengths of their opponents. Guerrilla warfare and the failure to win the "Hearts and Minds" of the people in the US and in South

Similar Essays

Winning Hearts Essay

683 words - 3 pages The original article “Winning Hearts and Minds in War on Plagiarism” by Scott Jaschik was published in an online news section on a website called “Inside Higher Ed.” Although this website may be accessed by the general public, it is mostly used by well-educated college professors. Therefore, the intended audience of this article is college level instructors. Due to Jaschik explaining the views of plagiarism from the perspective of students as

Critical Analysis:" Winning Hearts And Minds In War On Plagiarism"

821 words - 4 pages "Winning Hearts and Minds in War on Plagiarism" written by Scott Jaschik opens with the this statement, "It's come down to this: Writing professors are so desperate for new ways to teach undergraduates about academic integrity that they are assigning them to plagiarize "(Jaschik 92). Jaschik's essay begins with the experience of first year writing professor Kate Hagopian. In hopes of teaching the students a lesson which would have lasting

A Breif Description Of Hitler And Hitler's National Socialism

509 words - 2 pages World War II brings many names to mind; Eisenhower, Patton, Churchill, Stalin- but still, above them all, remains Adolf Hitler. He came from nothing and managed to become dictator of Germany. He turned a fragile democracy into a thriving dictation. He simplified hate, and made it easier than ever before. His obsession with the "Jewish Question," led to the death of 6 million people. A defeated, humiliated country turned its eyes and hearts to

Manchester United Dramatic Win: Champions League And The English Premier League

886 words - 4 pages Manchester United won the impossible dream by winning the English Premier League, the FA Cup and the Champions League in the same season. This was a dramatic win. This incredible victory was a combination of skill along with the great leadership and inspiration from the manager, Sir Alex Ferguson and the support from the fans. It was epitomised by the “never say die” attitude instilled in the team. In winning the Champions League, which is