Wishful Thinking Essay

921 words - 4 pages

The contrast between the characters of the Magistrate who is the protagonist in the novel, Waiting for the Barbarians, and Colonel Joll who is the antagonist is a perfect example of an antithesis based on their personality and moral outlook. The conflicting attributes of the characters form the basic elements of the antithesis. Throughout the novel, the Magistrate is portrayed as a truth-seeking person whereas Colonel Joll is described as a perpetrator of violence and injustice. In the sentence, “I was the lie that Empire tells itself when times are easy, he the truth that Empire tells when harsh winds blow.” J.M Coetzee tries to introduce an antithesis to the readers by contrasting the roles of the two characters. This sentence also indicates the Empire’s hypocrisy and duplicity. In the passage, the Magistrate comes to a conclusion that he is actually similar to Colonel Joll in a way that they both are part of the Empire’s machinery. The Magistrate’s character is simply a mask that hides the ugly face of the Empire, which is represented by Colonel Joll’s image. Concisely, the Magistrate and Colonel Joll are the two sides of the same coin, as the Magistrate puts it, “Two sides of imperial rule, no more, no less.” The contrast between ‘lie’ and ‘truth’ in the second sentence of the passage is very significant because it is the fundamental element of the antithesis introduced by Coetzee. The sentence implies that the role of the Magistrate in the Empire is merely superficial and the image of Colonel Joll is the reality. In the same sentence, Coetzee uses the phrases “when times are easy” to describe a ‘peaceful time’, and “when harsh winds blow” to depict a ‘trying period’. This choice of words is effective because it gives an active meaning to the sentence and I believe that the sentence would sound dull and dry if Coetzee used ‘peaceful time’ and ‘trying period’ instead of “when times are easy” and “when harsh winds blow”.
The passage that I choose demonstrates the conflict between idealism and realism. The Magistrate hopes that eventually the problems that were created by the presence of The Third Bureau and the mysterious threat by the barbarians will go away. The Magistrate knows that the situation in the frontier is deteriorating since Colonel Joll came but he cannot confirm that it is going to get better. Coetzee uses the word ‘temporize’ in the passage to indicate the shift from pessimism to optimism. Coetzee manipulates the Magistrate’s defense mechanism to support his ‘wishful thinking’. The Magistrate believes that the little frontier is indeed ‘peaceful’ and cannot be ‘disturbed’ by the interference. He tries to convince himself that everything will be fine. At first, he notices...

Find Another Essay On Wishful Thinking

Phantoms in the Brain by V.S. Ramachadran

1290 words - 5 pages born without a limb or limbs. When people are born without the limb or limbs and have this syndrome it can be described as wishful thinking or by having a soul. Wishful thinking is where the person wishes that they have the syndrome but they actually do not even if they are showing the signs of having the syndrome. This sort of thinking can be shown in the case of John McGrath who was an arm amputee that had contacted Ramachandran about his phantom

Mysteries of the Human Mind Essay

1402 words - 6 pages happen the soul would have to be controlling the body, would be tangible, be able to make decisions on its own, and have perception. Seeing as we have not yet proven that there is a soul, then the patients are not being controlled by a soul and there is no such thing as a soul. The psychological theorists would say that the patients were in denial and having wishful thinking to complete the tasks. The patients would believe that they were able to

Mrs. Mallard in Story of an Hour

721 words - 3 pages not"(450). Mrs. Mallard is a self centered women who did not appreciate a husband's loving care. This is found in her selfish behavior after Mr. Mallard's death. Finally, the third element shows Mrs. Mallard to be a wishful thinker. She is a day dreamer. As she contemplates the loss of her husband, she begins to think about life without him "her fancy was running riot along those days ahead of her" (450). Already she is thinking about the

Critical Thinking Analysis Paper

905 words - 4 pages are making it impossible for a large percentage of the population to buy a home. This displays the mistakes that occur when critical thinking does gather all the facts before making a decision. Many of these mistakes are listed by the author'slack of relevant background information, conformism, wishful thinking, overpowering emotions, and resistance to change. When purchasing or selling a home, criticalthinking is an important part of the

"The Brooklyn Reader" Describe the uncomfortable collision of cultures between the chracters in "The Assistant."

525 words - 2 pages have everything you want, at least take something. Don't be so goddam proud." In addition, the writer shows how much Louis is against Helen's way of life when he asks her with aggravation: "So what'll you be then, a dried-up prune of an old maid? What's the percentage of that?" He exemplifies Helen's wishful thinking in her response: "I'll wait. I'll dream. Something will happen." Moreover, Malamud clarifies the distinct ambiguity of Helen's

Critical Thinking

1039 words - 4 pages Critical thinkers: distinguish between fact and opinion; ask questions; make detailed observations; uncover assumptions and define their terms; and make assertions based on sound logic and solid evidence. (Elis, 1997).Critical thinking helps people make better decisions and come up with better answers because of the process of critical thinking. Critical thinking goes beyond the normal thinking process and takes it several steps further

Confronting Reality

1235 words - 5 pages education. Generally, the more degrees after the name, the more likelihood that arrogance can set in - doctors, college professors, CPAs, engineers, and attorneys top the list. In our consulting experience, it has always been more difficult for them to accept new ways of looking at or thinking about new things.2. Wishful Thinking. It is a childish belief that "if I think it, it is so". This defective habit seems to be strongly supported by the self


670 words - 3 pages didn’t work. Keynes notion of the government’s monetary and fiscal policies is just wishful thinking in the mind of Wolff. I agree with him, when looking at the facts of the past and its numerous failures. I thought the idea of American exceptionalism was very interesting. Every generation would live better than the previous. I always thought it was a something that my parents were saying but its not. The progression of society has proven it

Risks vs Planning

604 words - 2 pages can avoid attempting an unreasonable feat, thus saving precious time and energy. It also gives an individual more options to fallback on in case one should fail. In a perfect world, if someone gives his best, he should succeed. However, we do not live in a perfect world so this kind of wishful thinking is impractical. Giving one’s all may not be enough for success, therefore one must plan on what to do in case he does not succeed. Even if one

Bias, Rhetorical Devices and Argumentation

650 words - 3 pages Kane says that he (Kane) has more than a hope and Gettys has less than a chance it seems to hold some type of innuendo.By speaking to "decent ordinary citizens", "the working man" "the slum child", "the under paid", and "the underfed" Kane spoke directly to each and every person in the audience. By making the assurance that their welfare was on his list of priorities he made way for plenty of wishful thinking. This same tactic could easily address

Sigmund Freud's function as a neuropathologist

584 words - 2 pages 'free association' with his patients and soon recognized the traumtic impact of early sexual experience during childhood, seducations on the part of adults, above all the parents.In 1877, suffering from his own neurotic crisis, Freud discovered in a brave self-analysis that patients' fantasies and wishful thinking rather than real experiences play an unconscious role in the onset of neuroses. Freud's findings broke new ground in often

Similar Essays

Criminal Profiling: Real Science Of Just Wishful Thinking

2451 words - 10 pages purpose of this paper is thus to analyze in detail, whether or not criminal profiling is beneficial or is it just real science of wishful thinking? How effective is Criminal Profiling in the Solving of Crimes? Many critics of criminal profiling presume that criminal profiles are usually too big to create the desired picture and that it takes a little more than common sense to successfully profile a criminal. If we are to acknowledge that

Source Monitoring: A Look At Errors

1898 words - 8 pages of source error. This is the “inadvertent plagiarism that occurs when people come up with an idea that they think is original, when they were actually exposed to it earlier” (Landau & Marsh, 1997). If a participant attributes non-original ideas to themselves, it could be because they believe that they were a source of good ideas, rather than someone else, which is wishful thinking. Information can be learned unconsciously but the area of the

Addictions: Vital Lies, Simple Truths Essay

1142 words - 5 pages themselves against "wishful thinking" they are unlikely to deceive themselves. Actually, if one believes that all one must be on guard against is wishful thinking, then one may be more rather than less liable to self-deception. For example, many intelligent people have invested in numerous fraudulent products that promised to save money, the environment, or the world, not because they were guilty of wishful thinking but because they were not

"How Public Opinion Really Works" Essay

968 words - 4 pages with ti came out everyday, but few knew about them.Stage 4 is "Wishful Thinking". The public doesn't want to face reality and the tradeoffs that are needed to solve any issue. Not feeling connected with the decision-making process affecting them; they erect the wishful thinking barrier. People are urgent about the health care, but not willing now to face the hard truths.Stage 5, called "Weighing the Choices", is where the public does come to grip