This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Witchcraft, Magic And Rationality Essay

2353 words - 9 pages

Witchcraft, Magic and Rationality

Social Anthropology seeks to gauge an understanding of cultures and practices whether they are foreign or native. This is achieved through the studying of language, education, customs, marriage, kinship, hierarchy and of course belief and value systems. Rationality is a key concept in this process as it affects the anthropologist’s interpretation of the studied group’s way of life: what s/he deems as rational or plausible practice. Witchcraft and magic pose problems for many anthropologists, as its supernatural nature is perhaps conflicting to the common Western notions of rationality, mainly deemed superior. In this essay I will be exploring the relationship between rationality and witchcraft and magic, and will further explore rationality as a factor of knowledge.

Rationality from the Latin ‘rationari’ meaning to ‘think’ or ‘calculate’ is a significant concept in Western philosophy born out of the Enlightenment. During the 17th and 18th centuries many philosophers began to emphasise the use of reason as the best method of learning objective truth. Pioneers in this field include Descartes and Locke.
This was also a time when science came to the forefront of Western thought, seen as the embodiment of rationality. It was believed that the ability to reason is the very thing that separates man from other animals. It is what makes us human, and therefore it is our job to utilise this benefit at all times. As rationality grew in importance its contrasts such as ignorance and superstition were seen to have no place in a rational Western society. Things that were unexplainable through rational means were invalid. These are terms that can and are applied to practices such as witchcraft and magic.

Witchcraft and magic are practices that call upon supernatural, unseen forces.
Witchcraft is the use of these forces for negative ends, to extort evil, and magic asks for positive ends. Witchcraft has been found to exist in all corners of the globe at some point. It is no coincidence that during the Enlightenment, witch hunts in Europe and North America became common. The aim was to rid society of these people regarded as unreasonable and dangerous. By contrast self-proclaimed witches still have a function in some societies today, mainly in the developing world. Magic however is often a word used to describe certain people’s modes of divination, mainly those in the developing world. It is my view though that magic and the institution of religion are not as different as it may first appear. The Yorubas chanting to the god Shango is no different to the congregation of a church singing hymns. Both are with good intentions, and both may ask for some divine intervention. Labelling one form magic and one religion is just semantics.

To question whether it is rational to believe in witchcraft and magic is in fact just a question as to whether the belief in supernatural intervention is rational. Is it...

Find Another Essay On Witchcraft, Magic and Rationality

What does Othello’s speech and say tells us about his character?

1580 words - 6 pages Claude Lam F. 4B (16)What does Othello's speech and say tells us about his character?Brabantio accuses Othello, a black general, that he has used witchcraft to seduce his daughter, Desdemona. Othello, who has used no magic to capture the young lady's heart, began denying all sorts of charges.Othello then tells the senators that he is not good with words. That he has no elegant diction which Venetian men often uses to phrase their sentences. We

Witchcraft in the Small Village of Salem

1551 words - 6 pages girls were Betty Paris and Abigail Williams, her cousin (Dolan 4). Betty was nine years old, and Abigail was eleven (Dolan 4). Both girls lived with Reverend Samuel Parris, Betty’s father, the village minister (Dolan 4). The people of Salem believed in witches and their witchcraft. A witch is a woman who professes or practices the use of magic. A witch was believed by witchcraft experts to leave his or her body at night and travel freely (Kent 26

A Theoretical and Historical Comparison Debate Paper on the Beliefs and Perceptions

2063 words - 9 pages -Pritchard described Azande witchcraft as being part of a social category that regulates the way people act, and tries to explain events of misfortune when they lack a reasonable explanation. In the article Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande, he states that "witchcraft is an important theme of mental life in which it forms the background of a vast panorama of oracle and magic" (Evans-Pritchard 18). This means that witchcraft is seen

The Truth behind Witchcraft and Wicca

1942 words - 8 pages . "Witchcraft is a way of life, a practice, a belief system and a religion (Spring)." Witchcraft is considered an earth religion, which means being in harmony with the Earth and with all life (Covenant). People of witchcraft can be referred to as a pagan (someone who practices Earth Religions). A Witch is someone who worships the Gods and Goddesses. Witches also practice magic and follow the spiritual path of Witchcraft (Covenant). Witchcraft is

Hocus Pocus Abracadabra - Is It All Just Words and Show?

945 words - 4 pages As a child the notion of magic was as simple as a magician sawing a woman in half, then piecing her back together, or the illusion of a human gravitating in mid air. Even as adults, we are still awed by such pastime entertainments of magic. On the contrary, Rebecca L. Stein and Philip L. Stein depict magic as a way of life similarly to elements of religion. In The Anthropology of Religion, Magic, and Witchcraft Stein and Stein illustrated magic

The Unfair Prosecution of Women: Witchcraft in Early Modern Europe

2270 words - 9 pages and rural policy for the University of Wagenigen, provides socio-economic and rural views of the prosecution of witches in early modern Europe. He explains the evolution of witchcraft belief that coincided with agricultural and societal development. Brian Levack takes an in-depth look at all aspects of witchcraft in his Articles on Witchcraft, Magic, and Demonology: a Twelve Volume Anthology of Scholarly Articles, from which I chose to examine

Hocus Pocus Abracadabra Is It All Just Words and Show

1278 words - 5 pages As a child the notion of magic was as simple as a magician sawing a woman in half, then piecing her back together, or the illusion of a human gravitating in mid air. Even as adults, we are still awed by such pastime entertainments of magic. On the contrary, Rebecca L. Stein and Philip L. Stein depict magic as a way of life similarly to elements of religion. In The Anthropology of Religion, Magic, and Witchcraft Stein and Stein illustrated magic

Hocus Pocus Abracadabra

1278 words - 5 pages As a child the notion of magic was as simple as a magician sawing a woman in half, then piecing her back together, or the illusion of a human gravitating in mid air. Even as adults, we are still awed by such pastime entertainments of magic. On the contrary, Rebecca L. Stein and Philip L. Stein depict magic as a way of life similarly to elements of religion. In The Anthropology of Religion, Magic, and Witchcraft Stein and Stein illustrated magic

Black Magic vs. White Magic in Shakespeare’s The Tempest

585 words - 2 pages mechanical or behavioral means to affect others, and witchcraft as an inherent personal quality to the same ends….Divination, the skill of understanding mystical agents that affect people and events, should be distinguished from magic in that its purpose is not to influence events but rather to understand them (Encyclopedia Britannica, 302). What is important to recognize with the analogy of a ‘Divine Prospero’ is to know that Prospero is not made

Salem Witch Trials

1632 words - 7 pages consorting with the devil. The witchcraft hysteria in Salem, Massachusetts resulted from the strict Puritan code which aroused the girls interest in superstition and magic and caused strange behavior. The Salem witch trials were based on the Puritans and their God versus Satan and his followers and their strict codes. Puritans had always thought that they were the new chosen people, abandoning a land of sin and oppression to establish

Did Science and Magic Become Incompatible in Early Modern Europe? If So Why?

1561 words - 6 pages leading men in the criticism of witchcraft beliefs who went into press during the late 17th century are John Webster and John Wagstaffe. John Webster's book "Displaying of supposed witchcraft" had the Royal Society's imprimatur and he maintained opinions such as praise for the Royal Society for helping to combat the 'gross and absurd opinion of the power of Witches'1. Both men, along with many others, did not believe that magic had any real basis

Similar Essays

Witchcraft, Oracles And Magic Among The Azande

1006 words - 4 pages Reflection Paper # 2Topic: Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande.Witchcraft, for the Azande is 'ubiquitous' (Evans-Pritchard, 18), it is ever present in all aspects of their life, from 'fishing' to their 'technology and language' (Evans-Pritchard, 18). Evans-Pritchard explores the affect witchcraft holds over the sub Saharan tribe of Zande. In the reading he comes up with two purposes that witchcraft hold in society. The first one being

Commentary On Witchcraft, Magic, And Religion In 17th Century By Richard Weisman

2180 words - 9 pages mind and gain control of them for wrongdoings. An individual can be blinded by evil and can be taken away from God to glorify the Devil. In the book Witchcraft, Magic, and Religion in 17th-Century Massachusetts by Richard Weisman, the writer focuses on the origins of witchcraft in the village Salem in the 17th century. Weisman’s goal is to portray the people accused during the Salem trials as ordinary human beings and not witches; therefore

Religion Vs Magic In Dealing With Problems

1446 words - 6 pages people resolve problems using a logical belief system of witchcraft. All events and circumstances are not invariably and unanimously attributed to magical forces, and witchcraft is used solely to explain the unexplainable. Evans-Pritchard states in his analysis of the Azande people, that magic and witchcraft has its own logic, ‘its own rules of thought, and that these do not exclude natural causation. Belief is quite consistent with human

Magic Essay

1045 words - 5 pages , or skill” (“Magic”). Encyclopædia Britannica states that magic is “a concept used to describe a mode of rationality or way of thinking that looks to invisible forces to influence events, affect change in material conditions, or present the illusion of change” (“magic”, 2014). Magic covers a few different practices, including, but not limited to, divination, alchemy, sorcery, astrology, and necromancy. The term is also used in reference to